CV's ne karwayi Madhu se Overacting. [VB Note p.1 ]

carisma2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
An hour ago - I made the below post in very simple english, yet 😲 ppl failed to understand it miserably. Hence I decided to put it on a sugar coated spoon this time.
Secondary to RK ' Deepali's dialogues are always something to watch out for.

One of her lines regarding Madhubala's nautanki was animated by a scene from yesterdays episode. However the character was given this short string by the CV's, which could count as a blooper.

1. After the administration of drips, the patient is not in such excruciating pain as was shown in the show. I can validate this by personal experience.

(At the above ' It is not DD's acting that is criticised ' she was TOLD to act as though she's in the same level of pain as childbirth.. or almost, and she delivered according to the bad script perfectly). This is a blooper from the CV's part not the actress. CV's shud have known better than to make the character (Madhu) over act.

2.
When RK had to be hand fed, The CV's had a perfect plan of action ' a, he was tied up and b, he had a bandage on the other hand. Yet the feeding scene fitted in. Here the CV's didn't maintain the same standard of writing for Madhu's scene. Her right hand was intact and she could have been seen to attempt eating with her right hand ' before RK comes to her rescue.

The script was rather rushed, and the pain was exaggerated (in the script ' but the actress delivered as per the script).

RK ' Looked delicious in the pink shirt

DD ' Didn't look half bad in the transparent si saree.. the one with the burgundy borders. Above are compliments.. ' yet do not mistake them as a drool post.

Now see the difference? Had one not have to spoon feed their post to you, just coz they are a VD fan ' you catch the opposite end of the stick entirely.

Mods... Can I suggest if U haven't already - U shud have a thread for posts to CV's and a bloopers thread.
And no I am not an active member in this forum... BUT I excercise my rights of using this platform at my pleasure.
And u may comment and discuss if you like.. I may not get a chance to reply.
However any personal abuse - will be reported.
Cari.. xx
Edited by carisma2 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

77

Views

6.6k

Users

30

Likes

221

Frequent Posters

kahkashansakina thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 14th Anniversary Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
madhu USING left hand for eating n drip also in left hand she never use right hand u can watch again , i like both dressess both looking cute/hot ..rishbala rocked.
Edited by kahkashansakina - 12 years ago
carisma2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: happynfun


very often your posts are bent upon rubbing in the fact that you are a VD fan..we get it!

you drool on VD...some others drool on DD..quid pro quo!

live and let live...

my posts are vd related because anything not related to vd puts people's panties in twists. If ppl can't understand English.. not my fault. I don't go attacking people's posts and expect the same in return


SiMi615 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
DD is a great actress regardless of what someone says about her. She doesn't need to act a certain way for her to be recognized as an awesome actress! Her stage presence helps VD to stand out in the role of RK...DD and VD compliment each other in MEIEJ! Enough said!




***"You know that when I hate you, it is because I love you to a point of passion that unhinges my soul." ~Julie de Lespinasse ***

-Jwalamukhi- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Guys,

As referring back to Carisma's previous topic, ALL she is trying to point out is that showing MADHU, not DD as a damsel in distress was a blooper! She isn't comparing DD to her previous roles. She is merely blaming the CVs for their mistake and it is NOT a topic about VD, his acting better than DD's or DD's acting better than VD's. This is a topic about Madhubala the bloopers of the CVs!

As a member of this forum, EVERYONE is allowed to express their opinions so please before taking sides, look at the bigger picture and try to notice that for once a member is NOT talking about actors but about CHARACTERS. Everything a character does, does NOT have to do with them as an actor!

Please note this and any further members trying to make this topic into a "I hate VD because he overreacts" or "I hate his fans for bashing DD" or "DD v/s VD" comments, WILL face further consequences by the Development Team! No questions asked.

Thank you!
MB Dev Team
MysticalRealm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I get totally what you are saying. My mother and I are Madhubala obsessed and every time we saw Madhu hold her hand like she had slit her wrist was, quite frankly, pissing me off. When attached to an IV it should never pain below the spot of injection let alone pain at all. I had no idea what the CVs were getting at there. Also, the feeding part was so not necessary and although I loved to see it, it was very forced and also quite fake because I know for a fact that an intravenous hook up does not cause the amount of pain that was shown in the show. Now, poorly educated people would not realise this but for those who do have an idea they would understand how silly it was.


THIS BEING SAID, I am not saying it was over acting based on Dhrashti or Vivian's part, it was simply what the script demanded which was incorrect. I'm sure they felt pretty silly acting that scene too because even they know that it doesn't cause as much pain as shown.

I have no intentions for offending ANYONE/THING/ACTOR.
MysticalRealm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: *Shifali*

Guys,


As referring back to Carisma's previous topic, ALL she is trying to point out is that showing MADHU, not DD as a damsel in distress was a blooper! She isn't comparing DD to her previous roles. She is merely blaming the CVs for their mistake and it is NOT a topic about VD, his acting better than DD's or DD's acting better than VD's. This is a topic about Madhubala the bloopers of the CVs!

As a member of this forum, EVERYONE is allowed to express their opinions so please before taking sides, look at the bigger picture and try to notice that for once a member is NOT talking about actors but about CHARACTERS. Everything a character does, does NOT have to do with them as an actor!

Please note this and any further members trying to make this topic into a "I hate VD because he overreacts" or "I hate his fans for bashing DD" or "DD v/s VD" comments, WILL face further consequences by the Development Team! No questions asked.

Thank you!
MB Dev Team


Thank you for this! It was needed for those people who jump to conclusions with out understanding what the person has simply stated and what their intentions are.
carisma2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: *Shifali*

Guys,


As referring back to Carisma's previous topic, ALL she is trying to point out is that showing MADHU, not DD as a damsel in distress was a blooper! She isn't comparing DD to her previous roles. She is merely blaming the CVs for their mistake and it is NOT a topic about VD, his acting better than DD's or DD's acting better than VD's. This is a topic about Madhubala the bloopers of the CVs!

As a member of this forum, EVERYONE is allowed to express their opinions so please before taking sides, look at the bigger picture and try to notice that for once a member is NOT talking about actors but about CHARACTERS. Everything a character does, does NOT have to do with them as an actor!

Please note this and any further members trying to make this topic into a "I hate VD because he overreacts" or "I hate his fans for bashing DD" or "DD v/s VD" comments, WILL face further consequences by the Development Team! No questions asked.

Thank you!
MB Dev Team

Thank you Shifali.
And thanks for taking the time out to point out the obvious which ppl either fail to understand - or pretend to misinterpret.
carisma2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: MysticalRealm

I get totally what you are saying. My mother and I are Madhubala obsessed and every time we saw Madhu hold her hand like she had slit her wrist was, quite frankly, pissing me off. When attached to an IV it should never pain below the spot of injection let alone pain at all. I had no idea what the CVs were getting at there. Also, the feeding part was so not necessary and although I loved to see it, it was very forced and also quite fake because I know for a fact that an intravenous hook up does not cause the amount of pain that was shown in the show. Now, poorly educated people would not realise this but for those who do have an idea they would understand how silly it was.



THIS BEING SAID, I am not saying it was over acting based on Dhrashti or Vivian's part, it was simply what the script demanded which was incorrect. I'm sure they felt pretty silly acting that scene too because even they know that it doesn't cause as much pain as shown.

I have no intentions for offending ANYONE/THING/ACTOR.

Thank you...
I was really hoping for an attempt from MB to eat with her right hand.. it would have made it more interesting.
BUT yes it was a cute moment. And theMr India thing was so predictable.
MysticalRealm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: carisma2

Thank you...

I was really hoping for an attempt from MB to eat with her right hand.. it would have made it more interesting.
BUT yes it was a cute moment. And the Mr India thing was so predictable.


Personally, I think that if the situation was a little more realistic then I would have loved it more. But it was quite awkward for me watch because you know for a fact that this is definite acting and it didn't touch me as much as a real caring situation should have... but who am I to judge? It was definitely predictable
Edited by MysticalRealm - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".