Critical Analysis of Madhubala Ek Ishq Ek Junoon - Page 5

Amazing post dude👏 please write more here we r a serious lack of good writers😳

Dude maddy is slowing transforming into geet first the geet like hairstyle then the geet like cloths wid deep back cut😆...and now the geet like personality...geet was loud bubbly and obnoxious and childish and maddy had became loud and obnoxious when rk dumped water on her...i think maddy is more mature so she should have had subdued emotions remember in the beginng maddy was like the grandmother in her chawl she took care of everyone and understood ther needs...yep geet cried alot😆

Originally posted by: emptyworld

you know Tammy and Nishi I have many such issues but I should keep my mouth shut. The only person for whom I am watching is you guys know. Sometimes I cry inside ke kya kya karna padta hai apne favourite ke liye.😭

Note: This is friendly discussion only. My POV so please no bashing on me for this comment. It is not refer to anybody. Main pagal ho gai hoon isliye kuch bhi likh te ja rahi hoon.🤪

Originally posted by: Nishi.Singh

lol Nishi your post does not seem like a critical analysis to me😆 Well I disgaree with your points and I guess you know it too😆

This show started as a show based on Passionate Love Story with Film Faternity as a backdrop...and the name of the show was Kathputli which changed just few days before the show hit on air to Madhubala Ek Ishq Ek Junoon...it doesnt mean the theme of the show changed...the show was about how a simple girl called Madhu who had no high dreams for herself and wanted a simple life...she always wanted to stay away from film indutry but she falls in love with Superstar RK and ends up becoming a heroine as per his wishes and against her own wishes...thats how the name KATHPUTLI came and the show looked in the starting...RK's Love was described by himself as "AAG KA DARIYA"...remember RK making Madhu and Trishna's clay models and saying - CHALO BHAGWAAN-BHAGWAAN KHELE!
But somehow the story of a simple girl did not go well with audience esp.the Mukund track...the TRPs went down...
So then the makers changed the track a bit...they did their Tried and Tested Formula which works in thier every show that is Force marriage and Love-Hate track 😆...now the TRPs were high so they dont wanna change the track...

I do not think the theme of the show has changed as of yet...am not talking about any future track but whats shown till now. The promos and artciles before the start of the show stated what you have described..a simple girl forced into stardom and falling in love with a superstar. To show this you need to have a solid background and story...which they are giving. The mukund track or the forced marriage track is no change of plan...may be they rushed a bit into the marriage by skipping some of OTT drama of Mukund and party...but the creatvies already were giving hints to this...rem RK saying he about the bangles thing and the 40 yrs...these are small hints that it was always meant to be that way.

Kathputli was a working title and all shows have a working title and before going on air they get a final title which may or may not be the same...and about 'Aag ka dariya' dialogue, well thats what their love story is...

RK is the aag ka dariya...doob ke jana hai symbolises the suffering and heartbreaks and kinare par Rishabh is waiting for Madhu.

Then they thought what does audience like in these actors?...and they started making them do what they were famous for...😆

I cud feel Abhay in RK...he started saying dialogs like Abhay and i am sure all PKYEK fans will agree that RK acts like Abhay now - being an angel, protecting her but hiding it, taking all blames, bajaoing everyone from A to Z - all qualities of Abhay, isnt it?...even some Scenes and Songs (Raat Akeli) were inspired directly...now this Dream Love confession of Madhu - again same like happened with Pia...also Madhu is so much like Pia at times - stalking, questioning, not able to understand him - all qualities of Pia, isnt it?...and RK like Abhay wont confess that he loves her until she keeps a knief on his neck and tell him - Say that u Love me (not literally but u know what i mean 😆)

Well Abhay and Rishabh are a bit similar but like all heroes of telly world. Initially even I felt that they are way similar...in somethings yes they are...but there's a major difference between them. Abhay ALWAYS kept everyone else above him...be it even ppl who hated him. Abhay I guess had no such emotion called hate.😆 Its not the same with Rishabh...he hates few people in his life...loves and cares for people who are good and love him ...gets even with people who try to harm him and a few other differences as well. and Piya and Madhubala are not at all same. Tanzie explained it well.

Also Geet is famous for doing emotional scenes and though i have never watched that show but heard that she is really good in emotional and crying scenes...and Drashti said it herself in interview that she is phD in crying 😆...so i guess thats why she gets lots of senti wale scenes here too

Geet and Madhubala are way different...Madhubala is more calm and composed...I guess more matured too.

Well the question is - does the Film faternity track still hold true in this show? the Forced Stardom and Kathputli track? Does the show look the same how it started?...well i dont think so...when Saurabh Tiwari (the Producer of the show) was questioned recently abt the theme of this show, his new definition was "Its a Love Story with Family drama as backdrop"

LOL the definition changed, aahaan?! 😆
About the Saurabh Tiwari quote...he did not change it...before the start of the show he had said in an interview..MEIEJ will be a RJ type of love story with a HAHK background...so where did the definition change?🤔
About stardom track...I feel it was supposed to be after Madhu falling in love with Rishabh ( what I understood from promos) so that will be in future...and am not predicting anything...will wait for the story to progress.

PS: this is my POV...if u cant take it then no need to come and fight here...rest r welcome to give their opinion in a peaceful way and take it lightly in a fun way

Originally posted by: spn-abhay

agreed wid u nishi.the cvs hv changed a lot of story.it was a love story wid stardom backdrop bt its a family drama now as it brought trps.
regarding similartiy bw rk nd abhay,well agreed on dat part too.both hv bbb skils nd bad boy image stil a heart of gold.
4 me show rk n i wl watch it.otherwise tata bye bye to the show.infct i was sad dat in fri epi they didnt show rk:-(

Originally posted by: TrueKash

Itni lambi essay likhne ke baad koi bhi pagal hojayega🤣🤣🤣awww😆i understand😆even i keep my mouth shut🤣

Originally posted by: Sweet_Desires

Yeah... but you know they should have not promised us if they couldn't fullfill it!!

You see I was attracted to this because of it's promos and it's concept but now sometimes

it hurts to see as the concept got lost somewhere

Maybe I expected too much from this show😕...what I see now somewhat a mixture of PKYEK and Geet and any other saas bahu drama!!

So now I don't expect anything but CVs have to realise that this show might not run long especially if the younger age group audiences loose interest in it!!!

Originally posted by: ZAHARA.

Hm, will edit post to write more.

but in simple terms, I have to admit I prefer the old track - the old idea of Madhu venturing into films. After all, where would her dad and the prophecy fit in all this?

Originally posted by: emptyworld

Hey Nishi evreyone said everything and you have to reply them all. All the best. I will just say one important thing but- Hope this not get closed🤣. For me it is Vivian Dsena and his getting appreciation too. So carry on whatever they want to show just a request show him atleast once. As far RK's character ya he is nice character, from starting when he was evil I used like his character and still does. So for me it is that. Infact sometime I cannot even connect with Madhu's character. Anyways similarities - RK does has similarities to Abhay but still Vivian played both the part differently so there is one fine line to differentiate between them.

For Madhu I don't understand why they give them Geet look all over again. Let her be Madhu then Geet. Aur kuch nahin kehna chahathi Madhu pe.

As for story you know my friends too complaining same. Many are there who get attracted from promo and then they are sad that it not turn out to be that. See storyline they catched is also great. If they changed track that is also great but film fraternity is one very sensitive track and to make whole lot story on this is big and great decision. Still they need to handle it very carefully if they want it to work for long time. Like I said they going slow went not needed. They can actually wind Malik scene in this week. Also when they need to justify and go sensibly they are going fast like that seduction episode when suddenly Madhu came. Plus there is no smoothness in some of the scenes. So if they are also changing plot then at least change with sensibility. Also one thing now I am fed up with veer dheer and balbeer dialogue.😡 Friday episode mien toh do baar bulwaya . I was your three in one RK is sleeping so stop remembering and dig gun fast. Now a days blooper bhi itne ate hai.

RK is superstar really 😲 I mean woh agar flop hua future mien toh Madhu ke hit hone ki wajah se nahin balki khud ki galti se. Bande ki picture lagti rehti. Showing every where banner, showing him superstar and one question banda shooting kab karta hai koi samjhaye mujhe😕. Isse toh Dipali and Madhu se fursat mile toh kaam kare.🤔 Pehle toh karta bhi tha par ab uska haath bandke bitha diya😡. Now I am also fed up with his hand bandage, Kitne din se dhekh rahe hai, please usse jaldi thik karo and kaam dhande pe bhejo.🤔😡

Also dark passionate love is missing

Note: This is my POV so no bashing on me please 😳

(Aww Nishi tujhe nahin pata ab tak main apne disclaimer ke liye famous ho chuki hoon so socha permanent rakhlun isse. Akhir har writer ki apni phehchan hoti hai so main apni phehchan apni disclaimer ke saath karungi. Nice na).

Itna bada likh diya maine 😲. Aww don't bother to reply me I am one kinda crazy girl pata nahin kya likha itna maine.🤣