Who is Shamsher Malik? A real life hero ? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

6.4k

Users

18

Likes

118

Frequent Posters

vaani21 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Oh my god, you are brilliant, you make the show all the more interesting😊 My writing skills are poor, but i will try
I agree with your analysis, particularly the paragraph below.
Actually RK taunts shamsher so that he marries padmini.may be in future if CV's decide to bring a meaningful relation of padmini and malik.
Indirectly he is helping this dysfunctional family.His taunting has always reaped good results. 😆 From day one after his mock marriage with madhu, he is repairing everything with his taunts.
Shamsher's unreasonable hero act can damage madhu, trishna, padmini family in future.
Our Hero RK😊 with a villian mask will be there to help them, and is already in the process, right hubby/patidev for madhu and right damaad for padmini and hopefully trishna's future may also be bright . I for got about Balraj😆🤣 Rk is the right person to repair or put an end to his psycho father-in-law.
I hope the CV's don't spoil it with unnecessary stuff, cos it is a great concept.
Once again,your writing skills and between the lines analysis are impressive😊. I think you read lot of novels.
i just wanted to drop this line i am from bangalore cos ,there was some post you wrote about bangalore and majestic.

originally posted by O-SD-O
{What an irony that Real life hero act is so unreasonable when viewed from prevailing laws of human society, as seen in conventional ethics. Knights do not exist. One doesn't take law into their hands. Shamsher cannot think beyond this and perhaps that is the reason, it never occurred to him that his stay-put hero-act is not actually sanctioned by society which RK so easily ridicules him for. He takes care of a woman that is not his wife and raises two girls like his own daughters. Does Shamsher understand the ignominy that Padmini and his daughters may have gone through in their life on account of his knight status ?

What an irony that the RK who is a monster actually in real life takes heed of societal laws and does not kill Shamsher and when decides to destroy the woman, he provides her with a dignified status sanctioned by society. He makes her his wife. RK taunts Shamsher ''Aapki naajayez beti to Jaayez Biwi banaya hai maine" Does that hurt Shamsher in any manner ?}


Edited by vaani21 - 12 years ago
gennyM thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
I am so excited to see ure post on the main forum.All of us are so busy lapping up rishbala scenes,that there seems to be nothing exciting about anybody else.
But ure post makes us feel for the intricacies of each and every character and also makethe plot interesting,
Thank u.
Punit_Best98 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
Nice Post..! GReat Job S-D...!👍🏼
Sima14 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
I am caught in this uninteresting situation, forced to watch the two men. Until the two men understand each other, that they are mirror images of each other, that they both are the heroes in real life as well, they are not going to be at peace. Each needs to know the story of the other. Another epic story there. Can Madhubala please build a bridge between the two to end the vendetta ? Please

Shri

Sorry for the late reply... Busy with Navratri yesterday...This post was truly amazing..I just hope that in future both RK and Malik will join forces to defeat Ballu..When he enters I hope they will set aside their egos to protect their most important women in their lifes ,,, Madhu😊

Maria-capri thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: vaani21


Oh my god, you are brilliant, you make the show all the more interesting😊 My writing skills are poor, but i will try
I agree with your analysis, particularly the paragraph below.
Actually RK taunts shamsher so that he marries padmini.may be in future if CV's decide to bring a meaningful relation of padmini and malik.
Indirectly he is helping this dysfunctional family.His taunting has always reaped good results. 😆 From day one after his mock marriage with madhu, he is repairing everything with his taunts.
Shamsher's unreasonable hero act can damage madhu, trishna, padmini family in future.
Our Hero RK😊 with a villian mask will be there to help them, and is already in the process, right hubby/patidev for madhu and right damaad for padmini and hopefully trishna's future may also be bright . I for got about Balraj😆🤣 Rk is the right person to repair or put an end to his psycho father-in-law.
I hope the CV's don't spoil it with unnecessary stuff, cos it is a great concept.
Once again,your writing skills and between the lines analysis are impressive😊. I think you read lot of novels.
i just wanted to drop this line i am from bangalore cos ,there was some post you wrote about bangalore and majestic.

originally posted by O-SD-O
{What an irony that Real life hero act is so unreasonable when viewed from prevailing laws of human society, as seen in conventional ethics. Knights do not exist. One doesn't take law into their hands. Shamsher cannot think beyond this and perhaps that is the reason, it never occurred to him that his stay-put hero-act is not actually sanctioned by society which RK so easily ridicules him for. He takes care of a woman that is not his wife and raises two girls like his own daughters. Does Shamsher understand the ignominy that Padmini and his daughters may have gone through in their life on account of his knight status ?

What an irony that the RK who is a monster actually in real life takes heed of societal laws and does not kill Shamsher and when decides to destroy the woman, he provides her with a dignified status sanctioned by society. He makes her his wife. RK taunts Shamsher ''Aapki naajayez beti to Jaayez Biwi banaya hai maine" Does that hurt Shamsher in any manner ?}




I loved ur comments Ur writing skills is superb I really liked it.😳⭐️

Im also thought that RK wearing mask , he married MB not for ravage but

He want give back her respect in society 😳
Edited by maria_mahar - 12 years ago
aan-rish thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
Amazing analysis. Loved it 👍🏼
dee86 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
I like how you say Shamsher has a hero-complex. I think so too; he is the sort of a man who'll go charging into battle with his ideals held aloft. Not that there's anything wrong with it, but he's blind to greys. Everything is black and white. RK is bad, Madhu is being tortured, so it is up to the knight in shining armour, as you put it, to ride to the rescue.

@ no change in Malik's attitude reg RK - well, he has been immobile, hasn't he? RK has lived with Madhu all these days, his inner Rishabh has come through, he's begun to develop some feelings for her, so there is no surprise that what he thinks about Malik (her father. Malik doesn't exist for him in any other capacity) has changed a bit. On the other hand, poor Malik has been in a coma (?); he has no idea that a man called Rishabh exists, for whom his daughter is starting to feel. Which is why he's so confused and angry right now; it he probably thinks Madhu has Stockholm Syndrome or something.

Like you say, these two men need to know more about each other before they can be at peace. This applies especially to Malik. RK's relation with Sham has always been thru Madhu, so when his attitude towards her changes, so does his attitude towards her family. Not so with Malik, IMO.

0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: vaani21

Once again,your writing skills and between the lines analysis are impressive😊. I think you read lot of novels.
i just wanted to drop this line i am from bangalore cos ,there was some post you wrote about bangalore and majestic.


Vani,

Feels great to know that you liked my analysis. Thank you for the kind words. Yes, I was in Bangalore for almost 3 years when I was working there.
No, I don't read these days. 😆 Its been more than a decade now that I stopped reading books. If I get off my obsessive love for TV shows and my work, then maybe I can try to indulge myself in other pastimes. But yes, I got academically trained to analyze in that manner as I was a literature student in college. Add to that, I like observing and analyzing.


0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: nlm4

I am so excited to see ure post on the main forum.All of us are so busy lapping up rishbala scenes,that there seems to be nothing exciting about anybody else.

But ure post makes us feel for the intricacies of each and every character and also makethe plot interesting,
Thank u.


nlm4,

Thx, You know I owe that you 😉 Re; intricacies of each and every character, so true ! what an awful waste of canvas if they had to develop only two characters and forget the rest. So my interests to delve further.

And here's to MEIEJ junoons - Just my thoughts

The Maliks and Choudharies
Shamsher Malik - I need to be a knight in the shining armor, a hero
Padmini Chowdhary - I need to be Mother India
Roma Malik - XXX - some other time. I don't know her that well
Trishna Malik/Chowdhary - I need to play by step-daughter/sister card all the time
Madhubala Shamsher Malik - I need to be the daughter of my father and my mother, playing it to perfection. 😆 😆 I like this one best 🤣

The Bhatias
Kukku Bhatia - I need to be The Joker other than being the regular bad step-father and indulging father
Sikky Bhatia - I need to be the Monkey,dancing to the tunes of my Dad-the Madaari
Radha Bhatia - I need to cry at all times.
Deepali Bhatia - I need to shoo away my husband and get back my ex-love RK

The Kundras
Mohan Kundra - I need to haunt my son 😆
RK - I need to hide Rishabh Kundra
Rishabh Kundra - I need to be RK
Madhubala Kundra - XXX well good for her, she is not obsessing over anything now. Intelligent girl. But still can I just say for now. I need to be RK's Biwi 😆

Bittuji - I love my Chief, my multiple cells, my jewellery, my shirts. 🤣



0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: dee86

I like how you say Shamsher has a hero-complex. I think so too; he is the sort of a man who'll go charging into battle with his ideals held aloft. Not that there's anything wrong with it, but he's blind to greys. Everything is black and white. RK is bad, Madhu is being tortured, so it is up to the knight in shining armour, as you put it, to ride to the rescue.

@ no change in Malik's attitude reg RK - well, he has been immobile, hasn't he? RK has lived with Madhu all these days, his inner Rishabh has come through, he's begun to develop some feelings for her, so there is no surprise that what he thinks about Malik (her father. Malik doesn't exist for him in any other capacity) has changed a bit. On the other hand, poor Malik has been in a coma (?); he has no idea that a man called Rishabh exists, for whom his daughter is starting to feel. Which is why he's so confused and angry right now; it he probably thinks Madhu has Stockholm Syndrome or something.

Like you say, these two men need to know more about each other before they can be at peace. This applies especially to Malik. RK's relation with Sham has always been thru Madhu, so when his attitude towards her changes, so does his attitude towards her family. Not so with Malik, IMO.


dee86,

Exactly. Agree with your thoughts too. Thank you for the comment.

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".