The point of public voting???

Page

Next Last

sweet_JAY_FAN

@sweet_JAY_FAN

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

OK guys in this particualar show I do not understand the point of public voting if they're just gonna ask the participants themselves who should go out. Why is this show so complicated can't they just make it simple and sweet! Reshmi was already voted out she should have gone out!

Does anyone agree

Quote

Frequent Posters

293418

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

Yes, this show continues to defy sense though. It just keeps on getting more and more senseless.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

JiyaRe

@JiyaRe

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Hun theres no point, at the end of the day the show or in this weeks episode as Salil blantly blamed the audience for not voting enough for Panchi and Reshmi and that was the reason why these two groups were in the bottom two. Anyway its not like any of the results are transparent. Also why blame the audience for not voting enough, one can also question the judges to why arent they giving higher scores!

At the end of the day the production house and the sponsors gain profits out of the money charged for voting. So I personally would never vote. (Plus I cant vote anyway as am not a resident of India).

So the Shows producers will chose to use what suits them best, not the shows format or the talent search!

Quote

sweet_JAY_FAN

@sweet_JAY_FAN

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

This show has no reasonable concept!

Quote

sweet_JAY_FAN

@sweet_JAY_FAN

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: San Star
Hun theres no point, at the end of the day the show or in this weeks episode as Salil blantly blamed the audience for not voting enough for Panchi and Reshmi and that was the reason why these two groups were in the bottom two. Anyway its not like any of the results are transparent. Also why blame the audience for not voting enough, one can also question the judges to why arent they giving higher scores!

At the end of the day the production house and the sponsors gain profits out of the money charged for voting. So I personally would never vote. (Plus I cant vote anyway as am not a resident of India).

So the Shows producers will chose to use what suits them best, not the shows format or the talent search!

Yeah sometomes I feel the judges are a little low in marks

Quote

JiyaRe

@JiyaRe

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: sweet_JAY_FAN
Yeah sometomes I feel the judges are a little low in marks

Hi Sweet jay fan... totally and I think this is what Mihika was voicing out, in terms of the first week when Twinkle and co got 30, where as Jays performance was just as good if not better, and yet Jai was given lower marks.

Quote

sweet_JAY_FAN

@sweet_JAY_FAN

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: San Star

Hi Sweet jay fan... totally and I think this is what Mihika was voicing out, in terms of the first week when Twinkle and co got 30, where as Jays performance was just as good if not better, and yet Jai was given lower marks.

Plz call me Shriya😊 and I also agree abt Jay

he was far far far better and deserved 30 pts!

Quote

JiyaRe

@JiyaRe

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Hi Shriya :-) nice to meet you, I'm San

Yes indeed and i think this goes back to Karans arguement with the whole concept of public voting, whats the point if the contests themselves have to pick the final vote in regards to who goes and stays. But isnt this a contradition to the whole concept of the show, I mean of such means are used to keep and other contestants. Then where and how is the talent decided of who truely is worthy of staying. As evident in this weeks episode Reshmi was suppose to go out if the decision was left to public voting. And I personally do think that Twinkle and Puneet voted agaist Panchi and Rahul because of the whole hoopla that happened.

At the end its the publics choice in terms of who they want to see and who not, as Jay pointed out!!

Its just unlogical!! what more can be said its a K show right!!

Quote

JiyaRe

@JiyaRe

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: sweet_JAY_FAN

OK guys in this particualar show I do not understand the point of public voting if they're just gonna ask the participants themselves who should go out. Why is this show so complicated can't they just make it simple and sweet! Reshmi was already voted out she should have gone out!

Does anyone agree

Shriya you and me both!! lol seriously I mean other reality shows like Nach Baliye, Jhalak Dhikla jaa ect they they have one simple execution to eliminating the contestants... Is Bollywood ka ticket trying to be different just by adding confussion... I mean if the bottom two are decided by public voting then why on earth are the judges giving scores (although both hold 50%). They should eliminate oublic voting and just use the judges scores to keep the current format. The bottom two, hence this way the contestants will work harder knowing that its thier shere hard work that'll get them through and not rely on public voting. And if judges scores are soley used atleast this way its transparent in terms of the bottom two being pre selected and also to the winner too. (hope this makes sense)"

Quote

Aaliyah

@linkin_vonsky

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

They have a mess rule...

One if got High Marks and Low Votes and finally end up in the bottom 2, and other contestants doesn't like them...so still they will end up eliminate...

One if got Low Marks and High Votes and finally end up in the bottom 2, and other contestants doesn't like them...so they will end up eliminate too...

The point is judges and votes are useless...it depends on other contestants...so who are the biggest thread for them will be out...what kind of show is this...

So, Judges has paid only to show off their face and name...votes just to get money for the channel, production house, cell phone provider...

So Sahil, don't blame fans not to votes enough for them...it's meaningless, you know that...

Really really ridiculous show...

Edited by linkin_vonsky - 17 years ago

Quote

1 2

The point of public voting???

Related Topics

Explore Topics