An idiosyncratic analysis of 12/5 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

1.2k

Users

10

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

187214 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: spian

Me too completely in awe. But thanks to Nomi or else how wld u have done the analysis.

I second the thanks to Nomi!

Well it was to show the light mood of Abhimanyu. Now I have accepted that this is part of his charac in LRL. Oh you have made me remember Kurt Cobain and he wld have appreciated the attempt for being original.

Hey Lirh yeh toh maine socha hi nahi ki Cobain would have appreciated the attempt for originality alone!.... Waah kya defence hai! 😊

Oh come Shevtal that 'Maa' was just to show affectionately made cake. Tum toh baal ki khaal nikaal rahi ho😕. Naina is being portrayed to be as a very determined and focussed person. Till now she not detered from her goal👏. Naina is appealing to them precisely for her inner resolve,courage intermingled with emotions.

Lirh i disown you completely.... tumhe aaj tak yeh pata nahi chala... tumne aaj tak samjha nahi.... tumne aaj tak mujhe nahi pehchaana.... baal ki khaal nikalna is exactly what i do!!! 😆 😆 Yes i agree that she is focussed on her goal.... but she is also the only woman operating at the same level as these two men.... that imm sets her apart from the others.

'Jo chale gaye unhe gham nahi, jo rah gaye unke gham kam nahi' well...⭐️ Oh I loved this line so much and can hear it as many times😍. It has a deeper meaning too in reference to Naveen and separately to Naina.

Ok so someone is day dreaming again...

This was to enthuse humour into the situation it was already tense. Btw I liked his action here😛

Yes he said it so beautifully👏 The way it was bought into the conversation is applaudworthy. Great work Scriptwriter👍🏼 . Abhi is taking things as they come he is being patient with the proceedings. Abhi understands & trusts Rajveer and thats why he puts forth the ques to Naina ' What if he is right?'. Abhi is more thoughful and understanding of people and situtations. Naina has the sense of urgency to regain her brother's honor. She will be at peace only after she succeeds in her goal.

Yes the scriptwriter introduced it well.

Now this depicts Naina's dilemma to what after she succeeds in acheiving her goal. Now as she is a goal oriented person what wld she do? till now it was her brother's honor but what next? Apart from this she feels she has to accept her brother's loss and is slowly coming to terms with it.

.Thats what i meant to.... once she finds her answers, will those answers also bring peace and happiness?.... what next for her?... does she want to continue being in the army once her brother's 'honour' is restored?....

Yes I agree he was more philosophic here. And then gave her a pratical ans to live life. Perhaps trying to infuse some cheer in her life. I think Abhi will enable Naina to come to terms with her brother's death and finally overcome the grief. In totality I liked the scene. Wish the director gave it more time. I felt it was rushed thru.

Ya it was indeed too short.... they could have developed it further and made it a very warm and tender scene.

I think they are trying to be poetic.

Trying is a good word. It is also a good thing to do, every now and then!

yes waiting for some more meaningful scenes.

Intezaar.... intezaar.... 😆 😆

scorpiongal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12
187214 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: scorpiongal

shvetal..for me..praise is not subjected to agreement or disagreement. i praised u cuz i felt that u've written it very nicely...putting beautifully the whole situation in few lines.... it was my regard to ur articulation.

Thats a very mature thing to say. And that makes the praise all the more special!

superbike thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#14
Nice analysis Shvetal for a 2 minute scene... Though the scene itself is multilayered.... so many emotions portrayed by Gaurav as Abhimanyu... I too liked it very much the way he did it...Though I personally dun think that anyone can understand the pain she is going through... but he is trying to help her to come out of the shock and to get all the answers for her... But as far as "Aap phir se jeena to shuru kar dengi..." goes, it takes time... ya hopefully happiness will follow if she gets all the answers.. 😊
Edited by superbike - 18 years ago
187214 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15

😆

Originally posted by: superbike

Nice analysis Shvetal for a 2 minute scene... Though the scene itself is multilayered.... so many emotions portrayed by Gaurav as Abhimanyu... I too liked it very much the way he did it...Though I personally dun think that anyone can understand the pain she is going through... but he is trying to help her to come out of the shock and to get all the answers for her... But as far as "Aap phir se jeena to shuru kar dengi..." goes, it takes time... ya hopefully happiness will follow if she gets all the answers.. 😊

Teena jo main lambi lambi pothiyon mein likhti hoon woh tum effortlessly aur succinctly ek chote se post mein likh deti ho.... I knew you would like it too.... it was one of those less speech, more expression scenes that always appeals to both of us.... yes 'phir se jeena' definitely takes time.... but the way he said it, usmein iss baat ka ehsaas bhi tha... its not like he was saying 'your pain does not matter'... he just didnt want to reinforce her sadness, wanted to give her something beyond that.

Teena, do you realise that both you and i wished happiness for Naina... almost as if she were a real person that we know... and not a character from a show.... thats not just a tribute to our kind hearted and empathetic natures 😉 😆 but also to Priyanka's acting.... way to go girl 👏 👏

Chalo ab mujhe four dekhna hai... mujhe distrub mat karo!!

superbike thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: whynot

Teena jo main lambi lambi pothiyon mein likhti hoon woh tum effortlessly aur succinctly ek chote se post mein likh deti ho....

Infact I was thinking if I could learn detailing.😆.. and Shvetal... I think you shud also sometimes think about summarizing...😉

Edited by superbike - 18 years ago
187214 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: superbike

Infact I was thinking if I could learn detailing.😆.. and Shvetal... I think you shud also sometimes think about summarizing...😉

😆 😆 😆 😆

Teena kaash maine school mein precis pe thoda dhyaan diya hota 😆 😆

shahnaz12 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: superbike

Infact I was thinking if I could learn detailing.😆.. and Shvetal... I think you shud also sometimes think about summarizing...😉

Teena ... you are tooooooooo good😉...

I laughed sooooooo much😆😆 😆... you two are awesome👏...

gulrani thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: scorpiongal

shvetal....i m sure...whenever u would fail to watch the show on tv....we'll get to read these engaging, prodigious, & incredibly astonishing analysis. (i wish ur sab tv go for a toss every day...).... 😆 😆 😆
so that..u watch the episode online...(with repeats of scenes)..catch every micro-second..every single details of gaurav's body movement ..every single change of his expressions... & come here with a fantastic addition of ur own thoughts....that make us completely speechless. 👏 👏 👏

loved it..as always.... 😊

Very well said Shweta.... 😛

I am seechless too Shvetal with you usual fantastic analysis...👏👏

superbike thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: shahnaz12

Teena ... you are tooooooooo good😉...

I laughed sooooooo much😆😆 😆... you two are awesome👏...

Thanx Shahnaaz....😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".