New Age Byronic Hero-Dutta SHriram Patil

Wanderbug thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1


Well, another monday episode and again forum is divided into camps- singer Dutta supporters and singer dutta haters...my earlier post makes it clear which side I am..this post has nothing to do with Dutta singing, sulking or generally being a gadha. No,enough had been said on all that already.

This post is coming, after I discovered my hardbound copies of my favorite books this weekend,while packing my things before my family shifts permanently to Kolkata. While I was dusting them, I couldn't resist turning over the leaves and reread and relive the sheer magic of those words....those feelings....those untouched touches..those darkness and flaws.

And I while reading those books I could imagine a face for the first time..the face was MR, no doubt but the man was Dutta..

I could see Him as Mr.Darcy proposing to Lizzy Bennet in a rainy afternoon saying all the wrong words in his pompous manner but with love in his heart. I could see Him as Heathcliff,

the jealous lover of Cathrine who went to extreme lengths to get his vengeance, ultimately dying an old bitter man.

He is Mr. Edward Rochester who was deeply in love with Jane Eyre- an innocent soul, who soothed his jaded and cynical heart. He went to the lengths of disguising him as old fortune teller, to talk to her alone in his soiree, who lost his eye and his wealth saving his love from fire that was lit by his deranged first wife. A humbled man who declared that the blurred specter of his baby son's blue eyes- a reminiscence of his beloved Jane was the most beautiful thing he has ever seen.

He looked like Maxim who wanted a second chance at happiness with a simple companion, who he knows loves him to bits. He wants his past and Rebecca's past to stay hidden forever so that his present which is,his second Mrs.de Winter, stays with him forever.

I can see him as Pip who thinks that Mrs.Haversham is grooming him for his Estella. But with his snobbishness for Joe and Abel Magwitch. To me he is Mr.Jykll and Dr.Hyde. He is the beauty depicted in the portrait of Dorian Gray, in all his stark darkness and excesses.

You might think, how can I relate our beloved Gadha to these legendary characters. He may not be their exact portrayal, but his complexity is a blend of it all. Dutta has breathed life in a very old species of classic heroes..The Byronic hero- A hero who had many flaws and darkness of character yet the innocent,spunky, honest heroines could not help themselves from falling for them. Just like Nakusha who is a God praying, honest girl, innocent to the core of her soul but can't help herself from loving Dutta- a recluse, a self-confessed cold-blooded killer with a bleeding heart turned to stone.

She can't help herself from loving him even if he punishes her without giving her a chance to justify her actions, be it during the last wedding or Post-FR. She knows he loves her but can't accept her.

She is staying as a discarded wife in outhouse(it was her decision but still). She is taking all his harshness as a sign of his caring. Why? Because she loves him just like Lizzy ultimately loved darcy in-spite of his snobbishness because of his good heart. Because she loves him like Cathrine does her Heathcliff, in whose arms she breathed her last. Like Jaye loves Rochester in-spite of his lie. Like Mrs.de Winter believes in her Maxim even when she discovered that he was a murderer. Like Estella in the end realizes Pip's true worth.

Thank you for bringing back a dying class of heroes alive. Thank you Dutta Shriram Patil...singer or no-singer, but definitely the Lover- Day or Knight..Opps..Night.

Yours,
A hopeless Dutta addict.

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.2k

Users

14

Likes

74

Frequent Posters

rama_2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Oh wow shilpi... brought back memories of all heros........sumwhere though lost by me.... in keeping up with daily chores... Very true ... Dutta a mixture of all our legendary heros... a dream man sumwhere in my heart...
A true gift..... to revive those feelings... of true love....
Thanks to CV's and LTL team for a wonderful gift... for year 2010......
TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Very well written Shilpi! I do hope the CVs in the long run live up to the expectations they have set for themselves.
-Srushti- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Oh my ghosh Shilpita!!!!👏!!! wish the Cvs would read this... they would be so proud they have created a character like D....your post covers it all .... but I think it is most near to Darcy and Maxim....Darcy because of his arrogance and Maxim because Maxim being the murderer....having some criminal background like Dutta..
by the way as soon as i read the title of your post, I gave a google search on byronic hero and look what i found on wikipedia!


"The Byronic hero typically exhibits several of the following traits:

  • a strong sense of arrogance
  • high level of intelligence and perception
  • cunning and able to adapt
  • suffering from an unnamed crime
  • a troubled past
  • sophisticated and educated
  • self-critical and introspective
  • mysterious, magnetic and charismatic
  • struggling with integrity
  • power of seduction and sexual attraction
  • social and sexual dominance
  • emotional conflicts, bipolar tendencies, or moodiness
  • a distaste for social institutions and norms
  • being an exile, an outcast, or an outlaw
  • "dark" attributes not normally associated with a hero
  • disrespect of rank and privilege
  • jaded, world-weary
  • cynicism
  • self-destructive behaviour"
I think the only ones which I have made in bold are the characteristic we cannot associate with Dutta...high level of intelligence is joke😆 and cunning is out of question...and able to adapt ....welll... if he would have been able to adapt we would not have this pre FR and post FR dhamakas😆..
but all the other traits....i must say shipita spot on!!! there cannot be another better word for dutta...byronic hero...
again repeating....an excellent post👏

Edited by msthula - 14 years ago
Wanderbug thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: msthula

Oh my ghosh Shilpita!!!!👏!!! wish the Cvs would read this... they would be so proud they have created a character like D....your post covers it all .... but I think it is most near to Darcy and Maxim....Darcy because of his arrogance and Maxim because Maxim being the murderer....having some criminal background like Dutta..
by the way as soon as i read the title of your post, I gave a google search on byronic hero and look what i found on wikipedia!


"The Byronic hero typically exhibits several of the following traits:

    a strong sense of arrogance high level of intelligence and perception cunning and able to adapt
    suffering from an unnamed crime a troubled past sophisticated and educated self-critical and introspective mysterious, magnetic and charismatic struggling with integrity power of seduction and sexual attraction social and sexual dominance emotional conflicts, bipolar tendencies, or moodiness
    a distaste for social institutions and norms being an exile, an outcast, or an outlaw
    "dark" attributes not normally associated with a hero
    disrespect of rank and privilege jaded, world-weary cynicism
  • self-destructive behaviour"
I think the only ones which I have made in bold are the characteristic we cannot associate with Dutta...high level of intelligence is joke😆 and cunning is out of question...and able to adapt ....welll... if he would have been able to adapt we would not have this pre FR and post FR dhamakas😆..
but all the other traits....i must say shipita spot on!!! there cannot be another better word for dutta...byronic hero...
again repeating....an excellent post👏

Yaar...my thoughts exactly....I love a hero troubled by his past ...
Dutta could be intelligent afterall he is at the top of his "Career"
i guess since nakku entered his life his intelligence has taken a long vacation
lizdarcy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
OH MY GOD! This is so romantic!!!!! And so so true!!
*swoon*
*thud*
Thank you, Shilpita!
*swoons again*
msthula, that list is soooooo Dutta! 😃
TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
MS: Even the bolded traits Dutta does have...lets not forget he is a bigshot don.
kiran255 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
OH SHILPI !
what a beautiful post !
i totally agree with u that he has bring back a classic lover
who are mostly deep n dark !
awesome observation !
shruti10august thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
OMG SHILPITA. Aaj to lagta hai ki tum itni heart touching post karke hume heart attack hi dila dongi. Its too awesum as usual. Lagta hai aaj tumhare andar ka poet, writer, creator sab jaag gaye nd jaage bhi kyun nahi, afterall aaj ltl ki first anniversary jo hai.
Keep posting the gud work.
👏
Edited by shruti10august - 14 years ago
-Srushti- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 4 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

MS: Even the bolded traits Dutta does have...lets not forget he is a bigshot don.



yes, ksh, i agree he is a don....but high level of intelligence😲....saare image ki vaat lag jayegi, kshreya!!!!😆 then who will we call gadha😆
Shilpi is right...he might have lost his brains the moment nakku rhunjhuned into his life😳😆...but still .... intelligence and dutta just dont go together😆
i would dearly cry when he turns intelligent....dutta would lose his charm😆
Edited by msthula - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".