So, why DID Dutta marry Naku? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

4k

Users

17

Likes

86

Frequent Posters

Anandana thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
Does Dutta truly believes that Nakku loves him? I'm still not very clear about it...if he truly believes that she loves him, why would he torture her...pyar karna guna tho nahin...

after all supz gave him the biggest dhoka and not nakku...ok i get the point he thinks she helped supz elope to take her place (betrayal aspect)...but can't he also think that supz was in love with somebody else....its not like nakku schemed to get married to dutta and got rid of supz who was dying to marry him...😕
Edited by Anandana - 15 years ago
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Anandana

Does Dutta truly believes that Nakku loves him? I'm still not very clear about it...if he truly believes that she loves him, why would he torture her...pyar karna guna tho nahin...

after all supz gave him the biggest dhoka and not nakku...ok i get the point he thinks she helped supz elope to take her place (betrayal aspect)...but can't he also think that supz was in love with somebody else....its not like nakku schemed to get married to dutta and got rid of supz who was dying to marry him...😕



I too am not sure if he really believes she loves him .....he might think that what Naku thinks is love, is probably not love, bcoz in love u will not betray that person......so, probably to teach her a lesson that if u call this love then let me test it (sarcasm), he wuld torture her....

but whatever it is, whether he believes it or not, he is dng all this bcoz of the betrayal part not bcoz of the love part...love is just a reason y he thinks that Naku betrayed him....
bookworm2 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
and I too noticed how he asked the pandit, whether he shld walk first or shld it be the gal..... 😆 ....He wants to make sure that tomorrow noone nullifies his marriage with Naku....sab to bhag jaati hain......yeh na bhaag jaaye.... 😆

I too noticed this and found it really funny 😆 I hoping tomorrow when his senses return and he tries to clean and bandage her feet he notices her "Fairness". cant wait to see his reaction.
-Roopa- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14

I too will go with the option 1..
Though for him now the focus now is how Nakku betrayed him.. He may not be thinking much on her love aspect..
as he taunts her that she loves him so much that she can hurt him and he will not feel anything.. is that love?..
he is also hurt that after sharing his past with her how can she help sups to get away that too in that manner.. didn't she realize how much it would hurt him..
how can she do after after knowing everything about him..
it is like she took him for granted and did not trust him..
for him now his trust, his friendship is all broken..

so he wants to teach her a lesson that it is not love and as to how it will be like being his wife.. it is not as easy as she has thought..
imkt thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#15
Yar my point of view is very different regarding this concept. Your analysis is very good upon the secene, but what i think is dutta wants to prove all statements wrong that has been said by that old lady in sangeet and all. Dutta wants to console himself and apart from that he want to show that there is someone who loves him... hope i am little bit right frnds........
thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#16
*Aisha Ponders*
Okay this is what I think:
Firstly I think Dutta knows that Naku loves him. The way she said it with so much conviction and strength, he was completely blown away by it and overwhelmed and THAT is why he was so moved when she Confessed. BUT I think that he thinks that Naku THINKS she is in love with him. She isn't really in Love with him, she just THINKS she is. So basically he believes that SHE believes that she loves him.
Hope I'm not confusing anyone😉
Now the reason why he would think this is the fact that she betrayed him for that Love and in Dutta's eyes Love does not hurt the Loved one. Naku's actions hurt him so he's probably thinking that her Love isn't the Real-True-Once-In-A-Lifetime thing that it should be. He probably thinks that she's just infatuated with him. It's a Crush basically. Gadha kahin ka😆
SO! He's going to prove her wrong and in the process punish her for being wrong as well! Because let's face it first there was Seema, then Supriya and that Crazy Lady who all said noone would ever want to Love him. So although he IS moved by Naku's Love he thinks she's just being naive and now he's going to destroy her dream just like she destroyed his.
This is the real world and all this True Love and Happily-Ever-After isn't real! And what better punishment for Naku is there than this?
BUT here's the problem. Just as Kala underestimated Dutta, Dutta himself has underestimated Naku! Because Naku really DOES Love him. She HASN'T Betrayed him and she HAS accepted him, ALL of him, Good and Bad.
This is actually going to work in her favour in the long term because when Dutta realises that Naku didn't Betray him he will be even more stunned and overwhelmed at just how much Naku loves him. He was being sarcastic and mocking her when he said "You Love me so much that anything I do you won't even say Uff in response to it?" But THAT line is going to come back and haunt him when he realises the Truth.
As for Naku right now the poor girl is going to have to accept whatever Dutta does. She understands that its because hes hurt and angry and thats why she'll let him do what he wants. Plus until she has proof I don't think she'll try and convince anyone of her Innocence again. Shes accepted that everyone including the Man she Loves thinks her Guilty and now she's also accepted his Hatred and Punishment. Because Naku KNOWS that this marriage is a mockery of her Love. She knows Dutta is doing it to hurt her. And shes accepted it because she does feel Guilty for everything thats happened and the state Dutta is in now.
HOWEVER Naku won't let Dutta meander down the path of self-destruction. Once shes picked herself up again she'll turn her attention to healing Dutta and trying to make it up to him. She's a Sherni after all! And Dutta hasn't seen her in that avatar yet!
Because whether Dutta accepts this marriage or not Naku will, she'll accept it wholeheartedly and she will see Dutta as hers and she won't let what belongs to her be destroyed or hurt in any way.
Aisha xxx😉
TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
Hey guys...thanks for ur responses...I will reply to all of u aaram se...
But for now a thought struck me....yesterday lots of ppl tried to stop him...his mother, sister, baji but he didnt care to listen. he didnt listen to babi either...and thats not like him at all.
yesterday he behaved as if what he's doing is abt Naku and him....its the ware between naku and him. and no one dare come in between them.
jani-yeh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18
Dutta thinks he's punishing n teaching Naku a lesson... by marryin her...
after which he's guna torture her n mock her luv...so that she will regret ever feeling anything 4 him...😕...but boy o boy is he wrong...😉...Naku will take wateva he does or says 2 her...n continue 2 love him regardless...
as she knws he is only doing all this because he believes her guilty...😭
but if lyk Aisha said...n Dutta jus thinks wat Naku feels is sum kind of crush...
he will prob hope that after such ill treatment she admit 2 it being only a crush...n mayb start 2 h8 him...but we all know that aint guna happen...😳
thornewood9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: jani-yeh

Dutta thinks he's punishing n teaching Naku a lesson... by marryin her...

after which he's guna torture her n mock her luv...so that she will regret ever feeling anything 4 him...😕...but boy o boy is he wrong...😉...Naku will take wateva he does or says 2 her...n continue 2 love him regardless...
as she knws he is only doing all this because he believes her guilty...😭
but if lyk Aisha said...n Dutta jus thinks wat Naku feels is sum kind of crush...
he will prob hope that after such ill treatment she admit 2 it being only a crush...n mayb start 2 h8 him...but we all know that aint guna happen...😳

See Jani the way it looks to me (and I could be completely wrong here!) is that Dutta initially when he heard Naku Confess was extremely moved.
Then he went off and got Drunk and remembered Seema and Supriya and the Crazy Lady and the fact that Naku has betrayed him just like the other two.
Plus Dutta has never felt confident about someone loving him. He doesnt see himself as a catch or a prize and he never imagined he could ever get his dream of being loved and happily married. And now his dream is broken and apparently Naku helped to do that.
And the way Dutta sees it Love never harms the one who is being Loved. So maybe when he was up there getting Drunk he came to the conclusion that Naku THINKs that shes in Love with him and now hes going to wake her up and prove to her that shes living in a dream world.
I have no doubt that Dutta believes that NAKU believes that she Loves him.
But does Dutta really believe that Naku's Love is True? THATS what I'm wondering about. And the punishment makes more sense if I think of it that way because when you Love someone and they hurt you you will eventually forgive them because when you Loved them you accepted the Good AND the Bad that they have inside them. But if you're Crushing on someone then it won't take a lot to come out of that phase because with a Crush you build the person up in your head and imagine their Good points to be exaggerated and you don't even look at the Bad points!
And I think Dutta wants to punish himself in some way as well for falling for that Dream of family and marriage with Supriya. What better way to punish himself by getting the girl who apparently "loves" him to start hating him and pitying herself for being trapped in marriage with a guy like him? I think he IS testing Naku's Love in some weird way. And then he'll be vindicated when she admits she never loved him and she thought it was Love but he'll be heartbroken again because what he thought was true (that noone could ever love him) actually has been PROVEN to be true.
Aisha xxx😉
Edited by thornewood9 - 15 years ago
skavitha08 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
but i noticed that in the scene when he took nakku's hand to take her inside the mandap dutta looked at nakku once i felt kind of seeking permission sought but not so completely n nakku closed her eyes in acceptance only then he started n took her inside the mandap.

i feel dutta is actually punishing himself for trusting nakku thats the most important i don think seema or supriya matter here any more they both are gone cases the only one matters here is nakku whom he feels has betrayed him so he himself is punishing not nakku but himself for trusting her so blindly.

i think nakku is silent all of a sudden coz she feels she has tried enough but nobody seems to believe her u might have noticed she was not even moving her head in disapproval this time wen dutta said that for this love of urs u betrayed me.

I really want to know how the truth comes out. n sorry to say m really afraid that dutta is going to stoop low n wud find it hard later to make up to his mistakes. n i don think nakku feels herself to be guilty in ne manner for dutta's current state
when dutta could be fooled by sups acting of love like that wrist cutting stuff n all nakku is after all a soft peson easily won by neone.nakku has openly said that nakku dhokebaaz nai hai she has been screaaming this for a week now fo us of course but she has. and i don think she will stay silent forever that she wants dutta to be happy n not hurt himself again she has to bring out the most obvious loopholes of the plan in notice of dutta baji so that this could be investigated further.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".