Tanya committing 'suicide' - Page 2

Originally posted by: whimsical_soul

Wasn't Tanya a bit ludicrous today?

She was hell bent on commiting suicide. Yet, when she fell, she hung onto that branch.... WHY?! Why was she holding onto Nandini's hand for that dramatic effect... why didn't she just jump off. Better still, she was in her car. How about falling off the cliff with the car. Isn't the character being a tad silly? Unless she didn't want the car to be damaged (!) What was her intention anyway?

Even if I were to empathize with her before this debacle, everything is altered now. Today's episode was the ultimate doom of Tanya when it comes to sensibility and goodness.

P.S. I'm not trying to bash. It's just a general wondering. Please don't misinterpret, it's not Rakshanda I'm refering to, it's Tanya who seems touched in the head!

I Am Kinda agree With U But I Dont Feel Sorry Fo Her Means she Actually Deserve That!!!!!!!😃

Originally posted by: neela226

i feel sorry for both nandini and tanya. nandini was never able to get karans love because of circumstances. tanya always loved karan but he never loved her. i have been in love and i know how it feels when you really love someone but you cant have him because he is someone elses. i really cant side with nandini or tanya.she hated tulsi only for her insecurity.her love blinded her from seeing the truth.also her kids also love nandini now which made her more insecure.she gave bhoomi more love than any other stepmom would.she always gave bhoomi all the love and everything she ever wanted.so its really bad that people think tanya deserves all the pain because you have to look at it from her point of view.

Originally posted by: desiflavour101

It doesn't have to do with the pair as much as KN fans fed up of the problems/tragedies. For the past 3 years we have been watching this serial only to see some cute scenes between our favorite Hiten-Gauri. Instead, once out of the blue moon, we get to see something that makes watching this serial tolerable.

To some extent you are right, but you have to look at it from their point of view:

We don't blame Tanya for Nandani not returning to SN. It was Nandani's choice and we accept that.

But what we cannot tolerate, especially myself, is Tanya crying as if she's been wronged? She acts as if Karan has only loved her and that Nandani has stolen Karan from her?

You are one of the few members who is neutral enough to distinguish b/n KN and non-KN clearly:
Assuming you are talking about me 😳😆😆, Thank you for that, I try to be as much as possible...😊

Do you really think that Tanya's tears and insecurities are fault of Nandani's?
Nope, its Tanyas, but it started bcoz karan failed to show her the truth, that he was staying with her and not going to Nandini..
Wasn't Tanya wrong by telling Manthan that Nandani has stolen Karan from her by using fake tears and fake sacrifices?
She was very wrong, the things she did due to her insecurities are unforgivable..

Wasn't Tanya wrong for being jealous of Nandani-Bhoomi's bond instead of being happy that her friend finally got Bhoomi's love?
Well, to a point I understand Tanya being jealous, since she was scared bhoomi will not call her mom anymore..and when her doubts came true, she just lost it..and yeah, she was no more the friend she used to be, since she started not seeing sense in anything, for some reason, only nandini kept telling her she didnt want to come back to SN, karan never said that, never reassured her tht either...

Didn't Tanya marry Karan despite knowing he's in love with someone else? So why blame Nandani for coming out of the coma?
Well, if she blamed nandini for coming out of coma, tht is rather ridiculous, since coming out of coma was not in nandini's hand..tht is a rather stupid dialogue actually!

At the end:

There is no cure for the insecurity. There is no cure for Tanya's insecurity, because no matter what Karan will not ever come to love her.
She understood that a little bit too late, 23 years later...

She has to accept that if 23 years of marriage couldn't diminish Karan's love for Nandani without seeing Nandani and without Nandani being by his side, how will Nandani going away solve her problems?
It will not, neither will tanya's death bring KN together since everyone will end up blaming nandini for tanya's death...i feel bad for manthan..

Originally posted by: gaurihiten fan

Yes, I was speaking of you :) (Cool_kitty23)

In the mega 3 episode, Karan told her this:

I love Nandani and will never forget about her, but I have a responsibility to you which I will always live up to and the family.

He didn't tell her he loves her because he cannot lie to her. You have to give him credit for that. He's always been honest about his feelings for Nandani. In return, he's gotten accusations only despite him being honest with Tanya.

If it was up to Karan, he would have left everything and had gone to Nandani but Nandani stopped him. Tanya knows this (she overheard them talking) and this is why her insecurity is there because she knows she is just an obligation to him.

In yesterday's episode, this is what she told Nandani:

-I was going to tell Karan about my pregnancy but you came out of the coma. So many nights where you had come between us two. Etc. Etc.

Now when she said this, in my perspective she is making Nandani guilty for coming out of the coma. Because of Nandani's reaction later...

"I am the pain of her life. Its all my fault." She was hysterical 😭😭

Despite Nandani having nothing to do with Tanya's lifes decisions.

And Tanya did know what she was getting herself into...

Nandani went to jail and Tanya came back to SN to live with Karan. Karan clearly told her:

I cannot give you Nandani's place in my life nor my heart.

She said "It doesn't matter to me. I love you and that's okay if you don't love me."

After the 20 year leap:

Karan blames Tanya for being the reason why Nandani didn't come to him.

She tells him:

I have told you that once Nandani comes back I will go away.

**Again it was Nandani's decision. Nandani pretended to be married to someone else for Tanya's happiness. What has Nandani in return gottten 😭 Taunts. Accusations.**

And I don't think she is dead. She will be alive and blame Nandani for pushing her off the cliff. And Nandani will accept the blame and this will take everyone away from her, except for Karan-Baa and possibly Bhoomi.

Originally posted by: desiflavour101

Yes, I was speaking of you :) (Cool_kitty23)

In the mega 3 episode, Karan told her this:

I love Nandani and will never forget about her, but I have a responsibility to you which I will always live up to and the family.

He didn't tell her he loves her because he cannot lie to her. You have to give him credit for that. He's always been honest about his feelings for Nandani. In return, he's gotten accusations only despite him being honest with Tanya.

If it was up to Karan, he would have left everything and had gone to Nandani but Nandani stopped him. Tanya knows this (she overheard them talking) and this is why her insecurity is there because she knows she is just an obligation to him.

In yesterday's episode, this is what she told Nandani:

-I was going to tell Karan about my pregnancy but you came out of the coma. So many nights where you had come between us two. Etc. Etc.

Now when she said this, in my perspective she is making Nandani guilty for coming out of the coma. Because of Nandani's reaction later...

"I am the pain of her life. Its all my fault." She was hysterical 😭😭

Despite Nandani having nothing to do with Tanya's lifes decisions.

And Tanya did know what she was getting herself into...

Nandani went to jail and Tanya came back to SN to live with Karan. Karan clearly told her:

I cannot give you Nandani's place in my life nor my heart.

She said "It doesn't matter to me. I love you and that's okay if you don't love me."

After the 20 year leap:

Karan blames Tanya for being the reason why Nandani didn't come to him.

She tells him:

I have told you that once Nandani comes back I will go away.

**Again it was Nandani's decision. Nandani pretended to be married to someone else for Tanya's happiness. What has Nandani in return gottten 😭 Taunts. Accusations.**

And I don't think she is dead. She will be alive and blame Nandani for pushing her off the cliff. And Nandani will accept the blame and this will take everyone away from her, except for Karan-Baa and possibly Bhoomi.

Bhoomi said to Tanya the other day dat she didn't become good mom, good wife etc. She was doing the NATAK of becoming good, so dat her mom could stay away from her own house. So Bhoomi will think dat it was Tanya's conspiracy. Then Tanya will lose KARAN and BHOOMI FOREVER!