Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

2k

Users

8

Likes

13

Frequent Posters

1098676 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
The makers should better stick to the original storyline of Fatmagul and not use their own brain otherwise they will ruin the show. Even if Fatmagul had a runtime of 90 minutes and the Indian remake has only 20 minutes, then also there shouldn't be any changes in the basic storyline. Let Amala take one year to forgive Abeer and another year to fall in love with him. If it's executed properly then it'll not feel dragging.
darkwarrior200 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: deepikagupta9

Chill juhi , I was only assuming , as I had not seen fatmagul.


its a remake. and remakes are not promising to follow each and every minute detail. its up to the maker. they r only compelled to follow the original plot so that the audience can accept it. its a fictional story they can do anything they want to. jab historics follow nahi kartey, yeh to phir bhi fictional hai🤣

so cant say lets wait and watch 😉
Shlroy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: angel_juhi04


It's that the show we love we don't want distorted. That's the reason many oeople who watched the original dont want to see the remake version. Remember what Ekta did to even Mahabharat. If the makers ruin this show them the original makers may due use them and in future no foreign show will let India remake their shows. This show will follow original just like 24😊.

I am in that section of people who have watched the original Turkish version and I am not even gonna try the Indian version. Not becoz Indian version can't be a success or will absolutely be ruined but becoz for me this story will always be about fatmagul, kerim and her struggles, his desperation to prove himself innocent in fg's eyes. I can't relate with amala or abeer.
I know its against human behavior becoz that curiosity get the best of everyone but people watching amala should watch it patiently and if they want to watch fatmagul then they should watch it from the beginning to the end and not just out of curiosity as to what's gonna happen in amala next becoz that takes away the surprise element.
My pov
OriginalJuhi_04 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Shlroy

I am in that section of people who have watched the original Turkish version and I am not even gonna try the Indian version. Not becoz Indian version can't be a success or will absolutely be ruined but becoz for me this story will always be about fatmagul, kerim and her struggles, his desperation to prove himself innocent in fg's eyes. I can't relate with amala or abeer.
I know its against human behavior becoz that curiosity get the best of everyone but people watching amala should watch it patiently and if they want to watch fatmagul then they should watch it from the beginning to the end and not just out of curiosity as to what's gonna happen in amala next becoz that takes away the surprise element.
My pov


You are right. I said the same that the makers will not show leap just to quicken Amala softening 2wards Abeer by skipping her depression, trauma and fight for justice process. Very less people are used to see heroines wrong rude and arrogant to the heroes even if they have reasons but they can see the other way round even if the heroes don't have any valid reasons. People are used to see heroine forgiving the heroes very quickly instead of giving them a hard time. I think Beintehaa was only the show in recent times where the heroine actually gave the hero a hard time and tbe hero having a proper redemption track.
Shlroy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: angel_juhi04


You are right. I said the same that the makers will not show leap just to quicken Amala softening 2wards Abeer by skipping her depression, trauma and fight for justice process. Very less people are used to see heroines wrong rude and arrogant to the heroes even if they have reasons but they can see the other way round even if the heroes don't have any valid reasons. People are used to see heroine forgiving the heroes very quickly instead of giving them a hard time. I think Beintehaa was only the show in recent times where the heroine actually gave the hero a hard time and tbe hero having a proper redemption track.

I honestly find this trend of Indian TV having arrogant, unapologetic, rude, ill mannered heroes being glorified and their female counterparts falling for them and forgiving them bizarre. I don't think this is at all real as not all men are like this and today's women will never forgive such kind of a man and they are not a doormat. That's why I love serials of other countries like America, UK, Turkey, South Korea... and many more where men are portrayed as they should be gentle, kind, chivalrous and treating woman right.
SilverBell thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: angel_juhi04

There will be no leap just to quicken Amala forgiving Abeer. We need to accept it that this show will follow only the original. Why can't a heroine be shown angry and rude with the hero? We need to accept that this show is not a regular Indian show but a remake of a popular Turkish show. If Amala is shown forgiving Abeer quickly through leaps how will her trauma and struggle be shown? Dear, its 1st a social issue show about fighting against injustice. Love Story is a secondary thing in this show. As for Abeer, not all heroes can be shown businessman. Both the hero and the heroine are middle class. We need to be patient if we have to watch this show properly. If the makers will distort the original then what's the difference between Fatmagul/KQHAK and other Indian shows? We need to just wait and watch and enjoy the show how it's shown. Amala can't be shown lovey dovey so early even through the leaps as it will ruin the story and make joke of rape victims. The show is remade by 24 Frames not Ekta, Gul or Rashmi who will deviate from the main plot and start showing nonsense. I think very less people accepts a female lead being angry and cold to the male lead even when she has a strong reason to do so while the male lead can be a jerk to the female for months and years for the stupidest reasons. Amala can't be shown like Pragya, Shivani(Ghulam), Zoya, Sanam or Anika to be back to old self very soon and forgive the hero easily. Amala thinks Abeer raped her for Gods sake. We need to enjoy this remake like it will be followed as original instead of wishing for something else. As for not stretching the show just because FG took 6 months to forgive him and more than a year to fall in love with him it's because FG was not any
love story but it was a secondary thing of the show. A rape victim takes years to be normal or never ever becomes norma
l so FG show was realistic. We ask for realistic shows but when its finally given even if as a remake of an abroad show we start losing patience and wanting something else.



😊 Well Said.
Patharsitara thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Shlroy

I honestly find this trend of Indian TV having arrogant, unapologetic, rude, ill mannered heroes being glorified and their female counterparts falling for them and forgiving them bizarre. I don't think this is at all real as not all men are like this and today's women will never forgive such kind of a man and they are not a doormat. That's why I love serials of other countries like America, UK, Turkey, South Korea... and many more where men are portrayed as they should be gentle, kind, chivalrous and treating woman right.

I don't agree that all Indian serial portrayed rude unapologetic heroes. Just people like to discuss those shows online that has rude heroes. They never join those forum of those shows which have good heroes.

And there were many shows portrayed nice heroes were trp topper.
Like diya and bati hum in which hero helped heroine to become ips. Balika badhu in which anandi second husband and her sasur were ideal man. Yrkkh in which husband and wife supported each other. Shakti I'm which husband standing up for kinnar. Swaragini In which Swara was loved by her husband unconditionally long time. Nauc in which nisha was loved by two men and both were decent. Dil se dil tak have good hero. Piya albela has idealistic hero.
There are many examples if I will go on. Just coz few shows which are made by ekta and gul have rude heroes but still have large fan following them whom to blame. They are not still trp topper.
So Indian viewers should not be judged by few shows. I also watch other countries shows especially korean. And I also can give example of shows which have rude heroes. So I hope everyone should stop blaming Indian viewers.
It's not like viewers prefer rude heroes. They prefer actors and character because story drama drag for long time.
It's unfortunate that serial run for infinite days so quality degrade and stupid things are showed. Otherwise max shows start on good storyline. Only problem is infinite timeline and channel greed to continue show for making money even if show story reach saturation point.
Shlroy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Patharsitara

I don't agree that all Indian serial portrayed rude unapologetic heroes. Just people like to discuss those shows online that has rude heroes. They never join those forum of those shows which have good heroes.

And there were many shows portrayed nice heroes were trp topper.
Like diya and bati hum in which hero helped heroine to become ips. Balika badhu in which anandi second husband and her sasur were ideal man. Yrkkh in which husband and wife supported each other. Shakti I'm which husband standing up for kinnar. Swaragini In which Swara was loved by her husband unconditionally long time. Nauc in which nisha was loved by two men and both were decent. Dil se dil tak have good hero. Piya albela has idealistic hero.
There are many examples if I will go on. Just coz few shows which are made by ekta and gul have rude heroes but still have large fan following them whom to blame. They are not still trp topper.
So Indian viewers should not be judged by few shows. I also watch other countries shows especially korean. And I also can give example of shows which have rude heroes. So I hope everyone should stop blaming Indian viewers.
It's not like viewers prefer rude heroes. They prefer actors and character because story drama drag for long time.
It's unfortunate that serial run for infinite days so quality degrade and stupid things are showed. Otherwise max shows start on good storyline. Only problem is infinite timeline and channel greed to continue show for making money even if show story reach saturation point.

Well I never said that all the male heroes in Indian TV are rude or chauvinist and neither did I claimed that Korean or other countries shows never had a rude male lead. The point is if its needed in the story then it should be there with valid explanation and consequences but its kind of become a trend in Indian TV to portray such male leads and most of the time they don't have any reason for it for doing so. So basically it feels overdone to watch again and again such a male lead.
Just my pov

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".