Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

The same old bahu

  • October 7, 2012
  • By Nayare Ali
The same old bahu

Ho! Hum! Yet another dreary week in the world of soaps. In the serial, Love Marriage ya Arranged Marriage, the saasu ma is a control freak who wants the bahus to dance to her tunes. When the younger bahu steps out to work on the sly, she is issued an ultimatum — stay indoors and serve saasu ma or get out with hubby and never return. Now what would a sensible new-age girl do, opt for the latter, right? But then how will a show that feeds on dated values

garner TRPs from India's heartland? So, the bahu consults her parents, who hide their financial hardships and insist that she quit working and slave at saasu ma's feet. Regressive? The message that women should stay at home is further reinforced in Diya Aur Baati Hum, where the well-educated protagonist yearns to study further and even saves her domestic help from being blown up by her bomb. And what does she get in return? A saasu ma who fusses over her, but clearly adds salt and not just haldi to her wounds by softly muttering that she prefers her bahu to utilise her intelligence within the four walls of their home.

And of course these simpering and cloying sweet women dutifully bend their heads and agree. Where's the fire or the spirit to fight back? There is surely nothing wrong in being traditional or a homemaker if that's what the character desires, but to force women to a life of domesticity and reinforce this message through dominating mother-in-laws is surely not benefitting those women who deal with such battles everyday.

Not just this, in Kya Hua Tera Waada, the pendulum swings to the other extreme, where the over zealous in-laws want to get their wronged daughter-in-law married. Sure, they deserve brownie points for this decision but they don't care about the fact that the divorce papers are not yet signed. Their ex-bahu-turned beti gets the papers on her engagement day. And yes, the marriage is over, but the lady carps about her mangalsutra in a dreary monologue and frankly deserves two tight slaps! So it's left to ex-mum-in-law to plead her to remove her mangalsutra minutes before another engagement ring is slipped onto her finger. Regressive? Because the character is made to feel guilty about opting for a remarriage; what's worse, she is not ready for this new relationship. But her needs are trampled upon by the channel that wants to project its evolved stance. Female characters continue to be either shrews or spineless!

Where is the middle path?.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.7k

Users

9

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

swethasyam08 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
thanks for sharing Tanu!!

this article spoke our hearts out! really the track is becoming so... 🤢
aisha2080 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Totally agree what has been written about KHTV! I wonder why they portray Mona like this? Are the makers of KHTV so desperate to prolong the story? Or what? 😕
shanti05 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Thanks for sharing Tanu,

They r showing Mona pretty weak & oscillating deciding what she wishes in life..
The Mangalsutra & Sindoor is a part of her life Till her HUSBAND was keeping her TRUST. She was going through the divorce and that was the time she should have put aside that phase for her own dignity .. Well wonder what is in store next the show is weaking in the phase of showing some change and bringing the women to be shown rooted ..in seeing new phase of life .. The viewers are watching a show to see a new side of life but if they gives the same package and glorify things which are not to be what can be done critically read such things
rtms thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
thanks for sharing the article Tanu👍🏼.
nice to read wt v all were voicing👏.its high time for the makers to do some thing progressive if they want to survive.
blyton thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Totally agree with what the article said, not just about KHTV but about the other two shows.

..."the lady carps about her mangalsutra in a dreary monologue and frankly deserves two tight slaps!" Just took the words right out of my mouth.
seemasr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Nicely put Armu.
I wonder in almost all serials they are portrying women characters as spineless,too coy and adjusting which s sometime difficult in practical life.
As far as i remember i saw a serial called Udaan (in National channel) where they shown some positive things about a woman.Since then i have not seen same type of potential in any other serial character( I watch very less serials though)
ranjnanarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
This article ia bang on ans such state of women on Indian TV shows the putrid mind set of the makers.

The problem is the there are a lot of regressive people in this country who does not tolerate a strong women pratigonist which is a sad stae of affairs in a country which wants to call itself progressive.

Mentioning Dia aur Baati gosh how can this show enjoy the highest TRP is something which baffles me. I mean how regressive can our audience get.

About potrayal of Mona I have nothing to say this is a total spine less character. I mean still Sandhaya is adjusting to circumstances and is not regressive herself. She has resorted ot the fact that she cannot do anything in life but her thought process has not changed here this women is too much she has no self respect she is not seeing what a jackass her husband is. I mean it was still okay to try to adjust with a man if he is faithful and is doing his duty for you but this guy is neither and still she is crying over 12 years. Such a regressive thought process has forced me to stop watching this show.
summer7 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ranjnanarang

This article ia bang on ans such state of women on Indian TV shows the putrid mind set of the makers.


The problem is the there are a lot of regressive people in this country who does not tolerate a strong women pratigonist which is a sad stae of affairs in a country which wants to call itself progressive.

Mentioning Dia aur Baati gosh how can this show enjoy the highest TRP is something which baffles me. I mean how regressive can our audience get.

About potrayal of Mona I have nothing to say this is a total spine less character. I mean still Sandhaya is adjusting to circumstances and is not regressive herself. She has resorted ot the fact that she cannot do anything in life but her thought process has not changed here this women is too much she has no self respect she is not seeing what a jackass her husband is. I mean it was still okay to try to adjust with a man if he is faithful and is doing his duty for you but this guy is neither and still she is crying over 12 years. Such a regressive thought process has forced me to stop watching this show.


Yes, so regressive. And today's episode really was apalling...really showed us what Mona is, seems that the message the makers are sending out is - once a housewife, always a housewife... Why was she serving tea at the meeting? Is she at her house, hosting a tea or dinner party? If you noticed, she asks the peon to leave and actually offers to serve the tea! And she impressed the client with her home-cooked food???? Really?! Not with her professional skills,but her cooking skills! Shame on her! Or the makers of this show! So much for being VP (or President, whatever her designation is!)
Thanks CVs, for showing us Indian women our place!
ranjnanarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mitki


Yes, so regressive. And today's episode really was apalling...really showed us what Mona is, seems that the message the makers are sending out is - once a housewife, always a housewife... Why was she serving tea at the meeting? Is she at her house, hosting a tea or dinner party? If you noticed, she asks the peon to leave and actually offers to serve the tea! And she impressed the client with her home-cooked food???? Really?! Not with her professional skills,but her cooking skills! Shame on her! Or the makers of this show! So much for being VP (or President, whatever her designation is!)
Thanks CVs, for showing us Indian women our place!


That's the reason I have stopped watching this show. Seriously I have nothing against women being goof home makers and impressing people with their cooking and hospitable nature. I love doing this myself but then this is not the end of a woman. I read the update was happy that I have quit watching this.

Mona is being irrational on all accords and that's what is irritating me to the core about this show.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".