September Rishabh Discussion Thread - Page 2

Originally posted by: ws_loki

Soooo, Rishabh tells Arjun that he has no idea about Arjun's personal life.

Wah bhai wah, Rishabh Luthra, the businessman of the year recipient is going to enter into a business partnership without doing any background check on his future partner?

Didn't he ask his manager/assistant to do a background check on Arjun? Abhi tak report nahin mila?

Was it the same guy who was entrusted with the background check of Prithvi which we never got to see?

Plus the school cctv footage jiskay liye Rishabh was so hyper about is all forgotten.

Arjun or Anjali are not going to mention he is engaged to Nidhi, how convenient.

Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice........NOT😡

He even wanted to do bkg check on prithvi those days, remember.🤣🤣

Originally posted by: urmita

This is the Rishabh Luthra who being a good boy stood , watched and played referee, while Preeta fake-fought with Karan which led to flirt and love and the whole drama and Rishabh still hasn't told Preeta he loves her...this is also the Rishabh who got someone to background check Prithvi and didnt get the reports...same person who didnt know for so long that his fiance and then wife Sharlyn is a cheat, she was always another man's gf and wife...ofcourse he didnt do background chk on Arjun and forgot the footage...🤪

Satyavachan 🤣🤣👍👍

Part of rishab's miseries is his too much of a good boy with eyes closed🤣🤣🤣

Can't identify the red flags easily

Unable to confess his feelings was the biggest blunder 😭😭

But now he might as he learnt from his past mistakes.

We might get a drunk confession during his heartbreak 💔😭

Writer purposely didn't reveal rishab 's feelings to preeta before she falls for karan

Coz she would have chosen him instead 🤣🤣

It was deliberately done to pave way for preeran.

Any sane woman would chose rishab over karan anytime anyday.

Even now his feelings will be revealed only after preeran unites or will never be.

Again to pave way for preeran

So that preeta won't chose him over karan 🤣🤣

These are the dirty games the writer playing with rishab shippers that so much so they are pissed and wants him to be removed from that triangle finding new love.

And they are not wrong.

The writer messed up rishab real bad.😭

Originally posted by: Aniash

Satyavachan 🤣🤣👍👍

Part of rishab's miseries is his too much of a good boy with eyes closed🤣🤣🤣

Can't identify the red flags easily

Unable to confess his feelings was the biggest blunder 😭😭

But now he might as he learnt from his past mistakes.

We might get a drunk confession during his heartbreak 💔😭

Writer purposely didn't reveal rishab 's feelings to preeta before she falls for karan

Coz she would have chosen him instead 🤣🤣

It was deliberately done to pave way for preeran.

Any sane woman would chose rishab over karan anytime anyday.

Even now his feelings will be revealed only after preeran unites or will never be.

Again to pave way for preeran

So that preeta won't chose him over karan 🤣🤣

These are the dirty games the writer playing with rishab shippers that so much so they are pissed and wants him to be removed from that triangle finding new love.

And they are not wrong.

The writer messed up rishab real bad.😭

I havent watched the show regularly over the years...but in initial days I used to watch clips in youtube and if I am not wrong I remember the turning point where it became clear from now on Preeta will start getting closer to Karan and choose him...the first time she got arrested for something wrong at some party? that was probably the first and only time when Rishabh remained silent and let others accuse Preeta and her family and was too late in thinking he should try to help her...too late to go visit her...and that was also the first and one of the very few times TKL went against everyone and sided with Preeta and got her out of trouble....before that point it was balanced...Preeta liked Rishabh and genuinely disliked Karan...after that point Preeta started liking karan and the genuine anger became nokjhok....and though she was her usual respectful self with Rishabh and he swore he would always side with her from now on(and kept the promise since then) from that point on it became clear atleast to me that the choice has been made, makers have just made sure preeta will never love Rishabh that way and its Preeran they are after...

and after that I dont know all tracks but I know whatever happened they made sure Rishabh was the one watching from outside and being frustratingly silent about what he wants while Preeta and Karan are doing all their love drama melodrama whatever over the yrs...they always were very careful not to write anything good for Rishabh and ignore him...

Originally posted by: urmita

I would say they didn't mess up..in order to mess him up they would have to build his character good first...they never really wrote anything meaty for him, never built his character properly...

I havent watched the show regularly over the years...but in initial days I used to watch clips in youtube and if I am not wrong I remember the turning point where it became clear from now on Preeta will start getting closer to Karan and choose him...the first time she got arrested for something wrong at some party? that was probably the first and only time when Rishabh remained silent and let others accuse Preeta and her family and was too late in thinking he should try to help her...too late to go visit her...and that was also the first and one of the very few times TKL went against everyone and sided with Preeta and got her out of trouble....before that point it was balanced...Preeta liked Rishabh and genuinely disliked Karan...after that point Preeta started liking karan and the genuine anger became nokjhok....and though she was her usual respectful self with Rishabh and he swore he would always side with her from now on(and kept the promise since then) from that point on it became clear atleast to me that the choice has been made, makers have just made sure preeta will never love Rishabh that way and its Preeran they are after...

and after that I dont know all tracks but I know whatever happened they made sure Rishabh was the one watching from outside and being frustratingly silent about what he wants while Preeta and Karan are doing all their love drama melodrama whatever over the yrs...they always were very careful not to write anything good for Rishabh and ignore him...

They messed him by making him too selfless and sometimes bowing to the family demands.

That's why there were times he couldn't support preeta

I followed loyally for three yrs then regretted 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab preeta story was built initially quite well. Despite running into karan first, her friendship started with rishab .

Karan was rude rishab was polite. Karan a manchild rishab matured.

That was showed initially

From preeran nok jok we already knew their story will come first. Then only rishab and preeta.

In the the forum we already predicted she will marry both 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab supported her well initially but at times due to family pressure he stepped back . That was hardly once or twice.

He only doubted on her once for mahesh's accident then repented for not trusting her. Karan doubted numerous times 🤣🤣🤣

No repentance and redemption.

Comparatively with karan, rishab stood by her more in that past three years that i followed. After that i gave up so don't know how they went about with the storyline.

When karan married preeta out of revenge he told rishab firmly don't interfere. Rishab obeyed. That is the annoying thing about him

He sometimes gives in to his family.

There was a time preeta was jailed. And rishab cancelled his canada flight to rescue her while karan was busy feeding mahira at the hospital.

First rishab helped . Then only karan did. Coz it took him time to trust preeta.

This is why some people couldn't connect to preeran due to karan not trusting her

What amuses me is that this is fiction. But in reality if we put ourselves in preeta 's place will we accept karan or rishab as life partner??

This is the question that i ask myself and to all those who still shipped preeran after what preeta was put through.

Is chemistry and nok jok everything about them?.

I ask myself looking at those delusional fan girls on SM supporting preeran calling rishab a villain.

Will they prefer a man like karan in real life also?

Sometimes fictions can be connected to reality.

It speaks about characters and how we accept them

The initial story indicated preeran first then rishta. And it happened that way. Now when karan 's revelations are out , what would be preeta's reaction. She's married now to rishab. Earlier she wasn't. There's a difference.

If preeran unites after revelations, what will be left in rhe story then

As much as there is this hyoe that preeran is endgame and rishab gonna have a heartbreak, it could also be that preeta would have a change of heart

Perhaps she may not feel the same for Karan now

There will be many twists and turns.

Still early to conclude preeran as endgame.

Episodes in August portrayed preeta trying to appreciate rishab. She's taking the step towards him gradually. We feel will pave for rishab's heartbreak later on

But we don't know what writers have in mind this time.

Coz Preeta is not single. She's married to rishab.

Earlier she was not married to him. Does make a difference.

In award functions they promote a certain jodi but at the end of the day it's the trp that matters more

Just becoz they promoted preejun doesn't indicate them as endgame. It's still early. The ratings will decide.

If audience retaliate then they will go for rishta as the couple with karan still pining for preeta tortured by Nidhi and anjali.

If viewers accept preeran then they will remove rishab and start his journey separately.

If manit decides to leave. Rishab will be killed or replaced. Highly likely replacement coz kundali runs on the triangle. Preeran alone can't handle.

They need rishab as the third angle.

As for me i hope he moves on and finds new love. He definitely deserves better for the gem he is. Preeta is just not the right woman for him.

That old preeta is gone. This latest one is turned obsessive and selfish that i just can't connect to her any longer. Better she just stick to Karan only.

Preeran will look great if both changes. Karan being more matured and preeta stop being a busy body trying to save the world.

And rishab should go solo and chill

Perhaps becomes a rockstar 😎😎

That guy has the personality😎😎

I can't imagine manit in punk hairstyle with earrings. 🤣🤣🤣

Ps

Anshvi kriti and vir how are u doing.

Don't tell me u ran away🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Aniash

They messed him by making him too selfless and sometimes bowing to the family demands.

That's why there were times he couldn't support preeta

I followed loyally for three yrs then regretted 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab preeta story was built initially quite well. Despite running into karan first, her friendship started with rishab .

Karan was rude rishab was polite. Karan a manchild rishab matured.

That was showed initially

From preeran nok jok we already knew their story will come first. Then only rishab and preeta.

In the the forum we already predicted she will marry both 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab supported her well initially but at times due to family pressure he stepped back . That was hardly once or twice.

He only doubted on her once for mahesh's accident then repented for not trusting her. Karan doubted numerous times 🤣🤣🤣

No repentance and redemption.

Comparatively with karan, rishab stood by her more in that past three years that i followed. After that i gave up so don't know how they went about with the storyline.

When karan married preeta out of revenge he told rishab firmly don't interfere. Rishab obeyed. That is the annoying thing about him

He sometimes gives in to his family.

There was a time preeta was jailed. And rishab cancelled his canada flight to rescue her while karan was busy feeding mahira at the hospital.

First rishab helped . Then only karan did. Coz it took him time to trust preeta.

This is why some people couldn't connect to preeran due to karan not trusting her

What amuses me is that this is fiction. But in reality if we put ourselves in preeta 's place will we accept karan or rishab as life partner??

This is the question that i ask myself and to all those who still shipped preeran after what preeta was put through.

Is chemistry and nok jok everything about them?.

I ask myself looking at those delusional fan girls on SM supporting preeran calling rishab a villain.

Will they prefer a man like karan in real life also?

Sometimes fictions can be connected to reality.

It speaks about characters and how we accept them

The initial story indicated preeran first then rishta. And it happened that way. Now when karan 's revelations are out , what would be preeta's reaction. She's married now to rishab. Earlier she wasn't. There's a difference.

If preeran unites after revelations, what will be left in rhe story then

As much as there is this hyoe that preeran is endgame and rishab gonna have a heartbreak, it could also be that preeta would have a change of heart

Perhaps she may not feel the same for Karan now

There will be many twists and turns.

Still early to conclude preeran as endgame.

Episodes in August portrayed preeta trying to appreciate rishab. She's taking the step towards him gradually. We feel will pave for rishab's heartbreak later on

But we don't know what writers have in mind this time.

Coz Preeta is not single. She's married to rishab.

Earlier she was not married to him. Does make a difference.

In award functions they promote a certain jodi but at the end of the day it's the trp that matters more

Just becoz they promoted preejun doesn't indicate them as endgame. It's still early. The ratings will decide.

If audience retaliate then they will go for rishta as the couple with karan still pining for preeta tortured by Nidhi and anjali.

If viewers accept preeran then they will remove rishab and start his journey separately.

If manit decides to leave. Rishab will be killed or replaced. Highly likely replacement coz kundali runs on the triangle. Preeran alone can't handle.

They need rishab as the third angle.

As for me i hope he moves on and finds new love. He definitely deserves better for the gem he is. Preeta is just not the right woman for him.

That old preeta is gone. This latest one is turned obsessive and selfish that i just can't connect to her any longer. Better she just stick to Karan only.

Preeran will look great if both changes. Karan being more matured and preeta stop being a busy body trying to save the world.

And rishab should go solo and chill

Perhaps becomes a rockstar 😎😎

That guy has the personality😎😎

I can't imagine manit in punk hairstyle with earrings. 🤣🤣🤣

Ps

Anshvi kriti and vir how are u doing.

Don't tell me u ran away🤣🤣

Loved ur heartfelt post on Rishabh. I really like his soft, caring nature. For someone who is NOT Preeta, the home would be where Rishabh is. ❤️ I think even in the real world, subtle caring gestures often get missed out. Don't know why storytelling art does not encourage soft-spoken, positive persona and sweetly smiling people as attractive.

Originally posted by: InaMeenaDika

Loved ur heartfelt post on Rishabh. I really like his soft, caring nature. For someone who is NOT Preeta, the home would be where Rishabh is. ❤️ I think even in the real world, subtle caring gestures often get missed out. Don't know why storytelling art does not encourage soft-spoken, positive persona and sweetly smiling people as attractive.

Because they want high end drama for trps and only toxic ones gives them.

But lately it's been a trend. People are bored. They want changes.

That's why rishab is getting votes🤣🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Aniash

They messed him by making him too selfless and sometimes bowing to the family demands.

That's why there were times he couldn't support preeta

I followed loyally for three yrs then regretted 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab preeta story was built initially quite well. Despite running into karan first, her friendship started with rishab .

Karan was rude rishab was polite. Karan a manchild rishab matured.

That was showed initially

From preeran nok jok we already knew their story will come first. Then only rishab and preeta.

In the the forum we already predicted she will marry both 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab supported her well initially but at times due to family pressure he stepped back . That was hardly once or twice.

He only doubted on her once for mahesh's accident then repented for not trusting her. Karan doubted numerous times 🤣🤣🤣

No repentance and redemption.

Comparatively with karan, rishab stood by her more in that past three years that i followed. After that i gave up so don't know how they went about with the storyline.

When karan married preeta out of revenge he told rishab firmly don't interfere. Rishab obeyed. That is the annoying thing about him

He sometimes gives in to his family.

There was a time preeta was jailed. And rishab cancelled his canada flight to rescue her while karan was busy feeding mahira at the hospital.

First rishab helped . Then only karan did. Coz it took him time to trust preeta.

This is why some people couldn't connect to preeran due to karan not trusting her

What amuses me is that this is fiction. But in reality if we put ourselves in preeta 's place will we accept karan or rishab as life partner??

This is the question that i ask myself and to all those who still shipped preeran after what preeta was put through.

Is chemistry and nok jok everything about them?.

I ask myself looking at those delusional fan girls on SM supporting preeran calling rishab a villain.

Will they prefer a man like karan in real life also?

Sometimes fictions can be connected to reality.

It speaks about characters and how we accept them

The initial story indicated preeran first then rishta. And it happened that way. Now when karan 's revelations are out , what would be preeta's reaction. She's married now to rishab. Earlier she wasn't. There's a difference.

If preeran unites after revelations, what will be left in rhe story then

As much as there is this hyoe that preeran is endgame and rishab gonna have a heartbreak, it could also be that preeta would have a change of heart

Perhaps she may not feel the same for Karan now

There will be many twists and turns.

Still early to conclude preeran as endgame.

Episodes in August portrayed preeta trying to appreciate rishab. She's taking the step towards him gradually. We feel will pave for rishab's heartbreak later on

But we don't know what writers have in mind this time.

Coz Preeta is not single. She's married to rishab.

Earlier she was not married to him. Does make a difference.

In award functions they promote a certain jodi but at the end of the day it's the trp that matters more

Just becoz they promoted preejun doesn't indicate them as endgame. It's still early. The ratings will decide.

If audience retaliate then they will go for rishta as the couple with karan still pining for preeta tortured by Nidhi and anjali.

If viewers accept preeran then they will remove rishab and start his journey separately.

If manit decides to leave. Rishab will be killed or replaced. Highly likely replacement coz kundali runs on the triangle. Preeran alone can't handle.

They need rishab as the third angle.

As for me i hope he moves on and finds new love. He definitely deserves better for the gem he is. Preeta is just not the right woman for him.

That old preeta is gone. This latest one is turned obsessive and selfish that i just can't connect to her any longer. Better she just stick to Karan only.

Preeran will look great if both changes. Karan being more matured and preeta stop being a busy body trying to save the world.

And rishab should go solo and chill

Perhaps becomes a rockstar 😎😎

That guy has the personality😎😎

I can't imagine manit in punk hairstyle with earrings. 🤣🤣🤣

Ps

Anshvi kriti and vir how are u doing.

Don't tell me u ran away🤣🤣

Hehehehe. I actually have stopped watching and reading updates coz I was fed up with their dragging and lack of importance of Rishabh 😆

Originally posted by: anshvi

Hehehehe. I actually have stopped watching and reading updates coz I was fed up with their dragging and lack of importance of Rishabh 😆

Good to hear from u😍😍

Same here

Left onscreen a month ago

And updates since a week 🤣🤣

Too much dragging.

And prithvi is back 🤣🤣🤣

Same old story.

Functions and not more.

Originally posted by: Aniash

They messed him by making him too selfless and sometimes bowing to the family demands.

That's why there were times he couldn't support preeta

I followed loyally for three yrs then regretted 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab preeta story was built initially quite well. Despite running into karan first, her friendship started with rishab .

Karan was rude rishab was polite. Karan a manchild rishab matured.

That was showed initially

From preeran nok jok we already knew their story will come first. Then only rishab and preeta.

In the the forum we already predicted she will marry both 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab supported her well initially but at times due to family pressure he stepped back . That was hardly once or twice.

He only doubted on her once for mahesh's accident then repented for not trusting her. Karan doubted numerous times 🤣🤣🤣

No repentance and redemption.

Comparatively with karan, rishab stood by her more in that past three years that i followed. After that i gave up so don't know how they went about with the storyline.

When karan married preeta out of revenge he told rishab firmly don't interfere. Rishab obeyed. That is the annoying thing about him

He sometimes gives in to his family.

There was a time preeta was jailed. And rishab cancelled his canada flight to rescue her while karan was busy feeding mahira at the hospital.

First rishab helped . Then only karan did. Coz it took him time to trust preeta.

This is why some people couldn't connect to preeran due to karan not trusting her

What amuses me is that this is fiction. But in reality if we put ourselves in preeta 's place will we accept karan or rishab as life partner??

This is the question that i ask myself and to all those who still shipped preeran after what preeta was put through.

Is chemistry and nok jok everything about them?.

I ask myself looking at those delusional fan girls on SM supporting preeran calling rishab a villain.

Will they prefer a man like karan in real life also?

Sometimes fictions can be connected to reality.

It speaks about characters and how we accept them

The initial story indicated preeran first then rishta. And it happened that way. Now when karan 's revelations are out , what would be preeta's reaction. She's married now to rishab. Earlier she wasn't. There's a difference.

If preeran unites after revelations, what will be left in rhe story then

As much as there is this hyoe that preeran is endgame and rishab gonna have a heartbreak, it could also be that preeta would have a change of heart

Perhaps she may not feel the same for Karan now

There will be many twists and turns.

Still early to conclude preeran as endgame.

Episodes in August portrayed preeta trying to appreciate rishab. She's taking the step towards him gradually. We feel will pave for rishab's heartbreak later on

But we don't know what writers have in mind this time.

Coz Preeta is not single. She's married to rishab.

Earlier she was not married to him. Does make a difference.

In award functions they promote a certain jodi but at the end of the day it's the trp that matters more

Just becoz they promoted preejun doesn't indicate them as endgame. It's still early. The ratings will decide.

If audience retaliate then they will go for rishta as the couple with karan still pining for preeta tortured by Nidhi and anjali.

If viewers accept preeran then they will remove rishab and start his journey separately.

If manit decides to leave. Rishab will be killed or replaced. Highly likely replacement coz kundali runs on the triangle. Preeran alone can't handle.

They need rishab as the third angle.

As for me i hope he moves on and finds new love. He definitely deserves better for the gem he is. Preeta is just not the right woman for him.

That old preeta is gone. This latest one is turned obsessive and selfish that i just can't connect to her any longer. Better she just stick to Karan only.

Preeran will look great if both changes. Karan being more matured and preeta stop being a busy body trying to save the world.

And rishab should go solo and chill

Perhaps becomes a rockstar 😎😎

That guy has the personality😎😎

I can't imagine manit in punk hairstyle with earrings. 🤣🤣🤣

Ps

Anshvi kriti and vir how are u doing.

Don't tell me u ran away🤣🤣

💯💯💯

THIS!!!!!!

you’ve summed it up so well. Preeran aren’t just toxic, they’re unbearable together. At least for me. That’s why I could never connect with them no matter the nok jhok and stuff. I’ve always been drawn to Rishab’s silent yet strong person. I like people that are level headed. He’s AMAZING!!!!! I will always love him.

But I’m really really really fed up with the slowpoke growth in the story and how the writers generally handle RishTa.

Originally posted by: Aniash

They messed him by making him too selfless and sometimes bowing to the family demands.

That's why there were times he couldn't support preeta

I followed loyally for three yrs then regretted 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab preeta story was built initially quite well. Despite running into karan first, her friendship started with rishab .

Karan was rude rishab was polite. Karan a manchild rishab matured.

That was showed initially

From preeran nok jok we already knew their story will come first. Then only rishab and preeta.

In the the forum we already predicted she will marry both 🤣🤣🤣

Rishab supported her well initially but at times due to family pressure he stepped back . That was hardly once or twice.

He only doubted on her once for mahesh's accident then repented for not trusting her. Karan doubted numerous times 🤣🤣🤣

No repentance and redemption.

Comparatively with karan, rishab stood by her more in that past three years that i followed. After that i gave up so don't know how they went about with the storyline.

When karan married preeta out of revenge he told rishab firmly don't interfere. Rishab obeyed. That is the annoying thing about him

He sometimes gives in to his family.

There was a time preeta was jailed. And rishab cancelled his canada flight to rescue her while karan was busy feeding mahira at the hospital.

First rishab helped . Then only karan did. Coz it took him time to trust preeta.

This is why some people couldn't connect to preeran due to karan not trusting her

What amuses me is that this is fiction. But in reality if we put ourselves in preeta 's place will we accept karan or rishab as life partner??

This is the question that i ask myself and to all those who still shipped preeran after what preeta was put through.

Is chemistry and nok jok everything about them?.

I ask myself looking at those delusional fan girls on SM supporting preeran calling rishab a villain.

Will they prefer a man like karan in real life also?

Sometimes fictions can be connected to reality.

It speaks about characters and how we accept them

The initial story indicated preeran first then rishta. And it happened that way. Now when karan 's revelations are out , what would be preeta's reaction. She's married now to rishab. Earlier she wasn't. There's a difference.

If preeran unites after revelations, what will be left in rhe story then

As much as there is this hyoe that preeran is endgame and rishab gonna have a heartbreak, it could also be that preeta would have a change of heart

Perhaps she may not feel the same for Karan now

There will be many twists and turns.

Still early to conclude preeran as endgame.

Episodes in August portrayed preeta trying to appreciate rishab. She's taking the step towards him gradually. We feel will pave for rishab's heartbreak later on

But we don't know what writers have in mind this time.

Coz Preeta is not single. She's married to rishab.

Earlier she was not married to him. Does make a difference.

In award functions they promote a certain jodi but at the end of the day it's the trp that matters more

Just becoz they promoted preejun doesn't indicate them as endgame. It's still early. The ratings will decide.

If audience retaliate then they will go for rishta as the couple with karan still pining for preeta tortured by Nidhi and anjali.

If viewers accept preeran then they will remove rishab and start his journey separately.

If manit decides to leave. Rishab will be killed or replaced. Highly likely replacement coz kundali runs on the triangle. Preeran alone can't handle.

They need rishab as the third angle.

As for me i hope he moves on and finds new love. He definitely deserves better for the gem he is. Preeta is just not the right woman for him.

That old preeta is gone. This latest one is turned obsessive and selfish that i just can't connect to her any longer. Better she just stick to Karan only.

Preeran will look great if both changes. Karan being more matured and preeta stop being a busy body trying to save the world.

And rishab should go solo and chill

Perhaps becomes a rockstar 😎😎

That guy has the personality😎😎

I can't imagine manit in punk hairstyle with earrings. 🤣🤣🤣

Ps

Anshvi kriti and vir how are u doing.

Don't tell me u ran away🤣🤣

ya Rishabh did a lot for Preeta for everyone but they made him so selfless he came across like a do-gooder doing samaj seva and not a man doing something for the woman he loves...I mean yeah we know he loves preeta coz we were specifically told that, thats why people became Rishta fans but unlike viewers Preeta didnt see this, he was always too nice to express he wants her...to her he came across a real nice friend doing something nice without asking anything in return...He was written too respectful, too selfless, too shy, too nice...Chicks do not dig too nice...In tv world the goody goody boys never get the girl, they become bestie and see the girl fall for someone else...and that is exactly what happened...They never wrote Rishabh such a way that he would be any real competition for karan...mainly coz he was always too selfless to want someone or something for himself and get it...

Karan on the other hand was shown reacting always...mostly reacting wrong but reacting anyways...not being a good Samaritan at all and going after what he wants...be it loving Preeta, or saving her, or being jerk to her or throwing her out or doing anything good or bad or worst...I guess this made sure Preeta or anyone cud never take him for granted, while Rishabh's character sketch made sure everyone took him for granted always...

In real world though girls would choose neither brothers...Guy like Rishabh would make you feel he is some mahaan devta, too good for you, you would find urself unable to form any personal connection with him...girls absolutely hate is if her man all cool seeing her close to another guy, if he is not little bit jealous insecure immature it makes u think they don't care deeply...

Guy like Karan on the other hand would probably make u want to murder him...he would be too immature, too insecure, too much jerk, make you want to murder him and you would divorce him soon...

So in real life both are bad choice...