What if it is all Karan's plan? - Page 4

Originally posted by: RishabhXPreeta

Depend karega ke plan kya hai ya phir tha? And exactly kis tarah se dikhaya jaata hai? Even hypothetically ye sawal ka jawab iss waqt dena is very hard. What if wo mar ke wapis aajaye?

So you think death will redeem him? 😳

Originally posted by: TheM5393

So you think death will redeem him? 😳

but thats not possible before the last episode.

Originally posted by: Rosalinesak

Nowadays, Karan Luthra looks more evil, woman beater and psycho with bipolar disorders who needs to be taken to a psychiatrist before he kills Preeta which would be irredeemable.

I’ll be more happy that Mahesh Luthra sends Preeta to her home after he comes out of coma and helps Sarla in finding a suitable boy for Preeta.

I’m not into bhabhi marrying jethji Rishab.

I completely understand your feelings that you don't want Preeta and Rishabh to end up together. However, that is another topic of discussion.😆 Considering you have called Karan Luthra Evil, I'll assume that even if it was a plan you would not deem him redeemable?

Originally posted by: _Runa_

He is redeemable if he realises what he has done. If Preeta is ready to forgive him then why I shouldn't.

I might forgive even Sherlyn or Mahira once they realise that they have done awful things and become good characters.

I can forgive even real person if he is truly repenting. And these all are fictional characters only. Don't see any problem here.

That makes sense! If and when he appologises for his actions than sure. Do you believe it is within his personality to ask for for forgiveness?

Originally posted by: an_am

but thats not possible before the last episode.

Not if he pulls a Mihir Virani out of the hat.🤣

Originally posted by: TheM5393

That makes sense! If and when he appologises for his actions than sure. Do you believe it is within his personality to ask for for forgiveness?

I think that he can apologize if he truly realises and repents. He did it once at the bachelor party. That time it wasn't even a big thing.

I believe that apology itself could be done not only by words but by actions as well. Especially, by actions. Depends on the situation, the mistake itself and the type of relationship between the two people.

Originally posted by: _Runa_

I think that he can apologize if he truly realises and repents. He did it once at the bachelor party. That time it wasn't even a big thing.

I believe that apology itself could be done not only by words but by actions as well. Especially, by actions. Depends on the situation, the mistake itself and the type of relationship between the two people.

If words aren't the medium of apology and it is only actions than that is repentense and not an apology. The assumption of the hypothesis was that it is his plan and whether or not you would deem it enough for him to be redeemable?

Originally posted by: TheM5393

If words aren't the medium of apology and it is only actions than that is repentense and not an apology. The assumption of the hypothesis was that it is his plan and whether or not you would deem it enough for him to be redeemable?

the consequences of his plan will be serious enough to give him an agonizing pain for lifetime. he is punishing himself. he clearly knows that no apology will be enough for what he did to preeta.

Originally posted by: TheM5393

I wanted to know whether or not you would believe he was redeemable if it was a plan. 😆 That was a lot of what other people will say and think and do. Nevertheless, thank you for your opinion. Much appreciated. 😃

I honestly don't know. Which is why I generalized the whole thing. I do believe in forgiveness but Whether he is redeemable or not depends on what all he does in the redemption track and to what extent he goes I guess. So maybe I'll have a clear opinion on whether he is redeemed or not after the redemption track gets over I guess? If you get what I mean

Originally posted by: TheM5393

If words aren't the medium of apology and it is only actions than that is repentense and not an apology. The assumption of the hypothesis was that it is his plan and whether or not you would deem it enough for him to be redeemable?

I guess here I have my language problem again🙈

I even looked into the vocabulary what is the definition of the word "apology". And you are right that apology should be done by words. They say so.

In Russian language we use the word "apology" a bit wider. So it's my mistake, sorry

What I meant is that sometimes there is no need for the words as actions say a lot more. As I said it depends on the situation and people. Sometimes there could be words, sometimes could be actions and sometimes both should be done.

I believe Karan will do both at one point.

@bold - what is the plan? When did he start to execute it? What is he going to do?