Mina Show - Reactions Jan 2/17 (Ep 747)

-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Jan 2/17 Reactions - Episode 747 aka "When Purab Says He Loves Nikita"

What is Mina Show?
When I watch an episode and react with random comments/recaps moments that struck my attention

Can I comment?
While I am watching the episode, the thread has "Res" for a title, and I would ask for no comments then please so that all of my reactions can flow together. After that yes of course you can comment 😊

DISCLAIMER
Please keep in mind that what I'm posting here are instant reactions, not deeply reasoned thoughts. I'm not looking to start a debate, just sharing my reactions. You're welcome to agree or disagree but I'm not likely to respond with a detailed defense to any particular argument against a comment in the live reactions. At the same time, I am entirely likely to ramble endlessly with philosophical expansions on a live reaction from time to time 😉
Edited by -mina- - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.1k

Users

6

Likes

87

Frequent Posters

-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Aaliya encouraging Abhi to think he has a right to question Nikita is so annoyinggg.
Abhi asks Pragya to tell him the truth and says he'll support her if he just hears it from her mouth, he'll stand up for her character. OH!! I think I am supposed to be impressed. I am a little. I forget context entirely.

Pragya says the pics aren't morphed but the way they're being presented is false

Aaliya jumps in to say stop lying blah blah. Abhi says be quiet and let her talk. Aaliya continues. Abhi tells her again to stop. Aaliya again continues. Abhi again tells her to let Pragya say the truth...and a fourth time...and a fifth time! Wow! Hey, I am impressed.

HAAYE. He shuts her up when she calls Nikita ghatiya and giri hui!!!!!

Abhi against tells Prags to tell all. And now...she is going to be blamed for not availing his lovely insistence? Sorry. Seem to be in a sarcastic mood today.

Prags says the pictures are real but what they say is false. Typical ghumao firao dialogues.

Tanu jumps in to tell Purab to speak. Hey Abhi? Weren't you just telling someone to let Nikku speak...? Toh ab kya?

Also there was a weird jump in the editing.

This epi is so miserable. I wish I wasn't watching. But it's rare I get to watch live so I can't resist!

Aaliya comes and says Purab we caught you red handed tell us if it's true or not. Umm Aaalu can you say red-handed and then still give option of true or false???

Purab says why ask me the truth if it came in front, if you wanted to know the truth you wouldn't make a tamasha at your bhai's sangeet. But still I will tell you...

Prags is worried Purab will tell their history so she tells him not to say anything

Purab says they don't respect anyone, I won't regain my respect by staying quiet

LOL why are Tanu and Aaliya pushing this??? What if he does tell history!

Purab says our rishta is friendship, trust, care...better in Hindi but I don't remember

Aaliya says what about love. Purab says sure if taking care of someone is love then it's love

Stupid dramatic music plays...he didn't confess to an affair. Why are they doing thisss.

Purab starts walking towards her. If supporting someone who is alone, sacrificing your happiness for someone is love, fulfilling a promise is love, THEN IT'S ALL LOVE

OH MY GOD VIN IS AMAZING

Tanu sends her Mom away so she won't be tense. Almost like a kind heroine 😲
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Nikhil wonders what card is this that Purab has tossed that wasn't int he deck 🤣...decides he wants to hide and watch what happens next though all guests are leaving.

Abhi slaps Purab. WHY ON EARTH. They just made Abhi seem like a reasonable human being. WHY. WAS. THIS. NEEDED. Abhi's slaps are never needed (I've forgotten all of them except this one and the one with Prags in the rain).

Purab says you're right to be mad to me, I'm sorry, forgive me if you can

Abhi says itni badi galati karna ki baad...WHAT GALATI. WHAT GALATI. WHAT GALATI.

Abhi says you were my friend, how could you hide such a big thing to me, did you think I'd tell you to break up with her, didn't it matter to you?

Wait if he slapped him for being a bad bro keeping secrets I could deal with that IF ABHI WOULD JUST SMILE and say "Nice bro! You could've just told me!"

Prags says why are you doing this...Purab says why should we lie now...Guys. At no point has Purab said he has an affair with Nikita. Whyyy is everyone acting like he did.

Bless Abhi they're playing positive Abhi music I think he's going to accept them!!!

Purab comes up with a really gross false history for him and Nikita I DON'T APPROVE.
Edited by -mina- - 8 years ago
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Purab says we got to know each other through you and fell for each other and somehow now we love each other. DAMN IT, PURAB. You could have done this differently. Could have stuck with the other definitions of love you were going for.

Daadi looks sad and Tanu looks happy.

Purab says I'd have told you eventually. Abhi is so sad and says...WHAT...OMG I WAS WRONG...he says you're too late and I don't want to see your face. 😲

Why? BY WHAT RIGHT? What is wrong with you? How can you be such a terrible friend to both Purab and Nikita? WHAT HAS ANYONE DONE TO WRONG YOU. Seriously WHAT.

I hate this. I wish they made Abhi someone I can respect and understand. Please.

Abhi's in his room and breaks his water glass. Good raho akela tumhara kamra mein. Come out when you figure out how to be a good friend and reasonable person.

Abhi thinks back to Nikita's dialogues about being the river and the shore...freaks out about the pics...wonders how they could hide their feelings...calls himself an idiot and blames himself for falling into people's words

What is this? Why are they playing with me? Every two seconds Abhi shows flickers of rationality...but then they get doused...but then there are new flickers...I don't understand!!

Bizarre moment of Prags standing in a black place with voices tormenting her; Sarla wakes up in shock at home

Precap before break: Nikhil says team Aaliya rocks, team Pragya is in shock 🤣

For serious can we ditch this team dialogue. There is no team Pragya in this track. Pragya is all alone on the show. No one cares about her best interests; some might share her goal of reuniting her with Abhi but that, I am sorry to say, is not being team Pragya.
Edited by -mina- - 8 years ago
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Rodaadi asks if Sarla is ok, did she have a bad dream
Sarla freaking out Pragz isn't home and it's past midnight

Oh god...they don't know...they don't know what happened to her with the kidnappers

God if I was Pragya I would be so goddamn done. Done with trying to get back the life I never got to have done with trying to get back to the man that didn't put me first. Done with trying to focus on other people's dramas instead of being allowed to process the random acts of violence I was just subject to.

Good thing I am not Pragya.

Sarla says she will call Mehra house. Rodaadi disapproves but whatever.

Indu daasi is freaking out about what does any of this mean, why did Purab say this. She picks up Sarla's call. They're both super pereshaan and not talking properly. Sarla wants to talk to Pragya. Indu daasi...no idea what happens because commercial break again suddenly 😡


-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Nikhil jokes about giving best actor award to Aaliya, Tanu gives her a writer award...Tanu says Aalu turned Abhi-Pragya's story into a triangle story...OMG the meta 🤣

Tanu calls PurGya thing as bhabhi-dewar 😲

Some banters about best director and what should the movie be called...Aaaliya you need better friendsss god. So dweeby.

Aaliya gives Nikhil credit for being good at his job. Where's this AaKhil love coming from?? Didn't they used to hate each other?

Aaliya looks so happy. Time for a downfall!!!

Precap: Pragya taking out her rage at Purab! Love seeing her angry. Her last line is that instead of reducing the distance between me and him you've made things harder for me. Purab looks teary eyed. Daadi-Daasi watch. DID I MENTION I LOVE PRAGYA GETTING TO SPEAK HER MIND WHEN SHE IS ANGRY!
Edited by -mina- - 8 years ago
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Overall: Precap saved the episode for me...too much emotional torture for Pragya for me to enjoy it otherwise. I did appreciate Purab's powerful speeches. Aaliya's huge smile gave me a kind of masochistic joy - I love seeing her successful only so I can see her get her comeuppance in the constant fruitless wish to see her REFORM - I know, it's complicated. Abhi Abhi Abhi...god. So much potential in how he could have handled this. Points to him for calling himself out on being a confused mess, but...what he does while being a confused mess, I find hard to accept. Well he can redeem himself perhaps. Will have to see what happens. I'm glad I watched after all. Definitely heights of drama to start off the year, whether it makes me happy or not!
mili9 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -mina-

Overall: Precap saved the episode for me...too much emotional torture for Pragya for me to enjoy it otherwise. I did appreciate Purab's powerful speeches. Aaliya's huge smile gave me a kind of masochistic joy - I love seeing her successful only so I can see her get her comeuppance in the constant fruitless wish to see her REFORM - I know, it's complicated. Abhi Abhi Abhi...god. So much potential in how he could have handled this. Points to him for calling himself out on being a confused mess, but...what he does while being a confused mess, I find hard to accept. Well he can redeem himself perhaps. Will have to see what happens. I'm glad I watched after all. Definitely heights of drama to start off the year, whether it makes me happy or not!


Mina, thanks for the show. I am not sure if I want to watch or not today. I have some free time, but don't know if I want to walk around all angry and perplexed.

@ bold... can you elaborate this, Mina? I think I know what you are saying here, but would love to hear it from you😊 Are you talking about just being a BFF for both Pragya, Purab or confronting his own feelings or both? Hope I am not putting you on the spot😉
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mili9


Mina, thanks for the show. I am not sure if I want to watch or not today. I have some free time, but don't know if I want to walk around all angry and perplexed.

@ bold... can you elaborate this, Mina? I think I know what you are saying here, but would love to hear it from you😊 Are you talking about just being a BFF for both Pragya, Purab or confronting his own feelings or both? Hope I am not putting you on the spot😉


Mili, unless you're in the mood for finding glimmers of hope in a dark cave of misery, I don't recommend watching!

Abhi was really uneven and confusing to me in this episode. There were some moments I was so proud of him - shutting up Aaliya over and over again, realizing to himself that he falls too easily for other people's words. I'm impressed that he had the thought "they could hide their relationship with me, not their feelings"" - I like that he expects himself to pick up on their feelings. But then there were so many other moments that didn't match, that didn't build to what I wanted to see. I wanted to see Abhi genuinely trusting and loving both of his friends - either by insisting that the pictures didn't tell the whole story because he knew them better than that, or by accepting that there was a genuine love relationship like Purab was describing. I wanted to see Abhi being reasonable and understanding that not telling him about their relationship is not the kind of terrible betrayal and faithlessness Aaliya was presenting it as. I wanted Abhi to be patient and kind and humble and sweet and he wasn't. He wasn't. He was self-focused and hot-headed and uncompassionate and completely lost in his own ego. Which is so unfair to Abhi. He has the HUGEST heart...in a moment like this, that should have come out. Instead they made him look like a selfish easily manipulated baby again. I'm very disappointed.

Hope that helps...I can attempt to elaborate further if you want 😳
akshi. thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Even reading update is making me feel 🤢 u watched live hats off to ur courage.

Related Topics

Kumkum Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: pfalcon1949

1 months ago

No show on sunday and monday?

I didn't see any episode on sunday or monday. Is it already off air?

Expand ▼
Kumkum Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: Viswasruti

2 months ago

Kumkum Bhagya's Krishna Kaul to be part of Rajshri Productions show

This new venture offers viewers the chance to see Krishna Kaul in a fresh avatar, while also signalling a promising revival of classic-style...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".