Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

3.5k

Users

17

Likes

142

Frequent Posters

mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: shanti05



Ashutosh and Nidhi working together and their difference of opinion in medical matters should give them advantage in understanding each others personality better as the age factor should deal with more realistic ideas rather than noodles and hair dye and all random factors..

Hope your biopsy report is read by the CV's and Mr. KP



More than Mallika I am worried about Ashutosh and Nidhi. I really hope this biopsy report is read by the CV's and Mr. KP... How much ever the stellar performances could be, if they are not serious about this 'character resurrection', nothing is going to happen
simi5 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#32

Perfectly wriiten.

Hey Mudra ji, me a silent member here. Seems like u and a few others r on the same page as me. Considering that u regularly post here thought of asking u what is this sudden excitement about the chemistry between new ashu and nidhi. I mean no one has seen them together as ashu and nidhi but everyone still raving about it..me completely lost. What did i miss here. Looks like SK is really lucky here, has it really easy. I was watching the show for MB, endured all the torture 😭 but his stupendous performance and the beautiful Ashni chemistry made me even see the repeats . And the new Ashu to me looks of the same age as Nidhi so isn't the age gap concept totally lost here??? 😲 Unless they now show Mallika and Ashu then maybe kuch to log kahenge...

U know the irony of the show is first they were trying to show the old ashu even older and now they will have to make the new younger ashu look older...

Also to add to what u have written the sudden disappearance of characters here is completely mind boggling. It seems like they messed the whole show for trps.😡, So they ended up changing tracks every Wednesday depending on the trps..I mean.. Sandeep baghci, Mandira ...Aslo in the shok sabha, instead of a bunch of extras,the people attending should have been Aditya, Sue, Divya, the nurse and the rest of the interns. And how could they show her announcing her relationship in the shok sabha, Now the family knows and people who know Ashu, know about his relationship with intern..So if there is a PA everyone except Ashu knows.. And looks like the new track for trps is PDA...For trps they ruined a beautiful story. Now what we have is Kuch to log kahenge- Ten easy steps to ruin a show.

All the viewers were complaining that she is not shown as a doctor and what do they do show that her touch brings life into the dead Ashutosh. Sorry that did not connect with me. Somehow i thought that was way too filmy .. I hope the cvs do read what u have written. I doubt it. They just showed that while alive Ashutosh was a brain surgeon and when he died turned into a neurosurgeon..Poor souls like me who continue to watch this might need both..😆. But me happy to have come to the forum, will keep reading the reviews and the os here.

BTW Mudra ji Get well soon

NeelimaSJ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#33
Well written Mudra. 👏
indstp thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#34
i hope ishika wont leave this show
KunwaariDaayan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#35
Amen to that Mudra...couldn't have put it any better.Doesn't matter how brilliant the actors are, if the script is not written aptly then there is no hope for any show and in this show the script does not seem to have been well thought out at all,such a shame really.something that could have been so beautiful had to be completely put under mass destruction...the team sure have come across as a proper bunch of amateurs.
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#36
@nsylesh thanks for liking this
@simi

Thanks for the concern for my health. I am getting better already.
Now coming to KTLK..
What attracted me the most in KTLK was the characters and their perfect portrayal by the actors. Everything was initially so perfect...

The concerned people were so greedy, that they wanted to make a big success over night may be, started searching all the regular masala ingredients and in turn successfully converted the show as a c-grade one. This story was a different one, hero character had several insecurities and that was enough as the gray part... no need of a villain.. Dr Mallika is not an alter ego to Ashutosh..she is another character.
Come to think of it, some of the other shows were honest in their story lines..as viewers have no expectations and the show makers also did not offer any.

The script lost all its charm in a big way and according me no measures were taken to improve it, and at the same time digging further (perpetually) to the lower depths.

Some of the viewers (I guess all) stuck to the show for the Ashutosh(MB) magic..in the hope, The writers who had offered a beautiful story initially cannot go wrong...But the final straw was MB's exit...whatever reasons may be...we may not know what went wrong...But, I feel its good he had quit instead of doing every other crap track at the stake of his health..

Now, it is not correct on my part to comment on the new comer's acting or fitting into the character abilities...which may be a huge task for him as erasing an image that someone has created so intensively is very difficult...no.. not easy as you said...

I guess I am the wrong person to ask for this 'chemistry'..what ever meaning it has otherwise, I take it as the ease and compatibility of the actors to deliver a certain emotion together...These two actors have already proved themselves million times before and till the last moment...their characters were designed that way.

I have stopped watching for the past few episodes and may not continue...But deep down I feel sad, 'why this has happened?'

Ashutosh was introduced as Neurosurgeon and then specialised him as brain surgeon and now back to neuro. Please donot ask any logic... or research in the domain knowledge...you wont get any answers anyway.
Edited by mudraswathi - 13 years ago
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: shaz2009

Amen to that Mudra...couldn't have put it any better.Doesn't matter how brilliant the actors are, if the script is not written aptly then there is no hope for any show and in this show the script does not seem to have been well thought out at all,such a shame really.something that could have been so beautiful had to be completely put under mass destruction...the team sure have come across as a proper bunch of amateurs.



Thank you shaz..we are in the same boat...
You know some thing...Initially I named it as 'autopsy report' ...but, still a small (0.00000000001%) of me made me change to 'biopsy report'
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: mudraswathi

What went wrong with KTLK and how it could have been rectified while continuing with the love story?

wonderful analysis mudra... u covered everything beautifully ... and i agree wid every point except number 1 2 sum extent...
if the CVs had cared to take care of these issues the show could be toppin d charts but it was not meant 2 be... but hope wid SK ,the tides will change for good
1. A love story between the senior doctor and an intern in the back drop of Hospital environment

Went wrong: Started in those lines...but senior doctor did not behave as one...he made a mistake of removing her for no reason..
Rectification: Could have mentored her later. Could have motivated her to take up higher studies/ work for NGO(for street children) /given cooperation to set up on her own. Could have encouraged and acknowledged her academic brilliance.
he was confused .. and scared yaa... scared of his own feelings for a woman half his age... n was under pressure... from mallu...dont wanna defend d show but i feel he couldnt have faced log right on... but like u said ,he could have mentored her or atleast should have dealt wid d problem on hand tactfully , mean sendin her to study further rather than firin her..

2. A love story having huge age-gap

Went wrong:senior doctor (42 year) , shown too old fashioned for his age.. resulting the girl showed respect towards this uncle always and the senior pampered her as a child.Viewers left scratching heads about why & how these two were in love. All the best opportunities like ball dance, new year's eve, moral support when Col.Verma's financial and health losses ..were wasted..

Rectification: There was an attempt to rectify on V-day...but, it was not a spontaneous change from the hero's side. Should have taken her out to such places where really they both could talk more freely and get to know each other. Several more instances..could have been where Ashutosh him self realized the mistakes or accepted when the girl pointed out with grace. There was violin date. But when they could picturise the violin date very beautifully, why not some more such situations..where really mental-age-gap could have been reduced..
Ashutosh took her to the school..but, a poem about a girl at the age of 14 is a bit odd to think..(Ashutosh aged so early)..He must have definitely thought of a girl at the age of 28, that they could have shown.
totally agree.. at times i used 2 wonder why these 2 are in love... i mean kya dekh kar pyar kia.. but then d process of fallin in love was so rushed...
vday was again not a spontaneous change... they never got d chance 2 talk or get d chance 2 know each other like u said... whenever they met ,it was 2 highlight d difference of age between d two...only exception being d voilin date...and instead of his school,he could have taken her 2 his med school...that would have made more sense...

3. So many tracks went in to the black hole

Went wrong: Hero could have felt jealous about the youngster (Rohan). Armaan, Col. Verma & Anji belong to the same field---but no connection. Armaan's fashion house. Baba's house was not given a single thought later. Baba was not even remembered by Ashutosh. Why Rohan? what is the use of Ranganath? where did the Nidhi-Anji's friendship go? Col.Verma's losses...endless list


Rectification: each of the above are the situations to boost up & cement the love and could have been used for best results...when both the leads sit together and help others which helps togetherness as a couple-unit...
we all expected ashu 2 be jealous... but even ashu BD dint get 2 do that...any man in love ought 2 be a lil jealous of his woman's friendship wid another guy...esp when d other man knows his woman so well... n lives in her house... but no...vishal...such a talented actor wid a gr8 comic timin wasted...
4. Mallika's episodes
Went wrong: Mallika was a good doctor. Never her abilities were highlighted. Always she was shown in the very very bad light. Her talent as an actor was totally under utilised. Suhasini & Aditya's character in her life...A whole amount of Bakwas in her role after 50 episodes.

Rectification: Instead of silly things like hiding the files or giving continuous shifts, she should have shown trying to catch the young intern for some other wrong doings (exchanging anesthesia bottle for B12 injection was one such example). No need of Aditya (or minimise him). Suhasini's utilization should have been directly to Nidhi/Ashutosh as one of the 'log--kuch kahenge'
mallu's character was murdered ruthlessly.. no woman in her right mind would wait for some one for barah saal only 2 rub it at every opportunity...radha's dont scheme...neither then..not now... besides even if she does ,she isnt that stupid 2 do idiotic stuff...
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#39
Thank you Deepa...

One should salute your way of picking up exactly the right icons...

what you will write and then pick up icons????
jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: mudraswathi

Thank you Deepa...

One should salute your way of picking up exactly the right icons...

what you will write and then pick up icons????

thanks yaa...
yah I just write wat ever i want 2 n then just pick icons n daalo them just be4 posting
btw of late ur using some amazing emoticons ..i like ur choice as well
waise just noticed that i dint use a single emoticon in my review of ur post...


Edited by deepa_jd - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".