Thoughts on Oct. 10th - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.1k

Users

17

Likes

198

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Maz.

Nice post Nur..

Epi dekh kar I didn't even register much of that flashback..cos that one solid yelling session by Ashutosh was awesome!

But yea I agree they are trying for the poignant feel...like him standing holding on the bars of the gate...like his good times with his Baba have been locked in there and he isn't being allowed access to re-live them.. That's true...that is the feel they are trying to go for with the way they showed him holding on to the bars of the gate and even laying his head against them...MB was very good in that bit...but I feel otherwise the FBs showing "young" Ashutosh just have a bit of an unnatural vibe to them...they could allow them to flow better.


I also liked that telephone convo with Anjie...shows that Anjie did worry about her friend, and how she innocently says ki I'll talk to the doc...until she realizes that the situation is really bad.. Yeah their friendship is being beautifully shown...I think Anjie is doing a very good job...the actress I mean...their body language projects that feeling of deep friendship.

@Nidhi washing away the make up...nicely acted by KK...and even when she talks to Anjie...she uses all the same words...ghairzimedaari, murder by negligence...it shows that his words really got to her..and will of course now help her make her decision to continue working in the hospital or not.. Yeah KK did that bit well...you could see how she was feeling so shattered in a sense after the scolding she got from Ashutosh, each jab further adding on to her guilt over what had happened due to her negligence...

@Mallika..quite surprising to see her advising Nidhi to look at things positively..considering the fact that she found out about Shahenshah and attended to him...it seems like Ashutosh's comments on Nidhi to Mallika the other day has made her see things differently...and she had to be the considerate of the 2 senior docs at least...if one scolds the other should at least help recover.. Ahh good point...that makes sense...I guess that is why they showed it like this...good cop-bad cop so to speak?😆...both of them giving Nidhi different kinds of doses but giving her ample food for thought.

Filza. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Nice analysis! Loved reading it.

I liked today's episode. Nidhi and Ashu's scene was amazing, very powerful. Left an impact.

Liked Nidhi's bit in the washroom and also loved it how she was trying to control herself from breaking down when Dr Ashutosh is scolding her, when in his office. The nervousness, initially, and then the guilt when his words sink in was very well portrayed by Kritika.

I do think Dr Nidhi deserved the bashing from him and that she should have been responsible enough. But that said it's not entirely her fault but the nurse equally shares the blame. I felt bad for her when she was crying. The girl is really guilty, I hope the kid survives and Dr Ashutosh forgives her for her carelessness this time. She of-course needs to realize and act more mature.

Another scene that struck me was Ashu's outside the house mainly because of MB''s acting. He was good! I still can't really get Ashutosh's fixation with the house though. But him crying and the BG score was touching.

Also another bit i liked was when Nidhi comes face to face with him when she enters the hospital. Ashu's angry looks. Uff. Awesome. Liked that eye-lock.

achiever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
overall very nice epi in terms of everything.. the acting, the expressions, the chemistry, the emotions, comedy, and the drama.. it had every bit of each of these ingredients which make the show interesting..👍🏼

From a light hearted start to a heavy headed finish.. it was bang on!👍🏼

4 the first time i actually liked Rang-Angi scene.. it was funny and quite njoyable.. 😆

uff.. luved the way MB luked at the coat and did sort of tongue in cheek.. totally to die for... the way he reacted to nidhi's touch the other day, i was wondering if he wud even touch the coat again..😆.. but bingo! the director/writer kept the scene real.. and MB was grt...😍without a single dialogue he conveyed the feelings so beautifully.. I just luv his body language.. his expressions.. this director-actor duo is fantastic!.. he acts so real.. after a tiresome and hard works day, he still paused and reflected at the coat and all tht led it there..😆... very cute and romantic!😍
the otherwise calm composed, and usually sarcastic A can b even more lethal when he choses to convey his anger more thru eyes rthr thn words... the way he luked at N when she 1st came face to face.. totally awesome.. so alarming and dreadful.. N knew the worst was yet to come!

Well, i thot the uber cool and calm Mallika in A's cabin sort of soothed out his otherwise seething anger... with M, A showed how gud he was in controlling his emotions and reactions.. tht wud b pretty interesting to watch wen he wud realize his feelings for N...😛

the A-N confrontation.. was totally mindblowing..👏I was completely spellbound by MB in this scene..😍... A was perfect in everything.. he didnt restrain himself this time in expressing his extreme contempt for N's disregard for the medical profession... her casual attitude towards a patient's life.. and he was rite on every pnt.. and rightly severe on N in order to make her realize how her freewheeling antics can actually lead to the most dire and grave situations.. excellent scene!👏.. A was in total control.. I luv the way he handles his power.. his authority.. disciplinarian and strict he mite b, but he is totally adorable as a superior.. someone u can always luk up to..😳


Nidhi's expression told everything.. wen she realized how much disgusted A was with her and it came like a jolt.. the way A said those words "pathetic and wash ur face".. aaah.. it is gonna haunt her a big time.. and its already started as shown in the wash room scene...👏.

its like those times in our life.. wen v get an F in a test bcoz v chose to fool around instead of studying😆.. thn get rebuffed by fav teacher 😭, and so v vow to prove tht v r worthy of being proud of instead..😛... 😆.. N is gonna idolize A.. will leave no stones unturned to impress him..😆.. its gonna b damn interesting.. 😆

Mallika.. aah.. she is a gem.. 😳she really cares for her interns.. and for A and for hospital...😍 she brings in calmness and gentleness to complement A's strict attitude.. she is like a soothing breeze of air.. she is there for everybody.. sadly the one she likes is not there for her.. 😭i really feel for her.. so when she turns all jealous, she wudnt b so hateful.😳.bt I really dont want her to b a plain outright planning, plotting vamp.😡. I wud rather like her character 2 b complex.. justifying her jealousy and hence her actions.. 😳

reminds me serial "sailaab"😍 which had a story of ex-marital affair.. bt u jst cant simply hate the characters.. for their selfish and improper actions.😃. bcoz they werent bad as such.. bt thy jst cudnt help their feelings..😳

the rest of scene wer k..😳
overall, 4/5... extra 0.5 jst 4 MB..👍🏼

Edited by achiever - 13 years ago
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: nureat01


Yeah the mismatched socks bit was cute but I feel overall the scene did have a sense of trying too hard...the original mismatched socks scene in DK was cuter...I just adored Baba-Ahmer in DK...

But yeah Mallika was again the surprise package today...Rukhsar did a very nice job with this soft and wise side to her again...

Agree.. Anu... actually i really dun find the Baba-Ashu scenes as heartwarming as they ought to be.. not to mention that it makes me feel disconnected 😕... jus that yday was a wee bit better than the past scenes.. the violins .. n the wig ones 😆!! But th DK moments of Baba-Ahmer were a class apart 😳
Rukhsar does really well with the whites & blacks of her grey... a moment at the OT she was black.. a lil later... now she is white... one interesting character we have there 😛
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: achiever


its like those times in our life.. wen v get an F in a test bcoz v chose to fool around instead of studying😆.. thn get rebuffed by fav teacher 😭, and so v vow to prove tht v r worthy of being proud of instead..😛... 😆.. N is gonna idolize A.. will leave no stones unturned to impress him..😆.. its gonna b damn interesting.. 😆

reminds me serial "sailaab"😍 which had a story of ex-marital affair.. bt u jst simply hate the characters.. for their selfish and improper actions.😃. bcoz they werent bad as such.. bt thy jst cudnt help their feelings..😳


Did u say.. SAILAAB.. 😲 ... woohoo girl .. imma gonna CRUSHHH u with hugs...!! 🤗 .. ever since i have been on IF.. havent come across anyone who has watched our awesome Hindi shows... of DD n early Zee tv times... sooo happy yaara!! Tongue Sailaab jus rocked man.. that show.. mite make us feel disgusted with the steps taken or the choices made by the leads.. but.. they were all in GREY... rarely u found black or absolute white... n thats why m so intrigued with Mallikas character... n have so much faith in Rukhsar... she makes.. GREY look CLASSY 👏
N talk about ... it yaar... i cant wait for N to go all out to.. woo her BOSS as in impress him at first n then.. ofcourse we know.. the love-shove 😉 ... !! Loving the show..!
Btw folks TRPs will be out tomorrow... PLS PRAY ..that it does well 😊
fuzzyface thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
Anu I always like reading your thoughts coz you always notice the little things and state the obvious.

I personally think Nidhi needed to make this mistake to realise why she needs to become a real doctor. So far she has been reluctant and unaware of her what she wants to do, so hopefully, this will give her perspective.
achiever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
😆

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Did u say.. SAILAAB.. 😲 ... woohoo girl .. imma gonna CRUSHHH u with hugs...!! 🤗 .. ever since i have been on IF.. havent come across anyone who has watched our awesome Hindi shows... of DD n early Zee tv times... sooo happy yaara!! 😛 Sailaab jus rocked man.. that show.. mite make us feel disgusted with the steps taken or the choices made by the leads.. but.. they were all in GREY... rarely u found black or absolute white... n thats why m so intrigued with Mallikas character... n have so much faith in Rukhsar... she makes.. GREY look CLASSY 👏
--😆 yeah.. good old days..🤗 .. thr r so many fond memories with DDs shows of mid and late 90s b4 Zee and Sony invaded with different kinda soaps.. some of thm r still etched into my memory..

Farmaan, Kashish, mungeri laal, ye jo hai zindagi, wagle ki duniyan, Mr. Yogi, ramayan, palaash ke phool, mahabharat, chitrahaar, chankya, rangoli, malgudi days, tenali rama, , sailaab, Rishtey (collection of short love stories on Zee😍), saans,..flop show, zaban sambhal ke, dekh bhai dekh, family no. 1, padosan, filmi chakkar, vyomkesh bakshi, tehkikat, karamchand, alif laila, surbhi, Sigma, street hawk, tail spin, duck tales, jungle book, Ariel, heidi, stone boy, potli baba ki, gayab aaya, alibaba aur chalish chor, hum panch and game shows - ek minute and saap sidi.. wow TV was so much fun!😆

and the dubbed ones on Sony thn..I dream of jennie, silver spoon, different strokes.. three stooges, laurel and hardy, charlie chaplin..

also one chinese/japanese dubbed serial called Oshin..😳
after tht decade, i can hardly count a serial thts as endearing to me as those ones.. except tu tu main main and sarabhai versus sarabhai..

and i remember ETC was my fav music channel...😆 😆 😆

and yes DD had those famous short videos.. remember.. "ek chidiya.. anek chidiya"..😆 😆 😆 and "baje sargam" "mile sur mera tumhara" i have downloaded it and v often watch thm.. 😆 😆 😆
Btw folks TRPs will be out tomorrow... PLS PRAY ..that it does well 😊

--yeah hope it delivers. this show is defo deserving those TRPs..😳

Edited by achiever - 13 years ago
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: achiever

--😆 yeah.. good old days..🤗 .. thr r so many fond memories with DDs shows of mid and late 90s b4 Zee and Sony invaded with different kinda soaps.. some of thm r still etched into my memory..

Farmaan, Kashish, mungeri laal, ye jo hai zindagi, wagle ki duniyan, Mr. Yogi, ramayan, palaash ke phool, mahabharat, chitrahaar, chankya, rangoli, malgudi days, tenali rama, , sailaab, Rishtey (collection of short love stories on Zee😍), saans,..flop show, zaban sambhal ke, dekh bhai dekh, family no. 1, padosan, filmi chakkar, vyomkesh bakshi, tehkikat, karamchand, alif laila, surbhi, Sigma, street hawk, tail spin, duck tales, jungle book, Ariel, heidi, stone boy, potli baba ki, gayab aaya, alibaba aur chalish chor, hum panch and game shows - ek minute and saap sidi.. wow TV was so much fun!😆

and the dubbed ones on Sony thn..I dream of jennie, silver spoon, different strokes.. three stooges, laurel and hardy, charlie chaplin..

also one chinese/japanese dubbed serial called Oshin..😳
after tht decade, i can hardly count a serial thts as endearing to me as those ones.. except tu tu main main and sarabhai versus sarabhai..

and i remember ETC was my fav music channel...😆 😆 😆

and yes DD had those famous short videos.. remember.. "ek chidiya.. anek chidiya"..😆 😆 😆 and "baje sargam" "mile sur mera tumhara" i have downloaded it and v often watch thm.. 😆 😆 😆

Crushinggg u with jhappisss 🤗 Dil khush kar diya tune yaar 😛 ... i loveee these shows.. freagn... awesomeee..!! That was the golden era of DD.. n shows in general if u ask me... i loveddd ..every show u have mentioned and have watched them all... out of the ones not in the list...
Phir Wahi Talash.. Aloknath and Moushumi. ... then Kshitij ye nahi.. Supriya and Tushar Dalvi ... then Kiley ka rahasya... all three on DD ... then Mano ya na mano...(the epi thru which Sangeeta Ghosh debuted) ... then there was one... pachpan khambe lal dewaren ..(Aman Verma and Mita Vashisht) .. Parivartan... (Beena)
Oh u named one of my other fave... Oshin.. btw remember... Celeste???
Aah feels fab yaar.. reliving the past!! <3
@TRPs... yep indeed..this show deserves due recognition...only then good material and content will thrive...!! 😛
Mehek25 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
Nureat as always a superb post.

I too noticed that they are making good additions to the original screen play.

In fact now I have begun relating to it as a new show on Indian TV and am slowly drawing away from comparing it with DK.

KK was gr8 in the last bit when she was washing her face.

MB went way beyond my expectations in the scene where he reads out the riot act to Dr. Nidhi. Till now I had some qualms about MB's voice modulation in scenes where he has to act tough. But after seeing him yesterday I have no doubts now that his voice can turn tough when the need arises...Loved the way he said..."U are pathetic"...it had so much force and made an impact not only on Nidhi but I am sure on all viewers also.

Superb episode. Have gr8 expectations from this show.
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Crushinggg u with jhappisss 🤗 Dil khush kar diya tune yaar 😛 ... i loveee these shows.. freagn... awesomeee..!! That was the golden era of DD.. n shows in general if u ask me... i loveddd ..every show u have mentioned and have watched them all... out of the ones not in the list...

Phir Wahi Talash.. Aloknath and Moushumi. ... then Kshitij ye nahi.. Supriya and Tushar Dalvi ... then Kiley ka rahasya... all three on DD ... then Mano ya na mano...(the epi thru which Sangeeta Ghosh debuted) ... then there was one... pachpan khambe lal dewaren ..(Aman Verma and Mita Vashisht) .. Parivartan... (Beena)
Oh u named one of my other fave... Oshin.. btw remember... Celeste???
Aah feels fab yaar.. reliving the past!! <3
@TRPs... yep indeed..this show deserves due recognition...only then good material and content will thrive...!! 😛


This made me so happy😃-a list of all my favs.I loved Rishtey,Vyomkesh Bakshi,Kshitij yeh nahin(such a beautiful love story)Hum paanch.also Fauji,Cicus,star Best sellers and miit(based on Rabindranath Tagore's Nauka Dubi).Recently I got the DVD of Tehkikat and its still so much fun to watch.sorry got carried away with all these memories😊
Thanks for reminding me of those beautiful shows.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".