Tia's Thread - Jhooth Bole Rishte Kaate!!!/ DT Nt pg 26 - Page 22

Created

Last reply

Replies

235

Views

12.5k

Users

41

Likes

1.3k

Frequent Posters

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: DEFOM

FINALLY A DETAILED ANAYLSIS :

Dev-Sona

The episode started with a typical' conversation of our beloved couple! This kind of bickering is what I like, where it is not really arguing for the sake of arguing (okay well, in our Dev-Sona's case, it invariably is!!) but more a case of arguing because you care. I warmed up hearing the first of the dialogues... Arey, bachche ho kya?' Tum principal ho kya?'. Dev was insistent on getting inside the room to meet Suhana & Sona was trying her best to dissuade him from going in. I was smiling at the genuine concern Sona was showing, worried that Dev may also fall ill. This looked so nice & so real! Dev, stop acting like a petulant kid! And finally, it was the kid in question that managed to convince the kidult! Suhana made Dev promise that he wouldn't enter her room & Dev had to grudgingly agree. Oh Dev, its ok, your anxiousness is understandable but you need to be practical too. The KRPKAB music playing in the background was a nice touch and so was the understanding nod Sona had for Dev. It was really nice to see this level of quiet understanding they were now having where mere glances were enough to convey their thoughts. A very sweet scene!


Agree. Dev was behaving like a kid who was told that the candy jar are off limits to him. 😆

Bose House

BB was lost in thoughts about Sona & Soha leaving & everyone was trying to cajole him. When Asha informed him, BB was apologetic at ignoring Ronita's cooking & finally started eating. He was so lost in the delicious food that Asha calling out to him to gift Ronita a necklace went unheard. Now that's what I call focus & focus on the important things in life!

There was really nothing much to the scene but it showed how the family was again back to its cheerful mode & Ronita was making a place for herself in the Bose family. Nice!


Loved their family dynamics. They were incredible. That's exactly how a family should welcome a new daughter-in-law. 👏

Dev-Mamaji

I loved the scene for its simplicity in showing the nervousness that a caring parent would have towards his sick child. Dev hadn't slept the whole night & was fretting over Suhana's illness, feeling helpless reading about how she may be experiencing irritation & pain. Aww, that was so genuine. Dev told Mamaji that he wanted to consult another doctor for a 2nd opinion & Mamaji could only smile indulgently at Dev, understanding his worried state. Mamaji finally managed to assure Dev that chickenpox was not something he needed to overly worry about. He also persuaded Dev to agree to wait for some more time before deciding on an alternate course of action.

Sona watched this entire interaction from above & yet again, it warmed my heart to see her genuinely understanding Dev as a very concerned, caring & protective parent. In addition to that, this soft, emotional side of Dev which had always attracted her in the past, was making her soften her attitude towards him.


Sonakshi always liked this caring side of Dev as much as she hated the ruthless, mean side of Dev. Unfortunately, he seems to show only the later to Sonakshi even when she shows him empathy.

Sona-Boses

Sona informed Asha about Soha's illness. I was happy to see that the trio leaving at midnight was not something that was a big issue now. Asha advised Sona to not inform BB about Soha's illness as she was worried about him getting agitated & possibly insisting on getting them back to Bose House. I wondered if it was the right thing to do but it did seem to be the most appropriate thing to do & Asha has always had a better understanding of how to tackle sensitive issues.

I liked this realistic touch again by the Makers. While it is true that honesty is the best policy & one must not hide things from the family, sometimes delaying the truth does seem the best thing to do, keeping in mind the nature of the issue. Nice touch of realism, Makers!


I will have to disagree here. It's not about whether it was the right or wrong time to share a truth but if anyone has the right to keep this away from someone else. Here both Asha and Bijoy are grandparents. They are definitely concerns for their granddaughter. Sonakshi, as a parent, has the right to decide whether she wants to share the news with them. But Asha as a grandparent has no right to take that right away from Bijoy. How will Asha feel if Ishwari tells Dev and Sona to hide Soha's illness from her because she doesn't want her to visit her sick granddaughter? Sorry, I didn't find it anyway palatable. But then I find Asha to be a hypocrite.

Dev-Sona & the Magic!

Dev knocked on Soha's room with a tray laden with home remedies to alleviate her pain & suffering. I must admit, I quite like this frequent inclusion of home remedies in this show. I am a big fan of these remedies too, preferring herbal to chemical cures for small & common ailments so naturally this appeals to me!

As Sona opened the door, toweling her hair, the focus of the scene shifted from medicine to mini-romance! Dev was unable to take his gaze off Sona & even as she asked him to speak, he could initially barely mumble anything coherent! As I mentioned before, when it comes to Dev, Sona & eyelocks, I am ok with anything that's shown, miniscule or not, believable or not! The water droplets on Dev's face from Sona's wet hair, the eyelocks, electrifying' touch of fingers, arm holding... Bring It On Makers, this die-hard romantic is ever ready to watch all these! However filmy' it looked, for me the Magic of this amazing duo's chemistry always has me hooked & this time too, I was all smiles.

Amidst all this romance, Dev implored Sona to use the home remedies for Suhana as a supplementary cure. Sona understood Dev's genuine concern & appreciated his efforts. They were now behaving like a very normal couple, understanding & supporting each other. That was very endearing to watch.

Sona smiled warmly at Dev & a visibly affected Dev quickly moved away!


That was hilarious. Dev looked like the cartoon dog with his tongue tied and he looked like the old Dev. 😆

Sona-Elena

The conversation between the 2 sisters was started off with Elena telling Sona that she always longed for such times with her (Sona) & Sona also telling Elena that she missed her a lot.

This was a very nice scene but didn't have much emotional depth as it didn't bring out that sense of longing the 2 sisters claimed they had, as they missed each other all these years. Sona asking Elena as to why she never bothered to call & Elena apologizing guiltily had me wondering as to why Sona too couldn't have contact Elena if she too missed her as much? Sona mentioned that Asha & she used to often talk about her (Elena).

Ups & downs toh life mein hote rehte hain but I am fine'...I liked Elena's spirit as she stoically told Sona that things changed a lot after marriage. Her comment Tune jo bhi kiya na Sona, sahi kiya' was very telling. It wasn't so much about whether Sona was right in breaking off her marriage, it was more about the choice that Sona could make, to walk out of a relationship she didn't want to be in, which Elena felt she didn't have. I felt bad for Elena, she had eloped & married Vicky for love, gone against her family's wishes, now had a child to think about...walking out of that marriage with Vicky would have been something she would've considered many times but she was not in a position to break off due to various reasons...she didn't appear to be financially independent, probably wasn't emotionally strong to walk out, she had the responsibility of a child...all these may have forced her to stay on in the marriage which was now more a marriage of convenience than of love. Sad!

Elena cautioned Sona against the unscrupulous duo who were not pleased at her arrival into Ishwari Niwas. It was nice to see that Sona agreed & accepted that some things could never change & this duo came in that category. Hopefully this time around, Sona will not fall prey to Vicky-Mami's sinister plans. Elena's unstinting support would have surely given the additional confidence she needed in tackling with the problems ahead. Finally, they did what I was hoping for a long time now...both the sisters hugged each other with so much warmth & love. At last, all was really well between the 2.

Agar 1% bhi chance hai na, ki Soha ko uski family mil jaaye, toh please sochna zaroor'

Elena asked Sona to consider a reconciliation with Dev for the sake of Soha. She understood the meaning of having a complete family for the child's sake. Her own family was incomplete with Golu never really getting the parental love that he was rightfully entitled to & here I would definitely blame Elena for ignoring that sweet, innocent kid. Vicky was a bad father but Elena was a negligent mother & poor Golu suffered, saved only by his BigCha's unconditional & complete love. Her advice to Sona largely stemmed from her own inadequacies as a good parent.

Her comment had Sona wondering.


Exactly. Again I found Elena to be contradictory. On one breath, she tells Sona that she did right by leaving and on second breath she says that try to get back with Dev for Soha. It just doesn't gel. I think she just wants to have a support at Dixit house because she had been isolated from the rest of the family unit for 7 years. Funny no that how in spite of giving birth and being a mother, she is still treated as mindless doll who can be used and discarded as per their convenience?

Dev-Sona

Sona was in the kitchen when she heard some noise and with the lamp flashing in true filmy' style, noticed the main door ajar & went outside to check. Dev put Golu to sleep & headed to Suhana's room to check on her & was surprised to see Mami opening the door.

Mami spun a yarn about Sona missing since the last half an hour & Suhana asking for her mother and an anxious Dev left to look for Sona. Mami's knowing look as Dev departed had me wondering if she had any part to play in what happened earlier with Sona.

Dev noticed the door open too & was shocked to see Sona talking to someone, who he realized soon enough, was Jatin. Dev got understandably upset, having told Jatin earlier to not come to Ishwari Niwas. I am not sure as to what to make out of all this. My first question would be...what was Jatin doing outside Ishwari Niwas at that time of the night? Was it something urgent that couldn't have waited until morning that he had to come personally to meet Sona? Did he call before coming or was he hanging around there? Did Mami have any role in all this?

Dev's annoyance on seeing Jatin outside his home was an opportunity for Mami who tried to poison his mind about being concerned at Sona's inappropriate behavior & about people gossiping. Dev brushed aside her fake concerns but Mami insinuated Sona being an irresponsible mother as she was busy chatting away with no care about her sick daughter. Dev didn't rise to the bait but it was obvious that he was not pleased at Jatin's arrival & Sona's conversation with him.

As Sona came in, a very disturbed Dev accosted her & Sona's calm answer that as Jatin was forbidden from entering inside, she had gone out to meet him further annoyed Dev. They argued & Sona calling Jatin as Soha's godfather had me wondering. Was I reading too much into this term? Because being a father figure & being a godfather are 2 very different things. I will put this down as a creative glitch & ignore it for the time being. I will continue on the premise that Jatin is a father figure to Soha, nothing more.

Dev told Sona that he did not consider her to be a responsible mother who could take care of her daughter alone. His comment that in the last 6 years, Sona managed to take care of Soha because of able support from the Boses, though valid, were not right or even appropriate, in my view. Sona naturally prickled at that comment but what she said made me smile wryly. Here they were, arguing again, both equally concerned about their daughter & getting irritated at each other that they didn't realize what they were saying. Sona called Dev insecure & one can't completely disagree with that. It was a fact that Jatin was someone Dev felt insecure about at many levels, his closeness to both Sona & Soha was something Dev was not comfortable about. At this point, Dev was definitely not happy seeing Jatin with Sona but at the same time, he was also concerned about Soha & expected Sona to be around her all the time. Not seeing her with Soha was the real reason behind his initial outburst, although seeing Jatin with Sona was also an equal contributing factor. This time around, Sona understood this very well & hence her valid question stumped Dev.

Jo apne insecurities ka tamasha banaa raha ho...usey ye decide kar lena chahiye ke usey kis cheez se problem hai...Soha ke bimaar hone se ya Soha ki Maa kisse baat karrahi hai, usse'

As Sona left, Dev was left standing wondering at what she had asked & wondering at his own reaction.


Dev's accusations seriously pissed me off there. I wonder what he would say if Sonakshi tells him that he had zero responsibility and endless freedom these last 7 years so he is not capable of being a good father? Specially since his parenting style supports that claim.

Last Scene

A very poignant scene with flashbacks that got me emotional again. Dev with Golu (was that Ish's room they were in?) and Sona with Soha in Dev's room were lost in thought. Dev thought about Sona talking with Jatin & tightly closed his eyes, realizing that he was getting jealous. He then thought of the lovely moments he had spent with Sona 7 years ago. Sona too was thinking about the time she & Dev had spent together & it was interesting to note that they both were thinking of pretty much the same moments they had shared. The look Sona had as she looked at Dev's side of the bed was very poignant as she remembered her own words she had told him (Aap mere liye itne important ho chuke hain ke aapke alawa mujhe aur koi hurt hi nahi kar sakta'). She realized how Dev was yet again becoming important to her & his words were capable of hurting her even now.

The episode ended with both of them remembering that fateful night when they broke up before uttering those harsh words & realizing how much they still affected each other...Realizing how much they still cared.



Conclusion & Final Words

Things look like they were definitely improving between Dev & Sona, even if they were only in spurts. They still got annoyed with each other & they argued but now there was also the realization that they cared about each other. They both frequently remembered the times they had spent together & while Dev always remembered the happy moments, now even Sona was remembering those happy moments. They both were now more wistful than bitter about the past, although the way they separated still pains them. Their common purpose of their daughter's happiness & their genuine concern for her well-being was making them more understanding towards each other & making them realize that things needn't be as bad between them as they had set out making them. It was possible to have a relationship of cordiality & quiet understanding. While love didn't feature between them right now, they know they care. These come out in various forms like insecurity & mild jealousy for both of them but deep down, they know they are now hurt & had hurt the other in the past but don't want to deliberately hurt the other anymore.

Realization... the best step towards trying to make things better. Dev & Sona were on this path of realization now & things had to get better.


I don't know about that. What good is realization if people are not willing to rectify their mistakes? Dev is still easily influenced by his family and taking it out on Sona, Sonakshi is then again goes back to hating Dev and in her belief that this man can't ever change. So it's a vicious cycle.


PS - I love the title Tia😉


Thanks. 😳

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
Thank you, Deepak. 😊

Originally posted by: deepakloveskat

simply amazing. wish i have ur writing skills

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
Ashi, well said. Count me in too.

Hum tum ek naiya mein baithe ho, aur Bhaiya hole kar jaaye.
Hamari hope aur expectations paani mein doob jaaye.

Originally posted by: ---Andromeda---

The story of my journey with Dev Dixit.


Ladies and gentlemen!! What you are about to read is a heart wrenching story in which a poor viewer(read Ashi) gets tormented by a TV character.

So the story begins in 2016 when a simple,unsuspecting viewer with the name of Ashi began watching KRPKAB and got introduced to a character named Dev Dixit.The post below describes the various phases of the viewer's relationship with Dev.So here I present you 50 Shades of Dixit


Phase 1

Dev was a promising character.He was like a breath of fresh air.He was charming and sweet.Yes he had his own share of flaws but that made him realistic.He understood the value of relationships.He was devoted to his mother but that devotion and love was justified.He had found happiness when he fell in love with Sonakshi.She had filled his life with colors.In Natasha's case,though I really felt bad for Natasha yet we cannot ignore the fact that he had dealt with her in a sensible manner and not unceremoniously like Sona dealt with Ritvick.Now it was expected from him that when his mother would oppose to his relationship with Sona he would handle her maturely.He would act like an adult and convince Ishwari to accept his relationship.As a viewer I had expected Dev and Sona to act like a team and convince Ishwari.


Phase 2

This is when the first crack in his character happened.Instead of standing up and fighting for his love,he turned spineless and left Sona in order to cater to his mother's whim.Leaving Sona was not the solution.It was Ishwari who needed counselling.But Dev refused to see this.At this point the viewer observes that Dev is enslaved to his mother.He lacks the guts to fight for his love.And after he had thrown Sona out of his life,he misses her because she was something he desired.But he cannot take a stand because of his mother.Then the viewer gets to see a shocking aspect of Dev.He resorts to stalking,harassment,drinking and turns obsessive.He even attacks the professions of an innocent man (Ritvick).Towards the end of this phase,he becomes a whiny child who wants his toy at any cost and finally Mommy dearest gets it for him.Let this be noted.He took a step ahead ONLY after Ishwari gave her permission.


Phase 3

Kiddo has got his toy.Viewer has lost most of the interest in the character and is still sticking to see how Dev handles his relationships.And Dev Dixit scores a big zero in this paper.His wife is subdued and humiliated.He does nothing.The viewer expects him to adjust and understand his wife.He does nothing.The viewer expects him to become a man for once.He does nothing.The viewer is losing patience.Dev has become a ship without a mast.Finally that infertility treatment,the slap to Bijoy and the filthy,abusive words to Sona become the final nails in the coffin of the viewer's relationship with Dev.


Phase 4
Dev has become a mad,raging bull who is out of control.He gives a damn for women,behaves like a loafer and insults the woman he had once loved every time.He doesn't reflect on his mistakes.Infact he doesn't think that he has made any mistakes.

At first,viewer's blood boiled but later on the viewer got completely detached to Dev.Now Dev is dancing like a monkey and the viewer doesn't care.


However one thing which is constant in all these phases is Dev's undying love for Ishwari.His list of priorities are-
1.Ishwari
2.Himself

Moral of the story:The only person with whom Dev can be happy and whom he can make happy is Ishwari.


Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
OMG... That was hilarious. 🤣

Originally posted by: Ananya.

@Ashi--- So apt!

Phase 1-- "Munda yeh perfect hai, jo chaahe iske naam ka.. Special rab ne banaya hai, yahi hai bad ek kaam ka!"

"Yeh hai most wanted Munda.. kehti hai har kudi!"


Phase 2-- "Hero..Tu mera Hero hai. Villain jaise kaam na kar. Sapnon ki iss rani ko aise toh badnaam na kar. Deewani Yaar Kehta hai.. Pyaar achha, nahi deewanapan!"

Phase 3-- "Jisko Sanam maan kar shab bhar mare, wo kameena mataji ko dekh ke phuss ho gaya. Jisko Mohabbat ka teacher kehte rahe, ek phateechar so lesson me phail up gaya!"

Phase 4-- "Who let the dogs out??!!"

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
Dixits ke liye to saare rules alag hain naa. Sab ko unke hisaab se chalna hota hain. Kyunki Ishwari hain Bhagwan aur uska chamcha hain Mummy ka personal samaan. 🤢

Originally posted by: lalsunvid

Dev and Ish are same ... they only want to rule and possess... they never realize anyone's worth.

See they were in so much poverty ... and that money passion and obsession was in thier mind a lot...Dev earned so much ... and Ishwari was guarding it ... she looked Sona as an outsider always ... if ever she thought if her daughter happened to sign an agreement before marriage will she do that ...no only money mattered to her ... I can quote lot of instance from this serial for this obsession and want to posses nature ...

These two don't know what's love what's affection ... what's that in giving what pleasure you get in accepting a person as themselves... without making them bend for you...accept people as they are ...
Dev didn ask Sona to bend ... but he didn value her values and her way of things... that's why during the infertility track he talked one thing inside and in front of everyone he couldn't express his opinion also... he valued only his Mother's feelings and opinions...

Me and my mil have a lot of contrasting natures ... cooking ... dressing ... doing pooja ...money and lot of things ...but from the beginning she or my fil have not asked me to give up my wishes or my way of doing things ... nor I have asked them to do ... According to the time and place we do small adjustments and see that things go smoothly. Respect for everyone's value and wishes matter the most ...

Had Sona tried to do anything that night just similar to Ishwari what he would have done??


Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
Precisely. Bijoy's anger was justified. He kept his side of the truce. But Dev didn't keep his side of the decency. But what shocked me was Asha behaviour. She knew Soha was sick and didn't let Bijoy know about it? I hope Bijoy puts his foot down and moves out. Since he is such a problem for Asha, she can live on her own and Bijoy can find someone who respects him.

Originally posted by: IFfreak

Soha is a such a special member of Bose house. everyone adores her so much. Just because they are not clingy and do not exercise rights over living beings, does not mean it would not hurt them to know that their little girl is sneaked away for so many days in the middle of the night.

I wish Sonakshi had better sense than to present such a useless idea of shuttling between 2 households. She should have stuck to 'ONLY' Dev coming for stay at Bose house and limited visitation rights for other Trixits..that would have been fair.

Dev would have grown tired of this arrangement after some time and he'd stop faking concern and care for Sona even in front of Soha. that would have cured Soha's obsession.

Userdoesntexist thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Some kind person tell me about the episode with Madhurima. I wanna watch it.
Mujhe Bejoy ke liye Achhi ladki chahiye!
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
Check out the time when Ishwari thought that Sona was pregnant and Bijoy became secretary of the society. 😃

Originally posted by: Ananya.

Some kind person tell me about the episode with Madhurima. I wanna watch it.

Mujhe Bejoy ke liye Achhi ladki chahiye!

lalsunvid thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Tia.0

<font size="3" color="#336666">Check out the time when Ishwari thought that Sona was pregnant and Bijoy became secretary of the society.</font>😃




Haha super episodes ...

In all this we forget to appreciate the actress Supriya who scores well ...but now it's like she herself looks disappointed !!!

Boredom creeps in for all to do the same things again
Userdoesntexist thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Yaar tum log CC ko abandon kyun kar dete ho? Sir Dard hatana hai toh wahin Chalo na!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".