What exactly is Ishwari's issue with Sona?

ra_chi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
I didn't start seeing this show from very beginning, so I think I missed out something important and so I was researching from beginning. Is this the that she doesn't want Dev ever to get married? I saw she had difficulty accepting Natasha, though she was telling him to think for himself and all. Then Sona's entry. I thought she was angry/hurt that Dev didn't bother to the her himself. All the dirty tricks she played being innocent made me think she is far worse than GKB. They broke up later she herself went and convinced Sona to marry seeing Dev's Devdas mode. But then she tried to keep them apart. why doesn't want her son to be happy? If she wanted to have grand children why did she try to keep both away from each other? Then she got them separated. She saw the state Dev was in. Why didn't she realise only Sona could keep him happy if she is hurt that her son is sad? I don't understand what kind of mom she is? Why doesn't she want her son's family completed?

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

2.3k

Users

11

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

luvflicksgirl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Yes, I was just thinking about it last night. Ishwari claims to be a good mom and she portrays herself as World'd Best Momma but she was always concentrated on Dev. Again she could never accept any girl in Dev's life. She was and still is selfish.
She understood that Dev is not happy without Sona but still she didnot make an effort to accept Sona for her son.
I still don't get why she doesnt want Sona in Dev's life, when she can see that now with Soha in between the trio can become what Dev alwas wnated to have.
How can she herself being a mother expect Soha to leave Sona and come? She could never accept another woman in her son's life, she couldnot share her son and then she expects Sona to give away her daughter.
Jai Jagat Mata - what a mother...👏

purplegrapes thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Eshwari is a narcissistic mother.
Shlroy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
There is not 1 but many reasons. -
Ishu can act in front of family to be mahaan and a goddess who noone can deny anything becoz that's a cardinal mistake but she can't hide from herself from her own reality. She herself knows she is a pretty bad mother somewhere inside maybe that's why she keeps on repeating the contrary out loud. She knows she is selfish and her happiness is supreme to her. The main reason she hates sona is becoz she is not at all fake or immoral or selfish or vindictive as she really is. What characteristics ishu us acting she have actually someone really have them and that's sona and so ishu is afraid that sona can unmask the real ishwari and snatch dev from her forever.
The other reasons are-
Ishwari doesn't have any habit and neither want to develop to have a third person between dev ishu
All the rules changed when Dev fell in love and was not that obsessed with ishu as he was earlier and his behavior and routine too changed though unintentionally.
Ishwari always thought that dev and ishu were a team fighting with the world alone but with sona's arrival, sona and dev became the unbeatable team
Sona tried to win everyone's heart by adjusting, compromising and engaging with other family members which will ultimately mean that sona will become a good dil with her direct comparison with ishu
Dev and sona love each other to the infinity which is some kind of love ishu can't have from dev.
And many more like this. In short for ishwari dev is just exclusive for ishu and him giving any importance to anyone else is like loosing her importance in his life. If dev had a arrange marriage then things would have been little different as there would not be a love relationship between dev and his wife and the wife too would be under the thumb of ishwari.
Edited by Shlroy - 8 years ago
maharathikarna thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Its not problem of only ishwari. All mothers have this issue. Only thing is normally everybody keeps it under control. But ishwari mata has made parading it as a virtue.
In simplistic sense it the same feeling as you have when your puppy which you brought by great love and affection becomes somebody's else in front of your eyes. I know its crude comparison but it sums it up pretty well.
Edited by maharathikarna - 8 years ago
vibg thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
ishwari has a sic mind and wants her grown son to only love woman.. and thats herself! being manless, she wants Dev for herself.. sic
reeeh thumbnail
IPL 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail 11th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
This is the doubt I have since the show started... And the doubt has grown complicated after the leap... Vansh bhi aage badhana hai, lekin Dev ke saath koi ladki honi bhi nahi chahiye... The contradicting wishes of Iswari... 😆
On a serious note - I think it's 2 different issues, before leap it was her possessiveness, but after leap it's her ego which is against Sona...
kasaf_ZGH thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Even she said Dev aur soha ke beech sona kaise aa gayi? She doesn't understand had sona been not there soha wouldn't even come to world she is simply a typical Indian MIL.
someonelikeyou- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ra_chi

I didn't start seeing this show from very beginning, so I think I missed out something important and so I was researching from beginning. Is this the that she doesn't want Dev ever to get married? I saw she had difficulty accepting Natasha, though she was telling him to think for himself and all. Then Sona's entry. I thought she was angry/hurt that Dev didn't bother to the her himself. All the dirty tricks she played being innocent made me think she is far worse than GKB. They broke up later she herself went and convinced Sona to marry seeing Dev's Devdas mode. But then she tried to keep them apart. why doesn't want her son to be happy? If she wanted to have grand children why did she try to keep both away from each other? Then she got them separated. She saw the state Dev was in. Why didn't she realise only Sona could keep him happy if she is hurt that her son is sad? I don't understand what kind of mom she is? Why doesn't she want her son's family completed?


i)Basically, Deb's mother Ishwari is possessive, so much that she doesn't want him to share his life with anyone else but her.

ii)She earlier thought that if Sona comes into Dev's life then she will snatch him away from her.This makes her really insecure and jealous thus she doesn't want Dev to be married to Sona.

iii)Why wasn't she so reluctant when Dev spoke about marrying to Natasha? The reason is because he had been marrying Natasha for business reasons, thus no love was included at all.

iv)GKB, that is Radha maami's brainwashing/manipulation tricks.Earlier Ishwari had no problems with Sona until maami came to the Dixit mansion.She started brainwashing Ishwari about how clever and cunning sona is and all she wants was money.She had convinced Ishwari that Sona wasn't the right girl and all she wanted was money.

v)The reason why even Sona left the house was also partially GKB.She manipulated Ishwari of how Sona is making Dev come closer to her, and how Dev is not gonna love her anymore.Also the one who told Ishwari about the 5crore rupee drama was GKB...sab fasaad ki jad wahi hai.

vi)She accepted Sona as Dev's wife because she couldn't tolerate Dev's devdas drama.She loved her son, so she wanted him to live well, she could see the obsession he had...as in a reflection of herself in him.Hence, for his sake and well being she accepted this proposal.But since Ishwari is also possessive and obsessed about Dev, she couldn't tolerate Sona taking her place in his life.

vii)She does want her son to be happy.But with her not with anyone else.This is against Ishwari's rule book.

viii)She did want grand children, but maybe she'd forgotten the way she had kids or maybe the basic science one must know which has no relation to one's intelligence/literacy/education.

ix)She had made this fact really clear in her mind that she could be the only woman in his son's life.She loves her son and can do anything for him, except bringing a life partner for him.Even in real life a lot of women are like this sharing the same characteristics as Ishwari has:possessiveness, truly self centered-ness, immaturity , and senselessness

x)She hated the fact that since Sona has come into Deb's life, he had started hiding things from her which he had never done in his entire life, as if he will always be in her lap wearing nappy's.
She hated the fact that Deb had given 5 crore to Sourabh, Sona's brother without her permit.As if before signing all his deals, he asked her.
She hated the fact that Dev called Sona's mother, Asha 'ma' because Dev has the right to only call her as ma not anyone else.
This was also against Ishwari rule book.She had started to hate Sonakshi, and became spiteful and spineless.She was obsessed about dev, she wanted him to be with her for her sake not for Dev...everything which was happening was for her not for anyone else.Therefore it hurt her ego, and she had forced Sona to get out of the house.

I hope it cleared all your doubts, (I must have repeated some facts.)

Edited by someonelikeyou- - 8 years ago
ra_chi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: someonelikeyou-



i)Basically, Deb's mother Ishwari is possessive, so much that she doesn't want him to share his life with anyone else but her.

ii)She earlier thought that if Sona comes into Dev's life then she will snatch him away from her.This makes her really insecure and jealous thus she doesn't want Dev to be married to Sona.

iii)Why wasn't she so reluctant when Dev spoke about marrying to Natasha? The reason is because he had been marrying Natasha for business reasons, thus no love was included at all.

iv)GKB, that is Radha maami's brainwashing/manipulation tricks.Earlier Ishwari had no problems with Sona until maami came to the Dixit mansion.She started brainwashing Ishwari about how clever and cunning sona is and all she wants was money.She had convinced Ishwari that Sona wasn't the right girl and all she wanted was money.

v)The reason why even Sona left the house was also partially GKB.She manipulated Ishwari of how Sona is making Dev come closer to her, and how Dev is not gonna love her anymore.Also the one who told Ishwari about the 5crore rupee drama was GKB...sab fasaad ki jad wahi hai.

vi)She accepted Sona as Dev's wife because she couldn't tolerate Dev's devdas drama.She loved her son, so she wanted him to live well, she could see the obsession he had...as in a reflection of herself in him.Hence, for his sake and well being she accepted this proposal.But since Ishwari is also possessive and obsessed about Dev, she couldn't tolerate Sona taking her place in his life.

vii)She does want her son to be happy.But with her not with anyone else.This is against Ishwari's rule book.

viii)She did want grand children, but maybe she'd forgotten the way she had kids or maybe the basic science one must know which has no relation to one's intelligence/literacy/education.

ix)She had made this fact really clear in her mind that she could be the only woman in his son's life.She loves her son and can do anything for him, except bringing a life partner for him.Even in real life a lot of women are like this sharing the same characteristics as Ishwari has:possessiveness, truly self centered-ness, immaturity , and senselessness

x)She hated the fact that since Sona has come into Deb's life, he had started hiding things from her which he had never done in his entire life, as if he will always be in her lap wearing nappy's.
She hated the fact that Deb had given 5 crore to Sourabh, Sona's brother without her permit.As if before signing all his deals, he asked her.
She hated the fact that Dev called Sona's mother, Asha 'ma' because Dev has the right to only call her as ma not anyone else.
This was also against Ishwari rule book.She had started to hate Sonakshi, and became spiteful and spineless.She was obsessed about dev, she wanted him to be with her for her sake not for Dev...everything which was happening was for her not for anyone else.Therefore it hurt her ego, and she had forced Sona to get out of the house.

I hope it cleared all your doubts, (I must have repeated some facts.)


Yes you cleared most of it. But one more thing. now she doesn't have any issue in Dev bringing Soha home. Why is it so? If Soha comes home there is still a chance he will be spending his life with her, right? Ish wouldn't have him for herself. How can she want Soha in Dev's life then?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".