premheerfan thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I am new here and have been a silent reader of this wonderful forum. I have a few thoughts, hope you will like them.

The lead pair of this serial seem to have made a permanent place in my dil!! (i guess it's like many others on this forum). When they showed the current track I thought, here they go, they are now going to spoil the character of Prem to glorify Heer... but they haven't, really. They have infact led us to believe that and then justified the whole thing with one or two sentences from Prem. But here I would like to state that the creatives have got it all wrong. The issue here is not Prem choosing his family over Heer... infact, if he didn't than he wouldn't be The Prem. My major problem is that:
1) Prem never ever doubts Heer. Even when the rishabh and veera track was going on - in the good ol' days - he tells veera, heer jooth nahin bolti. So why now are you guys making him eat back his words? How can he now believe that Heer would hurt his mother in any way. That she would make gaya3 mom cry? Especially after her going 10 extra miles just to prevent Prem's mom's tears. (and this was also a track by you).
2) I have seen other serials, where the lead pairs are supposed to be besotted and completely in love with each other and believe me, none, absolutely none, have the chemistry to make me believe in them and their love. Here you have two, who just sort of meld into each other (prem sabse jyaada heer mein samaya hain!!), they only have to look at each other and they have the audience gripped and yet, you ignore it all?? You have not shown a single complete scene of their love? Have shown no development in their thoughts or in their feelings... infact, by making Prem think that Heer could be at fault, you are taking a major step backwards. And that, does not, I repeat, does not work in a story which so far has been about Prem Heer are one. Earlier they could feel each other across continents, and now seem to be falling short of understanding each other inspite of living under the same roof. What exactly are you creatives, trying to create? A pair which withstood everything including death - in great glory, I might add - now is at crossroads only because of two of the stupidest vamps!!! and one misguided mother!!!! Come on!!!!!!!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.8k

Users

12

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

sweetness4eva thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: premheerfan

I am new here and have been a silent reader of this wonderful forum. I have a few thoughts, hope you will like them.

The lead pair of this serial seem to have made a permanent place in my dil!! (i guess it's like many others on this forum). When they showed the current track I thought, here they go, they are now going to spoil the character of Prem to glorify Heer... but they haven't, really. They have infact led us to believe that and then justified the whole thing with one or two sentences from Prem. But here I would like to state that the creatives have got it all wrong. The issue here is not Prem choosing his family over Heer... infact, if he didn't than he wouldn't be The Prem. My major problem is that:
1) Prem never ever doubts Heer. Even when the rishabh and veera track was going on - in the good ol' days - he tells veera, heer jooth nahin bolti. So why now are you guys making him eat back his words? How can he now believe that Heer would hurt his mother in any way. That she would make gaya3 mom cry? Especially after her going 10 extra miles just to prevent Prem's mom's tears. (and this was also a track by you).
2) I have seen other serials, where the lead pairs are supposed to be besotted and completely in love with each other and believe me, none, absolutely none, have the chemistry to make me believe in them and their love. Here you have two, who just sort of meld into each other (prem sabse jyaada heer mein samaya hain!!), they only have to look at each other and they have the audience gripped and yet, you ignore it all?? You have not shown a single complete scene of their love? Have shown no development in their thoughts or in their feelings... infact, by making Prem think that Heer could be at fault, you are taking a major step backwards. And that, does not, I repeat, does not work in a story which so far has been about Prem Heer are one. Earlier they could feel each other across continents, and now seem to be falling short of understanding each other inspite of living under the same roof. What exactly are you creatives, trying to create? A pair which withstood everything including death - in great glory, I might add - now is at crossroads only because of two of the stupidest vamps!!! and one misguided mother!!!! Come on!!!!!!!!



You said it all in one go!! I with you in this!!!!! Yup showing separation because of the stupidest vamps is totally lame if you see that death could not separate them!!!!!!!!!!! Buck up creatives, show us Premeer are one!! I m glad they didnt separate the main leads like they do in all serials, like they dont talk to each other and all...Here at least Prem and heer know why all of this is happening.I just wish this doesnt turn into another Saas Bahu Saga! Please let it be an eternal lovestory!!!
-Bee- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Thank you for putting it so well and so concisely...
None of us expected Prem to chose Heer over his family, that is against his whole character. But, the basis of Prem-Heer's relationship was trust, and truth. Prem trusted Heer more when he had no idea who she was. The creatives can STILL undo what they did on Wednesday, if they just show a FEW lines of how he knows that Heer did nothing wrong, that he was just frustrated at the situation.
In fact, the whole basis of Prem's character was that he stood for right. Prem is the Ram of this story, and the creatives somehow lost his essence on Wednesday.
I completely agree about the chemistry HC-AG share. These two simply set the screen on fire. The emotions they manage to portray without uttering a word is simply amazing. I don't understand why the creatives are not encashing on these two, since most people do watch the show for these two...
sonu0511 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
i agree with whatever you said...
the prem would never choose heer over his mother...
but dint like wednesdays track
hope08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
Yeah. I agree completely. Prem thinking Heer lied or she's responsible for his mother's unhappiness is just plain wrong. If the creatives can't understand what Prem and Prem and Heer relationship is all about then the whole purpose of the show is lost, right?
I just don't understand why the creatives just don't encash on the whole HC and AG chemistry. Agreed there is no pair on television who can create magic with just their eye lock as much as these two can. They sizzle just by being in the same frame, without even uttering a single word. Agreed the story can't be always about them being lovey dovey but at least show us a couple of days of happiness. We feel really cheated that after all the stupid Gaurav/Prem drama we get a total of 7 mins worth of happy Prem and Heer!! i mean that is ridiculous. I guess the creatives have just lost the plot and the worst is they refuse to see it.
Aanandaa thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
Hey just for the records...Prem ONLY said Heer lied just for the heck of it, to convince the others...HE NEVER BELIEVED IT HIMSELF..Because whenever he said it, he was looking away or was fumbling....

@Premheerfan: Awesome post...Seems like your first post...welcome aboard

Soaps1 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Are you one of the creatives? 'Hehe' if you are I am so glad and if you are not I am even more glad. They damaged prem's char on wednesday and they need to redeem him completely by undoing that. Prem can never push heer like that or glare at her the way he did or think that she did wrong or that she made gyatri cry. Prem knows heer can never do that so they need to undo what they showed on wednesday other than that I don't hav a problem

Welcome aboard and have phun
-Ashoo- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
welcome to the phorum! great post!! we feel the exact same way!
Bul3 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Hey welcome dear...I totally agree with you..awesome post!!
premheerfan thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

@yes, iqbal does rock!! (whenever we see him!) - and kdm does too, whenever the creatives get prem heer right - or just focus on their love.

@hope08 - is there some sort of copyright for thought process??? Your thoughts are so so similar to the thoughts of my friend that i sometimes can just read your post and sometimes just talk to her... you guys really would make good money if you can get to the bottom of this!! Yeah, you're right... we saw more of their togetherness on the sbs then in the actual show!! I hope they show at least one segment per episode featuring only these two... (wishful thinking, I know, but what the hell?) - Hope the creatives get the plot right, otherwise we're definitely in for a rocky ride.

@ athena - thank you. Sorry, i beg to differ. The prem I have grown to love, would never think that heer could ever lie. And as for his fumbling and away looks, it's because he knows in his heart that he is wrong, very wrong.

@ nadia - thank you. How I wish, i was the creative or the assistant creative at least. The head creative job should definitely go to my friend who thinks a lot like Hope08!!!! Oh, for that matter, all of you guys on the forum would definitely do a much better job than what the creatives have been doing so far. Do you think any of us stand a chance? Is there an application form somewhere? I totally agree with you on this post, plus the others i have been reading all along.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".