Why Sidharth is a weak contestant ?

Everyone in this forum is jumping on Tanisha for her ' Decision' and declaring Jay a best captain, Sid a weak contestant ( oh well majority ( blind haters 😉 ) I am sure bcz of her past show, fans of an ahem ahem contestant😉 , anyways )

You have a point, you win some and you lose some.

I agree Sid can't be termed as weak contestant based on just one stunt.

It was his first stunt, that too game changer and he failed it in over enthusiasm. That doesn't make him weak. That stunt was really a tough one and they had big disadvantage of doing it first. Even Jay's team who did it later slipped in the same way, just that they knew that there is a possibility of slipping so they were careful and managed it for little longer time. The margin between the two teams was also not very big unlike the first stunt.

If Siddharth can manage to overcome his excitement based on first stunt's experience, he will manage to do well.

Based on first week stunts and precap, I feel Tina and Mahi are weakest contestants.

PS: The way he took Arjun's comment of him not being selected for any stunt sportingly, and later didn't blame Tanisha shows his team spirit. Any other guy would have cribbed about that. Tina's comment about him was completely unwanted for.

I won't say that Sid is weak. This is literally too early to say that. In the 5th season, Niketan used to end up in almost all the elimination tasks in the 1st half of the season. But he ended up as the runner -up. Even Rajneesh- the winner, was an underdog and not a favourite. So yes- We can't really say anything about who is strong and who is not- at this stage- and this is literally the first week.

Jai is a gud captain??a big hahaha at d statement
Going by his expressions when his team was losing d task, he dint seem sporty enough to b a leader..N by d promos of d upcoming episode d way he handled Mahi during d task speaks volumes of him as a leader..one needs to know how to deal wid members n how to encourage dem bt he was simply shouting at her..he is too aggressive to b a captain imo...His team won so all was well for him..I wud like to see how he wud react if he loses...
Saving Tina doesn't make him intelligent..whom to save amongst dem wasn't rocket science...it was too obvious
I feel all three himanshu, Vivan n sid were victims of d poor concept...I wish vivan n sid wud hv been given a chance before to perform a task n save demselves..unfortunately weaker members got saved n who appeared stronger had to face eliminations

wont blame any certain contestant why the other is out since the only one responsible for the unfair elimination of a strong contestant is the messed up concept of the show

but coming to Sidharth yes I do belive he is not a strong contestant
like @lovely_lady has said before "He may be big and strong, but he completely lacks flexibility and control over his body. His stint in JDJ totally displays that" I second that!
only upper body muscles dont help much in a show like KKK the best example for this was Iqbal in last season

I do n't think Sid is one of the weak contestant, He have great body he is very strong power but the Game concepts would not better to him, i do not like Team work if KKK concepts will be change if they give a chance to perform the task one by one every contestant should do their task solo

You do get an advantage by going 2nd because you get to see the other team perform the task but you do not necessary win by going 2nd.

Originally posted by: Fatima_Q

You do get an advantage by going 2nd because you get to see the other team perform the task but you do not necessary win by going 2nd.

While doing the task, his fellow team mates were blaming Sid for them not being to maintain the balance or get many flags. Was it his fault? I don't know...it's so easy to point fingers.

But then, his fellow team mate Tina said that he should have been sent into the elimination round because he's not a team player. Aishwarya also voiced her disapproval over the selection of Vivan and Himanshoo...so something must be amiss about Sid.

I mean we see an edited version of the show...something must be going on on the ground there that his team mates know that we don't.

Anyway...even if Sid had been sent into the elimination round, there is no saying that he would have lost...that we cannot and should not assume...because it didn't come to that.

IMO Tina's comment was just to create drama. She didn't even do a single stunt with him to judge him on his team spirit. Interesting she conveniently forgot about the important stunt that she herself lost while she was saying that Sid should have been in elimination.

Thanks for this post, TM
Actually calling Siddharth weak contestant considering that one task is unfair. He wasn't given any individual opportunity yet, and the group task he was sent first was such a task that a heavy built guy couldn't balance effortlessly. Comments of the other contestants can't be considered right, when they barely know each other. Sid isn't weak, it's just this week he hasn't got an opportunity to showcase his full potential yet.