Thanks for writing In but U have overlooked certain facts
Kiran wrote
Finally abt prem ,I can't understand why he always says "mera beta prem". Prem is not his son. Legally he is bajaj son becoz during prerana operation it was bajaj who signed the document as prerana husband. He never uses his brains chodo jo chiz ha hi nahin uske bare mein baat kya kara.
First of all in ur first Post U were not even clear which Prem does Anurag think about ? U haven't clarified. On the samadhi plank it is written Prem son of Anurag basu and Prerna ( It states very clearly who is the father)
Anurag communicates with Prem 1 in the last episode. What is the problem? Allow Anurag to grieve for a son who left him so early in life; here legalities do not come in. For all his faults he has a right to commune with the son he lost, for truly he was his father and mother for some time. A father is a father, blood ties are too strong, there are differences, anger hurt, rejection but love for ur own child encompasses everything.
A bout legalities u had to say
Prem is not his son. Legally he is Bajaj son becoz during prerna operation it was bajaj who signed the document as prerana husband. He never uses his brains chodo jo chiz ha hi nahin uske bare mein baat kya kara.
second post states : neither prem1 nor prem2 is anu son legally. I am talking of legally n not medically. Wen prem1 was born he was adopted by shekher(prerana brother) n it has never shown in kzk that anu has adopted him. ( the bold part is being replied in the last)
Kiran I beg to point facts
You brought the issue of legality
There is no mention of Prem one or two?????????? I will repeat, Bajaj was not on the scene when Prem 1( he came in the soap much later on the soap) was born, During Prerna's operation , he signed for Prem 2. You have not clarified this pt.
I repeat legal issues were brought up by U that is why I took the legal aspect, one does not adopt a child who is related to u by blood. In the first instance Prem 1 lived with Anurag later when Prerna too comes to the Basu fold, when she marries Anurag. So marriage is binding. Or Not?
Still I will like to point out that Legal issue is dead here. In fact in the entire soap, it is Apna Law that prevails. Anurag and Prerna are divorced, they make and break up, by law Sneha and Anurag can meet, he could take the help of law, to exert his rights as a father, the battle can be long drawn out, infact when Sneha was quite Young(once he gets to know of her paternity) he could have easily tried through the courts. . He does not, his guilt of rejecting her once is too much. He says I have to repent for it all my life. Even if Sneha comes close to him in the future, the realization will still be there.
UR SECoND POST STATES
Abt prem2 ,u talked that wen bajaj signed the document he was not related to prerana. -----------------------wen anu signed the document in the hospital during prem2 operation he was also not related to prerana n married to apo*na . accoding to law , legally he can never be prem2 father as such type of relationship is not accepted by law unless u adopt that child ----------------. com on anybody can go to the hospital n tell that he is prem father that does not mean he becomes his father.
I have to say this
Anurag will always be related to Prem 2 and Sneha by blood, he is not some one walking in the hospital and posing to be Prem 2's father without him prem 2 could never come to this world or even Sneha. He is Prem 2's father who stood by Prerna and did his duty the blood ties are much too strong . Prerna recognizes Anurag.
You said
that docter was never told that anu is sneha biological father. So they should not have allowed anu to sign the paper as father wen prerana,------------- was present.
During Sneah's operation Anurag signed the papers as a father for both the children, Prerna disappeared at the crucial moment and Bajaj was out of town. In the crucial moment Anurag did not lose his nerve he signed the papers for the Docs to go ahead. In your opinion Anurag should not have been allowed to sign--------------- . It means Anurag should have participated in the legal and illegal debate, let crucial time to pass off and lose his 2 children, eventually in the blame game there would have been another case against Anurag. It did not happen at all thanks to Anurag both the children are safe.
Even if u say legally or illegally ,
law recognizes the rights of illegal children, they will always have right in his property or what ever. Apo*na was already dead( disappeared cant be sure if Ekta will bring her bacK) so Apo*na was not there when Prem 2 was born and Anurag signed the papers, biologically he is his father. This child was brought in to this world by 2 consenting adults Prerna and Anurag to save their daughter Sneha. You have not responded to this.
U speak of legally and medically in one breath_______ can u explain. A/C to me Medically means
To be fit or unfit
You said :::
That's the fault of the hospital ----------------was bajaj n prerana who always takes sneha to the docter. N that docter knew that bajaj is sneha father. That docter was never told that anu is sneha biological father..
I have to say this:
After the leap the Doctor recognizes Sneha and commends her parents meaning Anurag Basu and Prerna Basu for taking an extraordinary decision of bringing Prem 2 in this world. How does he know? Sneha gets to know her real father's identity from the hospital.
Surely Anurag visited the hospital again and again. Besides him the entire family visits the hospital. To be a biological father is no crime. In fact it was this very thing that came handy when Sneha needed to be saved. The issue about Prem 2 has not been resolved, for sure, he is Anurag and Prerna's son. He must be 20, there is no compulsion on him to stay with Prerna and Bajaj or Anurag . But Ekta will bring in some twist here.
You said this :
legally he is bajaj son becoz during prerna operation it was bajaj who signed the document as prerana husband.
I repeat I have no problem with who signs, but u brought it, it is amply clear from ur statement who ever signs the paper( legally he is bajaj son becoz during prerna operation it was bajaj who signed the document as prerna husband.) becomes the father u brought the issue and I took ur statement further that u believe in signing documents about saying something about rships Prerna and Bajaj were not married at that time when Prem 2 was born , so how does Bajaj becomes Prerna's husband?.( Kiran said legally he is bajaj son becoz during prerna operation it was bajaj who signed the document as prerna husband ).
You said : So they should not have allowed anu to sign the paper as father wen prerana,the mother of the child was present. One thing more u mentioned that anu signed for both sneha n prem2. then it was clear by that time that sneha was bajaj daughter proof( All her certificate has father name as risababh bajaj n name sneha bajaj). --------------So sign of bajaj.
Yes I do know the importance of birth certificates but I also know that when Bajaj signed it was simply for medical reasons, Prerna was in a critical state, Doctors wanted an undertaking they do this when taking complicated cases, and not to prove about somebody's birth. Here too there is a flaw, Prerna's mother was present, she could have signed after all mother is the closest relative. But these things are overlooked. The birth certificate is given by a Municipal Corporation. What Bajaj signed in is a mystery? he was brought in by Anurag he does gets to know from the Doc that Bajaj chose Prerna over Prem in the event of operation getting complicated.
I keep repeating legalities are not for KZK PPL to see, they are superimposed, when dialogues fail or when they want to bring a twist.
You did not like Anurag communing with his son Prem 1, (neither prem1 nor prem2 is anu son legally. I am talking of legally n not medically.) Wen prem1 was born he was adopted by shekher(prerana brother) n it has never shown in kzk that anu has adopted him.)
Kiran U overlooked these facts
Prerna was single Anurag did not know Prem 1 was his child so she gives her son to Shekhar ( it was not shown legally, I am stressing the legal except earlier to and here too coz u have pointed them out ), it was a sister giving her son to the childless couple with ample doses of mushy dialogues.
Now what an irony Shekhar and his wife start neglecting Prem.
Prerna has disagreement with her brother and sister in law because the childless couple are about to have a child. There are no legalities here, hence forth Prerna starts looking after the child. Anurag gets to know about it later they are engaged , Bajaj comes does all that is possible to get Prerna and marries her.
Later we have a wailing Prem 1, Bajaj is not happy with the situation coz he wants Prerna to look after Cookie who is blind Prem would have been a distraction. So Prerna goes to Anurag handing Prem 1 with to him by saying now onwards u will be his mother and father. Anurag and Basu family look after the child. Later Anurag marries Prerna with Prem 1 participating in the wedding
The fact will always remain that Sneha Anurag, PRem1 and Prem 2 are all related by blood..
Anurag or any father does not require legal sanctity to sit before his son's samadhi, and contemplate on the days gone by or simply remember him, it is the ties that bind that bring him again and again for sure Prem 1 and Anurag shared a bond however short lived it was.
Kiran I would request U to read the posts of Shimmer and Shimmer1 and other Anurag fans. These are facts that have been pointed out before.
signora 2
Marathi TV
