Instigate; Revenge; Hypocricy

kenthad thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Taking revenge, instigating against one another and family disputes for property or money or now even having 2 wives have become a norm in the in the SERIALS/SOAP/DRAMA's. Lot of people watch these shows but here in the western world you do not hear that people put the killing, instigating and taking revenge into practice. But in India people put what they see into practice. I mean these shows are fun to watch but not entertaining any more - this just gives the general public more amunition to do things which they would not have thought of other wise. look at WRMK see what the inlaws put pari through just so that the son can marry someone else - even if they had half the brain they would realize that their own daughter is married to pari's brother. Another one KAVERI's character, or Jigyasa's character, how far does one go? similary same thing in every single drama. I don't take these shows seriously but I sure hope and pray that some day there will be justice and the directors, and writers and all people involved in breaking the up the families get the opportunity to enact the scenes that they have written and directed and made millions of. (I say this because I have seen how people have enacted what they see in these shows in their own families) Is this the so called Sabhyata and Parampara? is this what we want to teach our kids? I definitly would like comments on this topic. - thanks

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

471

Users

3

Frequent Posters

armana thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
k,
I see a lot of anger in your post.
I don't know quite what the source of your anguish is but here's my opinion for all its worth:
i would hesitate to make both the assumptions that you have made:
1. in the west ppl are not emulating/ putting into practise what they see on t.v.
2. in india ppl do emulate/practise what they see on t.v.

ultimately the producers and scritwriters produce only that which sells. shows do close down because of falling trp. ergo, ppl chose what they watch. case in point are the falling trp's of ks post ONS to the point where they had to pacify the audience by telling them that JW was drugged.
it's a different matter that quite often they willfully misunderstand what the audience is saying: but ultimately they have to give in. Mihir had to be shown alive. J&B will have to brought back together etc.
on a differnt note, i think that somewhere, in a certain sense, t.v. are a refracted reflection of the state of the society/culture they are produced in. so, i would not heap the blame on t.v.shows. that would be mistaking the symptom for the disease.
lastly, sabhyata and parampara are not the domain of t.v. if you are depending upon t.v. shows to pass cultural values on to your children, let me assure you that the battle is already lost. Culture and values are and ought to be transmitted from other more legitimate sources such as parents. and allowing children unrestricted access to t.v. shows meant clearly for adults is in anycase wrong. last, but not least, one could successfully argue the converse quite successfully: that through these shows many an important points are hammered home. that to be as selfish as pia is despicable. to be as honest as bani is admirable. that greed is a cardinal sin that can make a sister like Jigyasa turn into someone awful.
t.v is entertainment. it can sometimes strike a chord with the viewer: like the way JB captured our romantic imagination, but in the end it's only a fanatsy. nothing more and nothing less.
hope my reply made some sense without offending you.
armana

smitzz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
These TV shows cannot be considered as a source to cultural values. And whatever is shown is mostly larger than life. It's purely for entertainment. If one feels children get influenced by these serials, then parents need to moniter the TV viewing of their kids.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".