there is an advantage in introducing new character instead of new mani

if they introduce new character instead of new manik, there is a chance that parth can come back to kyy in somewhere in the future.

Yeah i agree
i js want happy ending of manan which we dind got in s1
hope ki s2 mei miracle ho with
manan/PANi only

what if parth doesnot come back... then manan will be over forever... repalcement is the best option... also if parth decides to come back which only has 0.1% chance again replacement... its illogical and weird to see nandu having feelings for someone else... manan are more important than pani...

Originally posted by: spnfan

what if parth doesnot come back... then manan will be over forever... repalcement is the best option... also if parth decides to come back which only has 0.1% chance again replacement... its illogical and weird to see nandu having feelings for someone else... manan are more important than pani...

Dont wanna sound pessimistic but Parth has taken the final call it seems like. Bringing Manik out of the dead or getting a plastic surgery done is far fetched ridiculous theories that work only in crappy daily shows like Ekta's. If the makers really manage to pull this up, they need a strong character n more importantly they should justify life giving second chances n show Nandini becoming a strong woman n how she and Navya bring the Fab 3 back coz now that Manik n Cabir are gone, they would have wanted that - see Nandini move on n Fab 3 stick together. In this way both MaNan and Fab 5 would be alive in their hearts. If Nandini moves on in life with a different life partner that doesn't mean Manik is no longer a part of her life. He will always be her soulmate.

Originally posted by: FieryHeart

Dont wanna sound pessimistic but Parth has taken the final call it seems like. Bringing Manik out of the dead or getting a plastic surgery done is far fetched ridiculous theories that work only in crappy daily shows like Ekta's. If the makers really manage to pull this up, they need a strong character n more importantly they should justify life giving second chances n show Nandini becoming a strong woman n how she and Navya bring the Fab 3 back coz now that Manik n Cabir are gone, they would have wanted that - see Nandini move on n Fab 3 stick together. In this way both MaNan and Fab 5 would be alive in their hearts. If Nandini moves on in life with a different life partner that doesn't mean Manik is no longer a part of her life. He will always be her soulmate.

After watching the precap I think the guy playing guitar is right handed we know manik is left handed

Originally posted by: spnfan

Its not confirmed whether manik is dead or not... he must be in a coma or must have left town coz of cabir's death... so no one is talking about plastic surgery or return from death..

He wont come back. He has got another show. Its not that he is sitting idle. 😆