twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

DAY 61! - NO!

No...not today...not tomorrow...not ever! No no never!

They all made their genuine attempts. To assure her. To support her. To assist her. To persist her. No Nandini...we won't let you lose...because "you mean a lot to us". No Nandini...you can't let go of music. The music that once brought you two together. You can't let go of the lyrics that you once wrote for him. You can't let go of the tune that he hums for you. You can't let go of the songs you've sung together. But denial still evident in her eyes. Fear still trembling in her voice. Defeat pouring through her tears. She tells them all...No...I don't have it in me any more...


But one friend has promised to always lend the helping hand in need. One well-wisher promises to enlighten her every time she feels herself to be stranded on an unknown island. No Nandini...you have to fight this time. If not for yourself, then "find it for Manik". No Nandini...you're not the only one hurting...he's crumbling too. No Nandini...you can't give up now, you can't give up on yourself otherwise his world would come crumbling down too. No Nandini...he's not as brave as strong as he portrays himself to be...your pain...it's killing him every second. Your suffering...it's weakening him with every progressing day...

"Because he's never loved anyone like the way he loves you now..." No...and never will he be able to love anyone like he loves you today...


"Main Mangalore ja rahi hoon. I need to go."

No Manik...I have to go...for myself, but mostly for you. "I'm breaking you"...I'm shattering you from inside. I know you'll never express your pain to me. No. Never. Because as you said..."mujhe koi farak nahi padta if it's hurting me" For you...it has always been about my pain...my smile...my happiness...my tears...my safety. But I can't deprive you of your smile, just because my smile doesn't exist any more. I can't snatch your breaths from you, just because I'm suffocating every minute. I can't become the reason for your agony just because my wounds aren't healing fast enough. No Manik...I can't be this selfish. My love is selfish...yes. Because I want to be able to protect you. I want to be able to smile for you. I want to be able to shine for you. But I can't be so selfish to make you suffer in my pain. I can't be so selfish to make you shudder when I dream a nightmare. I can't be so selfish to let you lose yourself whilst helping me find myself.

No..."I need to go". Today I need to distance you from myself so I don't pull you with myself into this dark hole. Today I need to fight my battle myself so I can protect you from further hurting yourself. Today I need to walk away from you so I can eventually return as the Nandini that you fell in love with. You had once said to me..."It hurts! It hurts to hurt you Nandini"...today I want to say that "It kills...it kills to see you dying a thousand deaths in front of me Manik." And so no...I can't be this unfair to you. I can be so heartless. I can't be so self-centred. It's not even your fault Manik. No. None of it. It's all my fault. I failed to trust you. I failed to recognise between right and wrong. I failed to protect our relationship from falling apart like this. Had I listened to you, we would be laughing right now, singing right now, making beautiful memories right now. Had I listened to you, I wouldn't be scared of our touch. Had I listened to you, you wouldn't have been in so much pain. But I failed. I failed you. And so I myself must find what has been lost. "Manik...please mujhe jaane do"


"No! You know what...I can't let you go. No, I can't...I just can't"

Are you listening to yourself Nandini? Are you listening to me? No...you can't leave. You can't leave me...you can't leave us...not for a second, not even for a moment, and certainly not for an unknown number of days that you plan on going away for. How will I...what will I? No no no...it'll be impossible for me to even make it through a second without being able to see you. I'll go insane not having your presence around me. I'll end up losing myself trying to find you, your scent, your shining earrings, your innocent eyes, your soothing voice, your beating heart. "No tum kahin nahi jaa rahi ho, mai tumhe kahin nahi jaane deh ra. Okay? Decided". I nearly lost you a few days ago. The wounds are still tender. The guilt is still drowning me. I don't think I will be able to face myself if god forbid something happens to you again. When you cry, my heart weeps tears of blood. When you flinch at our touch which originally bounded as in an unbreakable knot, it feels like someone has grazed their nails against my bleeding wounds. When I see you tremble in fear, my rage boils Nandini. The fire inside me wants to set the whole world ablaze. No no...you can't go. If you go today...I'm afraid I won't be able to control myself Nandini. I'm afraid the pain will overpower my senses. If you go...I'm afraid I won't be able to breathe in my own guilt.

"I can't let you go!" No Nandini...you can't leave today. You can't leave tomorrow. I'll never let you leave. You have to take me with you wherever you tread. I'll make sure my love keeps you tied to me...hamesha. I vow to keep myself bound to you...forever. You can try fighting off my hold...but my fingers promise to tighten their grip on you. You can try taking a step away...but my heart promises to follow your heart with ever step. You can chose to tread on a different path to me...but my soul vows to shadow your soul on any and every unknown road.

"Main tumhe nahin jaane de sakta". I disallow you to leave me. My love is selfish. No I can't let you walk away alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to protect you at every step. No I can't let you cry alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to wipe every tear that escapes those eyes. No I can't let you suffer alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to snatch away every pinching pain inside you. You may have it in you to live without me for a number of days...you may still have the strength to gather yourself "akele"...but my love is selfish Nandini. My touch is selfish. And my heart says I need you. My heart says it doesn't want to be left alone. It won't survive if it's left alone. My heart wants to claim its right to be able to help you gather yourself again. My heart wants you there for me to gather myself again...


"Nandini...look into my eyes...and say this. Come on..."

No Manik...please no. Don't make me do this. Don't make it so difficult for me. Don't make me hurt you again. Don't make me pierce your heart with the words you don't want to hear. Don't make me so helpless that I have no choice but to use the weapon you once gifted me...


"Manik...you'll have to let me go. Main apna blank promise use karoon gi. You won't follow me...to Mangalore."

N-n-n-no! No..no...Nandini...don't ask for what I can't give. I had once told you to never ask me for anything as precious as your Appa's pen because I won't be able to give it to you. Don't Nandini...please no. Don't ask me to give you the sole reason of my existence. Don't ask me to give you the only thing which keeps me alive. Don't ask me to give you my most precious thing...don't ask for yourself from me...


His tears weept their 'no'...the quivering lips stuttered their 'no'...the shocked eyes screamed their 'no'...but she didn't stop.

But she forgot...she forgot what Manik Malhotra is most known for. She forgot the words which he had once uttered to her with the most sternest voice; "Never have I ever, taken a no for an answer"...


"Tumne bhale hi apna blank promise use kar liya ho...but somewhere down the line...tum accept karo ya na karo...you also know that...that you need me...always"...

No Nandini Murthy...I didn't let go of you today. You've decided to leave on your own. You can push me away, but you can't force me to push you away. You can let go of me...but you can never compel me to let go of you.

"Ho sake toh...thoda pyaar jataa de...

Sookhi padi dil ki iss zameen ko bheega de"...

Your love may want to let loose of me today...but my love will always pull you back. You want to escape my eyes, my touch, my hold, my words...you want to make it easier for yourself to leave me...but I vow to make it beyond difficult for you to leave me,

"Aye hamnava...mujhe apna bana le"...

You may have decided not to make me a part of yourself today...but you can't stop me from making you a part of myself...

We're destined Nandini...my stars and your fireflies has written this story. And no one can pull you away from me...not even you yourself...

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'

So I literally sat their for half an hour...fanning myself and say no Twinkle...stop crying..just stop. Because I knew I had to post something up. My emotions are everywhere right now...This piece is all over the place too but I had to write something because MaNan's love literally broke my heart today...

Sorry I don't think I want to mention anything about Harshad and Aryaman's childhood friendship right now because well...I hope you all understand.

Parth and Niti...please take a bow! ❤️

Edited by twinkle10 - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

7.3k

Users

23

Likes

146

Frequent Posters

naddiya26 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
you made me cry yar
what an emotional description you said all that which was felt while watching

he tired his level best to help her to come out of the trauma

his NO was like as if i will die if you leave me


i want to write more but you have really made me cry with your this post



brilliant post dear
Edited by naddiya26 - 10 years ago
Preeshaxo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
*SIGHHH*
THIS SLAYED Utter perfection this was!! You nailed every emotion, every unsaid word down to a T. So beautiful to read, you be killing me these days!!! Take a bow girl, take a freaking bow 👏

Where do I begin? Episode was love today Tracks being set up, I'm excited too see what happens!

I know you didn't mention Aryaman and Harshad but let me touch on them quickly. Honestly I'm trying to rack my brain around how they are childhood friends and how Alya doesn't even know him? The logic behind Aryaman coming all the way from the states just to help Harshad take down Manik doesn't make any sense to me either. KYY and their blooper logic ways *face-palm*
But when all of them 3 were in one frame together ☺️

Fab3+Nandini. I adored this scene. One by one they told her their deepest secrets and how music helped them. The growth in all of them, telling her their fears and genuinely wanting to help heal her. "You guys are very special to me" How overwhelmed she felt in that moment, it meant a lot to her to know how they care for her and her music.
CabiNi You were the first person I thought of when I saw them together, we asked and we got it
He's the only one who gets both Manik and Nandini. I loved how honest she was with him. She told him how drained out she is, how she doesn't have the fight in her. He tells her however strong Manik might be looking from the outside he is breaking just as much inside, most likely twice as much. "Because he's never loved anyone like the way he loves you"

BABIES 😭
"It must be very difficult for you" she cares for him when he forgets to care for himself and he will go through any pain just to make her feel better because for them it's never about themselves but always about each other!
His face as she tells him she needs space, to go to mangalore ALONE 😭 His no, I can't let you go 😭
For the first time he pulled Nandini back without over thinking it and she didn't flinch at his touch. The head rest, shoulder kiss, temple kiss She lost herself for a moment because just like Manik can't resist her touch, she can't resist his either!
So she uses the blank promise and he shakes his head, his helplessness as he can't let her go. Brings out how vulnerable he is too, cause just like she needs him, he needs her too. His existence lies in her, never can he be away from her nor can he ever let her go.. NEVER!
"You also know that that you need me...always"
Just like she once said to him "Manik, I know you need me" cause even though he pushed her away he accepted that it was her love that could only heal him and just like that she'll also realize its his love that will heal her.

Under no circumstance will Manik let Nandini go, he will find a loophole! If he can't go to Mangalore, Mangalore comes to Mumbai 😎

Love always
Preesha aka Your Soheesha 🤗
Edited by Preeshaxo - 10 years ago
maankigeet4ever thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
me me

"akele". Alone. She wants to walk alone for a bit. So lost the light of Manik's life has become. She wants to be alone, alone in pain, alone in her misery, alone in her nightmares. She wants to be alone so her pain doesn't hurt anyone, not her love, not her friends. Those wonderful friends that open their vault of secrets in hopes of helping her find her music again. She wants to gather herself, but she wants to do it alone. It took them so long to become US from You and I. The staircase has been a witness. They have gone through different steps in their relationship. It has been a hard climb to the top where they could stand united. Now Manik refuses to let her journey through this difficult phase of life alone. He refuses to let her be just Nandini. He refuses to be just Manik. They need to be MaNan. She may not admit it but, he knows she needs him. And he, he needs her. And need, it's lifelong. One cannot ever outgrow a need.

Need, the need to touch. Their touch is a form of communication, has been since day one. But now he has to think, hesitate before he touches her, afraid his touch won't be recognized, afraid it will make her flinch in fear. But the heart, the needs what it needs. Today, it screamed out for Nandini as she took a step to walk away. Today, he pulled her back with righteous claim. Held her close because he needed to, with tenderness and gentleness only she brings out in him. Her touch, it soothes him. And at that moment, when fear of losing gripped his heart so tight, he needed to hold her close, he needed to rest his head on her shoulder, just for a moment. Sighs, that was MY beautiful moment. It just brought tears to my eyes. Two people who love each other so much. The peace they find in each other's arms is so beautiful; it brought tears to my eyes. The overwhelming need to kiss her, just a soft touch of his lips to her soft skin so he can soothe and loosen the grip of the fear that is holding his heart. But right away he realizes, his heart got carried away in the emotions of his love. "You okay?" that two questioning words spoke of how much her comfort matters to him.

Today, he demanded that she sees the truth in his eyes, hears the plea in his voice, when he says: I.Can't.Let.You.Go. I don't know how to live without you. If you leave my side, how will I breathe? You are the very oxygen I breathe, Nandini Murthy. I lost you for a few hours that night and I truly lost my sanity. I can't go through hell again.

Love..so selfless and selfish it is.

She loves him, loves him so selflessly. She can't see him breaking this way while he is trying to mend her. She can't be the one hurting him, giving him pain. She loves him, so selfishly. His pain increases a ten-fold in her heart. It hurts her more than Pandit ever hurt her. This is her Manik, a man who has just started breathing and living. A monster she turned into a human being. She cannot see him pull on another mask on, even if it is a mask of bravery and strength. She can still see that he is hurting. He is hurting. She is hurting. But she wants to hurt alone now, so he doesn't hurt for her. But love doesn't work that way, my Nandini. "If it doesn't hurt, it's isn't love." And true lovers share everything, especially pain.

He loves her, loves her so selflessly. He will hurt, it doesn't matter to him if he hurts, it doesn't matter if it's difficult. As long as she is healing. As long as he can find a way for her to smile and find happiness once again. He will do anything. He loves her , loves so selfishly, because he loves who he is when he is with her. He can't let her go, only because he simply doesn't know how to survive without her. Manik can't lose Nandini. If he loses her for even a second, he loses everything. He will lose his best friend, the one who makes him laugh and smile. He will lose his teacher of life, one who has taught all there is to know about loving and living. He will lose his soul mate, the one who owns his heart. He will lose his sanity, his calm, his reason for being. He will lose everything ! and Manik Maltorta never loses ! He has won his Nandini's heart, not fair and square but he has won it nonetheless. Now, that heart belongs to him, he will refuses to let it go. She has promised a short span of Hamesha to him, she has to remember that she has promised to be his, as he has promised to be hers. No blank promise can hold him back. He refuses to let her go. He needs her, she needs him. They need each other. Always. Hamesha.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Oh wow ! You know how much I love it when you write from Manik's POV. And today it was a double treat, when you wrote both of Nandini and Manik's inner thoughts. God, they were so heartbreakingly beautiful..honestly ached my heart and brought back all the feelings of the episodes. Kudus my twinkie bear. You have the power to rock us with emotions with your words..Truly talented you are, my girl 👏

love as always,

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3

DAY 61! - NO!

No...not today...not tomorrow...not ever! No no never!

They all made their genuine attempts. To assure her. To support her. To assist her. To persist her. No Nandini...we won't let you lose...because "you mean a lot to us". No Nandini...you can't let go of music. The music that once brought you two together. You can't let go of the lyrics that you once wrote for him. You can't let go of the tune that he hums for you. You can't let go of the songs you've sung together. But denial still evident in her eyes. Fear still trembling in her voice. Defeat pouring through her tears. She tells them all...No...I don't have it in me any more...

But one friend has promised to always lend the helping hand in need. One well-wisher promises to enlighten her every time she feels herself to be stranded on an unknown island. No Nandini...you have to fight this time. If not for yourself, then "find it for Manik". No Nandini...you're not the only one hurting...he's crumbling too. No Nandini...you can't give up now, you can't give up on yourself otherwise his world would come crumbling down too. No Nandini...he's not as brave as strong as he portrays himself to be...your pain...it's killing him every second. Your suffering...it's weakening him with every progressing day...

"Because he's never loved anyone like the way he loves you now..." No...and never will he be able to love anyone like he loves you today...

"Main Mangalore ja rahi hoon. I need to go."

No Manik...I have to go...for myself, but mostly for you. "I'm breaking you"...I'm shattering you from inside. I know you'll never express your pain to me. No. Never. Because as you said..."it doesn't matter if I'm hurting." For you...it has always been about my pain...my smile...my happiness...my tears...my safety. But I can't deprive you of your smile, just because my smile doesn't exist any more. I can't snatch your breaths from you, just because I'm suffocating every minute. I can't become the reason for your agony just because my wounds aren't healing fast enough. No Manik...I can't be this selfish. My love is selfish...yes. Because I want to be able to protect you. I want to be able to smile for you. I want to be able to shine for you. But I can't be so selfish to make you suffer in my pain. I can't be so selfish to make you shudder when I dream a nightmare. I can't be so selfish to let you lose yourself whilst helping me find myself.

No..."I need to go". Today I need to distance you from myself so I don't pull you with myself into this dark hole. Today I need to fight my battle myself so I can protect you from further hurting yourself. Today I need to walk away from you so I can eventually return as the Nandini that you fell in love with. You had once said to me..."It hurts! It hurts to hurt you Nandini"...today I want to say that

"It kills...it kills to see you dying a thousand deaths in front of me Manik."

( can I just mention how you already knew I would need to bold this line in red for the amazing perfection that it is that you helped me out and bolded it already. Freaking beautiful)

And so no...I can't be this unfair to you. I can be so heartless. I can't be so self-centred. It's not even your fault Manik. No. None of it. It's all my fault. I failed to trust you. I failed to recognise between right and wrong. I failed to protect our relationship from falling apart like this. Had I listened to you, we would be laughing right now, singing right now, making beautiful memories right now. Had I listened to you, I wouldn't be scared of our touch. Had I listened to you, you wouldn't have been in so much pain. But I failed. I failed you. And so I myself must find what has been lost. "Manik...please mujhe jaane do"

"No! You know what...I can't let you go. No, I can't...I just can't"

Are you listening to yourself Nandini? Are you listening to me? No...you can't leave. You can't leave me...you can't leave us...not for a second, not even for a moment, and certainly not for an unknown number of days that you plan on going away for. How will I...what will I? No no no...it'll be impossible for me to even make it through a second without being able to see you. I'll go insane not having your presence around me. I'll end up losing myself trying to find you, your scent, your shining earrings, your innocent eyes, your soothing voice, your beating heart. "No tum kahin nahi jaa rahi ho, mai tumhe kahin nahi jaane deh ra. Okay? Decided". I nearly lost you a few days ago. The wounds are still tender. The guilt is still drowning me. I don't think I will be able to face myself if god forbid something happens to you again. When you cry, my heart weeps tears of blood. When you flinch at our touch which originally bounded as in an unbreakable knot, it feels like someone has grazed their nails against my bleeding wounds. When I see you tremble in fear, my rage boils Nandini. The fire inside me wants to set the whole world ablaze. No no...you can't go. If you go today...I'm afraid I won't be able to control myself Nandini. I'm afraid the pain will overpower my senses. If you go...I'm afraid I won't be able to breathe in my own guilt.

(omggg..please stop SLAYING me with your perfection, woman. This is all so beautiful. Major struggles choosing what to bold)

"I can't let you go!" No Nandini...you can't leave today. You can't leave tomorrow. I'll never let you leave. You have to take me with you wherever you tread. I'll make sure my love keeps you tied to me...hamesha. I vow to keep myself bound to you...forever. You can try fighting off my hold...but my fingers promise to tighten their grip on you. You can try taking a step away...but my heart promises to follow your heart with ever step. You can chose to tread on a different path to me...but my soul vows to shadow your soul on any and every unknown road.

"Main tumhe nahin jaane de sakta". I disallow you to leave me. My love is selfish. No I can't let you walk away alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to protect you at every step. No I can't let you cry alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to wipe every tear that escapes those eyes. No I can't let you suffer alone because my love is selfish and I have every right to snatch away every pinching pain inside you. You may have it in you to live without me for a number of days...you may still have the strength to gather yourself "akele"...but my love is selfish Nandini. My touch is selfish. And my heart says I need you. My heart says it doesn't want to be left alone. It won't survive if it's left alone. My heart wants to claim its right to be able to help you gather yourself again. My heart wants you there for me to gather myself again...

"Nandini...look into my eyes...and say this. Come on..."

No Manik...please no. Don't make me do this. Don't make it so difficult for me. Don't make me hurt you again. Don't make me pierce your heart with the words you don't want to hear. Don't make me so helpless that I have no choice but to use the weapon you once gifted me...

"Manik...you'll have to let me go. Main apna blank promise use karoon gi. You won't follow me...to Mangalore."

N-n-n-no! No..no...Nandini...don't ask for what I can't give. I had once told you to never ask me for anything as precious as your Appa's pen because I won't be able to give it to you. Don't Nandini...please no. Don't ask me to give you the sole reason of my existence. Don't ask me to give you the only thing which keeps me alive. Don't ask me to give you my most precious thing...don't ask for yourself from me...

Oh man, leave it up to you to never forget anything they say to each other and add it like a punch to the heart !

His tears weept their 'no'...the quivering lips stuttered their 'no'...the shocked eyes screamed their'no'...but she didn't stop.

Captured Manik's devastation perfectly, beautifully !

But she forgot...she forgot what Manik Malhotra is most known for. She forgot the words which he had once uttered to her with the most sternest voice; "Never have I ever, taken a no for an answer"...

"Tumne bhale hi apna blank promise use kar liya ho...but somewhere down the line...tum accept karo ya na karo...you also know that...that you need me...always"...

No Nandini Murthy...I didn't let go of you today. You've decided to leave on your own. You can push me away, but you can't force me to push you away. You can let go of me...but you can never compel me to let go of you.

"Aye hamnava...mujhe apna bana le"...

You may have decided not to make me a part of yourself today...but you can't stop me from making you a part of myself...

We're destined Nandini...my stars and your fireflies has written this story. And no one can pull you away from me...not even you yourself...

Edited by maankigeet4ever - 10 years ago
Felicity_Khushi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
I love reading your analysis a lot
You make the scenes even more beautiful😳
Kapk thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
OMG Twinkle I cannot explain how much I'm in love with your analysis today I loooved, like really, really, REALLLY loved the way you chose to write down the thoughts of fab5, the thoughts of Nandini and the thoughts of Manik - especially how you played them against each other at the end. Loooved it


As usual, your writing style is beyond perfection and one can't do anything than 👏 it! And sorry for the overuse of the word "love" but for me that it what defines your analysis today. A biiig tight 🤗 to you for taking me into three different thought processes - you just made the whole experience (of a beautifully executed episode) so real and so mesmerizing 😊 I don't think your talent has any boundaries girl 😉 Aaahhh I'm still in MaNan world after reading your post
Edited by Kapk - 10 years ago
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Felicity1234

I love reading your analysis a lot

You make the scenes even more beautiful😳

Awww...thankyou so much!! My words will never do justice to the beauty of MaNan's relationship...but it always feels nice when you know others can connect to my writing so appreciate all your love! <3
pavi_ thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Woo ow
You expressed their emotion superbly. Beautiful 👏
That was a very poignant scene with immense depth.
"She can walk away but She can't stay away"
You just made me recall a quote of a wise person - "Love is selfish as well as selfless".
This suit MaNan very much. They are hopeless in love.
Edited by pavi_ - 10 years ago
BriNi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Ho Sake Toh, Thoda Pyaar Jata De
Sukhi Padhi Dil Ki Iss Zameen Ko Bhiga De
u should add this also...
this lines r actually suiting for maniks feelings...
dhvaneee thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
woww very nicely written You have described the scene so beautifully awwsum n ya even I had tears through whole scene pani nailed it.. Manan r creating magic

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".