|firefliesHaven|MaNan AT115|'Harshad Harshad Harshad.Tch.Tch' - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

101.2k

Users

63

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

anita0 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie



Just woke up, watched it again and now the review. And what a time to do so. 😳


I liked it for many reasons more so because they kept it so simple and yet in context.

MaNan - That phone call, on point where they both have pretty much locked each other's response and behaviour pattern .

NavShad- Never cared for them , never will. But gotta say one thing they cannot have Harshad and not play him around this bit , because as much as it's Navya's reality check -her story, harshad too plays a very important role. Before he goes bat-shit funny on fab5 , he needs to sort this .

Navya - They really want to make a strong b-story. Cabir's words, her own fancies and Harshad's return. She has me interested for a bit now. Her story in the initial 100 episodes have been around Harshad. And he too was played through her a lot. We might have different views but that was their arc all along. So basically it's a shout-out to the cherished earlier episodes

Alya- Again continuing with her eating disorder .

^Like how they are giving genuine good tracks to the other characters.Lets hope they execute it well. We wanted tracks for other characters, I guess they did decent by laying the foundation. MaNan were pretty much the b-story today.

MaNan- I like the light tone to how they are handling her trauma and recovery. That smile exchange was cute, this guy once cracked that gandhi joke, googled coffee,w rote 100 sorrys - so very point. I loved when she said she is came for him. Princi and everyone told her to take few days off but he is a huge part of her support system and right now she is using their love to regroup . That bit where she quivers on phone-ring- Nice, nuance.


Dhruv-Dart game.

Whos track was it? Not MaNan but Dhruv's.
He needs to apologize but that doesn't take away what he said. We all wanted to punch him, kick him at times. And he used that technique and confessed that he was an ASS , so please take out all the anger you have for me through this game. Smart, smart stuff- sort of games we have at work when those Inspirational coaches come to spew about anger management. His sorry after this will elevate him. To accept his own Assy behaviour is Major. Props Topi boy, go play splitsvilla now.


MaNan
Umm , light , breezy and sub-text. (less-screen space too)

But before that I would like to talk about Nandu's reactions when Dhruv tells her to try the darts, she is unassuming, doesn't want to dwell and is not ready to confront. And Manik's awareness of it- Score MaNan.

Liked how open they are about their equation. Nandu saw how it might be uncomfy for Manik and she accepted for the game. Her encouragement, the hand holding -that was brilliant, she is warming to his touch on HER OWN TERMS. Return of the Ishq Bulavva, kinda like how they are retracing it subtly . it's all about knowing the new Nandini- that Cabir spoke about. This Nandini is not the same, her perception is altered, which is why I will never compere her opinions before to now. She pretty much said it that she has lost her judgement, her opinion on stuff.


Dart game for me was for Dhruv and they used it to start Nandu's willingness and comfort at his touch. 😆

Loved the background teasing by Fab 5. CaBIni be nice and warm.
Navya-Manik usual. There was genuine bonding between the group.


Dhruv-Manik scene
I like how Dhruv is not dumping down on Manik, I know it's to write off Uttu for the time being but nice to see that the self-respect he wanted, he actually is trying to handle his problems on his own.

Precap- I hate assuming . So.
But she didn't say she is going forever. She is allowed days off to recuperate and she just wants to be alone for sometime and regroup. Space. But this is MaNan , Manik will always be there, as long they keep this sensitivity and let it be about her - Mangalore or no Mangalore doesn't matter.

I hate Adults on this show. But Amms is pretty harmless- she is dense, unaware but comes from a good place as far as her concerns are considered. If they play this track well, I only hope they don't make it about Manik but more about Nandini and let us in.







Lovely review!! 👏👏👏

When was the gandhi joke??
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
@anita0: It was when Manik kidnaps Nandu and takes her to the outhouse. When she is crying, he cracks that "teen bandar" joke.
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie




@Bold- +1000000

And on her terms. For him yes but at this point , only he knows her struggles, her pain so this is her way of healing , using their love to overcome her fears.

Reacquainting the touch is the whole point na, hence Ishq Bulavva song. Smart stuff that.


I am actually happy how they wrote the Dhruv break- gotta credit them for that . Uttu would have never nailed the dialogues but by conceding himself as a loser and having other call him names, it sort of did well for now.



All of this!
I agree... Clever writing that.. The hand holding touched me :) the way they are so in tune with each other's emotions is amazing...

Baaki, morning stalking

Hugs
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie


Just woke up, watched it again and now the review. And what a time to do so. 😳


I liked it for many reasons more so because they kept it so simple and yet in context.

Alya- Again continuing with her eating disorder .
I liked that they are being consistent with this. If she keeps talking about her figure to Mukti, I have a feeling that Mukti might be able to tell that Alya is suffering from this disorder and maybe help her out with it.
^Like how they are giving genuine good tracks to the other characters.Lets hope they execute it well. We wanted tracks for other characters, I guess they did decent by laying the foundation. MaNan were pretty much the b-story today.

MaNan- I like the light tone to how they are handling her trauma and recovery. That smile exchange was cute, this guy once cracked that gandhi joke, googled coffee,w rote 100 sorrys - so very point. I loved when she said she is came for him. Princi and everyone told her to take few days off but he is a huge part of her support system and right now she is using their love to regroup . That bit where she quivers on phone-ring- Nice, nuance.
MaNan scenes were definitely on the light-end note today compared to the scenes last week. They are nicely transitioning, IMO. Loved that poster scene. They were just adorable.

Dhruv-Dart game.
Whoever came up with this game idea - I liked it! 😆

Dart game for me was for Dhruv and they used it to start Nandu's willingness and comfort at his touch. 😆

Loved the background teasing by Fab 5. CaBIni be nice and warm.
I loved how Cabir joked about asking for Manik's permission when they want to have a conversation with Nandu. That was nice. It kind of shows that in the future, Manik doesn't need to be there for Nandu to bond with Fab4. She can do that on her own. She is now part of their family as well.
.

I hate Adults on this show. But Amms is pretty harmless- she is dense, unaware but comes from a good place as far as her concerns are considered. If they play this track well, I only hope they don't make it about Manik but more about Nandini and let us in.
I never really hated Amms even when she was here during Pandit track. 😆Her concern was genuine and I didn't feel she was OTT. First impression matters - she saw Manik punching Dhruv and others badmouthing him. Obviously, she will feel that Nandu's choice is wrong. Also, Nandu sneaked out to meet Manik that night and Amms caught her - who wouldn't be mad if they caught their grand daughter sneaking out in the middle of the night to meet that same boy? Then also, I felt she was strict and she left a nice letter for Nandu.
Well - I hope that at least, Ams will find out about his favorite student and how Manik saved Nandu. I don't know where they are going with this - so lets see - I will be a happy viewer if they keep it about Nandu as it should be like you said.



My comments in red!
Edited by -KP- - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
@KP - Exactly , I like how they are giving tracks to other characters now. Alya's eating thing has again started coming up and today I liked how they continued with it. Nice build up there.
This is fiction, 7-8 characters , you cannot grow or introduce new characters exclusively for Nandu , so they need to have her be friends with fab5 which is not bad, this is very in-tune right now. In college, same circle and they are bonding. That CabIni scene was nice- their dynamic is very interesting always. Mukti was fine too.

The whole episode was a well-written one for KY 2 overall. They glimpsed us at the upcoming tracks nicely.

Actually Nandu was still very lost and zoned out , it is visible that she is making efforts to actually seem involved .
SankiPagal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
KP and Genie you guys said it all.. I so wanted to talk about all this last night, but anyway.

It wasn't filler. They used a very light hearted tone, they aren't going melodramatic and also it was a new day...

They are being consistent about Alya's eating disorder, cabir -Navya - harshad thing is also handled well.. for now. I liked the dart board concept too.. something different light and not some dramatic showdown. The whole time i liked how we were shown Nandu's restlessness. It was good... These small details is what I love...


I love how they are balancing all the characters. Thumbs up and not one is making it irritating for me.. I do not skip anyones scenes... Thats good enough.


They are keep it subtle and non dramatic.. makes it all the more interesting for me to watch..:)
anu0111 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Hello!😳

I liked today's episode . It was cute and funny (intentionally and unintentionally ) . Atleast they were behaving like teenagers for once.😆

The first scene was adorable. Manik wanted to talk to her but then he wanted her to rest also. Gadha 😆

Harshad got bellies for Navya so that she doesn't slip! 🤣How thoughtful of him . And his expression when he saw Cabir living with Navya. 😆He's so clueless and still keeps on talking to himself and plannin god knows what! 😆

Loved the "I miss your smile" scene ! Parth was looking fresh. Nandini is trying to be normal . Loved the way she said "main itni buri dikh rahi hoo?" And Manik trying to copy that sad smiley face was adorable.
But she is so badly affected by the incident .She got scared when Manik's phone beeped . I like how they show such small details .

Fab5 and Navya teasing Manan was cute! Cabir and his dialogues are 🤣🤣Aliya was feeling so good after throwing the dart at Dhruv's photo. So finally, Dhruv apologised to Nandini...it was a little rushed up though. Was Dhruv going to throw a dart on his own photo ?😆
And I am liking Cavya friendship now . Thankgod the shaadi drama is over . Both of them were so synchronised in their reactions during the dart scene ! 😆

The last scene was hilarious ! The way Dhruv was screaming for Nandu's help🤣. And Manik dragged him away just like he drags Nandini away all the time . And Dhruv's face when Manik was going to punch him reminded me of Nandu's face after the Dhruv's fiasco when Manik was going to punch Nandini ! And what was that "I am ready" for? 🤣

Precap - no comments. Hope for the best and prepare for the worst ! After all I am just a viewer and not the writer .😆
white_beauty thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Lovely reviews guys!😊
Even i liked the episode rather the tone of it. It was lighthearted. Also the dart romance for me it was about the fact that nandini voluntarily let manik hold her hand. She is trying making efforts taking baby steps:)
The precap i will talk about that only post the episode cos more often than not precaps are misleading.
But i still doubt there is going to be a full fledged Mangalore track😆
SankiPagal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Yes i did face palm at Navya keeping the gifts and even wearing them the next day... but if i see it from Navya's POV and the kind of character she is... it was really natural.

She is in a state where emotions are at a different level altogether. One thing we need to understand is.. just right then Cabir and Navya had a talk about giving away the child for adoption... Navya for sure didn't like it... and that very moment the father of the child comes and says he is ready to take responsibility and all that jazz... Navya knows Harshad is a kameena has nt changed one bit... but she is the kind of girl, from wherever she will get the kind of attention she wants she would bend down there... what made their whole scene worth was Cabir's jibes at her.

I don't know whether i made sense here or not?
Edited by VKlovesFK - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
VK- I like you talking Navya- because for once I was very aware of her story. Don't know why but she made sense.
Very clever writing in many portions.

She saw Cabir take charge for her infront of Mommas . Then he gave her a reality check about the logistics which she refused to see . Whether it's maternal instincts but by throwing Harshad they are really testing her as character. Nobody is going to marry here, no kid is going to be born but Harshad -Navya equation was a huge thing during initial episodes , kinda full circle that he is in the mix to see how Navya reacts to his manipulations now.She might give in if Harshad assures to support and raise her kid, very desperate and very real.

Again the consistency with Nandu's recovery struggles , slight nuances with her shaking, even restless - so all over the episode. Nice!!


@White, Choco- Word. Light is the word. They were teens and throwing dark game for Dhruv's first baby step was a nice way of keeping it within their age-group and not making it melodramatic.

I just was too happy to see them all together and doing something silly. I cannot remember last when they were hanging out without any need to save the world kind of mission hanging over their heads.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".