|firefliesHaven|MaNanAT#107|Imperfectly Perfect ...Hamesha| - Page 115

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

85.5k

Users

60

Likes

3.4k

Frequent Posters

BoxedIn thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: OneThatGotAway

Dhruv was never supposed to be ANYTHING. Dhruv was done for the day they casted Utkarsh for that role. He is a sweet kid ... and all .. but he would NEVER be able to portray the intuitive , brooody whatever it is that you wanted to see in him. DhruNi franship. LEL. That ship sank before it even left the harbour. Because together MANIK and NANDINI were like Nuclear Warhead and B52-Stratofortress. NOBODY , I repeat NOBODY stood a chance uske aagey. Ab yeh Vikas ki galti hai that he casted two actors who have SUCH strong screen presence everyone else kinda fades into the background, and creatives ki marzi hai ke they gave all their attention to the characters they were to portray.


Manik before Nandini and Nandini before Manik were VERY one dimentional characters. It is with Manik that Nandini showed her fiesty , fiercely protective side and it is because of NANDINI that Manik was able to show his vulnerable , HUMAN side. No offence but his friends were obtuse morons and with them he was TopGun Moron. It was ONLY after his interactions with Nandini that we were able to come to love him as BABA.


I missed this. 😆

See that is why I said 'supposed to be'. Kyunki acting ki baat karein toh Uttu, like you said, doesn't cut close to anything. My 'assumption' about Dhruv was mostly based on the good dialogues they used to give him, or the way he could divert Manik from his temper tantrums. Point is, he had a mind of his own even if Manik treated him like a teddy bear which needed constant cuddling.
Same can be said for most of the cast apart from PaNi. CC has about two and a half expressions in her repertoire, so I still don't know who or what her true lou is. Abhishek looks forever confused and that worked as long as Harshad had some mystery, and Ayaz is plain lazy most of the time. So even if they get tracks, they don't work for the audience. so like you yourself said- story becomes all MaNan, saare layers bhi MaNan.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: OneThatGotAway



Long time indeed Genie 🤗. Too long 😆

See the MOMENT Manik met Nandini and Nandini met Manik ... they began to evolve as PEOPLE. Uske pehle their lives WERE all about Music and FRANSHIP !


Would u rather see their character growth or would you prefer Fuddu5 ke random group hugs and Nandu playing Veena and Naveli bajaoing dugdugi to cheer her on?

GROWTH hua ke nahin, that my friend is a matter of perception.



Rafs - You are sounding like me when I once tried selling these arguments to Boxter. But thing is now I see the light and I meekly accept that she be the Baws. 😆

See MaNan are still love, they have grown together but while Manik's growth is more visible because we have an tangible idea of his lel friendship with fab5 , his give and take , his world ,Nyo, we see a change in that now.

Biut with Nandini it was never there, those initial episodes left her nothing to base her reactions now. So we have to extrapolate, think , analyze her reactions.

Nandu ka harmonium be boss , don't know why they gave her Veena, but while now when people crib that she be blank canvas for Manik's angst , the main reason is they never gavr her shades to develop on. No other bond like Manik has with fab5 were developed initially that can be flirted now .

One thing RIshab is connected to Dhruv which means Manik again. So those episodes never gave any depth to the potentials that Nandu had.


TheFaerieQueen thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Few things that didn't go down well with audience in general I think are
1. Making Harshad the black guy, he was far better in grey tones.

2. Soha track did nothing good - It took away core story from Cabir. It diluted his struggle.
3. Dhurv Alya - So much potential but again they are not visible because too much focus on new entry
4. Dhruv Manik confrontation - waited so much for it, and hath laga thainga ...😆. Wasted to again because new entry Pandit.

5. Useless track of Abhi---What he did with Nandini, existing characters would have done...he was not needed for that. And with Mukti whats the use? where is her growth? She is still the same..

All these happened after initial 70 odd episodes. Actually they could have wrapped it up in 100 episodes. They lost there way moment it got extended.
TRaw thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
finally the AT is active, it was so dull this wknd!

There are flaws in the approach to the tracks, but I have to say I've loved MaNan from the beginning. Them as a couple, I feel have had growth. Its just irritating seeing cameos getting more screen time then the core characters. I would seriously want fun and light moments, and young vibe. Too much drama becomes boring, and this is a youth show, so they should keep at that. Plus, theyve got the advantage of exploring so many issues because its a youth show. Bu thanks for MaNan. I love the romance, and PaNi.

I butted in, but since the discussion of the show is going, adding my bit lol.😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".