Does the concert really matter?

BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hi all,

I started watching this show just a couple of weeks back and I had barely seen the first few episodes when I got hooked to it. Before I used to wonder what's the fuss about MaNan and I had not tried an Indian Youth Based Show yet. I fell in love with Parth's portrayal of Manik, friendship of Fab 5 and MaNan of course. But the craze lasted for about 70 episodes coz post that all I can see was endless break ups and make up of MaNan and Fab 5 took a back seat too I get why Nandini got mad at Manik for the first time coz it was wrong on his part to break her heart n his too just coz of Dhruv. I mean even if he had broken up with Nandini what guarantee was there that she would love Dhruv? 🤪

The second time they broke up was coz of Nandini's lack of trust and I suppose Manik's anger is partially justified coz given the circumstances anyone is bound to get doubts but Nandini's mistake lay in not confronting Manik about it directly before coming to a conclusion 👎🏼 Well when they were not dating and were bickering all the time she trusted him enough to not take advantage of her when she was intoxicated but when she was his girlfriend she could not trust him for not killing the psychotic girl who was hell bent on burning her alive 🤢 Ok I get it Manik is mad. But now the condition he put before her is ridiculous 😕

I understand music connects both of them but how on earth will a concert decide if they are meant to be together or not? Especially now? When they have been through so much and were there for each other when they needed it the most? 😕 Manik clearly loves her and Nandini has stood by him when things were rocky with his friends, be it with Dhruv or Mukti. If he does not want to forgive her for not trusting him fine. Let him atleast set her free. It will be far better than him brooding over whether he forgave her or not after being cozy with her. He had once accused Nandini that her actions and words are not in sync but what about him now? He is doing the same thing. Even if Dhruv sings with Nandini does it mean the end of their relationship? How silly can that get? Its just one show for God's sake and not like Nandini will sing only with him if she pursues music in future too. Manik has his own group and Nandini will go her route. I don't see Nandini becoming a part of Fab 5 even if she is friends with all of them in that group. The new promo does not make any sense at all 🥱 Dhruv will come around eventually and even if Dhruv got this opportunity coz of Pandit's dirty politics, this is his golden opportunity to come out of his friend's shadow and prove something. Maybe if Dhruv does that he might overcome his insecurity and get back to Manik or he might become an egoistic pig 😕 Well depends on future. But still how will Manik not singing with Nandini determine MaNan's fate? 😕

I don't mean to offend anyone here but just stating my view and I still love MaNan but this track had got me frustrated and I ranted away 😆 Please do share your views too.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.7k

Users

4

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Actually for us viewers the concert isnt important, because seriously linking a couple's fate on a concert is strange.
but for Nandini it is important because Manik clearly told her so, and again when Cabir asked Manik, Manik still maintained that he actually meant those words and challenge thing...
at start it was just a simple challenge on how much nandini really want to be with him, whether she can heal and wait for his forgiveness
but now the stakes have increased because Manik isnt performing, and given its Dhruv Manik doesnt even know what to do anymore?
on one side is Nandini's hope and the other side Dhruv, his buddy and friend!
from what was shown last week, it already seems that Nandini has been brought back to the same Musicana track, she actually remembered Manik's words during NYE also.
It's no longer the concert now, the concert is just a medium to either save or break their hope.
varshitap thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Well you have a point, I too was pondering along these lines...😳
How can one concert make or break a relationship?!! I can understand Manik's anger over Nandini not trusting him...but was that really anger?!! If so why did he want to pursue Nandini...what point did he want to make? Does any challenge make sense when you are sure you want to loose!!
Manik and Nandini both are in love but are so full of themselves that they dont want to accept it!!
Everytime they come close to accepting we have Dhruv take the limelight!!😆 then again we have a painful break-up...but one may wonder , when there is nothing then what breaks really?!! It is our hearts ( read fans!!)😡 This conflict of choosing between friendship and love for Manik has become a norm...and we may see the same with the Fusion Concert as we saw with Musicana !! 😆
So the Moral of the story is when there is a concert ..there is a... !! you can fill in the blanks!!😆😆
Hope this time around Manik grows up and is more mature in deciding what he wants. As for Dhruv, he is always there to confuse Manik...does it really need a him for Manik to know what he feels for Nandini?!! I dont know who has to come out of whose shadow?!! Is it Dhruv or is it Manik?!!😕
I have just written down my confusion 😕 and sorry if I have hurt anyone. By the way I love Manan and feel that these conflicts make their relationship special.😊
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Miminits

Actually for us viewers the concert isnt important, because seriously linking a couple's fate on a concert is strange.

but for Nandini it is important because Manik clearly told her so, and again when Cabir asked Manik, Manik still maintained that he actually meant those words and challenge thing...
at start it was just a simple challenge on how much nandini really want to be with him, whether she can heal and wait for his forgiveness
but now the stakes have increased because Manik isnt performing, and given its Dhruv Manik doesnt even know what to do anymore?
on one side is Nandini's hope and the other side Dhruv, his buddy and friend!
from what was shown last week, it already seems that Nandini has been brought back to the same Musicana track, she actually remembered Manik's words during NYE also.
It's no longer the concert now, the concert is just a medium to either save or break their hope.


Yes I understand because back then Manik had laid this challenge to see if Nandini could earn his forgiveness but right now Nandini is not the one who can control the situation. Pandit threw Manik out and it wasn't Nandini. Nandini is no longer the bone of contention for Dhruv and Manik either. So y punish Nandini for this? This is not fair at all. She has done enough to prove her love for Manik and Manik too had hurt her in the worst possible way before and though she took a long time to forgive him she did. Manik broke up with Alya just because she could not have faith in him and sent goons after Nandini to get rid of her as she felt Nandini was coming between their love and now if Manik feels Nandini's mistake has broken his faith in her love for him he should let her go rather than make her pin her hopes on this concert. Poor thing, she thinks that Dhruv taking his place has ended their hopes. If Dhruv does not step down should she live with the feeling that she failed their love? Even if Dhruv does sing, its not the end of Manik's life. His music and his life will go on and so can his relationship with Nandini if he lets go of this bet thing 😕
Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: FieryHeart


Yes I understand because back then Manik had laid this challenge to see if Nandini could earn his forgiveness but right now Nandini is not the one who can control the situation. Pandit threw Manik out and it wasn't Nandini. Nandini is no longer the bone of contention for Dhruv and Manik either. So y punish Nandini for this? This is not fair at all. She has done enough to prove her love for Manik and Manik too had hurt her in the worst possible way before and though she took a long time to forgive him she did. Manik broke up with Alya just because she could not have faith in him and sent goons after Nandini to get rid of her as she felt Nandini was coming between their love and now if Manik feels Nandini's mistake has broken his faith in her love for him he should let her go rather than make her pin her hopes on this concert. Poor thing, she thinks that Dhruv taking his place has ended their hopes. If Dhruv does not step down should she live with the feeling that she failed their love? Even if Dhruv does sing, its not the end of Manik's life. His music and his life will go on and so can his relationship with Nandini if he lets go of this bet thing 😕

actually i dont want Dhruv to step down this time!
Manik has to fight for Nandini this time, otherwise sorry i dont even think why should Nandini even still be with Manik? if Dhruv steps down, Manik wins and Nandini wins? but did Nandini really win here? did her hope really win here?
Not at all, i shudder to think what if Dhruv again creates problem later, then will Manik everytime just sacrifice Nandini at Dhruv's or Fab5's whims??
what kinda of future is that for a girl?
she has clearly become only a toy now, to be pulled or thrown depending on what Manik wantsOuch
anyway i'm not for Manik sacrificing Nandini this time, if he does, then clearly he doesnt love her the way she deserves to be loved😭
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: varshitap

Well you have a point, I too was pondering along these lines...😳

How can one concert make or break a relationship?!! I can understand Manik's anger over Nandini not trusting him...but was that really anger?!! If so why did he want to pursue Nandini...what point did he want to make? Does any challenge make sense when you are sure you want to loose!!
Manik and Nandini both are in love but are so full of themselves that they dont want to accept it!!
Everytime they come close to accepting we have Dhruv take the limelight!!😆 then again we have a painful break-up...but one may wonder , when there is nothing then what breaks really?!! It is our hearts ( read fans!!)😡 This conflict of choosing between friendship and love for Manik has become a norm...and we may see the same with the Fusion Concert as we saw with Musicana !! 😆
So the Moral of the story is when there is a concert ..there is a... !! you can fill in the blanks!!😆😆
Hope this time around Manik grows up and is more mature in deciding what he wants. As for Dhruv, he is always there to confuse Manik...does it really need a him for Manik to know what he feels for Nandini?!! I dont know who has to come out of whose shadow?!! Is it Dhruv or is it Manik?!!😕
I have just written down my confusion 😕 and sorry if I have hurt anyone. By the way I love Manan and feel that these conflicts make their relationship special.😊


Yes u said it absolutely right! Does a bet make any sense when ur sure u want to lose? He wants to lose his bet so that he can get back to Nandini but here neither of them can control the situation. Pandit has taken Dhruv and I dont get y Dhruv gets unnecessary footage? 😵 True they both are so full of themselves that they dont want to probe on the fact that there could be other options too 😛 Musicana I can say it was an impulsive move on Manik's part coz it was the first time Dhruv had fallen in love n he felt maybe he would be the reason for Dhruv's heartbreak but not for once did he consider what Nandini wanted. I felt like cursing him for that 😆 I love their nok jhoks too and the starting episodes were a treat. But after their break up it got dragged endlessly. Can u enjoy these nok jhoks if the story does not make sense to u anymore? 😕 So I watched few scenes here n there n now I am watching on air episodes. I understand for Manik his friends mean the world to him but what about the girl he loves? If Nandini wanted to separate him from his friends I understand he needs to take a call between her and them. But here she comes to his friends rescue even when they are hostile towards her (esp Mukti before the recent incident) just because she knows he wont be happy if anything is wrong with them. Y shd Manik even worry about making this choice when the girl he loves understands and respects his friendship? 😕
varshitap thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Miminits

actually i dont want Dhruv to step down this time!

Manik has to fight for Nandini this time, otherwise sorry i dont even think why should Nandini even still be with Manik? if Dhruv steps down, Manik wins and Nandini wins? but did Nandini really win here? did her hope really win here?
Not at all, i shudder to think what if Dhruv again creates problem later, then will Manik everytime just sacrifice Nandini at Dhruv's or Fab5's whims??
what kinda of future is that for a girl?
she has clearly become only a toy now, to be pulled or thrown depending on what Manik wants
anyway i'm not for Manik sacrificing Nandini this time, if he does, then clearly he doesnt love her the way she deserves to be loved😭

I totally agree with you. I dont know how it will be Nandini's victory if she performs with Manik and Dhruv steps aside. This whole sacrificing business is getting on my nerves!!😡 If Manik keeps sacrificing...then why should Nandini keep proving her point?!! Does she deserve this everytime? Is this her future of togetherness with Manik...I feel terrible thinking of it for a girl as sweet as Nandini. Such situations may keep cropping up and as usual Manik Baba may keep sacrificing...concerts after concerts!! What will Nandini do? How far can she keep hoping and for what?!! 😲 It is time Nandini takes a stand to make Manik aware that " Its not me , its you"!!
Sorry for using the tagline ! Hope I have not infringed any copyrights here!!😛
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Miminits

actually i dont want Dhruv to step down this time!

Manik has to fight for Nandini this time, otherwise sorry i dont even think why should Nandini even still be with Manik? if Dhruv steps down, Manik wins and Nandini wins? but did Nandini really win here? did her hope really win here?
Not at all, i shudder to think what if Dhruv again creates problem later, then will Manik everytime just sacrifice Nandini at Dhruv's or Fab5's whims??
what kinda of future is that for a girl?
she has clearly become only a toy now, to be pulled or thrown depending on what Manik wants
anyway i'm not for Manik sacrificing Nandini this time, if he does, then clearly he doesnt love her the way she deserves to be loved😭


Agreed! Nandini isn't a toy n its high time Manik realised this. Not for once has Nandini come in the way of his friendship, in fact she was there for his friends too. Y? Just coz she knew his friends meant the world to him and anything that was important to Manik was important to her too. Manik does not have to worry about choosing his love or friendship if u actually consider the situation. It is Manik who is unnecessarily complicating matters by linking Nandini with his friendship when there is nothing to be linked with 😵 He needs to find the balance here and if his friends have a problem with Nandini (which they clearly dont and now even Mukti likes her) then its their problem for not understanding how important Nandini is to Manik. If they dont accept Nandini they are being selfish here and why should Nandini suffer everytime? Y should Manik give the test for friendship everytime? Shouldn't Fab 5 too do the same? But here no point discussing coz Fab 5 isn the problem. It never was but its only Manik and Nandini deserves better.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: varshitap

I totally agree with you. I dont know how it will be Nandini's victory if she performs with Manik and Dhruv steps aside. This whole sacrificing business is getting on my nerves!!😡 If Manik keeps sacrificing...then why should Nandini keep proving her point?!! Does she deserve this everytime? Is this her future of togetherness with Manik...I feel terrible thinking of it for a girl as sweet as Nandini. Such situations may keep cropping up and as usual Manik Baba may keep sacrificing...concerts after concerts!! What will Nandini do? How far can she keep hoping and for what?!! 😲 It is time Nandini takes a stand to make Manik aware that " Its not me , its you"!!
Sorry for using the tagline ! Hope I have not infringed any copyrights here!!😛


True, its about time Manik realised if he wants to be with Nandini or not, keeping everything else aside. The concert or Dhruv should not decide their fate. It should be him and Nandini alone who will make this call. If Manik takes Nandini for granted everytime y should she put up with his whims and fancies? 👎🏼

Oh man that tagline is perfect 🤣 True! Its not Nandini but Manik 🤣
Edited by FieryHeart - 10 years ago
Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
😭

Originally posted by: FieryHeart


Agreed! Nandini isn't a toy n its high time Manik realised this. Not for once has Nandini come in the way of his friendship, in fact she was there for his friends too. Y? Just coz she knew his friends meant the world to him and anything that was important to Manik was important to her too. Manik does not have to worry about choosing his love or friendship if u actually consider the situation. It is Manik who is unnecessarily complicating matters by linking Nandini with his friendship when there is nothing to be linked with 😵 He needs to find the balance here and if his friends have a problem with Nandini (which they clearly dont and now even Mukti likes her) then its their problem for not understanding how important Nandini is to Manik. If they dont accept Nandini they are being selfish here and why should Nandini suffer everytime? Y should Manik give the test for friendship everytime? Shouldn't Fab 5 too do the same? But here no point discussing coz Fab 5 isn the problem. It never was but its only Manik and Nandini deserves better.

when he sacrificed her at start, it was genuine and he was right, because then he himself didnt know it was love and Nandini was just a girl he knew for a few months and he wanted
but now it's different
he loves her, he knows she loves him and will break down if he leaves her
can he give her so much pain for a friend who is only fighting for his own demons?
is it so difficult to choose here?
Dhruv is wrong and we all agree, but letting Dhruv do whatever he wants, is that right?
Manik is still being over-protective and suffocating Dhruv, so what does this mean?
Dhruv will change after the concert, what if his ego gets bigger and he's more determined to go away?
what is Manik even thinking?
i understand his love for Dhruv, but this time his sacrificing Nandini for Dhruv doesnt make any sense, in fact it will be an insult to that girl hoping against all hopes for Manik's love😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".