The mind vs the Heart! - Thread - I need You! (Day 17); pg 28 - Page 16

Created

Last reply

Replies

237

Views

29.6k

Users

20

Likes

434

Frequent Posters

MaNanmatic_Sana thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: twinkle10


Thankyou thankyou! :D
Very well pointed out and said... She certainly was the winner and I think we all feel that somewhere inside that's exactly what Manik always wants too... For her to win because it means he'll get to see her beautiful smile again! That scene was epic when he pulls her down because he just couldn't take it anymore. He couldn't bear to see her in colours that he hadn't smeared on her and so he decided to play Holi his way; 'the dirty way' lol

Btw have you watched the new promo??



To find you answer read this...😛

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4328912
.

And about the merger... it was a bad dream... where KYY cast doing a formality... I choose to be patient.. obviously after a lot sarcastic acts...😆
Edited by Manan_aRMAAN - 10 years ago
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Awww my baby... I shall give you a hug because I'm in the same boat atm. I know the feeling... it was just soo... like I don't have words but the feeling when you just stare at your computer screen, twirling your fingers at 1am in the morning going ummm so what was I supposed to be doing again? Oh right... my response on manan.. and then BAM! I realise that for them it's only one day biut I have to put up with this state of depression for two days. *sigh* look where manan and ky2 has brought us. We should be studying for godsake hahaha
But anywho.. this break must be worth it. I better see a restlessly overwhelmed Manik on Friday who just barges into Nandini and pnaditji's class just to see one glimpse of her. And well I better get to see that peaceful and -to-die-for look he always gives Nandini which pretty much means that "how did you even happen to me" So yeh... I'm waiting and I shall wait with patience because patience is a virtue and we all must learn to practice it lol
anywhooo let us talk about the bit I highlighted in red which was your bit about how he can actually kill someone. Oh you bet darling! And we all know that if the circumstances had arrived with soha's case that if she had actually managed to cross limits, he would've pushed her in the same fire she was trying to burn Nandini in. Perhaps he might even realise this by the end of this track? Like obviously we won't see him killing panditji but in his need and determination of protecting nandini, he might realise the extents oh his love and that he is capable of going to any extent just to see her safe and protected.
Oh and you forgot the "alligator" after the see ya later :P kekeke
Twinkie <3
Edited by twinkle10 - 10 years ago
maankigeet4ever thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: twinkle10

But anywho.. this break must be worth it. I better see a restlessly overwhelmed Manik on Friday who just barges into Nandini and pnaditji's class just to see one glimpse of her. And well I better get to see that peaceful and -to-die-for look he always gives Nandini which pretty much means that "how did you even happen to me" So yeh... I'm waiting and I shall wait with patience because patience is a virtue and we all must learn to practice it lol
anywhooo let us talk about the bit I highlighted in red which was your bit about how he can actually kill someone. Oh you bet darling! And we all know that if the circumstances had arrived with soha's case that if she had actually managed to cross limits, he would've pushed her in the same fire she was trying to burn Nandini in. Perhaps he might even realise this by the end of this track? Like obviously we won't see him killing panditji but in his need and determination of protecting nandini, he might realise the extents oh his love and that he is capable of going to any extent just to see her safe and protected.
Oh and you forgot the "alligator" after the see ya later :P kekeke
Twinkie <3

@bolded. DITTO DITTO. I shall have high expectations for how Manik will be anxious to see his Nandu. He bound to worry about the Pandit as well and how much time he got to spend with Nandini 'alone'. Knowing Manik, he will ask her straight in his typical MM way..and knowing Nandini, she will answer honestly. But friday can't come soon enough ! ( yes, i am not as patient as you...lol)

Yeah, maybe that's why the decent Pandit is developing weird intentions. Honestly speaking, i liked a strict music teacher role who was interested in flourishing and polishing Nandini's music. I don't like the new direction his character has taken. But maybe the Cvs purpose is for Manik to realize that he can indeed kill for Nandini ! let's see.
Thou i have been waiting for the Soha death issue to investigated and wrapped up neatly but i doubt the Cvs will give us that.

Later 'Alligator'..lol

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: maankigeet4ever

This is me having Manan withdrawals



Oh how could the production house do this to us ? Give us NO Manan at all. The state of my poor heart



- Reya aka Sunny <3


Awww... come here you!! I shall give you a tight-as hug!!


twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: maankigeet4ever


@bolded. DITTO DITTO. I shall have high expectations for how Manik will be anxious to see his Nandu. He bound to worry about the Pandit as well and how much time he got to spend with Nandini 'alone'. Knowing Manik, he will ask her straight in his typical MM way..and knowing Nandini, she will answer honestly. But friday can't come soon enough ! ( yes, i am not as patient as you...lol)

Yeah, maybe that's why the decent Pandit is developing weird intentions. Honestly speaking, i liked a strict music teacher role who was interested in flourishing and polishing Nandini's music. I don't like the new direction his character has taken. But maybe the Cvs purpose is for Manik to realize that he can indeed kill for Nandini ! let's see.
Thou i have been waiting for the Soha death issue to investigated and wrapped up neatly but i doubt the Cvs will give us that.

Later 'Alligator'..lol

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3


Man.. I like panditji as panditji... he was that focus and discipline that nandini needed in order to strive in her music. but but like now it just doesn't seem like it's going to happen. aaah wells let's see what the coming up episodes will bring.

But omg dude!! like it'll finally be ky2 time soon and manan and gosh can't wait! :D

And yess... are we actually not going to get any words from khurana or any revelation? like my manik will never know how they all bombarded his nandu with spears and daggers and arrows of lies, manipulation and selfish intentions. Seriously breaks my heart.

hahah thanks for remembering :P

see you around!
Twinkie <3
maankigeet4ever thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
This is us in preparation for TODAY ( OMG OMG OMG IT"S FRIDAY PEOPLE)



Keeping your minion love in mind..lol 😆

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3
Edited by maankigeet4ever - 10 years ago
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: anotheranfan


Haha i liked your last times Manan discussion for later so i am going to do same :)

On WH, yes today's episode was better than yesterday's but i still felt like there was disconnect. What i saw missing was when V asks him if he is on same level as her and she is right, i would have liked to see some contemplation, some hesitation, some reminiscence of his time with nandini.. May be he was thinking about it on his way to WH after pandit's same question but i needed that to see that realization of true love in maanik. It isnt just his past talk with V that made him realise.. It is Nandini, her asking him to believe in it, asking him to see it in Mukti and Abhi's relation.. so i really needed to see that here for me to believe that Maanik has accepted that there exists *true love*. Offcourse i get what they wanted to show.. and i am not against V and Maanik friendship and Maanik's desire in past to be more than friends with her, infact i love that angle as it gives more glmpse in Maanik and his belief in love, relations etc which even you pointed out.. So all i felt was cheating from what was promised.. I thought of it more of WH episode rather than KYY episode.. Because shouldnt V have puzzled, confused, confronted Maanik who seems to be like very very good childhood friend to her and her being so mature about who the girl is that made him realise this.. Question his 180degree turn... So yeah my complaint from today's episode is more for KYY disconnect from merger than content.. (BTW i ignored race and other scenes because i really just couldnt connect with it.. And the WH student names are too spooky and too confusing for me to wrap my mind around actual episode:))

On bold in your comment.. That would be interesting to see... Would maanik chose to loose just to keep dhruv happy or win for nandini.. This would be test of his priorities.. Remember he had asked nandini(when he had kidnapped her) where does he fit in her priorities.. We really need to see him not repeat the mistake again.. and able to pass his own *trust test* And winning would mean more problems with dhruv and would be interesting to see how that will play out.. How Manan together would sort out problem with dhruv and help him... Wow now i cant think of any better way to get this track moving.. :) Hope cvs get as brilliant idea as yours :)


Hello again! :D

oh definitely the disconnection was still present from my side too. It's unarguably precise that the execution of this merger episode was a let down and so many of the viewers were dissapointed. Which is fair enough because technically it should've been a half-half episode but it was more of a special appearance by the Fab 5 and just a mega episode for WH. Also was it just me or you also didn't really connect to their performance? I guess I'm just so used to seeing Manik sing for nandini and have flashbacks of her whilst he performs that I just couldn't connect to him today. Their was that little bit of emotion lacking for me. But nevertheless, new episode tonight and I'm super dooper keen to see what CV's have in store with us. Glad to be back to kyy and manan world haha

Oh yay you liked it :D Yeh I reckon it'll be a good experience for manik and he needs to bring that balance in life I think where he should be clear about what his priorities are and how to tackle situations where he has to chose amongst his friends or nandini. So even if i's not the exact story plot of what we just discussed.. I'd like them to showcase this concept. It sort of falls into place eh like we've always wanted Nandini to focus onto her music and balance her life out too but she seems to have her priorities figured out and right now her priority is manik. I feel she knows that after everything falls into place with manik, her music will find a direction too because this performance of them performing together will open up the doors of new opportunities for the both of them hopefully. Now it's just a matter of time for manik to realise his priorities too.

Fingers crossed that this episode is a pleasant comeback! :)

Twinkle :)
MaNanmatic_Sana thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
Hi dear...lovely as usual...
How can you be so relaxed??? The date and the hate ...!!!

I was driving crazy... too much emotions in one kid's face!!!

And than I started writing letter from Monster Mind to heart... which was actually a reply to a letter from coconut heart to Monster Mind

So I did my mind vs heart in my last two emotional encounters...I am kind of inspired by your title...😆

Please check ...I'll love if you love them...

Since I am guessing you did not read any of the two... check this one ...it has the link for the first letter at start...

please read... it will means a lot
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4331661
Preeshaxo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Ok so how can I leave without writing a tiny response.
Out of the 2 days of this stupid merger the one thing I truly missed was your posts!
With our manan back we got our twinkles posts back 😳
I'm really ill at the minute but as soon as I get my energy back I will be back to write my response. You always have a way of explaining things so thank you for making me understand why Manik did what he did in the last scene!

🤗
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: maankigeet4ever

___________

This friday was like a Monday..Manan were back after two agonizing days !
And this was me ( really developing a love for animations..lol)


Cavya: Firstly, your section on Cavya was excellent. I doubt i can add anything, you did it too well. i have to say not the best way for the truth to be out but i am glad it's out there. Boyfriend ! lol, my poor Cabs. Loved his meeting with Navya's mother..haha. his fumbles, his stuttering..lol.But now Navya has learned not to jump to conclusions. She should have waited to see what exactly the conversation was about before she dropped the bomb. But i feel as thou she was so heavily weighted with the stress and guilt, that deep down even she is relieved. She is upset with Cabir, maybe she has a right to be but this happened for the betterment of them. But i am glad they didn't stretch it out. And you are right: now Navya can fully focus on bringing this child to the world. Cavya's friendship will be tested and they will definitely get stronger. I don't know if Cabs is about to become a 'boy-friend' to Navya in the eyes of Navya's mother and the father of Navya's child but i think that is what the mother shall think and Cavya might along with it. LOL. I see Hi-Larious written all over it..

Mukti: Damn, the poor girl ! Abhi despite his best intentions to stop hurting Mukti..he keeps hurting her. If she has chosen to stay with him till his last breath, then he can't walk away every time he wants to. Why ? Why ? Multi is right. Why is killing her in this way ? She doesn't deserve to be denied his presence until the end. He is being selfish and it's not fair. We will have to see which way their story goes according to the note but i am not liking the fact Abhi is dictating how their relationship runs. Bro, it's a two-way street, two people in a relationship and they make decisions together.

Dhruv and Manik: Okies, what's is this man's problem ? like just tell me what it is. I am sort of getting past of the point of trying to understand his problem with Manik. When you look through the world with a certain lens, you are bound to percieve in that manner. So negativity if all Dhruv is seeing. He is aloof with Manik, distancing himself and not giving a damn because he resents Manik. He so desperately wants to be like Manik that he is forgetting what a special friend, a brother Manik has been to him. I feel as thou if an attack would be triggered for Dhruv, it would help these two out. Their emotional bonding. But at least they have decided to talk about it. For now, Dhruv pisses me off..lol.

What a homecoming ! Manik's home is Nandini Murthy so when he claimed, he could have gone home, he lied. He did indeed come to his home. And her sweet catch up date touched him. The cousy, romantic atmosphere brought that tiny smile to his face. The feeling of a loved one waiting for him to return. Seeing how she spent her time awaiting his return: that's such a foregin feeling. Such a good foreign feeling.She knows him too well, he is becoming too predicable.lol. I am glad that thou in a teasing manner, she did clear up about the Pandit, knowing he would be want to know, that's it's bugging him. Quite thoughtful of our Nandu, the reassurance she gives him.

And he sits next to her, unwinds, shares about his day because he is past the point of denying himself the pleasure of her presence. I agree with you, he did seem mentally tired, a tad reluctant to share with Nandu, but the important sentence: " She is just a friend, now" So we shall take it as such. Honestly, i am not very interested in Manik's past ( his love life to be precise). The truth, the reality is that Nandini is his present as well as his future.

She brought him to watch the stars. And star gazing he did do indeed. "You can't resist the stars." So right you are Nandini, he simply can't resist you. He turns to face her, and stares at his own shining star with a look full of love, her smile brightening his life again, her presence bringing peace to his heart. She reaches out and takes hold of his hand, and his entire being comes to life. That little twitch, that's him coming back to life. Away from her, he just exists but with her,he lives. He is alive. She is his reason for everything. For preponing the tickets, for coming straight to her after a long tiring flight. She is the reason for everything he does.

They played a beautiful song for Manan today. Apt in every sense.

Tujhko jo paaya aha
Toh jeena aaya
Ab yeh lamha thehar jaaye tham jaaye bas jaaye hum dono ke darmiyaan haan

With you, i have learnt to live. In every sense, Nandini has taught him how to live, taught him how to look at look at life with positivity, taught him to see the goodness within himself. And this moment, the moment of lying together under his stars, he wants to be in this moment with her forever, because that's all he needs from life: just her. Their love doesn't have room for a third person. Pandit's question is still haunting him but we touch on that later. But what i want to say that while the question still lingers at the back of his mind..for now, his inner turmoil is quietened. He is where he belongs, right next to his love, his heart is content.

"Actually now, it's not hurting as much." The heart is indeed healing, his anger is nonexistent now. I loved the honesty of Manik Matltorta, how he always tells her the truth within his own lies. Because somewhere in his heart, he wants to tell her, "I am not angry anymore, i have forgiven you, our love is past all that, my trust in you is rebuilding." But he can't, not yet. The heart may want to, but maybe the mind isn't ready for it. So instead he tells her to hope. Because her hope is his hope and together as they hope, they shall find their way back to each other. Manan don't really need to confess their love as you have said. Moments like these, coming home to his love after a long day, lying together to talk, sharing and being with each other..That's love.

Now..onto the aggressive Manik Maltorta. Loved the way you described and explained his reason for lashing out in the way he did. Last night when he was with her, the questions, the tensions, all his mental stress he was able to shed. But today, everything is back full force. the inner turmoil is back. He rushes to the music room, slightly out of breath worried his Nandu being alone with 'that Pandit". Nandini was being playful, she enjoys his jealously but she isn't aware of what is plaguing his mind. And you said it: she pushed him to the edge and he erupted. She isn't aware of the war that has been declared between Pandit and Manik. So the 'hold' isn't about their hope vs.hatred game, that game has ended already in a way. As much as Manik hopes for heir hope to win and for them to perform together. This all goes past that. This hold about his Nandini. He is holding her so tightly, he loves her so much that he know no one should even think about stealing her away. His is his life and he will fight for her and he will protect her. So Pandit, i keep warning you and you aint listening: watch out, older generation guy. This younger generation lad is about to kick your ass (figuratively and eventually literally)

Okies...i think i am done..Such a joy to be able to write my essays again.lol. Awesome-sauce as always, written to beautiful perfection.

- Reya aka Your Sunny <3


Heya girl!
Omg yayayay!! My minions!! Oh they are just adorable :D

Okies so firstly dude I can't agree with you more that how amazing it finally feels to be writing a response and just having manan scenes to drool over, And I already know it that i'll be watching the episode again tonight just to absorb the enotions even more haha.
Anywhoo time for me to reply now!
So yuss I'm really keen to see how Navya handles the situation now. I know she'll break down and perhaps she might even be shattered once she finds out that Cabir in fact was the one to call her mum to bombay but I know my Cabira wll set everything right. I know there's a part of him that is used to her presence in his home and the way she takes care of him so now it will be his turn to perform the responsibility of a friend here.
Man so true... Mukti didn't deserve any of this. And abhi did exactly what Manik did to Nandini. He didn;t consider that there was Mukti in this relationship too and she has just as much as a right to decide about his relationship with him. I know that perhaps the intentions weren't as such but he let her down. She had trusted him to trust her and her love and he abandoned her in this painful journey. Her emotional pain I feel is much more than the physical pain he's probably going through and he's left her all alone to deal with it. But I still have hope that perhaps that letter has some sort of number or address or information about his whereabouts. So keeping my fingers crossed there,
I really like how you mentioned that dhruv is trying way too hard to be like Manik at this stage. And I think that's the reason he isn't being able to see anything beyond his frustration. He has seemed have let go of his identity which I reckon is actually the real crux of the whole situation. The day he reunites with his own identity, alot of the things will seem to fall in place I reckon. He has too much building inside him and he just needs to let it out and spill. So hopefully this talk with manik works out well for these two brothers but at the same time I feel it's only the start of the test their friendship will go through.
Alrightey soo my manan! *daydreaming* still about them! Gosh they're soo cute! It was absolutely beautiful to see my manik just give up his fight and sit next to her and just start talking. As we both said, he had so much to talk to her and tell her but he was just so caught up in his turmoils that he didn't know how to start, where to start and what to say. I think to some extent he wanted to talk to her about V but he was in a dilemma as to why does he want to share it with her. And that's why when she asks him questions about V, his mind speaks up to say "tum itne sawaal kyun karti ho." But he wanted to tell her that whilst she might just be his friend now, she is the reason he was able to meet Nandini; his true love. Manik can never cheat on Nandini, we already know that. And we know that our Nandu also knows that Manik is hers now. After all she herself stopped Manik from disclosing about his private moments with Aliya when she was doing that petition to bring back Navya into the college. So V just seems to be an old chapter now and the only thing he seems to have learnt from meeting her once again is that they were always only friends and that he's glad that what he was trying to force their relationship into, never happened. Exactly... same here. I myself am not too interested in what happened in Manik's love life before Nandini because that was the time where he wasn't even aware of the essence of love. It was just an attraction, an infatuation. What matters to us now is how he struggles with his mind every day to resist from opening up his heart in front of her. How he tries to resist himself from showering her with his love but ends up doing it anyway. I felt just soo happy for him when I saw that homely emotions on his face. And especially that part after they hold hands when he sits up on his elbow and just stares at her with his most love-filled eyes. That look said it all. His thankyou to her, his love for her and simply appreciating for the time and care she showered him with today. She understood his turmoils and knew exactly how to calm them and for that, his heart healed a little bit more today.
Honestly speaking, I really liked that aggressive scene of Manik. That fire for her was evident today and that fire can burn down the whole world if anyone ever tries to separate his Nandu from him. It was just a glimpse to the audience of his passion and mad-love for her that can take him to any extent to keep her protected and bound to him. And this is just the start. Next monday, when nyonika will further instigate and air this fire, his passion and need of protection will grow even more. And it will be interesting to watch how he fights with this whole world to be able to sing and perform with her. Because mind you... that night will be the victory of their hope. And biggest of all, his hope's victory.
Yayy! Finally we can have our essayed responses on Manan! Feels really good to be able to write about them again!

Talk to you soon love!
Twinkie <3
Edited by twinkle10 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".