Why shouldn't Nandini plead? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

3.5k

Users

21

Likes

199

Frequent Posters

danceismyworld thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake



She was asked do you think Manik was involved in Soha's death. If it was a choice between killing Soha or letting Soha kill Nandini, what would have Manik's choice been or for that matter any of us. When threatened, the human response in psychological terms is flight or fight, when flight is not an option, only fight is left. I think its a little unfair for Manik to talk about trust on such absolute terms. She said I dont know because anyone and especially Manik can kill in such a situation.

@bold, exactly my thoughts..
His raising question on trust is not an issue but talking about trust on such absolute term is a problem

Edited by danceismyworld - 10 years ago
MKrayZee thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#22
The Question is not whether Manik is being fair in his assessment of the situation. The question is, from his point of view, he got betrayed by the woman he loves most, trusts most.
She was not pissed during musicana that he left her and deliberately broke her heart, what hurt her the most was that he didn't trust her enough to let her make her own choice, that he didn't trust her feelings for him, that he thought that because D was a nice guy she would like him.

It is not the same thing, but trust is what has been broken here. He is seeing it as black and white, she broke his trust - how, why, what led her to do it is immaterial at this point. Im not saying it is not important. It is, and it will come to him eventually because Baba is a lovable gadha like that. But right now, no. Right now, what she is doing is right. If it goes on beyond this, then I would say she is pleading and begging.


Firebolt thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
Doc :') I missed you're words :') I'm having more flashbacks than MaNan right now 😆
Look I get everything. Both sides of the coin. BUT IF SHE WOULD JUST STOP CRYING. 😆

Today the baes were perfect. Nandini pleading makes sense for right now. Because she doesn't know what else to do and she loves him so much. And Manik being Manik also makes sense. He is dramatic and extreme. It's a flaw, one that makes him the Manik we love. If however Manik continues on, she will move on.

IMO she asked him if it would be easy to forget her. Well it's time she walked off and watched him fail.

Then they kiss sax etc.

K? K.

PS - that's Matt Smith on my DP 😆 Grey's got hella depressing 😆
Edited by Firebolt - 10 years ago
-MKB- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#24
Like I said somehwere before why are we forgetting that it has just been one day in KYY land, we have been watching her pleading for 5 days now but for Manik it has just been a day. His hurt is still raw, he is still going through the pains of losing his love and so is Nandini that why she is pleading to him..

Because if u love someone then you of course will try to hold on to them right? And like Cabir once said that "Pyaar mai koi kisi ko adhura nahi chodhta" that is what she has been doing here right? Trying every attempt to win him back, striking his emotional chird by recollecting the memories because she knows his hurt and pain and also his anger. Right now Manik is being angry, impulsive and is not thinking anything straight, he has become some sort of "angry animal" and Nandini knows this, that is why she is desperately trying everything because once Manik calms down he will surely regret his actions!
And plus the 17 year old has just lost her love why shouldn't she cry?

I am waiting for the Pandit angle to come because then he will divert her attention from Manik to music because of the fusion which will stop this roaming around and clinging to Manik! Then it will be
Maniks turn to come around and he will because babies are made that way..one can not survive without the other...Yin Yang :')

PS- were u also on the IPK forum? Coz I remember reading your posts there too 😆
Edited by -MKB- - 10 years ago
...Doctor... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Firebolt

Doc :') I missed you're words :') I'm having more flashbacks than MaNan right now 😆

Look I get everything. Both sides of the coin. BUT IF SHE WOULD JUST STOP CRYING. 😆

Today the baes were perfect. Nandini pleading makes sense for right now. Because she doesn't know what else to do and she loves him so much. And Manik being Manik also makes sense. He is dramatic and extreme. It's a flaw, one that makes him the Manik we love. If however Manik continues on, she will move on.

IMO she asked him if it would be easy to forget her. Well it's time she walked off and watched him fail.

Then they kiss sax etc.

K? K.

PS - that's Matt Smith on my DP 😆 Grey's got hella depressing 😆


I know this is turning cheesy but I missed you so much Shri :D

Nandini needs to stop crying. Like stop right now. She cries so much, I feel she'll dehydrate herself with all the water leaking 😆

Sax! Hahaha. That's the reason I miss you and the gang 😆

Me agrees with all that you said.

I know Grey's is hell complicated :/
...Doctor... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: -MKB-

Like I said somehwere before why are we forgetting that it has just been one day in KYY land, we have been watching her pleading for 5 days now but for Manik it has just been a day. His hurt is still raw, he is still going through the pains of losing his love and so is Nandini that why she is pleading to him..


Because if u love someone then you of course will try to hold on to them right? And like Cabir once said that "Pyaar mai koi kisi ko adhura nahi chodhta" that is what she has been doing here right? Trying every attempt to win him back, striking his emotional chird by recollecting the memories because she knows his hurt and pain and also his anger. Right now Manik is being angry, impulsive and is not thinking anything straight, he has become some sort of "angry animal" and Nandini knows this, that is why she is desperately trying everything because once Manik calms down he will surely regret his actions!
And plus the 17 year old has just lost her love why shouldn't she cry?

I am waiting for the Pandit angle to come because then he will divert her attention from Manik to music because of the fusion which will stop this roaming around and clinging to Manik! Then it will be
Maniks turn to come around and he will because babies are made that way..one can not survive without the other...Yin Yang :')

PS- were u also on the IPK forum? Coz I remember reading your posts there too 😆


This is bang on!

Yes I was there 😆 A lot of people are asking me that on PMs too :P

IPK fangirls come out and say hi to our fellow IPKians 😆
-MKB- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#27
If yes then I myself was IPK Phankie...

Oh those golden days...Arshi, SaRun ❤️

Glad to see IPK peeps here as well
eveline thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#28
Great post...because a lot of times I have noticed a bias...a gender bias...its okay for boys to chase, to beg and grovel when it comes to us girls...we have dignity!! 😆
Seriously, its an issue in love stories...men are supposed to follow and chase us ...its expected and given but if we are made to do so...its all wrong...I will be killed for this...trust me!!😃
...Doctor... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake


She was asked do you think Manik was involved in Soha's death. If it was a choice between killing Soha or letting Soha kill Nandini, what would have Manik's choice been or for that matter any of us. When threatened, the human response in psychological terms is flight or fight, when flight is not an option, only fight is left. I think its a little unfair for Manik to talk about trust on such absolute terms. She said I dont know because anyone and especially Manik can kill in such a situation.


You have a valid point. And I think you're right to some extent. Manik needs to understand her point of view too but right now he's too angry to give a damn. For him, he has been betrayed and Nandini has to do something to make him sit and listen to her. Nothing is happening until they have a proper conversation about it.
...Doctor... thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: -MKB-

If yes then I myself was IPK Phankie...

Oh those golden days...Arshi, SaRun ❤️

Glad to see IPK peeps here as well


Same here. So good to see so many IPK people.

See you around :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".