Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 17, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
🏏T20 Asia Cup 2025: UAE vs Pak, 10th Match, Group A at Dubai🏏
BACK TO MUSSORIE 17.9
HEALING SHUROO 18.9
Premiere - The Ba***ds Of Bollywood
Akash Ambani constantly holding radhika's hand and waist
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sept 18, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
War 2 sets record as biggest flop in Indian cinema history
Soo EMA or SR?
Anupamaa 17 Sept 2025 Written Update & Daily Discussions Thread
Bigg Boss 19: Daily Discussion Thread - 18th Sept 2025
Abhi-Ash Separation Rumours Is Garbage
Deepika Removed From Kalki 2
🏏T20 Asia Cup 2025: AFG vs SL, 11th Match, Group B at Abu Dhabi🏏
Bollywood Celebrates Modi's 75th Birthday
Abhishek reminds me of young Puneet Issar
The Ba***ds Of Bollywood - Reviews
And Ranveer Singh was never the same anymore after that day
ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel Off Air for Charlie Kirk Comments
Who is more beautiful? Mariah Carey or Kareena Kapoor?
Originally posted by: Nikki_Titli
Helloo MaNan fans..😊😊...After this week mon,tue epis,its tonites epi aka thursday epi makin me post yet another topic in this forum..!! This week,evn though painful,is deliverin back to back AMAZING epis frm MaNan angle..Their passionate love can be seen,felt more n more in this track..!! And ofcourse once again Parth n Niti excelled in all those emotional scenes tonite..👏👏👏...!!
@I totally agree with the red marked portion. There love will only garner more strength and passion as they are away from each other. You know suddenly when I was watching the episode on Youtube, I realized that they have completed more than 70 episodes and from day 1 till now, their story has undergone sea change. So, fingers crossed I wish when they have reached 100 episodes, our MaNan will be back. I have this weird feeling that they will be back or on the verge of it. *don't hit me if by chance they don't*
I hv chose the color of this post as BLUE coz my tonites topic is dedicated to tht BLUE CURTAIN SCENE of Silent Heartbroken MaNan tonite...!! Best scene of tonites epi acc to me n hands down-one of the best scenes of MaNan till date...👏👏👏...!!@
Well, perfect color. Blue, the new color of sadness and pain. The new color of a new beginning and new struggles for our MaNan and other characters in the show. Blue, shall give them strength and a ray of hope to fight back all odd situations.
My post will be INCOMPLETE if i make this post WITHOUT pics of heartwrenching yet beautiful moments of MaNan from this scene..As they say A PIC SAYS A LOT...Evry single screencap i hv took from this scene speaks VOLUMES...!! So here goes the 10 best moments of this scene acc to me n hence i hv took caps of those particular moments...!!@Pics are perfect. I saw the pics and went to watch the episode as I am on a break.Those 3 smileys above perfectly described my condition seeing this blue curtain scene...!! I ws crying with MaNan..for MaNan..!!
Nandini ws COMPLETELY SHATTERED..!! The more she tried to control herself,the more she ws more n more breaking internally..!! Every single second of realization of SHE BEING CHEATED.. SHE BEING MADE TO PAY FOR LOVING MANIK ENDLESSLY.. ws totally KILLING her from inside n thts wht visible via her UNSTOPPABLE TEARS..!!@Our Nandu was shattered but she is today's girl and she managed to handle her pain well. She has the strength to fight her fears, her enemies, her competitors and her innocence by far is her strongest strength which can even turn a Monster into a Man who not just thinks about himself, but for others. One who comes to help her in all odd situations, Is with her even if not physically present for her. Manik, now can destroy himself for our very own Nandu and maybe he'll do it in some episodes. Nandu doesn't need the caress of Dhruv, she is strong enough. She is broken, hurt and shattered but she can't be put down. She might not be able to trust now for sometime but I am positive of the fact that she can repose her trust on Manik once again when all the clouds of confusion clears out.
On the other side,Manik ws EVEN MORE HEARTBROKEN seeing her SHATTERED lik this...!! Ek toh this decision of being away from her ws KILLING him every moment...But the sight of she being devastated n shattered n tht too coz of him,tht ws THE MOST PAINFUL thing for Manik..!! No wonder he remembered his promise n her decision of past where he promised he would never hurt her n she told him tht she WONT forgive him if he hurt her next time..!! And unfortunately tht exactly happened...HE HURT HER BEYOND LIMITS n he knw she WONT forgive him..!! He knew he cant be near her to wipe her tears n hold her...!! But hw could he control himself after seein her in such utmost vulnerable state n tht too coz of him?Thtsy he end up trying to FEEL her...COMFORT HER...by touching her shadows..!!@I am in loss of words to describe Parth as Manik and how big a fan I have become of his after seeing his potential and the knack in the craft. He is a true, professional actor who gets into the skin of his character and executes it to the T. Hats off to him. Kuddos to his awesome work and acting capability.
Those shadow moments of holdin her shoulders,wiping tears slowly-all via shadows-ws the HEIGHTS OF MOST HEARTWRENCHING MOMENTS acc to me...😭😭😭...Jitna tht moment ws BEAUTIFUL seeing his IMMENSE LOVE for her...utna hi it ws HEARTBREAKING to see he hving to do this care to her shadow n NOT the real her n tht too only coz of him..!! Also Nandini being TOTALLY UNAWARE of this n she CRYING for him where at the same time he ws rite there beside her n tryin to console her in his own HOPELESS manner-made tht scene evn MORE HEARTBREAKING...😭😭😭...!!@Very few heart break moments have ever touched my heart because I feel it's an inevitable part of any serial, ways of grabbing TRPs, but PaNi or MaNan bleed true love and when they are apart, it does hurt a lot. They are beautiful together and apart and they do total justice to their character and I am happy to be a part of this show in the smallest manner that I am.
But this scene took a BEAUTIFUL TWIST for few seconds,when BOTH of them had small moments of HAPPINESS of BEING TOGETHER lik old times n forgettin evrything else as shown in last 3 caps above..!! Manik felt happy for few seconds by leanin close to her shadow n feeling her presence..!! And at the same time,Nandini unknowingly came closer to curtain n leaned towards it which had Manik at the opp side n somewhere she DID FEEL HIS PRESENCE n thtsy she ws able to STOP her tears n feel those SAME PEACE n HAPPINESS which she used to get when she ws with him n hence her SMILE for few seconds ws visible as seen in pics above..!!
After few seconds,Nandini realised MAYBE MANIK ws there for her seeing some1's shadow n MAYBE the matter could be still resolved if he came there for her..And tht time evn Manik came back n realised wht he ws doing..!! So all he could do ws running away frm tht place before she could spot him..And when she came out she saw none n she felt HER HOPES THRASHED AGAIN n hence she also ran away with tears in her eyes...😭😭..!! And tht scene ended with Manik helplessly watchin her goin away being hurt once again COZ OF HIM....!!@Her realization that Manik might be there depicts her true love for him and I am happy that she hasn't forgotten his touch, his feel and she felt her and he was in so much pain that he can't be virtually present to console her. The scene has it's own magic and one of those scenes which I am going to put on repeat. One of the true MaNan scenes.
Though my this post is for the scene which i explained above..I need to mention two more spl moments..1)When Manik told Dhruv tht when a girl is heartbroken,the guy who loves her must be there for him to lend his support...Manik then tried to point fingers towards himself first automatically which indicated how badly he wished to go near her n hw he STILL wanted to be there for her n console her n take all her pain n replace with smiles..!! But he quicky changed tht n pointed fingers towards Dhruv n said so he should go near her..!! Damn tht ws AGAIN very emotional moment..!! 2)Nandini came n meet Manik before his performance n hurt him with her words..!! She told hw he will be an ETERNAL LOOSER evn if he wins Musicana and she also told him tht HE CANT BREAK HER n shes STILL proud of her innocence n its STILL her strength..!! Though truth ws she ws broken...she did felt her innocence did bcame her weakness n hence shes paying price for it..!! But she obviously wanted to show him THE EXACT OPPOSITE..!! And yes Manik does realise hes THE LOOSER as he feels he hv lost HIS LIFE..HIS LOVE-Nandini forever n so hes already considerin himself as ETERNAL LOOSER,but lik Nandini he also trying to show HES STILL STRONG n UNAFFECTED..!! But wht these two dnt realise is they hv STILL feelings for each other n thtsy they r trying to hurt each other by faking this breakup means NOTHING to them-though truth is far far from tht..!!@I pity Dhruv, I do. I mean this guy didn't even get a chance to propose her but he has already his heart broken. I mean hopefully if CVs don't plan anymore twists, then DhruNi is not a possibility as a couple. And the MaNan confrontation is out of the world. That scene portrays the specialty of the show that the people usually don't keep things within themselves if it's not for the welfare of people (you know what I mean).
So to conclude...I can say...Tonite v saw both being broken..both trying to hurt each other...both felt happy when they felt their presence for few seconds lik old times n he trying to console her in his own direct n indirect hopeless manners...!! All these r happening coz evn though they SAID the breakup has happened what they r NOT realising now is whtver they did tonite-the reason behing all ws THEIR LOVE for each other chaahe vo maane ya maane..!! They r not realizing tht breakup bolne se breakup hota nahi coz they had travelled far in this journey of love n its absolutely IMPOSSIBLE to behave EVERYTHING is OVER just like tht..!! They r yet to realise tht though physically separated,mentally they r gonna be STILL together coz the LOVE b/w them ws TRUE n so both r gonna be there in each other's evry feeling...in their every heartbeat...in their every pain..in their every memories..!! And thtsy i hv chosen this song line from the song-"Nahin Saamne" from the film-"Taal" to describe their current condition esp tonites epi scenes in one line as it perfectly suits MaNan..!! And tht song line is.."Bichadke Bhi Mujhse Juda Tu Nahin!!!"
Originally posted by: Desigirl_21
Beautiful post 👏.. Oh my I love the pics the shadow acne was just amazing and the pics that u put just add so much
I just loved the way Manik when telling Dhruv about consoling the girl he was going to point at himself he is trying so hard but Manik is not going to be able to manage without Nandini he is in so much and Nandini is heartbroken but i loved how she still had faith on her innocence..they will soon realize how much they need each other no matter what
Originally posted by: Manhoos_JSG
That curtain scene is now my most fav MaNan scene, it made more impact on me than the kiss ! I cried with them, this scene was so well executed and Part and Niti nailed it !
Originally posted by: Madhura..
Nikki v beautiful post dear...v well explained.
Manik the more he tries to appear strong..he breaks more inside..but he covers himself with perfection..he covers the good side..the pain..and he is an ocean...not crystal clear like Nandini..
He has the depth which wont b seen if u dont go that deep but his emotions truth in bits is there just as the waves splash water on the shore.But Nandini is too broken to see anything..
Manik tries to heal her by sending someone..or aim of his sacrifice..but no one is there to heal him..to just give him that one hug..to say things wl b alright..and now new issues wl come up in fab 5..and for them team comes first.
Originally posted by: apardh_ba
I dnt knw I really want to feel sorry for manik but if truth to be said I m having fun by seeing him like this. Bcoz of this pain only he is going to realize dat what he did was wrong. Today itself he hd started doubting his decision of sending dhruv to nandu. And my most fav part was when he shouted dhruv's name to take him away from nandu and then the look nandu gave him ws priceless for me. I dnt knw u guys hv noticed or nt bt she hd made a face that clearly said she doesnt give a damn bout him.
The scene u hv mentioned it was indeed very emotional & heartbreaking and the way manik wiped the shawdows tears bt then its his fault that he is in this condition. Bt it ws a very good scene.
And its ky2 so dnt knw what will happen nxt but hoping for d best as always.
Nice post and sry as I ws nt able to comment bout ur earlier post. Bt as always ur post is amazing.
Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan
In his mind KK has decided that u r like Manik's sister... So he is fine... He says, nice try though. Only AK makes him jealous :D
Members Lounge
Book Talk
Current Affairs
