sourmisery thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Not DDLJ...but HSKD 😆

Was it just me or was the first scene edited in a messy way? I was convinced that it was Manik imagining Nandini's indifferent reaction. Like it happens in funny movies ke someone wants to go for a joke but they imagine some possible reactions to it and then tread accordingly. But ye tou sacha scene nikla. Messily edited scene but the implications though <3

I liked it how they confronted the night head on and covered everything. No keeping secret and burning in angsty though I was kinda of looking forward to that. But that's KY2's strength; it doesn't play of major tropes as they are like other shows and adds their own twist to it. Manik was being all teasy about the night and Nandini was all O.O at his gall. I squealed so hard at the way he casually kept touching her and she didn't fight. Partly cuz she was in her own shocked land and partly cuz she's used to it. Best bit was her running away from her and his smile at that xD Awwwiiee!! Babies be so cute! <3

"I trust you."

These words. The words which mean the world, no, the UNIVERSE to Manik. The words he doesn't get to hear so often. The words for which he has always work so hard, always on the lookout, always so alert; she said those words. And she didn't say them in a manner to stop him or as a last straw to use as a means of escape from. She stated them. Simply and plainly. Told the truth as it was meant to be told. Bila jhijhak. Without hesitation. And Manik's reaction? He had come there to surprise and shock her, he was being all teasing and deliberately bringing up the night in a way that was exaggerated and most uncomfortable for her. But ultimately it was him who ended up getting the shock. The way this girl, HIS girl, affects him. With her simplest of words, with her most normal of gestures. She blasts it all on him and he doesn't even realize it. The way his grip loosened and he took a step back...aah. Precious <3

Can I just applaud the way that they never take a step back? Everything that happens takes them forward, always. No stopping, no going back. It's just progress for them. CVs could've taken the amnesia way, delaying the confrontation for days, but they didn't'. It was talked about and dealt with the very next day. And it added more to their comfort level. Him asking her to tell him about her spiked drink, her promising to do so. Her turning around when he didn't even say anything. They be so fated and perfect ke I go all speechless.

Dhruv had me smiling throughout. HE WAS SO DARN ADORABLE!! The makeover session of his...aaah! I love this Dhruv and this Alya who has something to do. Too cute for words! It was so good to see Utkarsh's face in all its glory. I am still shocked ke he's 20?! :O There aren't any cute 20 year guys where I study! WHY LORD, WHY?!

Fab5 joking around, having fun, laughing and teasing - PRECIOUS SOULS!!! I can see them being like this for days and I wouldn't get bored. They all bring such wacky fun to the scene with their individual quirks. Their snark, sarcasm, wit; it's just too darn precious. Cabir ordering Manik as if he's a waiter and Manik's, "Acha point hai. Parliament mein uthaouga" had me 🤣 Dhruv and Manik are adorable but Cabir and Manik is my fav duo! They are just too darn hilarious! Though seeing them, I am believing it more and more that Cabir will be the first one to support Manik in whatever decision he takes. He was actively teasing Manik about Nandini but trust Manik to avoid the subject. Koi nahin, aage sahi. But on a serious note, Manik has been so supportive of Cabir and for all the right reasons; the concern for Cabir's safety and secret never left Manik's mind. If not for anything else, Cabir owes Manik for that at least. Though I wish it won't be like that and Cabir would help, support, whatever Manik because that's what friends do.

Dhruv-Nandini. Poor lad Dhruv. Seeing him all SMILING like that, mera dil toot gaya. Nandini's head is occupied with so many things that Dhruv is taking a back step with every passing day. When she didn't immediately notice his change and the way Dhruv's face fell, NOOO! Baby! I don't think I can handle your angst! I would've hated it if Nandini would've gone away without noticing it but that's not like Nandini. She's just too damn sweet and observant to let her friends go away without a smile. The way Dhruv's face lighted up when she said so firmly that any girl would be lucky to have Dhruv was aww worthy! <3 But she also called the girl who wouldn't fall for him a retard' 😆 I am confused...should I call her that? She's gonna fall for Manik so...😆

Navya-Harshad. It was a nice touch to add, Navya's fear and trauma of being laughed at like that. Harshad is being a great friend, I dunno if he has any other motive in mind. Probably does. But I doubt he wants to use her like a tissue paper and throw away. I guess he doesn't know what to do with her; let her remain his friend only or pursue something more with her. So maybe that's why he's doing it both.

Oooh...Nandini found out about RagBir! Raghav was back in his stern mode and it sucked to see Cabir always trying to calm him down. But this secret is too big and now that more people are finding out...yikes, the promo is gonna come true sooner than later.

Precap - reserved till tomorrow. Though from this point, I'd say it's completely justified. Feelings for Nandini aside, Manik has always prioritized his friends over anything. He panicked and got angry when she told her that she knew and threatened her which was so like Monster Manik, the one who wants to remain in control. The one which ain't going away because that's essentially him. Nandini can modify it, mellow it down but she can never take it all away from him.

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

3.5k

Users

17

Likes

90

Frequent Posters

Sparks-galore thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
RES 😃

Unres... Me first!!!!! 😆 Beautiful post Mais. You be a star ⭐️

It was 'Case of the mother hen' for me.

Manik- Nandu : Manik is a fiercely protective mother hen masquerading as a human, caring intensely for his loved ones. The tenderness towards Nandu in her inebriated state, then the good natured ribbing the following morning screamed adorable! And she stated it- implicit trust. She trusts him, which in both their perspectives is the essence of love. To be able to do a free fall knowing you will be safe, come what may. He trusted and acted on her words- words that asked him to understand and accept changes, new emotions. That's what hit him at that moment, the magnitude of those words and the warm, fuzzy feelings that ensued ❤️.

Cabir-Manik are HOWLARIOUS! 🤣 But, I love how underneath all the snarky banter is a vigilant Manik, who has taken it upon himself to safeguard interests/ secrets of his loved ones. He lets Cabir know of the spiked drink intended for him and advises him to stay alert. Cabir's secret is a sensitive issue and hence the outburst in the precap- the fiercely protective mother hen coming to the fore yet again. I'm glad Manik- Nandu will tackle this issue together. United we stand, divided we fall. This coming together foreshadows what's to come hereafter. (me gets to see Cabir- Nandu !! )

Cabir- Raghav: Another real conflict in this relationship. They have different takes on friends, family and society in general. One wants to be free and fearless, has implicit faith that his closest circle will accept them, while the other wants to remain in hiding (painful past/ unsupportive circle). It's very important to show that same-sex couples experience love and tackle conflicts in the same way as couples do especially to Indian audiences that have only seen caricatures of gay relationships so far 👏. I pray for these two to get on the same page soon, at the same time use a balanced approach to handle their issues. We, as a society have become cruel, vicious and insensitive. My heart breaks a little every time I see them and think of all the impending anguish and torment in store💔.

Dhruv-Alya: They look like different people when they are together- cheery and pleasant. Isn't this another beautiful aspect about friendship- to be able to talk openly, smile, to give each other advice on just about anything. They are quite the equals, no controlling behavior. I like how she said that he needs to shed his inhibitions, steps out of the shadows, interact and put words to his feelings 😊.

Dhruv-Nandini: Very unfortunate. How one is hurtling forward in infatuation/ love at breakneck speed while the other always maintained a platonic and chaste take on the relationship.

Harshad- Navya: Harshad essentially isn't an evil sadist who enjoys others pain, he is just manipulative and wants what he wants - without thinking through the consequences. I do not know if and how Navya is his brahmaastra' in his plans. Not yet. Navya's behavior makes me cringe.🤢


Edited by Sparks-galore - 10 years ago
nyxx thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
"Because I trust you"

How easily and naturally did Nandani say these words to Manik? Manik has finally found his world. He instantly lets go of her arms, drops the entire teasing act, and smiles in front of her. He just cannot hide it away, because she has given him that pure, unadulterated joy. Who said only a Talli Nandu can shock Manik? Everyday, this guy gets a new shock, something she says so simply, that holds such profound meaning, to him, to the both of them. I love how Nandu has become comfortable with his touch.

Both of them have associated the word "Love" with "Trust", and it really is not surprising that she gives him her trust, and while he takes it in so beautifully. Manik's reaction here is something...ahdjshf let me speechless. Parth nails these scenes so well, he has moulded the character of Manik wonderfully - you can make out what Manik is feeling just through his eyes. Ahh! <3

For me, this was the closure. Nothing less or nothing more. There was no need to drag this, and I liked that the writers did just that. Nandani remembers, and Manik gets his share of fun & teasing, but its back to business when he asks her if she remembers who give her the drink. This guys brain is always on the move, constantly. He knows that there is a dark cloud looming around, in the name of Harshad, so he makes sure to warn Cabir of the same. Its in him to do. Before I move forward though, I loved how Nandani turned around for the last time without Manik calling back to her...these two dont need words <3

Dhruv - I loved the re-branding. While Alya has finally found something to do, I am just glad we can see the guys face without his hair covering it. He is in dire need of an confidence boost, though! Him asking Nandu for that reassurance that a girl would fall for him, broke my heart. He asks the same questions to Manik and Alya...and with Nandani not even noticing his makeover instantly, she has completely friend-zoned him, every scene of their only re-inforces that. They way she ruffled his hair, and complimented him gave me a very brotherly-sisterly feeling lol! I really don't think Nandu can see him in any other light, especially, with Manik already reserving that spot in her heart. He has been guarded and very protected, and an impeding heart-break will give his character a lot of depth, and hopefully, the ability to stand up on his own. I liked that Manik didnt buy that the Makover-for-Musicana thing...He knows something is up and it is very closely related to Dhruv's fondness for Nandani.

Cabir-Manik - LOVE THESE TWO <3 Their conversation today, be it about red velvet cheesecake or parliament or Manik warning Cabir about Harshad...it screamed Brother-hood! They give you that reassurance that these characters are just a bunch of students in college, dealing with life. Their camaraderie is contagious!

Nandani finding out about Cabir-Raghav - This was completely a surprise for me. All this while, we all thought it would be Manik who would find out first about Raghav, and here, the CVs have given another twist. Why her? Or maybe, why not? I liked that Nandani went to speak to Manik right away in the precap, it only shows that the trust factor is something very natural for both of them. She seeks out for him, and even though he screams at her, she will understand him. It would have actually been very odd if Manik has let Nandani finish talking about Cabir's homosexuality...It just makes so much more sense for Manik to get that impulsive-protective streak in him to stop Nandani, grab hold of her, and push her so that she doesn't anything further...For him, Friends are always first...and Nandani gets that. A character does not change overnight, and I liked that the writers payed heed to that, and keep Manik true to his character. It is who he is.

So Nandani is actually one step ahead of Manik now - While Manik knows about Cabir, Nandani knows about Raghav in Cabir's life...I wonder if she will tell Manik about him...

The writers have set the foundation for the promo now along with a lot of other things in todays episode...the upcoming Diwali Sequence, Musicana in 3 days...and Im looking forward to it all!

- Dee
Edited by nyxx - 10 years ago
Star_girl thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Trust you to explain the precap so wonderfully Mais.
I actually really loved it and I love how consistent Manik has been as a character. The Manik I know, would have reacted like this. He wouldn't have listened quietly to someone speaking about Cabir and his potentially life-threatening secret, especially when he has no idea about the perspective of the other regarding homosexuality. I cannot praise the CVs enough for keeping Manik true to his character. On another note, how good was Parth in that-I trust you scene and the precap? His Manik is a joy and delight of analysers because of his own ability. He literally owns Manik. I hear people saying this all the time-so and so actor owns so and so roles. And more often that not, it's exaggerated. But Parth has really made Manik his very own.
I like how clear the CVs are being about a potential Dhruv-Nandini track. There is no room for speculation really, especially with Nandini's complete lack of interest in Dhruv tonight. But it will make his heartbreak all the more intense. Utkarsh is positively gorgeous and looked extremely adorable tonight. His lack of confidence is almost sad. He has always been so guarded, so carefully protected that he cannot even take decisions or understand people and their reactions. Because Manik has always done that for him.
Fab-5 moments are so precious, so beautiful that I want to see them all the time. Cabir-Manik though. Howlarious together. Dhruv-Manik gives me a sense of calm, but Cabir-Manik are the ultimate. Nobody else even comes close. Lol at good point, Parliament mein uthana. I love sarcastic Manik and Cabir together. <3
What I like about Manik-Nandini is that how they are able to have a normal conversation with each other along with romancing each other. Most pairs don't. I also loved how neatly the drinking track was closed. With no extra drama, no theatrics. Bad editing, but well. Overall, I liked the episode MUCH better than the previous few. The previous few were like living in a pink haze, but we came back to reality tonight. And it feels fantastic.

Edited by Star_girl - 10 years ago
keerthu27 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
nice post!!!!
nd epi was too gud...
the cast is the first thing i fell in luv with the show...
they each nd everyone has talents...
and MANAn scenes was perfect as always...
manik dhruv cabir they alwayz amaze me with their acting expressions...
nd cming to dhruv is he just 20??😲
then he is elder for me my line is clear...🤣
but parth is my first priority☺️🤣
FBANU thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
I agree with u on the precap thing.. Many people would say that even if Nandini trust him,Manik doesnt trust her etc etc... But today at precap, what I saw in Manik was his caring side for friends.He was watching out his friend's secret which would turn out a disaster if its out.He can't let it happen. And he dont know Nandu's idea about someone being Gay...
Edited by FBANU - 10 years ago
Sanely_Insane thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Aye chal, mere first spot gaya. 😳
Edit: I swear I typed the longest post and load shedding hogai. -.-
Manik wanted to shock Nandu and he got shocked instead. Kya kya armaan thay bande ke, god a shocker instead. xD
Manik wanted to tease her, a little more but the moment she said "I trust you", he was a goner. I have blabbered this so much in the AT that if I say it one more time, I'm' afraid people might slap me and ask me to shush. 😆
He has always wanted someone who could trust him, no matter what, and he found that someone, standing right there, innocently looking at him. She has no idea what she does do to him. He found her world, the meaning of love was right there, this child-woman.
Honestly, I think "I trust you" is more magical than "I love you". But that's just me. 😆

Like you said, he is so practical. I love practical men. He straight away talked business, and he was quick to conclude that the spiked drink was for Cabir, he didn't go all "who could have spiked my Nandu's drink". That's so not Manik, who would only think about Nandu.

Cabir and Manik be my brotp. I found it hilarious yet real when Cabir said "itni bhi bhook nahi lagi hai, pizza nahi chahiye", then he goes "tu yeh sab nahi laane wala hai?" I died laughing. 🤣
I am sure Cabir is going to be shipping Manan, someone keep a count on the number of Manan shippers on the show, direct and indirect. LOL

Harshad has a motive, maybe he doesn't want Navya to almost back out like she did previously. He wants to break fab5, win that damn Musicana and he can't afford to lose Navya. But, I'm not going to rule him out as a black character, coz it seems to be more than it appears. There has to be a reason why Harshad is so focused on breaking Fab5.
But can he please stop saying stuff like "main tumhare liye kuch bhi karsakta hoon Navya" please. That is only going to make Navya fall harder for him and it is not good.

DHRUV! Kya bolun main? He looked adorable. And looking at him all happy made my heart break. Nandini was so occupied with stuff that she didn't notice the change initially. His face dropped. But she did notice him and also asked him who's that special someone? Poor guy needs confidence boost more than anything. No re-branding will help him. He needs confidence. His constant need for assurance kills me. On a positive side, this realization will make him find his individuality. He needs to find himself before he finds his someone special.
On a side note, I think Manik had an inkling that the make-over had something to do with Nandini. And if he sees Dhruv - Nandini together, maybe then he'll start processing his feelings, coz at the moment, he's only letting those feelings take him over, he doesn't know what those feelings are, so maybe when he sees them together he'll see the real deal. I'm just being a cruel Manan shipper. Yes. 😈😆
I see why the break up happens. Raghav is realizing that people are getting to know the truth, he can't live with the pressure, and hence, this huge step. Lets see how it turns out.

Precap. I don't think Manik was being way too harsh, he's just being himself, the monster. He is a protector, always was, always will be. He saw a threat coming his friends way and he reacted instinctively. There was no planning. And I love how the character is still consistent, he didn't change into a sassy puppy after one night, he's changing slowly, but that protective instinct won't go. Once Nandu comes into his life, he'll be protecting her the same way like he does with his friends. And I don't think that Nandu might go all "how dare you treat me like that?" on Manik. She won't make him feel guilty, she understands where that anger is coming from. He will be the one to calm down and realize that he was wrong and he will be the one to apologize.

P.S. I enjoy intense scenes more than the mushy ones. :P




Edited by Sanely_Insane - 10 years ago
Cat. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
I loved loved the episode and I am so happy they didnt go the cliched way with the female lead misunderstanding the male lead and copious tears being shed and me rolling my eyes at it.
Last night was dealt with both of them fabulously, as expected Manik took the piss out of poor Nandini. I know there were editing issues but I thought it was pretty damn clear that Nandu remembered, her expressions after each flashback scene was pretty darn revealing. She had a horrified expression after each of the flashback😆. She of course quickly tells him she doesn't remember last night ,after all she doesn't want Manik to hold it above her head. Manik's question as to why and subsequent answer "Trust" wasn't applicable to last night only. Nandini trusts Manik not only with her virtue but with Rishabh, which I think for her is as important as virtue itself. She remembers those 3 incidents, she remembers him being a gentleman, she knows she can trust him but god forbid she is still not in that easy relationship with him to discuss the details of last night. There is too much awareness between them right now and if she does indeed acknowledge, she might have to question herself and her feelings for Manik, which right now she is not in a state to do so.

Dhruv looked really adorable as he subjected himself to whatever "torture" Alya inflicted on him and he looked pretty darn adorable. I loved how he zinged Manik today, thats what friendship is all about, the ability to zing your friend and get away with it😆

But his scene with Nandini, broke my heart, yes I ship MaNan, but that does not mean it does not hurt when the guy seems to set up for a big fall. Nandini treated him like a little brother, ruffling his hair, teasing him about girls, it is painfully obvious that Nandini has only platonic feelings for him.

Mukti voices her concern about Manik and Nandini and Cabir dismisses it, I felt here Cabir was trying not to make Mukti delve further. I could be wrong.

Manik-Cabir :They really sparkle with humour, on equal footing, they can trade barbs for barbs like how normal friends do. It reminded me so much of my friendship with my besties. I liked Cabir's teasing questioning about Nandini to Manik, he has noticed MaNan and is not so clueless as he pretended to be with Mukti.

Manik is always looking out for the Fab5 and he knows that Cabir is really vulnerable with Harshad waiting to pounce. I loved how he took the time to warn Cabir, he might have had a romantic moment with his lady love but that doesnt preclude him from warning Cabir.

I always had hopes for a Cabir Nandini friendship and I hope this Nandu finding about Cabir will lead to it. I think it will be pretty darn cute friendship.

Precap: I know Manik will cool down, his reaction has been pretty much what we expect from Manik when Fab5 are threatened. They are not friends for him, they are his family and at the end of the day, while he has feelings for Nandini, she still is friends with the master manipulator Harshad. A slight inkling from Nandini to Harshad and the guy will be all over Cabir like a rash.

Edited by Catatonic_Cat - 10 years ago
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
🤣 Manik - Cabir are seriously it! Nothing be as awesome as these two. I've been sub-consciously waiting for more Cabir-Manik scenes because they are at their sarcastic and snarly best when they are together. They just bring it out of each other so easily. Like, I enjoy Manik -Cabir-Mukti together so much too ... But there is something about Manik-Cabir ... It is just there dynamics -- I still remember how Cabir's mom was cursing Cabir's friends for not letting her sleep and that why is Cabir leaving so early? and Cabir's answer -- Mom, Its Manik.
I used to wonder if Manik fills that Father-Brother shaped hole in Cabir's life ... I think it is true even more than I thought. And it is just there personality -- they thrive on Sarcasm and witty one-liners.

😆 I am still not over the milkshake -- cheese cake talk -- so random and refreshing. The parliament thing was my favorite though.

And as far as I remember Cabir was just as shocked to see Nandu-Manik dancing but he was all casual and stuff about it with Mukti only because he was covering up for Manik there. And he was so light when he was teasing Manik about drunk Nnadu -- There was nothing suspicious or calculating about his smile -- Just a brother teasing another.

While someone might think Manik undid everything between MaNan with that one act of throwing Nandu around and threatening to put her in grave.😆 After getting over my initial shock of seeing him shout and rave like an actual Hulk, I was very happy to see him react like that. Kudos to you CVs. Manik staying true to himself is what I wanted to see for Nandu can break some of his walls and make him softer but Manik being completely changed and losing his Monster Mommy nature and over-protective essence? Nope, Absolutely not. If he would have reacted any different, I would have been disappointed so bad. I think Nandu already knows how Manik is when it comes to the rest of fabulous people of Fab5. And after giving him a good tongue lashing in her innocent way and making him realize she is not a threat to Cabir, she will have Manik feeling guilty. For she said that she trusts him, at it needs to go both ways.


Edited by Medha.S - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

I don't know about the editing, but I just loved that it wasn't dragged or was over-dramatized. He teased her , but she remembered- rightly said that nobody forgets after one drink. But it had cute significant moments - like how Nandu sat a step below Manik and went along with her sorry spree. It was Manik who had to step down and be on her level . The comfortable teasing , he was touching her face and she was comfortable with it. No jerking, no shying, it had a "matter of fact air".

And then it happened , she said it - Trust you. For Manik, to be trusted is a greater compliment than being loved .

By saying that one word , she reinforced that he is her person, someone who will always keep her safe, care and is a home too. Without any spiked drink, this girl unsettled him again. Her honesty just does it to him all the time. The trust was not asked or begged by him, she gave it to him just because she wants to . The realization of it numbs him. The smile was fighting to come out in the open .

But when Nandu turned to his silence , that was the fireflies wala love. The connection- their souls are singing to each other.

Now that they both are aware of the night. Manik would be more assured in expressing himself, Nandu still has the Alya block to cross.

Harshad-Navya
There is goodness in him, we cannot deny , he is good at reading people yet it's his obsession which supersedes everything that messes him. I feel while he is trying to be there for Navya, his awareness of how she is perceiving his closeness makes me not like it.

Cabir-Manik
They are so adorable together, snarks , sarcasm -My , I love. Good jibe at the women empowerment. Manik's concern and his extra mile protection for his friends makes him who he is . Cabir is his family and he will fight the world.

Dhruv-Nandu
It broke my heart , I like how Alya told Dhruv that rebranding is just for his clothes , he remains his true self otherwise.
But dear O dear, Nandu is very clear with her friend-zoning. I just feel that makes it heart-breaking , yet so right. He needs to have this journey to gain confidence and take control of his life .

Cabir-Raghav
See this is the couple who have to maintain the relationship. The conflict would be their different perspectives to life and it's varied situation. Raghav's dismissal of Cabir's friendships and his trust issues would be the obstacles. I like how the conflicts are so real, common and similar to any other relationships.

Precap- Proud of cvs for keeping Manik in his character. He should never let go of his over-caring , protective nature. For him his friends would always be family and while he feels for Nandu , he will sacrifice his thing with her, if need be, to safeguard his mates because he understands how vulnerable and dependent they are on him.
I am happy Nandu decided to tell him. Trust with actions. She will be part of him now . She understands and respects the anger but her wise , calm words would settle his uneasy for the time being. Less suffocation for him.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".