Sudha's track

Page

Yuks

@-Yuks-

Rocker

+ 7

Posted: 16 years ago

Im really starting to hate Sudha's track

It's not making any sense at all

1) It can be easily proven that Devika acted out of self defense, she didn't need to be convicted and treated so harshly

2) There were other ways of brining out Sudha's disorder, like she could have changed in front of the family randomly (like she is now) and maybe even slap Padma a couple of times as a treat to the viewers

3) The guy was drunk at the club and probably didn't know what he was doing, how psychotic is he that he's stalking and threatning Sudha for trying to defend herself?

4) Why isn't that boy arrested? Devika made it clear that he was trying to abuse her at the club, that's a couple of days atleast for him

Like this whole track isn't making any sense

Why didn't they come up with something more real and more believeable for Sudha?

Yuks

Quote

Frequent Posters

Miss_Random

@Miss_Random

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

ur right, but all tests proved that she has a disorder

even in real life u have to believe if a person is like this, u cant know if its true or not, but u have to believe the patient, everyone believes what they see

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Vrish

@Vr15h

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: queenyuks
Im really starting to hate Sudha's track

It's not making any sense at all

1) It can be easily proven that Devika acted out of self defense, she didn't need to be convicted and treated so harshly

2) There were other ways of brining out Sudha's disorder, like she could have changed in front of the family randomly (like she is now) and maybe even slap Padma a couple of times as a treat to the viewers

3) The guy was drunk at the club and probably didn't know what he was doing, how psychotic is he that he's stalking and threatning Sudha for trying to defend herself?

4) Why isn't that boy arrested? Devika made it clear that he was trying to abuse her at the club, that's a couple of days atleast for him

Like this whole track isn't making any sense

Why didn't they come up with something more real and more believeable for Sudha?

Yuks

I agree - they are now clearly dragging this out. And someone who was in a coma and struggling to survive not only recovers, but is now an active stalker, and that too w/o his fellow travelers at the club. Also, Sudha has bad memories of home, but largely pleasant ones of Uday. So how is it that she turns into a pretty vicious Devika at that Dandia party, but doesn't make a peep when Padma abuses her? There's nothing I want more than to see her turn into Devika (maybe as she catches Padma stealing more of her money) and give her the thrashing of her life.

One thing about Sudha's DID left unaddressed by the doctors was Sudha having flashbacks of Devika, and vice versa: I wish they had covered that as well. On one hand, all those doctors have said that Sudha and Devika had none of each other's memories, and yet, it's Devika's memories that are haunting Sudha. Even in the past, Devika had flashbacks of Sudha giving Uday his shirt, as well as Sudha's past activities, while Sudha had flashbacks of entering Uday's home when she went for Ganesh chaturthi, as well as flashbacks of Devika when Uday mentioned the latter. Shouldn't this be mentioned as well? Also nothing about the medications Sudha is taking, and whether she'll run into a shortage as a result of Padma stealing money from her treatment to give to Sushma?

But please, cut short the Ronnie Pande scenes, and start w/ Uday helping Sudha recover. Maybe, in the process, have a day when Sudha recalls everything that both she and Devika ever experienced so that she has the entire picture and can move from there. Maybe that'll even help her w/ her confidence, since she'd then know what all she achieved as Devika.

Quote

Vrish

@Vr15h

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 16 years ago

Today's episode - from the POV of Ronnie Pande - was anti-climactic, even though I'm glad it ended fast. I mean, a bunch of days and episodes wasted on him, and at the end, it's just a tame arrest? Also, does he fall under the stupid criminals category? He knows that Devika could identify him from a line-up, doesn't know about Sudha and the DID problem, uses the newspaper reports on Sudha's arrest to track her, and finally starts stalking her. Did he think that Sudha would never identify him from a line-up, or that those familiar with the story - which would be everybody in Udaipur - would put his mugshot front and center in a line-up?

Quote

Sudha's track

Related Topics

Explore Topics