Jodha Akbar 85-86: Imperial stratagems

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Folks,

I normally discuss three episodes per post. This time too, though it looks like just two, the ground covered will be the same since No. 85 was a mahaepisode.

The title is because all thru this stretch, Shahenshah Jalaluddin Muhammad was at the top of his game as he worked to further his twin objectives: the one of co-opting the Rajputs as a pillar of the Mughal sultanat, and the other of getting closer to his prickly Amer ki mirchi. I doubt if he himself was aware of when one ended and the other began, for they were overlapping all the time, before and during their journey to Amer, and at Amer itself! So let us begin.

Episode 85a: Mischief abounding!

This one is of course for Jalal, whose eyes were exactly like the magical potions bubbling and boiling in a witch's pot. Eyes that gleamed at times, clouded over at others, as diametrically opposite emotions chased each other in their depths. Emotions that swam up to the surface for varying periods, just to tantalise us, and then vanished again as Jalal gazed, at times outwards, thru a lattice, at the setting sun, at others at his own reflection in the mirror, as if to share with it a secret he could share with no one else.

A Puck in Jodha Akbar:This sub-title is for the impish sprite of Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, if you will bear with the superficially incongruous comparison of such a creature with the Shahenshah-e-Hindustan, in all his imperial splendour. But Jalal in this episode was nothing if not puckish.

The leit motif throughout was mischief, unbridled, unfathomable mischief. Jalal was devilishly provoking, teasing, confusing, with both the women in his life: Ruqaiya Sultan Begum , demanding and doubtful, seeking reassurance ever as she sought to control him , and Jodha Begum, exasperated and enraged by this dancing dervish of a husband, who managed to unsettle and infuriate her with his mocking sallies even while always dodging out of reach when she attempted a comeback.

After weeks of indecision and trauma, of physical and emotional stress , Shahenshah Jalaluddin Mohammed was back at last. Clear-minded and decisive, a surface candour veiling his secret plans as he reassured Bharmal, countered his Badiammi, convinced Ruqaiya and baited Jodha, and laughed conspiratorially with, not at, his aks in the mirror.

Two useful maxims: Before we proceed, two thoughts I would like to leave with you.

Firstly, I begin to think that we all, and I am a major culprit here, parse and analyse the show too much, to the extent that the pleasure of watching it gets eroded. We are dissecting it even as we look at it, and it becomes like reducing an impressionist painting, a Van Gogh or a Monet, to a collection of coloured dots. This is to do, not Jodha Akbar, but ourselves a disservice.

So, after pondering the question marks on the episode before this one and then cobbling them together into my ???????? post on Episode 84, I decided, for the next episode, to go with the flow, and soak up broad impressions. I did not bother about what seemed like a discontinuity in the screenplay and the characterization, I just watched. And what I have set down above is what stayed with me.

Secondly, there are only 2 distinct ways of analyzing a show. One is to treat the characters as individuals, and praise or critcise them for their acts of omission and commission. The second is to treat them as creations and puppets of the CVs, and blame the scriptwriters for everything that we feel is wrong with this or that character.

I always follow the first option. But that is not the point. The point is that we cannot follow both options at the same time. When things seem to us to going wrong with a character whom we have been praising and defending till the day before, we cannot suddenly say that he/she seems to have gone bonkers because the CVs have messed up!

nuff said. Let us come to the collection of scenes of which Episode 85a, the first half of the mahaepisode, consisted. Throughout this, what struck me was how adept Jalal was becoming - astonishing in such an alpha male who claims he finds it difficult to understand his begums - in handling all the very different women in his life, Maham included. And he does this not by blunt commands, but by finessing his equation with each expertly, so as not to bruise the relationship seriously, and if possible at all, while still getting his own way and disregarding what each of them wants from him. If this means that he has to dish out plausible, not lies, but half-truths, who shall blame him? Even an emperor seeks, like any other male of the species, to avoid domestic discord!😉

Jalal-Ruqaiya 1 & 2: In the first scene between them, Ruqaiya quizzes Jalal about the reasons for his having arranged this marriage for Sukanya - whereupon he firmly denies, with a great (and misleading) air of truthfulness, that he has done it for Jodha Begum!😉- and about whether he is proposing to go to Amer for this wedding. She then asserts her right, as his friend, to forbid his making this journey. Jalal's face as he looks at her retreating form, his eyes narrowed, is a study in controlled exasperation. Haq jataakar humse hamara hi haq cheen liya! Tumhara andaaz ajab hai, Ruqaiya!

Not that he has any intention of allowing even his Begum-e-Khaas to decide things for him, for at the meeting soon after with Bharmal, Jalal confirms that he is accepting Bharmal's invitation. Ruqaiya learns of this only thru Maham who, having failed to stop Jalal from going to Amer, now makes a desperate appeal to Ruqaiya to try to ensure this. So we come to Jalal-Ruqaiya 2.

It is a very beautiful scene, most aesthetically set up and shot, with the rays of the setting sun, filtered thru the lattice, creating shifting patterns on the Jalal's face and adding an extra layer of mystery to his deep set eyes.

No sunset for their rishta: Those who see the sunset motif in the latter scene as an (admittedly attractive) symbolism for the fading of Jalal's relationship with Ruqaiya as that with Jodha gains ground, are doing Jalal a signal disservice. He is emphatically not one of those who discard an old, time-tested relationship for a new one, no matter how beguiling the latter might be. He values those who stood by him when he needed them - his Khan Baba, his Badiammi, and Ruqaiya - very greatly, and he will never abandon them until he is forced to do so, and then it will be like having an amputation. Whence his agony when it seemed that Maham was the culprit in the dature ka ark affair.

As for Ruqaiya, however antagonistic she might become towards Jodha as matters develop, this antagonism, rooted in jealousy, would not be a reason for Jalal to break up with his childhood friend; he would merely be amused and even pleased! So I do not see any sunset ahead for the two of them, and in any case, all that Jalal says is that she has come at the right time, and how beautiful the sunset is.

Testing the waters:But Jalal is testing the waters with Ruqaiya, for he does not want excessive friction with her as he becomes closer to Jodha, something he intends to achieve, whatever the Amer ki Mirchi might be thinking. The whole spiel about Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se is part of this exercise. And how superbly it is executed!

Jalal turns to Ruqaiya and raises his eyes, with visible hesitation, to hers, and then turns away again. The words flow with increasing speed, and devastating candour, after he begins with Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se. Here he looks Ruqaiya full in the face. Her eyes are wide with dismay, and Jalal looks away again. Hum aapko yeh baat batane ko majboor nahin hain ( a clear putdown!) lekin sach yahi hai.Pata nahin kaise, ek jadoo sa kar diya hai unhon ne hum par. Unhein dekhte hi dil mein kuch hone lagta hai (a riff, 436 years earlier, on KKHH!). Unhein door jaate dekhte hi, dil isi suraj ki tarah doobne lagta hai. Hum mohabbat karte hain unse, deewaane ban chuke hain unke, ghulam ban chuke hain unke. Ab har din, har pal hum unse aur judte jaa rahe hain, Ruqaiya!

At this point he turns, looks at her face frozen in shock and worse , and begins to laugh. Aaj pehli baar aapke maathe par shikanj dekha hai! Aapko hairaan kar diya hai Ruqaiya!

Jalal is very convincing at the beginning, and in 2013, I was really foxed and confused, for all that his confession seemed most premature. It was only when he got to unke deewane, unke ghulam, that I knew it was a con, for never would Jalal (at least at this stage!) become any woman's ghulam, not even of the love of his life! But when he turns back after that deliberately exaggerated confession - not fake, be it noted - and sees the frozen shock and despair in Ruqaiya's eyes, Jalal knows that he has gone too far and has to retreat, for he has no notion of wrecking his bond with her. Not for anything, least of all for the uncertain prospects that lie ahead with Jodha.

A more devious explanation: There is another possibility: that Jalal shocks Ruqaiya with Hum mohabbat karte Jodha Begum se quite deliberately, so that in the overwhelming relief when he tells her that he was only joking, she will easily accept that the visit is a purely political exercise. Personally, I would opt for this, for there is no real reason that I can think of for Jalal to inform Ruqaiya that he has fallen in love with the woman of whom she is acutely jealous!

Siyaasati wajah: So, he now appeases Ruqaiya by repeatedly laying exclusive emphasis on the siyasati wajah for the Amer trip, embroidering it with the ancillary themes of winning over the Ameri awaam and eliminating any rebellion for keeps, as he moves step by step, adding one relationship after another with erstwhile enemies, towards uniting all of Hindustan under his rule.

Hum Amer rishtedaari nibhane ke liye nahin ja rahe hain..hum wahan sirf aur sirf siyaasati matlab se jaa rahe hain. . Hum chahte hain ki hamara auda unki nazaron mein aur bhi bad jaye...Humne Amer par fateh ki hai, ab uski riyaya ke dilon par raj karna hai humein. Zindagi bhar baghawat ka khyal nahin aayega unke zehen mein!.. He rounds off this misleading peroration by asserting Hum unke jhuke hue sar dekhna chahte hain!

For us to shrink at this old chestnut of jhukofying the Rajvanshi sars , which is meant only for Ruqaiya's consumption, would be as unwarranted as for us to assume that the entire siyasati rationale is just a smokescreen to hide Jalal's real reason, to get opportunities to spend time in Amer, as up close and personal as can be managed, with Jodha.

We should not forget that Jalal is an emperor, and the expansion and strengthening of his empire would, for him, come first, always and every time, and this no matter what he feels, or does not feel, for Jodha. This is as it should be, for I for one would, in 2013, have hated to see Jalal reduced to a pathetic lover sighing verses to his mistress' eyebrow', as, who else, Shakespeare would put it. Let us not even talk of what happened later!

However, the siyasati reasons are not the whole truth either. Jalal knows his Gatti, and banks on her believing his half truth to be the whole truth, because she believes what she wants to believe.

A menage a trois?:When he asks her if she is not coming to Amer with them, he might have assumed, knowing Ruqaiya, that she would refuse. But he could not have been sure, so why does he broach it at all? Methinks it was just more of mischief, for I am sure he does not doubt his ability to juggle both these balls in the air while at Amer and never drop either!😉

Jalal-Maham: It is revealing that Jalal does not go to the lengths he goes to with Ruqaiya to persuade Mahaam to accept the Amer trip. For one thing, he knows that if he argues this one out with her, his shrewd Badiammi will start trying to take his siyasati rationale apart, and he does not want to go down that road.

Moreover, emperors do not explain their decisions. So two crisp sentences, ending in Yeh tai hai ki... and it is all wrapped up (it is to be noted that his Ammijaan is not in his list, but I am sure she will add herself!). Again, in the Diwan-e-Khas with Bharmal, he neatly prevents Maham from raising any objections by saddling her with the responsibility for the gifts for the bride.

In all of this, one also sees that while asserting that his decisions are not to be altered, he nonetheless is never abrupt towards or dismissive of Maham. He merely sidesteps her, and is considerate even while being unyielding. He has, beyond any doubt, grown up, has our Jalal.

Jalal-Jodha : & 1: The half scene is the exchange of understanding glances between them as Bharmal leaves. Jodha's eyes brim over in gratitude, as Jalal acknowledges it by an almost imperceptible nod (Rajat must be having a micrometer in his head, to be able to achieve such miniscule shifts of position and expression!) that seems to say: Don't worry, it will all be fine. Very nice going, I said to myself, and got ready for a pleasant rubaru between them soon.

Then came the Scene 1, which of course upset all my calculations. For the first 30 seconds, as Jodha neither enquired after Jalal's health, nor sought to apologise for the narnaal fiasco, nor even thanked him for arranging Sukanya's alliance, but launched into a broadside against his taking aapke parivaar ko (in which she obviously does not include herself) to Amer, I was all at sea.

Then I switched to my earlier resolution, abandoned any attempt to understand the discontinuity in Jodha's behaviour, and simply went with the flow. It was a wise choice, for what followed was pure delight.

This scene too was amazingly well envisaged and shot, with most of the action being shown in the mirror, an unusual trick that heightened the impact of each frame.

Jalal: Mischief abounding: Rajat's Jalal is here fabulous from start to finish. He never misses an opening to trip up his angry, flustered Jodha Begum. He is brimming over with mischief - it is there in every glance of his, in the teasing tones in his voice, in the mocking lines after he has extracted a reluctant and qualified thank you from her:Aapke is upkaar ke liye hum aabhaar prakat karte hain parantu... .

He he follows that up without missing a beat: Magar kya, Jodha Begum? Bura socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai, achcha socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai. Yeh hunar aap mein paidayeshi hai, ya baaqaida aapne isme taaleem haasil ki hai?

And much more in the same vein, about a baaghin from whom humein khatra hamesha hai. The flummoxed Jodha exclaims in disbelief Kya??? Whereupon Jalal embroiders further on this enticing theme, about the mortal danger to him from Jodha's assorted deadly weaponry- top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar aapka gussa, shamsheer se tez aapki zubaan, aur katar ki dhar dar aapki nazar, in teenon ka hamla hum par ho gaya to koyi marham humein bacha nahin sakta!

All delivered with the same lightness of touch, the same effortless mastery of flirtatious leg pulling, while his eyes, gleaming with ill-suppressed merriment as they never leave her fuming face, seeking to unsettle her even more.

Jodha: Easy prey: I was sorry to see Jodha play right into his hands, and make a complete, pokered-up, ungracious fool of herself by the time she reacts to his last sally about what all she can do for him in Amer in return for the itna nek kaam he has done for her family.

Hum to soch rahe hain kyon na roz aapke haathon se banaya khana khayein? Waise humein ab teekhe ki aadat ho gayi hai. And as Jodha's eyes narrow in anger, Ab hum par mirchi ka asar nahin hota hai! She responds to this teasing by turning her back on him and stomping off in a huff. She leaves Jalal, predictably, chortling in glee with his companion in the mirror.

Her problem is that she is utterly devoid of a sense of humour. If she had only laughed out loud at his description of her top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar gussa, shamsheer se tez zubaan, and all the rest, and declared :

Apitu hum to Amer ki beti hain, Shahenshah, Amer ki mirchi jaisi teekhi. Hum jaise bhi hain, aapko to isise santrusht rahan padega! Humein apne aap mein kuch bhi parivartan laaneki koyi bhi ichcha nahin hai. Aap to is janam mein to kya, agle cheh janam ke liye hamare isi kaaya aur isi pravrutti se bandhe rahenge. Kya karenge aap, Shahenshah? ,

Jalal would have been totally stumped, and might have started laughing with her, not at her.

Similarly, if she had thanked him warmly for arranging Sukanya's marriage, and told him how sorry she was about her having put him in such mortal danger without at all meaning to do so, he would have been disarmed.

But no, she has to go wandering into the morass of accusing of having ulterior motives in arranging Sukanya's marriage, which was ungracious, to say the least. From there to insisting that he never does anything without the hope of gaining something else, is but a step, as she plays further into his hands. As a feminist, I felt like shaking some sense into her head. Not that it would have helped!

So, finally, she stormed off, looking nothing like the baaghin he was comparing her to, and more like an angry kitten frustrated at not having been able to sharpen her claws on her tormentor!😉

In all this relentless, but not malicious teasing, for that is what it was, one revealing point has to be noted.

When Jodha asks, angrily, whether he had no faith in Amer or her Bapusa's ability to ensure his safety, Jalal answers her seriously and reassuringly, stressing his conviction that her brothers would be ready to do anything, including giving up their lives if necessary, to protect him. A girl with a bit more of perceptiveness would have noted the sudden change of tone and of content, from being frivolous towards her to admiration and respect for her family, and reacted accordingly.

We might them have had the first ever civilized conversation between them. Alas, this was was not to be!

Hopes belied: We are , beginning from right now, going to be treated to every corny trick in the panoply of romantic pulp fiction, up to the Ratanpur Qila contretemps, which is when the script starts picking up again. The interim Jalal-Jodha interactions bored me stiff the first time around, and the Govinda style tel maalish sequence had me fuming.

So much for my vain hopes for Jalal and Jodha, of seeing mutual caring and affection develop, slowly but surely. Of an edgy friendship morphing, insensibly, into love, with all its yearnings, its restlessness in the absence of the loved one, the misunderstandings, the jealousies, the protectiveness and the possessiveness, and beneath it all, the undercurrent of a hidden sensuality.

Of a Jodha whose pride in her magnificent husband would make her say, as Cleopatra once said to Julius Caesar : "But for you, the world is full of little men".

What a fall this is going to be, my friends (apologies to Mark Antony)! Anyhow, I am going to number the Jalal-Jodha scenes from now on, and give them a rating of 1 to 10. You, my gentle readers, are more than welcome to give your own ratings in your comments, with reasons for them.

There is only one thing I was looking forward to in 2013, and that was Dadisaa getting to know Jalal. I would bet anything that if she had been 50 years younger, Jalal would have flipped for her without a second thought, instead of this sulky, irascible, pokered-up female he has now landed himself with, complete with her bhashanbaazi and her tantrums😉 .

Kunwar Pratap ki duvidha: I normally do not devote too much space to this gentleman, mainly because Ekta's casting has, for once, gone awry with this Kunwar Pratap. Moreover, most of the lines given to him are pure bombast or ranting against the deshdrohi Bharmal. However, this time, I was so impressed by the lambent wisdom of his guru , as also by Pratap's articulation of his unwavering commitment to the Rajput code of honour, that I am going to spread myself a bit!

Of geedhads and shers: I loved it when Pratap, after listening impassively to a whole line up of his (most unimpressive and dismal looking) advisers push for a sneak attack on Jalal's cortege on the way to Amer, in order to put paid to him easily (being stupid, they assume that he will not have a military escort!), responded with a caustic Theek kah rahe hain! Uttamtam (the Sanskrit superlative) hai, parantu kaayaron ke liye, veeron ke liye nahin! ..Avasar ki prateeksha kaayar karte hain, aur peeche se vaar geedhad. Singh nahin! Singh hamesha saamne se vaar karte hain, garajkar, vijaynaad ke saath!..Is tarah peeche se vaar karna na hi hamara rashtra dharma hai, na hi Rajvanshiyon ki maryada.

This was the clear, uncomplicated code of honour by which this great warrior lived, fought, and died. This, and his fierce determination- his head unbowed and his tenacity a byeword - never to accept the suzerainty of the Mughals. No wonder that his legend endures.

Chanakyan advice : While Pratap oscillates between the conflicting pulls, the duvidha of which to choose between shatruta aur swabhimaan on the one hand, and sambandh and kartavya (of upholding family ties) on the other, his guru is clear-eyed and categoric, insisting that the latter should prevail, and that Pratap should attend the wedding.

But not solely, or even largely for familial reasons. Rather because the Mughal Shahenshah will also be there at Amer. Brushing aside Pratap's distaste for meeting Jalal, the guru sets out the tactical and strategic rationale for what he advises. Yuddh karne se pehle, apne shatru ki shakti, uski neeti, aur uski chaal ka avalokan karna, yehi rajneeti hai. Yeh tumhare liye ek avsar hai, Jalal ko theek se jaan ne ka, uski shakti aur chaal ko samajhne ka. Itihaas wo hi likhta hai, Pratap, jo apne shatru ki shakti ko jaanta ho. Yon samajh lo ki yeh nimantran tumhare liye ek rajnaitik aavashyakta hai. Yeh jan ne ka avasar hai ki kya tumhari talwar ki dhaar itni saksham hai ki wo Jalal ki dhal ko bhed sake?

The great Acharya Chanakya, from nearly 19 centuries back, would have approved wholeheartedly! Whether the results from this sakshatkaar that Pratap's guru had hoped for actually materialized is an open question.

Episodes 85b and 86: A jaundiced view

This one is going to be -now don't start laughing already! - relatively short. It is more of a venting of exasperation than an analysis.

Let me therefore just put it down as a series of questions, and you can then amuse yourselves thinking up the answers. And if any of you is still in a roseate haze induced by the boat ride, please snap out of it!

Q1) It is all very nice to educate the viewers in the complexities of Mughal-Rajput animosities, and I was duly moved by the noble sentiments in the invitation sent by the Rajmata of Amer to Maharani Jaiwantibai of Mewar. But apart from the fact that the Rajvanshis shown confabulating with Kunwar (not Rana) Pratap looked like a bunch of extras from a gangster film togged out in royal attire, there was another major problem with this segment

What about the invitation to Pratap's estranged father, the Maharana of Mewar, Udai Singh? It was to him, as the head of the Sisodias of Mewar, that the invitation would have been addressed, not to Pratap, who was not even the Yuvraj. It would have been unthinkable in terms of royal protocol.

The CVs seem to have forgotten all about Maharana Udai Singh, but when Akbar laid siege to Chttor in 1568, It was still Maharana Udai Singh who was on the throne. He had moved to Udaipur, which he founded as his new capital, and left Jaimal and Patta to defend Chittor. MaharanaUdai Singh also stood firm against the Afghans first and then the Mughals, so this premature emphasis on Kunwar Pratap seems odd, to say the least.

Q2) Why is it that Jodha is not even thinking of throwing out any of the Kabul ke zevarat gifted to Sukanya by Hamida Banu ? Should they not remind her of the Devi Maa's jewellery the Mughal raiders looted from the temple? And it is not even as if this was after Jalal had, at the Kali Maa mandir, fulfilled the sankalp Jodha had taken after that incident. Not only does she not reject the jewellery now, but she does not burn the Dhaka mulmul either, inconsistent wench that she is!😉 In fact, she seems quite in ecstasies over her Ammijaan's largesse for Sukanya, this sammaan for Amer that they would never forget!

Joking apart, of course the context of the two sets of gifts could not be more different. I was decidedly critical of Jodha's immature and thoughtless act in burning the Shahenshah's gift of the shaadi ka joda, which might have seriously endangered Amer. But I also feel that if it had been Hamida Bano who had brought it, instead of the vicious Maham Anga, Jodha might, just might not have burnt it, even if she accepted it only with a sullen face. There seems to be an instant soul connect between Hamida and Jodha, probably dating back to a poorva janma!

Q3) Why is the Shahenshah's chief minister, Atgah Khan, shown to be such an incompetent that, with a large military contingent at hand, he suggests that his emperor go for a boat ride on a lake in hostile territory, a sitting duck for any attacker, without first securing the perimeter of the lake? In his place, having handled such visits as an Ambassador, even if it was not in hostile territory, that is the first thing I would have done.

Q4) How many times is Jalal to cut his hand - not to speak of worse - in order to promote his shaky romance with the Amer ki Mirchi? At this rate, he will fade away from sheer blood loss 😉 . This is the third time, and it is getting to be so hackneyed. Can't they think of something a bit more intelligent for a change? The script's sole brainwave for promoting the Jalal-Jodha romance seems to be to get him to injure some limb so that Jodha Begum can set to work on it with her patented lep. And how the devil did he cut it this time anyway? His hand was quite saabut when he got into the boat.

It is a good thing for Jalal that the lake water in which his sulky begum is washing the cut must have been pure in those days. If it was today, he would die of chemical poisoning, possibly from mercury, as in the Minamoto affair in Japan.

Q5) What was it with the pathetic standards of marksmanship among the tribal warriors? Their arrows fell in showers, reminding one of the Yuddha Kanda in the Ramayana, and if they had been even halfway proficient, our nascent lovers should both have been reduced to pincushions. At this rate, the tribals must be starving in the jungle!

Oh dear, I had forgotten the numbering of the Jalal-Jodha scenes. Here goes, then.

Jalal-Jodha 1: Nauka vihar: This began in a promising fashion. I perked up when Jodha Begum was quizzing a daasi about her khema, displaying a sure-footed certainty as to which was the Shahenshah's. (This bit was edited out by Zee Anmol).Apart from this indication of interest in his doings, she had also given up her unseemly habit of haranguing him about a separate khema for herself. Whether it was due to the presence of Hamida Banu is not clear, but Jodha seemed reasonably well-behaved, even summoning up a reluctant smile when her Ammijaan summarily decided that she would go with the Shahenshah on the nauka vihar.

As for Jalal, he was assessing the possibilities as soon as he spotted the Amer ki Mirchi. His eyes, as he looked at her, and then up at the full moon, lit up with nascent mischief. This became even more pronounced as he saw manna descend from Heaven, in the shape of his Ammijaan, who delivered his recalcitrant begum up to him without his having to exert himself in the least! So, when Jodha was trying to catch his eye and nodding her head in the negative, Jalal blandly informed his Ammijaan: Hum bhi Atgah Saheb se yahi kehnewale the!😉

No wonder then that Jodha, forced to trot after her exasperating spouse, muttered audibly about his daft idea of going for a boat ride this late at night. She then responded to his Aapne kuch kaha? , in an irritated tone: Kaha bhi to kya? Apne hat ke aage aapko kisi ki baat sunayi kahan deti hai? Anything more typically biwi-like could not be imagined😉! Or perhaps Asha Parekh in a 1960s Hindi film? So far so good.

From then on, however, things go steadily downhill. Jodha hesitates visibly, in fact for what seemed an age, about letting her husband help her into the small boat. Once in the boat, after grabbing his arm when she loses her balance, she continues with her 1960s film heroine stance. She looks everywhere but at Jalal, while he gazes unblinkingly at her.

When, in an effort to make some conversation, he enquires pleasantly about her liking boat rides, what is it with her reply? Anand milta hai ya dand, yeh kiske saath ho us par nirbhar karta hai! It is insolent and ungracious, and for that one moment, his smile fades. As a follow up, she informs him that the problem with him is that aap baatein nahin, kewal vivaad karna jaante hain!What vivaad there was in his innocuous question I could not make out, not to speak of the fact that Jodha Begum has a PhD in vivaad or behas!

She keeps up this snippishness without a let up. When, after washing the cut in his hand, in slo mo, with the lake water, she sulks and gets up suddenly, if there had been any justice in the world of soaps, she should have fallen into the water and got the dunking of her life! No such luck, alas!😉

This is not how royalty behaves, and that too in front of servants. And there is a lot of space between a goody two shoes, and this humourless, ill-mannered young woman, and this should not be forgotten. It does not have to be one or the other. That Jalal does not seem to mind her ungraciousness, and when he does, he seems to get over it fast, changes nothing in this. I long, simply long for a sensible conversation between the two of them, free of taanas and sallies of the cutting kind, but where is this to be found? Not in this script, that is for sure!

In 2013, at the end of this episode, with the two of them facing a steady shower of arrows from the bank, I was wondering how on earth Jalal was proposing to save our Amer ki Mirchi! At that moment, she seemed to be in front and more exposed, for all his bravado of letting nothing happen to her. The only option would have been for him to dive under the boat with her, and use the inverted boat as a shield.But then her regalia, when wet, would be heavy enough to sink them both!😉

The whole boat ride scene was contrived in the extreme, farce with a capital F. Not that I think anyone cared!

Rating: 4 out of 10, and 2 of those for the pleasing beginning!

Jalal-Jodha 2: Saanjha khema: Now this one was a delight, and this not only because Jalal was in full flow as the Puck of Agra. Jodha too played off him with praise-worthy comic timing.

When Jodha turns up unannounced in Jalal's tent (which is odd, but perhaps the guards assumed that a begum has this privilege!), he usurps her standard opening line: Aap yahan?, and hiding his surprise well, informs her kindly :Zara gaur farmayiye, Jodha Begum! Aap galat kheme mein aa gayi hain!

When Jodha counters this with a poker-faced: Hum bilkul sahi sthan par aaye hain, and announces Wo...h...Aaj raat hum yahin, aapke kheme mein hi rahenge!, Jalal is not about to let any rising tide of gladness, however tentative and hesitant, show on his face. So he gets up from the bed, and takes refuge in an ironic comment: Wallah! Aaj pehli baar kisine Shahenshah ko hukum diya hai!

Her eventual explanation, about her sudden descent on him being due to their Ammijaan's orders, must have brought him down to earth with a thud, but he hides that too well in badinage about offering her the bed while he sleeps on the couch. Her predictable refusal of his upkaar, adding, as an afterthought, Waise bhi, is upkaar ke badle mein na jaane kya maang baitein aap humse? does not faze him, for this sort of thing is now old hat for apna Jalal!

So he does not respond in kind. Instead, eyes mock serious, he sends up a prayer to the Almighty: Phir saanp bichuon ki jaan par Khuda khair kare! Hum aaj unki jaan nahin bacha paayenge, kyonki hum kisiki jaan bachata bahut thak gaye hain!😉 And he retires to the bed, leaving fully half of it free, undoubtedly anticipating the future developments, and closes his eyes.

What follows is delightfully comic. Jodha, sitting on the couch, mulling over Jalal's sanp bichoowala comment, her eyes scanning the tent with increasing trepidation, is assailed by memories of the Mohini kaand on the road to Ajmer. That does it! She gets up, sidles over to the left side of the bed, seats herself gingerly after moving the coverlet towards Jalal, and looks at him, apparently asleep already, out of the corner of her eyes.

Just when she looks reassured (of what?), Jalal suddenly moves, blows out the only candle in the room, and again closes his eyes. Jodha, startled , exclaims aloud: Inhon ne diya kyon bujha diya?, to Jalal's secret amusement.

She next looks Heavenwards, and sends up a petition : He Ambe Maa! , presumably for divine assistance to keep Jalal on his side of the bed😉. I was wondering why Ambe Maa had been selected this time, and not Jodha's regular Kanha, but this was very likely because Jodha felt that the Goddess would have some extra feminine solidarity with her! 😉Next, a concerned (but not nervous) Inhein kehne ka bhi koyi labh nahin hoga! , before she too settles down for the night. Jalal, watching all this unobserved, must have been chortling inside! Peace then presumably prevails in the Shahi khema for the rest of the night.

The significant point about these goings on is that Jodha now clearly trusts her patidev to keep the line. Which ensures that the stree ke liye laalasa theme has been laid to rest ( not permanently, alas!). This is a baby step forward in her relationship with Jalal, and undoubtedly has a bearing on her agreeing to share his bedroom while at Amer.

As for Jalal, who has surely never before had to woo any woman, especially one who will not even give him the time of the day, such incremental progress must have the charm of novelty!

Rating: 7 out of 10, 2 of which for Jalal's saanp-bichoo crack!

Much of a muchness: Well, we now know that a lot more more of this jejune stuff is going to be unloaded on us in Amer. The sad truth is that after a while, even Jalal's mischievous, dancing eyes begin to pall; one can have too much of a good thing, especially when the object of all his badinage and flirtatiousness continues to look as if she has been attacked by a swarm of bees! It is now the nth time that he is teasing Jodha calling her a baaghin. And being a completely humourless girl, she is unable to think up a single smart retort. Or better still, laugh it off. I have by now grown tired for writing snappy lines for her!😉

Don't mind me, folks, I am already out of sorts after having to watch all this laboured nonsense. Carry on with the joyfest over the Akdha/Parijat prem katha. They should have had Jalal cutting another limb the day after, and Jodha being be stabbed by the assassin the day after that. Phir kya, yeh prem katha toh chalti nahin, daudti!

Jokes of the day: 1) Bharmal, who was not present at the main gate of the Amer fort to greet his javaisa the Shahenshah, leaving Jalal to the care of his sons, while personally escorting Kunwar Pratap, not even the Yuvraj of Mewar, to his rooms, for all the world as if he was his ADC. It was beyond ridiculous.

2)The idea of Maham Anga singing a lori😉. It had me in splits!

Scene of the day: The relentlessly hyped face to face encounter between Jalal and Pratap. It was so stagey and affected, and so obviously meant to impress the viewers, that it was almost amusing. The wooden faced Pratap did not disappoint me, never departing from the flat monotone which characterizes all his utterances. Jalal was of course far more nuanced and subtle, but Rajat had no one and nothing to play off, and there was only so much even he could so with that scene.

Finally, I almost expected a large announcement at the bottom of the frame when they were eyeing each other : YAHAN, SHAHENSHAH JALALUDDIN AUR MAHARANA PRATAP, US SADI KE DO MAHAAN HASTIYON KA AAMNA SAAMNA HUA!😉

Rather like the caption of the frame in the 1982 film, Coolie , when it was released after Amitabh Bachchan's recovery from near death, showing the exact moment when Amitabh took that mistimed, almost fatal punch to his abdomen!

That is it for now, folks. The next time, en avant to the Kali Maa mandir, and the cutting of a Gordian knot!

Shyamala/Aunty/Akka/Di

Edited by sashashyam - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

82

Views

8.3k

Users

15

Likes

207

Frequent Posters

IshqHaiWoEhsaas thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
This was a mind - blowing analysis, Shyamala Aunty. This was one of your best till now, atleast for me. Really amazing! 👏⭐️ I had thought of marking the parts I loved the most, while I was reading. But by the time I finished, I realized that each and everything is just as fabulous. 👏
Time for my Urdu Class :

It was not shikanj, but shikan, what Jalal saw for the first time on Ruqaiya's face.

And, one more thing. I think that Jodha's comment on Jalal only knowing to do vivaads was based on his reply that, " Aapse toh behas karna hi bekaar hai." It is the use of the word 'behas' due to which she says that, and not because of his question about her liking of boat - rides.

My comments on the episodes :
I have tried to be a little less on the fantasy and romantic side, but this was a set of episodes which didn't actually favour me to do so. 😛😃😆

Episode 85 :

Lovely episode it was. 😃

I always love Ruks and Jalal's interactions. Not because of their friendship or chemistry or something. Just because Jalal knows her too well, and that shows. He knows the thing even before she speaks. Just like today. I wonder she'll ever be able to know him that much. I guess never. Loved his witty replies to all the obvious questions of Ruks. I wonder why he said, " Kamaal ke sawaal hai tumhare" These were very obvious questions anybody would ask after all that happened.

I wanted to see Ruks expressions in the DEK. But sadly, she was not there. Anyway, she had to be away. Otherwise how would that Maham - Ruks convo be done...😆 But, Maham's shocked expressions made for that, anyway...😆

I don't know why Jo is in such a hot mood. It should've been Jalal this time. He had just accepted the invitation, right? And she was like as if he had done some ghor paap. But, I'm loving Jalal's cool attitude with Jodha. This ice and fire combination is a killer. 😳😆
Loved the way Jalal spoke to his mirror image. " Ye kya kiya aapne Shehenshah , itna accha mauka gawaan diya." Lovely bit. 😃

The comparisons of Jodha to cannonballs and swords...OMG...Hilarious...😆
" top ke gole ki tarah fatne ko tayyar aapka ghussa shamsheer se tez apki zubaan aur kataar se dhaar dhaar apki nazar inn teeno ka hum par humla ho gaya toh hume koi marham nahi bacha sakta hai..." 😆
Bang on lines Jalal!...😆

The Maham - Ruks convo. Awesome scene. I don't know how over - confident she is and that too all the time...Notice how she said, " Na aap Amer jayenge aur na hum aapko jaane denge " Heights of stupidity. Does she still think that she can control Jalal?...Living in her own delusional world as always. 🤢

Every scene which shows Adham plotting, automatically becomes hilarious for me. That pea - brain is planning something...OMG...Jalal should go and hide somewhere now...😆

As I mentioned before, Jalal - Ruks convo's are always enjoyable. That is because Jalal is the Mr. Cool here. 😎😆 He is the same with Jo too, but Ruks one is better, as she is a total dumb. 😆 The first time around, the love confession was a totally hot topic. It was nail - biting scene. Loved the way Jalal made a fool out of the already quite foolish Ruqs. 😆 Way to go Jalal! 👍🏼😃😆
The setting of this scene makes it really divine. It was a beautiful scene. 😳

Loved Dadisa's letter to Pratap's family. A very well - written one. Dadisa is the most sensible person in the whole of Amer Royal Family. She proved it again this time. 😃
As you said, Jalal would have been lattu over her in no time flat! 😉

The sword unsheathing scene was a very symbolic one. Symbolic of the clash between both the great warriors.

Pratap is man of ideals. He believed in attacking from the front, and not being a coward, unlike what his men thought. Every argument that he gave here was bang on. 👍🏼😃

Jodha is learning fast. This time she hearself found out Jalal's tent. But the daasi, took out another meaning out of it. 😆 Great going Jo! Last time Jalal had to point out his khema, but this time she did it herself. I wish she learns something else from Jalal too. That is, how to be Ms. Cool. 😎😆 But then, what about our ice - fire combo?...🤔😆

Jalal taking turns to watch the moon and his hot - headed moon. Wow!... So, once again Ammijaan is here to help her betasa...😆 Actually, she's helping us here. Giving us awesome scenes of AkDha. I thank you from the core of my heart, on behalf of all the members of the AkDha Admiration Association, Hamida Bano. 😃

So, finally their boat ride. First of all, there were lovely BGM's all through it. This made the scene more endearing and magical. So many cute moments in a single scene...OMG...A treat for us...😃 First, the girna nad sambhalna of Jodha. It looked as if Jodha is allergic of Jalal. 😆 She hesitated even to hold his hand, see her expressions when she removes her hold on his hand, after he prevents her from falling. Such disgusted looks...OMG...😆 Try to be a little cool, dear Jo. I still think its Jalal's chance to get all hot on Jo. But this girl won't allow that...😆 Anyway, Jalal too loves being Mr. Hot with his very own Ms. Cool. 😆

Then the dupatta one. Dupatta down or not, we anyway know that Jalal is forever in shararat mood only. 😆 I guess everybody knows that. And, what was Jo exactly planning to do, when she stood up with such a jerk. Planning to run away by walking on water?...😆 She fell because of her hurry, I guess. Jalal was all steady when he stood up to correct her dupatta. I wonder what the boatman must be thinking all throughout the ride. Pooor guy! He died na...We can't even get his views now...😆

And Jalal said, " Yaad rakhiyega, humne aapki fir se jaan bachayi. " One more saving is about to come. I think both of them will have to make notes on how many times each of them saved the other...😆 There are just too many incidents na...😆

Loved how Jalal protected her during the attack. Everytime she made a fearful expression, his hold on her only got stronger. " Ghabraiye mat Jodha Begum, hum hain na aapke saath. " 😳😃
Loved his protective nature towards her. 😃 Not that he wouldn't have protected anyone else on her place, but seeing him protect so strongly, the person whom he claimed to hate, is just incredible. 😳😃 Even Jodha seemed comfortable there, the usual disgusting expressions were not there. 😃

BTW, I agree about Jalal's claims to save her being hawaai only. How the hell was he planning to do that? 😆

Episode 86 :

Again a nice epsiode. 😃

The boat - ride scene was symbolic. Symbolic of the understanding that is developing between them. Look at the way he assures her, and she replies with a nod. And how she helps to move the boat while he is rowing it. Ofcourse, there was the need to save herself also somewhere, but the little understanding developing between them is quite evident. They are beginning to understand each other without a word being uttered by the other.

When will an investigation really result in the punishment of the real culprit? JA is really allergic to positive things maybe. I don't think that the man behind this attack ever became known.

Then comes the treat of the day. ( For me, Aunty. 😉😆 ) I initially thought that Jo had come to Jalal's khema as she was afraid to sleep alone. 😉 But then came to know that it was HB. Again a big thanks to her on behalf of the AAA ( AkDha Admiration Association ) 😉 . I loved the way Jalal welcomed her. This teda + cool Jalal is really a treat to watch. Lately, he has been taking everything Jodha says, very lightly and in a cool fashion. Unlike the earlier days, when each sentence used to create a havoc in his mind. This is a big and considerable change. Though, as I said yesterday too, Jodha is being too hot - headed these days, and that too without a valid reason.
BTW, she went to sleep on his bed, only beacuse he said that " saanp bichhuon ki jaan par khuda khair kare", right? But then, Snakes could have attacked on the bed too...😆Like the previous time. What difference does the bed make?...😕😆
I think JB doesn't know that at night we do switch off the lights. She was so shocked at his putting off the diya. The light in the room was not affected anyway. It was as bright as ever. 😆
This scene somehow looked incomplete to me. 😕

And anyway, why was the ever fiery, a trained warrior Jodha, so scared of mere saanp - bicchus? 🤔

You didn't mention the Jo - Maina scene, so I am just adding that up, anyway. Though, I liked it that you mentioned mainly the AkDha scenes, only. 😉😆

I perfectly understand what Jodha feels for Mainavati right now. But she was perfectly fine with her in Amer, right? What has changed now, then? Any daughter would react the same way Jo did. But Mainavati too, was never wrong, I suppose. She was just being a queen first. The thing is that she could have discussed that with Jodha, before hurling everything infront of her, amidst the whole DEK.

Loved Jodha's scene in her hojra. Very realistic it felt. How good she must've felt after seeing her room in the exact same condition she left it. A very pleasing feeling. Home Sweet Home is really sweet! 😳😃

The patch up of Jodha with Maina was also nice. Jo's hurt was evident from her saying that, " Humara kaksh ab tak bilkul pehle jaisa hi hai, kuchh nahi badla, lekin aap badal gayi hain Maasa. " Sums up the whole scene.

BTW, It was hilarious to see Adham eyeing the Baandis and Maham eyeing him...😆 Some people never change...😆

I somehow felt here that Jalal and Pratap are the perfect enemies. Look at the way BD praises Jalal's memory and wit, and at the same point Pratap too considers them the best weapons. I would say, competitors worthy of each other.
Loved that dialogue, " Ek hi samay mein itihaas ki do badi hastiyaan Amer padhaar chuki thi. " 👏 Sums up the entire scenario soo well. 😃

Look at the way Pratap and Jalal looked at each other during their face - off. Especially Jalal...biggg waala ghurofy...😎😆

BTW, Don't Rajvanshi's apply kajal? Jalal was the only one having lots of it there. 😆

As for your question 3, 4 and 5, these were the exact same ones in my mind. I was wondering if anyone would point them out. 😛

PS : I have colored my post, only because I really wanted to try something new now. 😛😃😆

Edited by -AkDha.Lover- - 9 years ago
Sabdabhala thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Folks,

I normally discuss three episodes per post. This time too, though it looks like just two, the ground covered will be the same since No. 85 was a mahaepisode.

The title is because all thru this stretch, Shahenshah Jalaluddin Muhammad was at the top of his game as he worked to further his twin objectives: the one of co-opting the Rajputs as a pillar of the Mughal sultanat, and the other of getting closer to his prickly Amer ki mirchi. I doubt if he himself was aware of when one ended and the other began, for they were overlapping all the time, before and during their journey to Amer, and at Amer itself! So let us begin.

HI AUNTY, READY FOR YOUR POST, HAVING WATCHED THE SAID EPISODES JUST LAST EVENING. BUT I MUST MENTION THAT YOUR PREVIOUS POST IS SO ADDICTIVE, THAT I HAVE READ IT COUNTLESS TIMES AND BEEN IN SPLITS EVERYTIME, SO MUCH SO, THAT HUBBY DEAR, WHO USUALLY ATTCHES HIS FACE TO HIS LAPTOP WITH A NON-MOVEABLE CHARM, ACTUALLY GLANCED MY WAY MULTIPLE TIMES AND EVEN QUESTIONED MY ACT 😆

APT TITLE AUNTY, AND, BY NOW, I HAVE STOPPED WONDERING HOW YOU COME UP WITH THEM, EACH MORE SUITABLE THAN THE OTHER. IN HINDI THERE IS A WORD SATEEK, AND IT FITS PERFECTLY WITH EACH OF YOUR PERFECT TITLES

THE HOPELESS ROMANTIC IN ME REJOICES CAUSE I REALLY LOVED THE SUKANYA TRACK OF JA. EVEN THOUGH, AS YOU RIGHTLY SAY, PARIDHI'S JODHA IS QUITE LIMITED WITH HER EXPRESSIONS, SOMETIMES, DUE TO CVS FAULT, AND A LOT OF TIMES DUE TO HER OWN ABILITIES, FOR ME, RAJAT'S JALAL MORE THAN MAKES UP FOR IT.

Episode 85a: Mischief abounding!

This one is of course for Jalal, whose eyes were exactly like the magical potions bubbling and boiling in a witch's pot. Eyes that gleamed at times, clouded over at others, as diametrically opposite emotions chased each other in their depths. Emotions that swam up to the surface for varying periods, just to tantalise us, and then vanished again as Jalal gazed, at times outwards, thru a lattice, at the setting sun, at others at his own reflection in the mirror, as if to share with it a secret he could share with no one else.

A Puck in Jodha Akbar:This sub-title is for the impish sprite of Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, if you will bear with the superficially incongruous comparison of such a creature with the Shahenshah-e-Hindustan, in all his imperial splendour. But Jalal in this episode was nothing if not puckish.

The leit motif throughout was mischief, unbridled, unfathomable mischief. Jalal was devilishly provoking, teasing, confusing, with both the women in his life: Ruqaiya Sultan Begum , demanding and doubtful, seeking reassurance ever as she sought to control him , and Jodha Begum, exasperated and enraged by this dancing dervish of a husband, who managed to unsettle and infuriate her with his mocking sallies even while always dodging out of reach when she attempted a comeback.

After weeks of indecision and trauma, of physical and emotional stress , Shahenshah Jalaluddin Mohammed was back at last. Clear-minded and decisive, a surface candour veiling his secret plans as he reassured Bharmal, countered his Badiammi, convinced Ruqaiya and baited Jodha, and laughed conspiratorially with, not at, his aks in the mirror.

Two useful maxims: Before we proceed, two thoughts I would like to leave with you.

Firstly, I begin to think that we all, and I am a major culprit here, parse and analyse the show too much, to the extent that the pleasure of watching it gets eroded. We are dissecting it even as we look at it, and it becomes like reducing an impressionist painting, a Van Gogh or a Monet, to a collection of coloured dots. This is to do, not Jodha Akbar, but ourselves a disservice.

So, after pondering the question marks on the episode before this one and then cobbling them together into my ???????? post on Episode 84, I decided, for the next episode, to go with the flow, and soak up broad impressions. I did not bother about what seemed like a discontinuity in the screenplay and the characterization, I just watched. And what I have set down above is what stayed with me.

Secondly, there are only 2 distinct ways of analyzing a show. One is to treat the characters as individuals, and praise or critcise them for their acts of omission and commission. The second is to treat them as creations and puppets of the CVs, and blame the scriptwriters for everything that we feel is wrong with this or that character.

I always follow the first option. But that is not the point. The point is that we cannot follow both options at the same time. When things seem to us to going wrong with a character whom we have been praising and defending till the day before, we cannot suddenly say that he/she seems to have gone bonkers because the CVs have messed up!

nuff said. Let us come to the collection of scenes of which Episode 85a, the first half of the mahaepisode, consisted. Throughout this, what struck me was how adept Jalal was becoming - astonishing in such an alpha male who claims he finds it difficult to understand his begums - in handling all the very different women in his life, Maham included. And he does this not by blunt commands, but by finessing his equation with each expertly, so as not to bruise the relationship seriously, and if possible at all, while still getting his own way and disregarding what each of them wants from him. If this means that he has to dish out plausible, not lies, but half-truths, who shall blame him? Even an emperor seeks, like any other male of the species, to avoid domestic discord!😉

YES I AGREE, JALAL, IN THESE EPISODES, IS A MASTER STRATEGIST, DEALING WITH EVERYONE IN A DIFERENT MANNER. AND WHY ONLY WOMEN, EVEN MEN

Jalal-Ruqaiya 1 & 2: In the first scene between them, Ruqaiya quizzes Jalal about the reasons for his having arranged this marriage for Sukanya - whereupon he firmly denies, with a great (and misleading) air of truthfulness, that he has done it for Jodha Begum!😉- and about whether he is proposing to go to Amer for this wedding. She then asserts her right, as his friend, to forbid his making this journey. Jalal's face as he looks at her retreating form, his eyes narrowed, is a study in controlled exasperation. Haq jataakar humse hamara hi haq cheen liya! Tumhara andaaz ajab hai, Ruqaiya!

I WONDERED WHAT RUKKAIAH HAD IN MIND WHILE SHE WAS QUESTIONING JALAL THUS. DID SHE THINK HE WOULD SAY THAT HE DID THE ALLIANCE TO PLEASE JODHA, EVEN IF THAT WERE THE TRUTH? AND FOR A BEGUM WHO IS POLITICALY ASTUTE AND AWARE, IT SHOWED HER IN POOR LIGHT.

Not that he has any intention of allowing even his Begum-e-Khaas to decide things for him, for at the meeting soon after with Bharmal, Jalal confirms that he is accepting Bharmal's invitation. Ruqaiya learns of this only thru Maham who, having failed to stop Jalal from going to Amer, now makes a desperate appeal to Ruqaiya to try to ensure this. So we come to Jalal-Ruqaiya 2.

It is a very beautiful scene, most aesthetically set up and shot, with the rays of the setting sun, filtered thru the lattice, creating shifting patterns on the Jalal's face and adding an extra layer of mystery to his deep set eyes.

I AGREE. THIS SCENE WAS EXTREMELY BEAUTIFUL. THE SUN, THE LATTICE, AND JALAL, ALL THREE WERE ABSOLUTELY MESMERISING, GIVING THE SCENE AN AMAZING VISUAL APPEAL.

No sunset for their rishta: Those who see the sunset motif in the latter scene as an (admittedly attractive) symbolism for the fading of Jalal's relationship with Ruqaiya as that with Jodha gains ground, are doing Jalal a signal disservice. He is emphatically not one of those who discard an old, time-tested relationship for a new one, no matter how beguiling the latter might be. He values those who stood by him when he needed them - his Khan Baba, his Badiammi, and Ruqaiya - very greatly, and he will never abandon them until he is forced to do so, and then it will be like having an amputation. Whence his agony when it seemed that Maham was the culprit in the dature ka ark affair.

As for Ruqaiya, however antagonistic she might become towards Jodha as matters develop, this antagonism, rooted in jealousy, would not be a reason for Jalal to break up with his childhood friend; he would merely be amused and even pleased! So I do not see any sunset ahead for the two of them, and in any case, all that Jalal says is that she has come at the right time, and how beautiful the sunset is.

Testing the waters:But Jalal is testing the waters with Ruqaiya, for he does not want excessive friction with her as he becomes closer to Jodha, something he intends to achieve, whatever the Amer ki Mirchi might be thinking. The whole spiel about Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se is part of this exercise. And how superbly it is executed!

Jalal turns to Ruqaiya and raises his eyes, with visible hesitation, to hers, and then turns away again. The words flow with increasing speed, and devastating candour, after he begins with Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se. Here he looks Ruqaiya full in the face. Her eyes are wide with dismay, and Jalal looks away again. Hum aapko yeh baat batane ko majboor nahin hain ( a clear putdown!) lekin sach yahi hai.Pata nahin kaise, ek jadoo sa kar diya hai unhon ne hum par. Unhein dekhte hi dil mein kuch hone lagta hai (a riff, 436 years earlier, on KKHH!). Unhein door jaate dekhte hi, dil isi suraj ki tarah doobne lagta hai. Hum mohabbat karte hain unse, deewaane ban chuke hain unke, ghulam ban chuke hain unke. Ab har din, har pal hum unse aur judte jaa rahe hain, Ruqaiya!

I FELT THAT JALAL WAS TRYING TO SHARE THE BUBBLING IN HIS HEART WITH HIS BEST FRIEND, SOMEONE WITH WHOM HE HAS SHARED LOTS OF HIS UPS AND DOWNS. THE FACT THAT SHE TOO IS HIS WIFE AND THAT TOO AN EXTREMELY JEALOUS ONE, ALONG WITH BEING RUTHLESSY POWER HUNGRY,IS JUST SAD FOR HIM. ONE.OOKAT HER AGHAST FACE AND HE IS FORCED TO RETRACT

At this point he turns, looks at her face frozen in shock and worse , and begins to laugh. Aaj pehli baar aapke maathe par shikanj dekha hai! Aapko hairaan kar diya hai Ruqaiya!

Jalal is very convincing at the beginning, and in 2013, I was really foxed and confused, for all that his confession seemed most premature. It was only when he got to unke deewane, unke ghulam, that I knew it was a con, for never would Jalal (at least at this stage!) become any woman's ghulam, not even of the love of his life! But when he turns back after that deliberately exaggerated confession - not fake, be it noted - and sees the frozen shock and despair in Ruqaiya's eyes, Jalal knows that he has gone too far and has to retreat, for he has no notion of wrecking his bond with her. Not for anything, least of all for the uncertain prospects that lie ahead with Jodha.

COMPLETELY AGREE WITH YOU. HE FEELS FOR JODHA, WANTS TO SHARE IT WITH RUKKAIAH, BUT YET, DOES NOT WANT TO MESS WITH HER, SPECIALLY WHEN HE CAN SEE THAT SHE IS QUITE VISIBLY UNCOMFORTABLE. SO HE RETREATS IN A WAY THAT SHE FEELS THAT THE WHOLE THONG WAS HIS ATTEMPT AT HUMOR. WHICH IS PROBABLY WHY HE GIVES HER AN EXTRA LONG EXPLANATION ABOUT HIS STRATEGY TOWARDS AMER AND RAJPUTANA, AND ALSO ADDS THE JHUKE HUE SAR DIALOGUE.HE IS SURE THAT THAT DIALOGUE WILLFIND ITS MARK IN HER MIND AND APPEASE HER

A more devious explanation: There is another possibility: that Jalal shocks Ruqaiya with Hum mohabbat karte Jodha Begum se quite deliberately, so that in the overwhelming relief when he tells her that he was only joking, she will easily accept that the visit is a purely political exercise. Personally, I would opt for this, for there is no real reason that I can think of for Jalal to inform Ruqaiya that he has fallen in love with the woman of whom she is acutely jealous!

Siyaasati wajah: So, he now appeases Ruqaiya by repeatedly laying exclusive emphasis on the siyasati wajah for the Amer trip, embroidering it with the ancillary themes of winning over the Ameri awaam and eliminating any rebellion for keeps, as he moves step by step, adding one relationship after another with erstwhile enemies, towards uniting all of Hindustan under his rule.

Hum Amer rishtedaari nibhane ke liye nahin ja rahe hain..hum wahan sirf aur sirf siyaasati matlab se jaa rahe hain. . Hum chahte hain ki hamara auda unki nazaron mein aur bhi bad jaye...Humne Amer par fateh ki hai, ab uski riyaya ke dilon par raj karna hai humein. Zindagi bhar baghawat ka khyal nahin aayega unke zehen mein!.. He rounds off this misleading peroration by asserting Hum unke jhuke hue sar dekhna chahte hain!

For us to shrink at this old chestnut of jhukofying the Rajvanshi sars , which is meant only for Ruqaiya's consumption, would be as unwarranted as for us to assume that the entire siyasati rationale is just a smokescreen to hide Jalal's real reason, to get opportunities to spend time in Amer, as up close and personal as can be managed, with Jodha.

We should not forget that Jalal is an emperor, and the expansion and strengthening of his empire would, for him, come first, always and every time, and this no matter what he feels, or does not feel, for Jodha. This is as it should be, for I for one would, in 2013, have hated to see Jalal reduced to a pathetic lover sighing verses to his mistress' eyebrow', as, who else, Shakespeare would put it. Let us not even talk of what happened later!

However, the siyasati reasons are not the whole truth either. Jalal knows his Gatti, and banks on her believing his half truth to be the whole truth, because she believes what she wants to believe.

A menage a trois?:When he asks her if she is not coming to Amer with them, he might have assumed, knowing Ruqaiya, that she would refuse. But he could not have been sure, so why does he broach it at all? Methinks it was just more of mischief, for I am sure he does not doubt his ability to juggle both these balls in the air while at Amer and never drop either!😉

HE CERTAINLY IS A JUGGLER EXTRAORDINAIRE, NO DOUBT!! 😆😉 THATSPROBABLY HOW HE MANAGED HIS RAATRI NIRDHARAN VYAVASTHA IN A HAREM FULLOF WILING WOMEN

Jalal-Maham: It is revealing that Jalal does not go to the lengths he goes to with Ruqaiya to persuade Mahaam to accept the Amer trip. For one thing, he knows that if he argues this one out with her, his shrewd Badiammi will start trying to take his siyasati rationale apart, and he does not want to go down that road.

I DONT KNOW HOW RIGHT I AM, BUT I DO FEEL THAT EVER SINCE THE MISCARRIAGE, JALAL'S JHUKAAV TOWARDS MAHAM IS A BIT REDUCED

Moreover, emperors do not explain their decisions. So two crisp sentences, ending in Yeh tai hai ki... and it is all wrapped up (it is to be noted that his Ammijaan is not in his list, but I am sure she will add herself!). Again, in the Diwan-e-Khas with Bharmal, he neatly prevents Maham from raising any objections by saddling her with the responsibility for the gifts for the bride.

In all of this, one also sees that while asserting that his decisions are not to be altered, he nonetheless is never abrupt towards or dismissive of Maham. He merely sidesteps her, and is considerate even while being unyielding. He has, beyond any doubt, grown up, has our Jalal.

Jalal-Jodha : & 1: The half scene is the exchange of understanding glances between them as Bharmal leaves. Jodha's eyes brim over in gratitude, as Jalal acknowledges it by an almost imperceptible nod (Rajat must be having a micrometer in his head, to be able to achieve such miniscule shifts of position and expression!) that seems to say: Don't worry, it will all be fine. Very nice going, I said to myself, and got ready for a pleasant rubaru between them soon.

Then came the Scene 1, which of course upset all my calculations. For the first 30 seconds, as Jodha neither enquired after Jalal's health, nor sought to apologise for the narnaal fiasco, nor even thanked him for arranging Sukanya's alliance, but launched into a broadside against his taking aapke parivaar ko (in which she obviously does not include herself) to Amer, I was all at sea.

Then I switched to my earlier resolution, abandoned any attempt to understand the discontinuity in Jodha's behaviour, and simply went with the flow. It was a wise choice, for what followed was pure delight.

This scene too was amazingly well envisaged and shot, with most of the action being shown in the mirror, an unusual trick that heightened the impact of each frame.

IT WAS A BRILLIANT SCENE, WITH JALAL LOOIKING SPECIALLY YUMMILICIOUS WITH THE SCARS AND SMIRKS!! UFFF

Jalal: Mischief abounding: Rajat's Jalal is here fabulous from start to finish. He never misses an opening to trip up his angry, flustered Jodha Begum. He is brimming over with mischief - it is there in every glance of his, in the teasing tones in his voice, in the mocking lines after he has extracted a reluctant and qualified thank you from her:Aapke is upkaar ke liye hum aabhaar prakat karte hain parantu... .

He he follows that up without missing a beat: Magar kya, Jodha Begum? Bura socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai, achcha socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai. Yeh hunar aap mein paidayeshi hai, ya baaqaida aapne isme taaleem haasil ki hai?

And much more in the same vein, about a baaghin from whom humein khatra hamesha hai. The flummoxed Jodha exclaims in disbelief Kya??? Whereupon Jalal embroiders further on this enticing theme, about the mortal danger to him from Jodha's assorted deadly weaponry- top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar aapka gussa, shamsheer se tez aapki zubaan, aur katar ki dhar dar aapki nazar, in teenon ka hamla hum par ho gaya to koyi marham humein bacha nahin sakta!

All delivered with the same lightness of touch, the same effortless mastery of flirtatious leg pulling, while his eyes, gleaming with ill-suppressed merriment as they never leave her fuming face, seeking to unsettle her even more.

Jodha: Easy prey: I was sorry to see Jodha play right into his hands, and make a complete, pokered-up, ungracious fool of herself by the time she reacts to his last sally about what all she can do for him in Amer in return for the itna nek kaam he has done for her family.

Hum to soch rahe hain kyon na roz aapke haathon se banaya khana khayein? Waise humein ab teekhe ki aadat ho gayi hai. And as Jodha's eyes narrow in anger, Ab hum par mirchi ka asar nahin hota hai! She responds to this teasing by turning her back on him and stomping off in a huff. She leaves Jalal, predictably, chortling in glee with his companion in the mirror.

Her problem is that she is utterly devoid of a sense of humour. If she had only laughed out loud at his description of her top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar gussa, shamsheer se tez zubaan, and all the rest, and declared :

Apitu hum to Amer ki beti hain, Shahenshah, Amer ki mirchi jaisi teekhi. Hum jaise bhi hain, aapko to isise santrusht rahan padega! Humein apne aap mein kuch bhi parivartan laaneki koyi bhi ichcha nahin hai. Aap to is janam mein to kya, agle cheh janam ke liye hamare isi kaaya aur isi pravrutti se bandhe rahenge. Kya karenge aap, Shahenshah? ,

Jalal would have been totally stumped, and might have started laughing with her, not at her.

Similarly, if she had thanked him warmly for arranging Sukanya's marriage, and told him how sorry she was about her having put him in such mortal danger without at all meaning to do so, he would have been disarmed.

But no, she has to go wandering into the morass of accusing of having ulterior motives in arranging Sukanya's marriage, which was ungracious, to say the least. From there to insisting that he never does anything without the hope of gaining something else, is but a step, as she plays further into his hands. As a feminist, I felt like shaking some sense into her head. Not that it would have helped! .

SUBTELTY AND A SENSE OF HUMOR ARE TWO IMPORTANT QUALITIES THAT BOTH JODHA AND PARIDHI LACK. OF COURSE, JODHA MORE THAN PARIDHI

JODHA IS ON HER OWN TRIP, WITH LITTLE TO DO WITH REALITY. I THINK, LIKE JALAL, WE TOO SHOULD JUST TAKE HER COMMENTS IN STRIDE AND GENERALLY IGNORE HER

BUT FOR A WIFE WHO HAS BEEN THE CAUSE OF JALAL'S ALMOST FATAL CALAMITY, HER BEHAVIOUR IS EXASPERATING AND IRRITATING, TO SAY THE LEAST

So, finally, she stormed off, looking nothing like the baaghin he was comparing her to, and more like an angry kitten frustrated at not having been able to sharpen her claws on her tormentor!😉

In all this relentless, but not malicious teasing, for that is what it was, one revealing point has to be noted.

When Jodha asks, angrily, whether he had no faith in Amer or her Bapusa's ability to ensure his safety, Jalal answers her seriously and reassuringly, stressing his conviction that her brothers would be ready to do anything, including giving up their lives if necessary, to protect him. A girl with a bit more of perceptiveness would have noted the sudden change of tone and of content, from being frivolous towards her to admiration and respect for her family, and reacted accordingly.

We might them have had the first ever civilized conversation between them. Alas, this was was not to be!

Hopes belied: We are , beginning from right now, going to be treated to every corny trick in the panoply of romantic pulp fiction, up to the Ratanpur Qila contretemps, which is when the script starts picking up again. The interim Jalal-Jodha interactions bored me stiff the first time around, and the Govinda style tel maalish sequence had me fuming.

So much for my vain hopes for Jalal and Jodha, of seeing mutual caring and affection develop, slowly but surely. Of an edgy friendship morphing, insensibly, into love, with all its yearnings, its restlessness in the absence of the loved one, the misunderstandings, the jealousies, the protectiveness and the possessiveness, and beneath it all, the undercurrent of a hidden sensuality.

Of a Jodha whose pride in her magnificent husband would make her say, as Cleopatra once said to Julius Caesar : "But for you, the world is full of little men".

What a fall this is going to be, my friends (apologies to Mark Antony)! Anyhow, I am going to number the Jalal-Jodha scenes from now on, and give them a rating of 1 to 10. You, my gentle readers, are more than welcome to give your own ratings in your comments, with reasons for them.

There is only one thing I was looking forward to in 2013, and that was Dadisaa getting to know Jalal. I would bet anything that if she had been 50 years younger, Jalal would have flipped for her without a second thought, instead of this sulky, irascible, pokered-up female he has now landed himself with, complete with her bhashanbaazi and her tantrums😉 .

Kunwar Pratap ki duvidha: I normally do not devote too much space to this gentleman, mainly because Ekta's casting has, for once, gone awry with this Kunwar Pratap. Moreover, most of the lines given to him are pure bombast or ranting against the deshdrohi Bharmal. However, this time, I was so impressed by the lambent wisdom of his guru , as also by Pratap's articulation of his unwavering commitment to the Rajput code of honour, that I am going to spread myself a bit!

Of geedhads and shers: I loved it when Pratap, after listening impassively to a whole line up of his (most unimpressive and dismal looking) advisers push for a sneak attack on Jalal's cortege on the way to Amer, in order to put paid to him easily (being stupid, they assume that he will not have a military escort!), responded with a caustic Theek kah rahe hain! Uttamtam (the Sanskrit superlative) hai, parantu kaayaron ke liye, veeron ke liye nahin! ..Avasar ki prateeksha kaayar karte hain, aur peeche se vaar geedhad. Singh nahin! Singh hamesha saamne se vaar karte hain, garajkar, vijaynaad ke saath!..Is tarah peeche se vaar karna na hi hamara rashtra dharma hai, na hi Rajvanshiyon ki maryada.

This was the clear, uncomplicated code of honour by which this great warrior lived, fought, and died. This, and his fierce determination- his head unbowed and his tenacity a byeword - never to accept the suzerainty of the Mughals. No wonder that his legend endures.

Chanakyan advice : While Pratap oscillates between the conflicting pulls, the duvidha of which to choose between shatruta aur swabhimaan on the one hand, and sambandh and kartavya (of upholding family ties) on the other, his guru is clear-eyed and categoric, insisting that the latter should prevail, and that Pratap should attend the wedding.

But not solely, or even largely for familial reasons. Rather because the Mughal Shahenshah will also be there at Amer. Brushing aside Pratap's distaste for meeting Jalal, the guru sets out the tactical and strategic rationale for what he advises. Yuddh karne se pehle, apne shatru ki shakti, uski neeti, aur uski chaal ka avalokan karna, yehi rajneeti hai. Yeh tumhare liye ek avsar hai, Jalal ko theek se jaan ne ka, uski shakti aur chaal ko samajhne ka. Itihaas wo hi likhta hai, Pratap, jo apne shatru ki shakti ko jaanta ho. Yon samajh lo ki yeh nimantran tumhare liye ek rajnaitik aavashyakta hai. Yeh jan ne ka avasar hai ki kya tumhari talwar ki dhaar itni saksham hai ki wo Jalal ki dhal ko bhed sake?

The great Acharya Chanakya, from nearly 19 centuries back, would have approved wholeheartedly! Whether the results from this sakshatkaar that Pratap's guru had hoped for actually materialized is an open question.

Episodes 85b and 86: A jaundiced view

This one is going to be -now don't start laughing already! - relatively short. It is more of a venting of exasperation than an analysis.

Let me therefore just put it down as a series of questions, and you can then amuse yourselves thinking up the answers. And if any of you is still in a roseate haze induced by the boat ride, please snap out of it!

Q1) It is all very nice to educate the viewers in the complexities of Mughal-Rajput animosities, and I was duly moved by the noble sentiments in the invitation sent by the Rajmata of Amer to Maharani Jaiwantibai of Mewar. But apart from the fact that the Rajvanshis shown confabulating with Kunwar (not Rana) Pratap looked like a bunch of extras from a gangster film togged out in royal attire, there was another major problem with this segment

What about the invitation to Pratap's estranged father, the Maharana of Mewar, Udai Singh? It was to him, as the head of the Sisodias of Mewar, that the invitation would have been addressed, not to Pratap, who was not even the Yuvraj. It would have been unthinkable in terms of royal protocol.

The CVs seem to have forgotten all about Maharana Udai Singh, but when Akbar laid siege to Chttor in 1568, It was still Maharana Udai Singh who was on the throne. He had moved to Udaipur, which he founded as his new capital, and left Jaimal and Patta to defend Chittor. MaharanaUdai Singh also stood firm against the Afghans first and then the Mughals, so this premature emphasis on Kunwar Pratap seems odd, to say the least.

Q2) Why is it that Jodha is not even thinking of throwing out any of the Kabul ke zevarat gifted to Sukanya by Hamida Banu ? Should they not remind her of the Devi Maa's jewellery the Mughal raiders looted from the temple? And it is not even as if this was after Jalal had, at the Kali Maa mandir, fulfilled the sankalp Jodha had taken after that incident. Not only does she not reject the jewellery now, but she does not burn the Dhaka mulmul either, inconsistent wench that she is!😉 In fact, she seems quite in ecstasies over her Ammijaan's largesse for Sukanya, this sammaan for Amer that they would never forget!

IT IS AL L A MATTER OF CONVENIENCE FOR JODHA. RIGHT NOW SHE OBVIOUSLY THINKS THAT HER IZZAT, HER FAMILY'S IZZAT AND ALSO SUKANYA'S IZAT WIL GET A HUGE FILLIP WHEN THE SOON TO BE INLAWS KNOW THE LARGESSE THAT SHAHENSHAH E HIND HAS BESTOWED ON SUKANYA

Joking apart, of course the context of the two sets of gifts could not be more different. I was decidedly critical of Jodha's immature and thoughtless act in burning the Shahenshah's gift of the shaadi ka joda, which might have seriously endangered Amer. But I also feel that if it had been Hamida Bano who had brought it, instead of the vicious Maham Anga, Jodha might, just might not have burnt it, even if she accepted it only with a sullen face. There seems to be an instant soul connect between Hamida and Jodha, probably dating back to a poorva

THAT WOULD HAVE BEN THE RIGHT PROTOCOL TOO. EITHER HAMIDA OR BAKSHI. BUT IN THEIR ABSENCE MAHAM WAS PROBABLY THE ONLY CHOICE

Q3) Why is the Shahenshah's chief minister, Atgah Khan, shown to be such an incompetent that, with a large military contingent at hand, he suggests that his emperor go for a boat ride on a lake in hostile territory, a sitting duck for any attacker, without first securing the perimeter of the lake? In his place, having handled such visits as an Ambassador, even if it was not in hostile territory, that is the first thing I would have done.

IT IS THE SAME LIKE EVERYONE EAVESDROPS ON MOST OF HIS SECRET CONVERSATIONS, SPECIALLY MAHAM AND RESHAM. BESIDES WHICH, MOST CVS SEE A GLOOMY AND FRAUGHT WITH DANGER SCENARIO AS THE ONE IN WHICH TO SOW THE SEEDS OF A ROMANCE :) HENCE JALAL'S PERMANENTLY CUT HAND

Q4) How many times is Jalal to cut his hand - not to speak of worse - in order to promote his shaky romance with the Amer ki Mirchi? At this rate, he will fade away from sheer blood loss 😉 . This is the third time, and it is getting to be so hackneyed. Can't they think of something a bit more intelligent for a change? The script's sole brainwave for promoting the Jalal-Jodha romance seems to be to get him to injure some limb so that Jodha Begum can set to work on it with her patented lep. And how the devil did he cut it this time anyway? His hand was quite saabut when he got into the boat.

😆😆

It is a good thing for Jalal that the lake water in which his sulky begum is washing the cut must have been pure in those days. If it was today, he would die of chemical poisoning, possibly from mercury, as in the Minamoto affair in Japan.

Q5) What was it with the pathetic standards of marksmanship among the tribal warriors? Their arrows fell in showers, reminding one of the Yuddha Kanda in the Ramayana, and if they had been even halfway proficient, our nascent lovers should both have been reduced to pincushions. At this rate, the tribals must be starving in the jungle!

Oh dear, I had forgotten the numbering of the Jalal-Jodha scenes. Here goes, then.

Jalal-Jodha 1: Nauka vihar: This began in a promising fashion. I perked up when Jodha Begum was quizzing a daasi about her khema, displaying a sure-footed certainty as to which was the Shahenshah's. (This bit was edited out by Zee Anmol).Apart from this indication of interest in his doings, she had also given up her unseemly habit of haranguing him about a separate khema for herself. Whether it was due to the presence of Hamida Banu is not clear, but Jodha seemed reasonably well-behaved, even summoning up a reluctant smile when her Ammijaan summarily decided that she would go with the Shahenshah on the nauka vihar.

As for Jalal, he was assessing the possibilities as soon as he spotted the Amer ki Mirchi. His eyes, as he looked at her, and then up at the full moon, lit up with nascent mischief. This became even more pronounced as he saw manna descend from Heaven, in the shape of his Ammijaan, who delivered his recalcitrant begum up to him without his having to exert himself in the least! So, when Jodha was trying to catch his eye and nodding her head in the negative, Jalal blandly informed his Ammijaan: Hum bhi Atgah Saheb se yahi kehnewale the!😉

ANOTHER LOVELY SCENE! JALAL WAS JUST TOO GOOD.

No wonder then that Jodha, forced to trot after her exasperating spouse, muttered audibly about his daft idea of going for a boat ride this late at night. She then responded to his Aapne kuch kaha? , in an irritated tone: Kaha bhi to kya? Apne hat ke aage aapko kisi ki baat sunayi kahan deti hai? Anything more typically biwi-like could not be imagined😉! Or perhaps Asha Parekh in a 1960s Hindi film? So far so good.

From then on, however, things go steadily downhill. Jodha hesitates visibly, in fact for what seemed an age, about letting her husband help her into the small boat. Once in the boat, after grabbing his arm when she loses her balance, she continues with her 1960s film heroine stance. She looks everywhere but at Jalal, while he gazes unblinkingly at her.

When, in an effort to make some conversation, he enquires pleasantly about her liking boat rides, what is it with her reply? Anand milta hai ya dand, yeh kiske saath ho us par nirbhar karta hai! It is insolent and ungracious, and for that one moment, his smile fades. As a follow up, she informs him that the problem with him is that aap baatein nahin, kewal vivaad karna jaante hain!What vivaad there was in his innocuous question I could not make out, not to speak of the fact that Jodha Begum has a PhD in vivaad or behas!

She keeps up this snippishness without a let up. When, after washing the cut in his hand, in slo mo, with the lake water, she sulks and gets up suddenly, if there had been any justice in the world of soaps, she should have fallen into the water and got the dunking of her life! No such luck, alas!😉

EVEN THEN AUNTY, SHE WOULD LAID THE BLAME OF ALL HER AGONIES (WET AND OTHERWISE :)) SQUARELY ON JALAL'S SKLL, SO I GUESS ITS GOOD THAT SHE DIDNT FALL

This is not how royalty behaves, and that too in front of servants. And there is a lot of space between a goody two shoes, and this humourless, ill-mannered young woman, and this should not be forgotten. It does not have to be one or the other. That Jalal does not seem to mind her ungraciousness, and when he does, he seems to get over it fast, changes nothing in this. I long, simply long for a sensible conversation between the two of them, free of taanas and sallies of the cutting kind, but where is this to be found? Not in this script, that is for sure!

NEVER IN THIS SCRIPT IS A BETTER WAY TO PUT IT. JALAL, OF COURSE FOLLOWS HIS END OF THE DEAL TO THE T, BUT HAMARI JODHA SA DOES NOT BELIEVE IN CONVERSATIONS - ONLY IN ACCUSATIONS, LAMENTATIONS,AND BHAASHANS

In 2013, at the end of this episode, with the two of them facing a steady shower of arrows from the bank, I was wondering how on earth Jalal was proposing to save our Amer ki Mirchi! At that moment, she seemed to be in front and more exposed, for all his bravado of letting nothing happen to her. The only option would have been for him to dive under the boat with her, and use the inverted boat as a shield.But then her regalia, when wet, would be heavy enough to sink them both!😉

The whole boat ride scene was contrived in the extreme, farce with a capital F. Not that I think anyone cared!

Rating: 4 out of 10, and 2 of those for the pleasing beginning!

8/10 TO JALAL AND -6/10 TO JODHA FOR HER UNNECESSARY RANTS. BUT FOR HER, THE SCENE WOULD HAVE BEEN SOOO MUCH MORE ENJOYABLE

Jalal-Jodha 2: Saanjha khema: Now this one was a delight, and this not only because Jalal was in full flow as the Puck of Agra. Jodha too played off him with praise-worthy comic timing.

When Jodha turns up unannounced in Jalal's tent (which is odd, but perhaps the guards assumed that a begum has this privilege!), he usurps her standard opening line: Aap yahan?, and hiding his surprise well, informs her kindly :Zara gaur farmayiye, Jodha Begum! Aap galat kheme mein aa gayi hain!

When Jodha counters this with a poker-faced: Hum bilkul sahi sthan par aaye hain, and announces Wo...h...Aaj raat hum yahin, aapke kheme mein hi rahenge!, Jalal is not about to let any rising tide of gladness, however tentative and hesitant, show on his face. So he gets up from the bed, and takes refuge in an ironic comment: Wallah! Aaj pehli baar kisine Shahenshah ko hukum diya hai!

Her eventual explanation, about her sudden descent on him being due to their Ammijaan's orders, must have brought him down to earth with a thud, but he hides that too well in badinage about offering her the bed while he sleeps on the couch. Her predictable refusal of his upkaar, adding, as an afterthought, Waise bhi, is upkaar ke badle mein na jaane kya maang baitein aap humse? does not faze him, for this sort of thing is now old hat for apna Jalal!

So he does not respond in kind. Instead, eyes mock serious, he send up a prayer to the Almighty: Phir saanp bichuon ki jaan par Khuda khair kare! Hum aaj unki jaan nahin bacha paayenge, kyonki hum kisiki jaan bachata bahut thak gaye hain!😉 And he retires to the bed, leaving fully half of it free, undoubtedly anticipating the future developments, and closes his eyes.

What follows is delightfully comic. Jodha, sitting on the couch, mulling over Jalal's sanp bichoowala comment, her eyes scanning the tent with increasing trepidation, is assailed by memories of the Mohini kaand on the road to Ajmer. That does it! She gets up, sidles over to the left side of the bed, seats herself gingerly after moving the coverlet towards Jalal, and looks at him, apparently asleep already, out of the corner of her eyes.

Just when she looks reassured (of what?), Jalal suddenly moves, blows out the only candle in the room, and again closes his eyes. Jodha, startled , exclaims aloud: Inhon ne diya kyon bujha diya?, to Jalal's secret amusement.

She next looks Heavenwards, and sends up a petition : He Ambe Maa! , presumably for divine assistance to keep Jalal on his side of the bed😉. I was wondering why Ambe Maa had been selected this time, and not Jodha's regular Kanha, but this was very likely because Jodha felt that the Goddess would have some extra feminine solidarity with her! 😉Next, a concerned (but not nervous) Inhein kehne ka bhi koyi labh nahin hoga! , before she too settles down for the night. Jalal, watching all this unobserved, must have been chortling inside! Peace then presumably prevails in the Shahi khema for the rest of the night.

The significant point about these goings on is that Jodha now clearly trusts her patidev to keep the line. Which ensures the the stree ke liye laalasa theme has been laid to rest ( not permanently, alas!). This is a baby step forward in her relationship with Jalal, and undoubtedly has a bearing on her agreeing to share his bedroom while at Amer.

As for Jalal, who has surely never before had to woo any woman, especially one who will not even give him the time of the day, such incremental progress must have the charm of novelty!

BEAUTIFUL SCENE. JALAL, IN HIS SHAWL, WAS JUST OUT OF THIS WORLD, AND HIS EXPRESSIONS - WALLAH!! AND EVEN JODHA, FOR A CHANGE, HAD FEWER LINES BETTER EXPRESSIONS, AND NO JIBES! PHEW! SUCH SCENES ARE SO FEW AND SO FAR BETWEEN

Rating: 7 out of 10, 2 of which for Jalal's saanp-bichoo crack!

10/10 AND ALL TO JALAL :) SORRY I DIDNT EVEN NOTICE JODHA :)

Much of a muchness: Well, we now know that a lot more more of this jejune stuff is going to be unloaded on us in Amer. The sad truth is that after a while, even Jalal's mischievous, dancing eyes begin to pall; one can have too much of a good thing, especially when the object of all his badinage and flirtatiousness continues to look as if she has been attacked by a swarm of bees! It is now the nth time that he is teasing Jodha calling her a baaghin. And being a completely humourless girl, she is unable to think up a single smart retort. Or better still, laugh it off. I have by now grown tired for writing snappy lines for her!😉

I, FOR ONE, LOOK FORWARD TO FHE ROMANCE, AUNTY. I KNOW IT IS HALF BAKED BUT, LIKE I SAID, JALAL'S EXPRESSIONS MAKE UP FOR ALL THAT JODHA SAYS, OR DOES NOT

Don't mind me, folks, I am already out of sorts after having to watch all this laboured nonsense. Carry on with the joyfest over the Akdha/Parijat prem katha. They should have had Jalal cutting another limb the day after, and Jodha being be stabbed by the assassin the day after that. Phir kya, yeh prem katha toh chalti nahin, daudti!

Jokes of the day: 1) Bharmal, who was not present at the main gate of the Amer fort to greet his javaisa the Shahenshah, leaving Jalal to the care of his sons, while personally escorting Kunwar Pratap, not even the Yuvraj of Mewar, to his rooms, for all the world as if he was his ADC. It was beyond ridiculous.

2)The idea of Maham Anga singing a lori😉. It had me in splits!

Scene of the day: The relentlessly hyped face to face encounter between Jalal and Pratap. It was so stagey and affected, and so obviously meant to impress the viewers, that it was almost amusing. The wooden faced Pratap did not disappoint me, never departing from the flat monotone which characterizes all his utterances. Jalal was of course far more nuanced and subtle, but Rajat had no one and nothing to play off, and there was only so much even he could so with that scene.

BUT THROUGHOUT THE SCENE RAJAT HAD A SMILE ON HIS FACE. IT WAS ALMOST LIKE HE WANTED TO TELL PRATAP - I AM HERE, AND EVEN HERE, IN THE HEARTLAND OF YOUR RAJPUTANA, YOU CANT DO A THING

Finally, I almost expected a large announcement at the bottom of the frame when they were eyeing each other : YAHAN, SHAHENSHAH JALALUDDIN AUR MAHARANA PRATAP, US SADI KE DO MAHAAN HASTIYON KA AAMNA SAAMNA HUA!😉

Rather like the caption of the frame in the 1982 film, Coolie , when it was released after Amitabh Bachchan's recovery from near death, showing the exact moment when Amitabh took that mistimed, almost fatal punch to his abdomen!

That is it for now, folks. The next time, en avant to the Kali Maa mandir, and the cutting of a Gordian knot!

LOOK FORWARD TO THAT AUNTY! TAKE CARE

Shyamala/Aunty/Akka/Di

karkuzhali thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Dear Shyamala,
I am seeing a very pleasing, witty,balanced, harmless(?) and friendly Shyamala of my ilk here.👏 If I were asked to assess your review I would give you 10/10. I even gave a thorough second reading but found nothing to bring your top score down!
Today I wanted to assume myself as a teenager in the process of reviewing your thread.
My comments are as usual in red.

Saraswathi.




Originally posted by: sashashyam

Folks,

I normally discuss three episodes per post. This time too, though it looks like just two, the ground covered will be the same since No. 85 was a mahaepisode.

The title is because all thru this stretch, Shahenshah Jalaluddin Muhammad was at the top of his game as he worked to further his twin objectives: the one of co-opting the Rajputs as a pillar of the Mughal sultanat, and the other of getting closer to his prickly Amer ki mirchi. I doubt if he himself was aware of when one ended and the other began, for they were overlapping all the time, before and during their journey to Amer, and at Amer itself! So let us begin.

I am sure that only this topped his priority list.

Episode 85a: Mischief abounding!

This one is of course for Jalal, whose eyes were exactly like the magical potions bubbling and boiling in a witch's pot.@

@What a comparison!

Eyes that gleamed at times, clouded over at others, as diametrically opposite emotions chased each other in their depths. Emotions that swam up to the surface for varying periods, just to tantalise us, and then vanished again as Jalal gazed, at times outwards, thru a lattice, at the setting sun, at others at his own reflection in the mirror, as if to share with it a secret he could share with no one else.@@

@@What a lovely description!

A Puck in Jodha Akbar:This sub-title is for the impish sprite of Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, if you will bear with the superficially incongruous comparison of such a creature with the Shahenshah-e-Hindustan, in all his imperial splendour. But Jalal in this episode was nothing if not puckish.

The leit motif throughout was mischief, unbridled, unfathomable mischief. Jalal was devilishly provoking, teasing, confusing, with both the women in his life: Ruqaiya Sultan Begum , demanding and doubtful, seeking reassurance ever as she sought to control him , and Jodha Begum, exasperated and enraged by this dancing dervish of a husband, who managed to unsettle and infuriate her with his mocking sallies even while always dodging out of reach when she attempted a comeback.

After weeks of indecision and trauma, of physical and emotional stress , Shahenshah Jalaluddin Mohammed was back at last. Clear-minded and decisive, a surface candour veiling his secret plans as he reassured Bharmal, countered his Badiammi, convinced Ruqaiya and baited Jodha, and laughed conspiratorially with, not at, his aks in the mirror.

Two useful maxims: Before we proceed, two thoughts I would like to leave with you.

Firstly, I begin to think that we all, and I am a major culprit here, parse and analyse the show too much, to the extent that the pleasure of watching it gets eroded. We are dissecting it even as we look at it, and it becomes like reducing an impressionist painting, a Van Gogh or a Monet, to a collection of coloured dots. This is to do, not Jodha Akbar, but ourselves a disservice.

So, after pondering the question marks on the episode before this one and then cobbling them together into my ???????? post on Episode 84, I decided, for the next episode, to go with the flow, and soak up broad impressions. I did not bother about what seemed like a discontinuity in the screenplay and the characterization, I just watched. And what I have set down above is what stayed with me.

Secondly, there are only 2 distinct ways of analyzing a show. One is to treat the characters as individuals, and praise or critcise them for their acts of omission and commission. The second is to treat them as creations and puppets of the CVs, and blame the scriptwriters for everything that we feel is wrong with this or that character.

I always follow the first option. But that is not the point. The point is that we cannot follow both options at the same time. When things seem to us to going wrong with a character whom we have been praising and defending till the day before, we cannot suddenly say that he/she seems to have gone bonkers because the CVs have messed up!

I am trying to understand.

nuff said. Let us come to the collection of scenes of which Episode 85a, the first half of the mahaepisode, consisted. Throughout this, what struck me was how adept Jalal was becoming - astonishing in such an alpha male who claims he finds it difficult to understand his begums - in handling all the very different women in his life, Maham included. And he does this not by blunt commands, but by finessing his equation with each expertly, so as not to bruise the relationship seriously, and if possible at all, while still getting his own way and disregarding what each of them wants from him. If this means that he has to dish out plausible, not lies, but half-truths, who shall blame him? Even an emperor seeks, like any other male of the species, to avoid domestic discord!😉

Jalal-Ruqaiya 1 & 2: In the first scene between them, Ruqaiya quizzes Jalal about the reasons for his having arranged this marriage for Sukanya - whereupon he firmly denies, with a great (and misleading) air of truthfulness, that he has done it for Jodha Begum!😉- and about whether he is proposing to go to Amer for this wedding. She then asserts her right, as his friend, to forbid his making this journey. Jalal's face as he looks at her retreating form, his eyes narrowed, is a study in controlled exasperation. Haq jataakar humse hamara hi haq cheen liya! Tumhara andaaz ajab hai, Ruqaiya!

Not that he has any intention of allowing even his Begum-e-Khaas to decide things for him, for at the meeting soon after with Bharmal, Jalal confirms that he is accepting Bharmal's invitation. Ruqaiya learns of this only thru Maham who, having failed to stop Jalal from going to Amer, now makes a desperate appeal to Ruqaiya to try to ensure this.

Serves them right! Serves them right!

So we come to Jalal-Ruqaiya 2.

It is a very beautiful scene, most aesthetically set up and shot, with the rays of the setting sun, filtered thru the lattice, creating shifting patterns on the Jalal's face and adding an extra layer of mystery to his deep set eyes.

We can see Jalal like this in some more scenes in future.

No sunset for their rishta: Those who see the sunset motif in the latter scene as an (admittedly attractive) symbolism for the fading of Jalal's relationship with Ruqaiya as that with Jodha gains ground, are doing Jalal a signal disservice. He is emphatically not one of those who discard an old, time-tested relationship for a new one, no matter how beguiling the latter might be. He values those who stood by him when he needed them - his Khan Baba, his Badiammi, and Ruqaiya - very greatly, and he will never abandon them until he is forced to do so, and then it will be like having an amputation. Whence his agony when it seemed that Maham was the culprit in the dature ka ark affair.

As for Ruqaiya, however antagonistic she might become towards Jodha as matters develop, this antagonism, rooted in jealousy, would not be a reason for Jalal to break up with his childhood friend; he would merely be amused and even pleased!

Why not? Salima Begum will always there to help him out if in case of any problem arising between them!😆

So I do not see any sunset ahead for the two of them, and in any case, all that Jalal says is that she has come at the right time, and how beautiful the sunset is.

Testing the waters:But Jalal is testing the waters with Ruqaiya, for he does not want excessive friction with her as he becomes closer to Jodha, something he intends to achieve, whatever the Amer ki Mirchi might be thinking. The whole spiel about Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se is part of this exercise. And how superbly it is executed!

I know it is not partly, but fully true!

Jalal turns to Ruqaiya and raises his eyes, with visible hesitation, to hers, and then turns away again. The words flow with increasing speed, and devastating candour, after he begins with Hum mohabbat karte hain Jodha Begum se. Here he looks Ruqaiya full in the face. Her eyes are wide with dismay, and Jalal looks away again. Hum aapko yeh baat batane ko majboor nahin hain ( a clear putdown!) lekin sach yahi hai.Pata nahin kaise, ek jadoo sa kar diya hai unhon ne hum par. Unhein dekhte hi dil mein kuch hone lagta hai (a riff, 436 years earlier, on KKHH!). Unhein door jaate dekhte hi, dil isi suraj ki tarah doobne lagta hai. Hum mohabbat karte hain unse, deewaane ban chuke hain unke, ghulam ban chuke hain unke. Ab har din, har pal hum unse aur judte jaa rahe hain, Ruqaiya!

Wow! wow ! wow!

At this point he turns, looks at her face frozen in shock and worse , and begins to laugh. Aaj pehli baar aapke maathe par shikanj dekha hai! Aapko hairaan kar diya hai Ruqaiya!

I wish he said it tongue- in- cheek!😛

Jalal is very convincing at the beginning, and in 2013, I was really foxed and confused, for all that his confession seemed most premature. It was only when he got to unke deewane, unke ghulam, that I knew it was a con, for never would Jalal (at least at this stage!) become any woman's ghulam, not even of the love of his life! But when he turns back after that deliberately exaggerated confession - not fake, be it noted - and sees the frozen shock and despair in Ruqaiya's eyes, Jalal knows that he has gone too far and has to retreat, for he has no notion of wrecking his bond with her. Not for anything, least of all for the uncertain prospects that lie ahead with Jodha.

So he is playing safe!

A more devious explanation: There is another possibility: that Jalal shocks Ruqaiya with Hum mohabbat karte Jodha Begum se quite deliberately, so that in the overwhelming relief when he tells her that he was only joking, she will easily accept that the visit is a purely political exercise.** Personally, I would opt for this, for there is no real reason that I can think of for Jalal to inform Ruqaiya that he has fallen in love with the woman of whom she is acutely jealous!

** How? Will it not give Ruq more reason to suspect that his visit is for Jodha?

Siyaasati wajah: So, he now appeases Ruqaiya by repeatedly laying exclusive emphasis on the siyasati wajah for the Amer trip, embroidering it with the ancillary themes of winning over the Ameri awaam and eliminating any rebellion for keeps, as he moves step by step, adding one relationship after another with erstwhile enemies, towards uniting all of Hindustan under his rule.

This is also really true.

Hum Amer rishtedaari nibhane ke liye nahin ja rahe hain..hum wahan sirf aur sirf siyaasati matlab se jaa rahe hain. . Hum chahte hain ki hamara auda unki nazaron mein aur bhi bad jaye...Humne Amer par fateh ki hai, ab uski riyaya ke dilon par raj karna hai humein. Zindagi bhar baghawat ka khyal nahin aayega unke zehen mein!.. He rounds off this misleading peroration by asserting Hum unke jhuke hue sar dekhna chahte hain!

For us to shrink at this old chestnut of jhukofying the Rajvanshi sars , which is meant only for Ruqaiya's consumption, would be as unwarranted as for us to assume that the entire siyasati rationale is just a smokescreen to hide Jalal's real reason, to get opportunities to spend time in Amer, as up close and personal as can be managed, with Jodha.

We should not forget that Jalal is an emperor, and the expansion and strengthening of his empire would, for him, come first, always and every time, and this no matter what he feels, or does not feel, for Jodha. This is as it should be, for I for one would, in 2013, have hated to see Jalal reduced to a pathetic lover sighing verses to his mistress' eyebrow', as, who else, Shakespeare would put it. Let us not even talk of what happened later!

However, the siyasati reasons are not the whole truth either. Jalal knows his Gatti, and banks on her believing his half truth to be the whole truth, because she believes what she wants to believe.@@

@@ and also she knows him so perfectly, that she wants to believe what he supposedly wants her to believe!

A menage a trois?:When he asks her if she is not coming to Amer with them, he might have assumed, knowing Ruqaiya, that she would refuse. But he could not have been sure, so why does he broach it at all? Methinks it was just more of mischief, for I am sure he does not doubt his ability to juggle both these balls in the air while at Amer and never drop either!😉

Hero Jalal! Balancing the two wives! Just like Lord Krishna!

Jalal-Maham: It is revealing that Jalal does not go to the lengths he goes to with Ruqaiya to persuade Mahaam to accept the Amer trip. For one thing, he knows that if he argues this one out with her, his shrewd Badiammi will start trying to take his siyasati rationale apart, and he does not want to go down that road.

Moreover, emperors do not explain their decisions. So two crisp sentences, ending in Yeh tai hai ki... and it is all wrapped up (it is to be noted that his Ammijaan is not in his list, but I am sure she will add herself!). Again, in the Diwan-e-Khas with Bharmal, he neatly prevents Maham from raising any objections by saddling her with the responsibility for the gifts for the bride.

In all of this, one also sees that while asserting that his decisions are not to be altered, he nonetheless is never abrupt towards or dismissive of Maham. He merely sidesteps her, and is considerate even while being unyielding. He has, beyond any doubt, grown up, has our Jalal.

It is a rule that as one enters, another should exit giving space to the other!

Jalal-Jodha : & 1: The half scene is the exchange of understanding glances between them as Bharmal leaves. Jodha's eyes brim over in gratitude, as Jalal acknowledges it by an almost imperceptible nod (Rajat must be having a micrometer in his head, to be able to achieve such miniscule shifts of position and expression!) that seems to say: Don't worry, it will all be fine. Very nice going, I said to myself, and got ready for a pleasant rubaru between them soon.

Then came the Scene 1, which of course upset all my calculations. For the first 30 seconds, as Jodha neither enquired after Jalal's health, nor sought to apologise for the narnaal fiasco, nor even thanked him for arranging Sukanya's alliance, but launched into a broadside against his taking aapke parivaar ko (in which she obviously does not include herself) to Amer, I was all at sea.

Then I switched to my earlier resolution, abandoned any attempt to understand the discontinuity in Jodha's behaviour, and simply went with the flow. It was a wise choice, for what followed was pure delight.

Oops! I was about to start giving my sermon to you after the previous para, thank God, I proceeded to read the next!

This scene too was amazingly well envisaged and shot, with most of the action being shown in the mirror, an unusual trick that heightened the impact of each frame.

Jalal: Mischief abounding: Rajat's Jalal is here fabulous from start to finish. He never misses an opening to trip up his angry, flustered Jodha Begum. He is brimming over with mischief - it is there in every glance of his, in the teasing tones in his voice, in the mocking lines after he has extracted a reluctant and qualified thank you from her:Aapke is upkaar ke liye hum aabhaar prakat karte hain parantu... .

He he follows that up without missing a beat: Magar kya, Jodha Begum? Bura socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai, achcha socho to bhi aapko gussa aata hai. Yeh hunar aap mein paidayeshi hai, ya baaqaida aapne isme taaleem haasil ki hai?

And much more in the same vein, about a baaghin from whom humein khatra hamesha hai. The flummoxed Jodha exclaims in disbelief Kya??? Whereupon Jalal embroiders further on this enticing theme, about the mortal danger to him from Jodha's assorted deadly weaponry- top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar aapka gussa, shamsheer se tez aapki zubaan, aur katar ki dhar dar aapki nazar, in teenon ka hamla hum par ho gaya to koyi marham humein bacha nahin sakta!

All delivered with the same lightness of touch, the same effortless mastery of flirtatious leg pulling, while his eyes, gleaming with ill-suppressed merriment as they never leave her fuming face, seeking to unsettle her even more.

I loved this scene. Does anyone still have a doubt that Jalal has not started loving his begum?

Jodha: Easy prey: I was sorry to see Jodha play right into his hands, and make a complete, pokered-up, ungracious fool of herself by the time she reacts to his last sally about what all she can do for him in Amer in return for the itna nek kaam he has done for her family.

Hum to soch rahe hain kyon na roz aapke haathon se banaya khana khayein? Waise humein ab teekhe ki aadat ho gayi hai. And as Jodha's eyes narrow in anger, Ab hum par mirchi ka asar nahin hota hai! She responds to this teasing by turning her back on him and stomping off in a huff. She leaves Jalal, predictably, chortling in glee with his companion in the mirror.

Her problem is that she is utterly devoid of a sense of humour. If she had only laughed out loud at his description of her top ke gole ki tarah hamesha phatne ke liye tayyar gussa, shamsheer se tez zubaan, and all the rest, and declared :

Apitu hum to Amer ki beti hain, Shahenshah, Amer ki mirchi jaisi teekhi. Hum jaise bhi hain, aapko to isise santrusht rahan padega! Humein apne aap mein kuch bhi parivartan laaneki koyi bhi ichcha nahin hai. Aap to is janam mein to kya, agle cheh janam ke liye hamare isi kaaya aur isi pravrutti se bandhe rahenge. Kya karenge aap, Shahenshah? ,

Jalal would have been totally stumped, and might have started laughing with her, not at her.

Similarly, if she had thanked him warmly for arranging Sukanya's marriage, and told him how sorry she was about her having put him in such mortal danger without at all meaning to do so, he would have been disarmed.

But no, she has to go wandering into the morass of accusing of having ulterior motives in arranging Sukanya's marriage, which was ungracious, to say the least. From there to insisting that he never does anything without the hope of gaining something else, is but a step, as she plays further into his hands. As a feminist, I felt like shaking some sense into her head. Not that it would have helped!

It suddenly brings to my memory a scene in the film 'Michael Madhana Kama Rajan" where Manorama teaches her daughter, with her beautiful gestures, how to approach the lover( Kamala Hasan) during the song "..Shivaraththiri...thookamedu..hoi..?😆"

So, finally, she stormed off, looking nothing like the baaghin he was comparing her to, and more like an angry kitten frustrated at not having been able to sharpen her claws on her tormentor!😉

In all this relentless, but not malicious teasing, for that is what it was, one revealing point has to be noted.

When Jodha asks, angrily, whether he had no faith in Amer or her Bapusa's ability to ensure his safety, Jalal answers her seriously and reassuringly, stressing his conviction that her brothers would be ready to do anything, including giving up their lives if necessary, to protect him. A girl with a bit more of perceptiveness would have noted the sudden change of tone and of content, from being frivolous towards her to admiration and respect for her family, and reacted accordingly.

We might them have had the first ever civilized conversation between them. Alas, this was was not to be!

Hopes belied: We are , beginning from right now, going to be treated to every corny trick in the panoply of romantic pulp fiction, up to the Ratanpur Qila contretemps, which is when the script starts picking up again. The interim Jalal-Jodha interactions bored me stiff the first time around, and the Govinda style tel maalish sequence had me fuming.

So much for my vain hopes for Jalal and Jodha, of seeing mutual caring and affection develop, slowly but surely. Of an edgy friendship morphing, insensibly, into love, with all its yearnings, its restlessness in the absence of the loved one, the misunderstandings, the jealousies, the protectiveness and the possessiveness, and beneath it all, the undercurrent of a hidden sensuality.

Of a Jodha whose pride in her magnificent husband would make her say, as Cleopatra once said to Julius Caesar : "But for you, the world is full of little men".

What a fall this is going to be, my friends (apologies to Mark Antony)! Anyhow, I am going to number the Jalal-Jodha scenes from now on, and give them a rating of 1 to 10. You, my gentle readers, are more than welcome to give your own ratings in your comments, with reasons for them.

There is only one thing I was looking forward to in 2013, and that was Dadisaa getting to know Jalal. I would bet anything that if she had been 50 years younger, Jalal would have flipped for her without a second thought, instead of this sulky, irascible, pokered-up female he has now landed himself with, complete with her bhashanbaazi and her tantrums😉 .

I can imagine him doing it even now for political reason!!!😆

Kunwar Pratap ki duvidha: I normally do not devote too much space to this gentleman, mainly because Ekta's casting has, for once, gone awry with this Kunwar Pratap. Moreover, most of the lines given to him are pure bombast or ranting against the deshdrohi Bharmal. However, this time, I was so impressed by the lambent wisdom of his guru , as also by Pratap's articulation of his unwavering commitment to the Rajput code of honour, that I am going to spread myself a bit!

Of geedhads and shers: I loved it when Pratap, after listening impassively to a whole line up of his (most unimpressive and dismal looking) advisers push for a sneak attack on Jalal's cortege on the way to Amer, in order to put paid to him easily (being stupid, they assume that he will not have a military escort!), responded with a caustic Theek kah rahe hain! Uttamtam (the Sanskrit superlative) hai, parantu kaayaron ke liye, veeron ke liye nahin! ..Avasar ki prateeksha kaayar karte hain, aur peeche se vaar geedhad. Singh nahin! Singh hamesha saamne se vaar karte hain, garajkar, vijaynaad ke saath!..Is tarah peeche se vaar karna na hi hamara rashtra dharma hai, na hi Rajvanshiyon ki maryada.

This was the clear, uncomplicated code of honour by which this great warrior lived, fought, and died. This, and his fierce determination- his head unbowed and his tenacity a byeword - never to accept the suzerainty of the Mughals. No wonder that his legend endures.

Chanakyan advice : While Pratap oscillates between the conflicting pulls, the duvidha of which to choose between shatruta aur swabhimaan on the one hand, and sambandh and kartavya (of upholding family ties) on the other, his guru is clear-eyed and categoric, insisting that the latter should prevail, and that Pratap should attend the wedding.

But not solely, or even largely for familial reasons. Rather because the Mughal Shahenshah will also be there at Amer. Brushing aside Pratap's distaste for meeting Jalal, the guru sets out the tactical and strategic rationale for what he advises. Yuddh karne se pehle, apne shatru ki shakti, uski neeti, aur uski chaal ka avalokan karna, yehi rajneeti hai. Yeh tumhare liye ek avsar hai, Jalal ko theek se jaan ne ka, uski shakti aur chaal ko samajhne ka. Itihaas wo hi likhta hai, Pratap, jo apne shatru ki shakti ko jaanta ho. Yon samajh lo ki yeh nimantran tumhare liye ek rajnaitik aavashyakta hai. Yeh jan ne ka avasar hai ki kya tumhari talwar ki dhaar itni saksham hai ki wo Jalal ki dhal ko bhed sake?

The great Acharya Chanakya, from nearly 19 centuries back, would have approved wholeheartedly! Whether the results from this sakshatkaar that Pratap's guru had hoped for actually materialized is an open question.

Episodes 85b and 86: A jaundiced view

This one is going to be -now don't start laughing already! - relatively short. It is more of a venting of exasperation than an analysis.

Let me therefore just put it down as a series of questions, and you can then amuse yourselves thinking up the answers. And if any of you is still in a roseate haze induced by the boat ride, please snap out of it!

Q1) It is all very nice to educate the viewers in the complexities of Mughal-Rajput animosities, and I was duly moved by the noble sentiments in the invitation sent by the Rajmata of Amer to Maharani Jaiwantibai of Mewar. But apart from the fact that the Rajvanshis shown confabulating with Kunwar (not Rana) Pratap looked like a bunch of extras from a gangster film togged out in royal attire, there was another major problem with this segment

What about the invitation to Pratap's estranged father, the Maharana of Mewar, Udai Singh? It was to him, as the head of the Sisodias of Mewar, that the invitation would have been addressed, not to Pratap, who was not even the Yuvraj. It would have been unthinkable in terms of royal protocol.

The CVs seem to have forgotten all about Maharana Udai Singh, but when Akbar laid siege to Chttor in 1568, It was still Maharana Udai Singh who was on the throne. He had moved to Udaipur, which he founded as his new capital, and left Jaimal and Patta to defend Chittor. MaharanaUdai Singh also stood firm against the Afghans first and then the Mughals, so this premature emphasis on Kunwar Pratap seems odd, to say the least.

Q2) Why is it that Jodha is not even thinking of throwing out any of the Kabul ke zevarat gifted to Sukanya by Hamida Banu ? Should they not remind her of the Devi Maa's jewellery the Mughal raiders looted from the temple? And it is not even as if this was after Jalal had, at the Kali Maa mandir, fulfilled the sankalp Jodha had taken after that incident. Not only does she not reject the jewellery now, but she does not burn the Dhaka mulmul either, inconsistent wench that she is!😉 In fact, she seems quite in ecstasies over her Ammijaan's largesse for Sukanya, this sammaan for Amer that they would never forget!

Joking apart, of course the context of the two sets of gifts could not be more different. I was decidedly critical of Jodha's immature and thoughtless act in burning the Shahenshah's gift of the shaadi ka joda, which might have seriously endangered Amer. But I also feel that if it had been Hamida Bano who had brought it, instead of the vicious Maham Anga, Jodha might, just might not have burnt it, even if she accepted it only with a sullen face. There seems to be an instant soul connect between Hamida and Jodha, probably dating back to a poorva janma!

Q3) Why is the Shahenshah's chief minister, Atgah Khan, shown to be such an incompetent that, with a large military contingent at hand, he suggests that his emperor go for a boat ride on a lake in hostile territory, a sitting duck for any attacker, without first securing the perimeter of the lake? In his place, having handled such visits as an Ambassador, even if it was not in hostile territory, that is the first thing I would have done.

All these 'Royal' boats do not look royal at all. They look like fishermen's.

Q4) How many times is Jalal to cut his hand - not to speak of worse - in order to promote his shaky romance with the Amer ki Mirchi? At this rate, he will fade away from sheer blood loss 😉 . This is the third time, and it is getting to be so hackneyed. Can't they think of something a bit more intelligent for a change? The script's sole brainwave for promoting the Jalal-Jodha romance seems to be to get him to injure some limb so that Jodha Begum can set to work on it with her patented lep. And how the devil did he cut it this time anyway? His hand was quite saabut when he got into the boat.

Pl. see my Nursery rhyme in your previous thread!

It is a good thing for Jalal that the lake water in which his sulky begum is washing the cut must have been pure in those days. If it was today, he would die of chemical poisoning, possibly from mercury, as in the Minamoto affair in Japan.

Q5) What was it with the pathetic standards of marksmanship among the tribal warriors? Their arrows fell in showers, reminding one of the Yuddha Kanda in the Ramayana, and if they had been even halfway proficient, our nascent lovers should both have been reduced to pincushions. At this rate, the tribals must be starving in the jungle!

Oh dear, I had forgotten the numbering of the Jalal-Jodha scenes. Here goes, then.

Jalal-Jodha 1: Nauka vihar: This began in a promising fashion. I perked up when Jodha Begum was quizzing a daasi about her khema, displaying a sure-footed certainty as to which was the Shahenshah's. (This bit was edited out by Zee Anmol).Apart from this indication of interest in his doings, she had also given up her unseemly habit of haranguing him about a separate khema for herself. Whether it was due to the presence of Hamida Banu is not clear, but Jodha seemed reasonably well-behaved, even summoning up a reluctant smile when her Ammijaan summarily decided that she would go with the Shahenshah on the nauka vihar.

As for Jalal, he was assessing the possibilities as soon as he spotted the Amer ki Mirchi. His eyes, as he looked at her, and then up at the full moon, lit up with nascent mischief. This became even more pronounced as he saw manna descend from Heaven, in the shape of his Ammijaan, who delivered his recalcitrant begum up to him without his having to exert himself in the least! So, when Jodha was trying to catch his eye and nodding her head in the negative, Jalal blandly informed his Ammijaan: Hum bhi Atgah Saheb se yahi kehnewale the!😉

No wonder then that Jodha, forced to trot after her exasperating spouse, muttered audibly about his daft idea of going for a boat ride this late at night. She then responded to his Aapne kuch kaha? , in an irritated tone: Kaha bhi to kya? Apne hat ke aage aapko kisi ki baat sunayi kahan deti hai? Anything more typically biwi-like could not be imagined😉! Or perhaps Asha Parekh in a 1960s Hindi film? So far so good.

From then on, however, things go steadily downhill. Jodha hesitates visibly, in fact for what seemed an age, about letting her husband help her into the small boat. Once in the boat, after grabbing his arm when she loses her balance, she continues with her 1960s film heroine stance. She looks everywhere but at Jalal, while he gazes unblinkingly at her.

When, in an effort to make some conversation, he enquires pleasantly about her liking boat rides, what is it with her reply? Anand milta hai ya dand, yeh kiske saath ho us par nirbhar karta hai! It is insolent and ungracious, and for that one moment, his smile fades. As a follow up, she informs him that the problem with him is that aap baatein nahin, kewal vivaad karna jaante hain!What vivaad there was in his innocuous question I could not make out, not to speak of the fact that Jodha Begum has a PhD in vivaad or behas!

She keeps up this snippishness without a let up. When, after washing the cut in his hand, in slo mo, with the lake water, she sulks and gets up suddenly, if there had been any justice in the world of soaps, she should have fallen into the water and got the dunking of her life! No such luck, alas!😉

This is not how royalty behaves, and that too in front of servants. And there is a lot of space between a goody two shoes, and this humourless, ill-mannered young woman, and this should not be forgotten. It does not have to be one or the other. That Jalal does not seem to mind her ungraciousness, and when he does, he seems to get over it fast, changes nothing in this. I long, simply long for a sensible conversation between the two of them, free of taanas and sallies of the cutting kind, but where is this to be found? Not in this script, that is for sure!

In 2013, at the end of this episode, with the two of them facing a steady shower of arrows from the bank, I was wondering how on earth Jalal was proposing to save our Amer ki Mirchi! At that moment, she seemed to be in front and more exposed, for all his bravado of letting nothing happen to her. The only option would have been for him to dive under the boat with her, and use the inverted boat as a shield.But then her regalia, when wet, would be heavy enough to sink them both!😉

The whole boat ride scene was contrived in the extreme, farce with a capital F. Not that I think anyone cared!

Rating: 4 out of 10, and 2 of those for the pleasing beginning!

Jalal-Jodha 2: Saanjha khema: Now this one was a delight, and this not only because Jalal was in full flow as the Puck of Agra. Jodha too played off him with praise-worthy comic timing.

When Jodha turns up unannounced in Jalal's tent (which is odd, but perhaps the guards assumed that a begum has this privilege!), he usurps her standard opening line: Aap yahan?, and hiding his surprise well, informs her kindly :Zara gaur farmayiye, Jodha Begum! Aap galat kheme mein aa gayi hain!

When Jodha counters this with a poker-faced: Hum bilkul sahi sthan par aaye hain, and announces Wo...h...Aaj raat hum yahin, aapke kheme mein hi rahenge!, Jalal is not about to let any rising tide of gladness, however tentative and hesitant, show on his face. So he gets up from the bed, and takes refuge in an ironic comment: Wallah! Aaj pehli baar kisine Shahenshah ko hukum diya hai!

Her eventual explanation, about her sudden descent on him being due to their Ammijaan's orders, must have brought him down to earth with a thud, but he hides that too well in badinage about offering her the bed while he sleeps on the couch.

Eventually Ammijan will be replaced by Bapusa!

Her predictable refusal of his upkaar, adding, as an afterthought, Waise bhi, is upkaar ke badle mein na jaane kya maang baitein aap humse? does not faze him, for this sort of thing is now old hat for apna Jalal!

So he does not respond in kind. Instead, eyes mock serious, he send up a prayer to the Almighty: Phir saanp bichuon ki jaan par Khuda khair kare! Hum aaj unki jaan nahin bacha paayenge, kyonki hum kisiki jaan bachata bahut thak gaye hain!😉 And he retires to the bed, leaving fully half of it free, undoubtedly anticipating the future developments, and closes his eyes.

What follows is delightfully comic. Jodha, sitting on the couch, mulling over Jalal's sanp bichoowala comment, her eyes scanning the tent with increasing trepidation, is assailed by memories of the Mohini kaand on the road to Ajmer. That does it! She gets up, sidles over to the left side of the bed, seats herself gingerly after moving the coverlet towards Jalal, and looks at him, apparently asleep already, out of the corner of her eyes.

Just when she looks reassured (of what?), Jalal suddenly moves, blows out the only candle in the room, and again closes his eyes. Jodha, startled , exclaims aloud: Inhon ne diya kyon bujha diya?, to Jalal's secret amusement.

She next looks Heavenwards, and sends up a petition : He Ambe Maa! , presumably for divine assistance to keep Jalal on his side of the bed😉. I was wondering why Ambe Maa had been selected this time, and not Jodha's regular Kanha, but this was very likely because Jodha felt that the Goddess would have some extra feminine solidarity with her! 😉Next, a concerned (but not nervous) Inhein kehne ka bhi koyi labh nahin hoga! , before she too settles down for the night. Jalal, watching all this unobserved, must have been chortling inside! Peace then presumably prevails in the Shahi khema for the rest of the night.

The significant point about these goings on is that Jodha now clearly trusts her patidev to keep the line. Which ensures the the stree ke liye laalasa theme has been laid to rest ( not permanently, alas!). This is a baby step forward in her relationship with Jalal, and undoubtedly has a bearing on her agreeing to share his bedroom while at Amer.

As for Jalal, who has surely never before had to woo any woman, especially one who will not even give him the time of the day, such incremental progress must have the charm of novelty!

Rating: 7 out of 10, 2 of which for Jalal's saanp-bichoo crack!

Much of a muchness: Well, we now know that a lot more more of this jejune stuff is going to be unloaded on us in Amer. The sad truth is that after a while, even Jalal's mischievous, dancing eyes begin to pall; one can have too much of a good thing, especially when the object of all his badinage and flirtatiousness continues to look as if she has been attacked by a swarm of bees! It is now the nth time that he is teasing Jodha calling her a baaghin. And being a completely humourless girl, she is unable to think up a single smart retort. Or better still, laugh it off. I have by now grown tired for writing snappy lines for her!😉

Don't mind me, folks, I am already out of sorts after having to watch all this laboured nonsense. Carry on with the joyfest over the Akdha/Parijat prem katha. They should have had Jalal cutting another limb the day after, and Jodha being be stabbed by the assassin the day after that. Phir kya, yeh prem katha toh chalti nahin, daudti!

Jokes of the day: 1) Bharmal, who was not present at the main gate of the Amer fort to greet his javaisa the Shahenshah, leaving Jalal to the care of his sons, while personally escorting Kunwar Pratap, not even the Yuvraj of Mewar, to his rooms, for all the world as if he was his ADC. It was beyond ridiculous.

2)The idea of Maham Anga singing a lori😉. It had me in splits!

Scene of the day: The relentlessly hyped face to face encounter between Jalal and Pratap. It was so stagey and affected, and so obviously meant to impress the viewers, that it was almost amusing. The wooden faced Pratap did not disappoint me, never departing from the flat monotone which characterizes all his utterances. Jalal was of course far more nuanced and subtle, but Rajat had no one and nothing to play off, and there was only so much even he could so with that scene.

Finally, I almost expected a large announcement at the bottom of the frame when they were eyeing each other : YAHAN, SHAHENSHAH JALALUDDIN AUR MAHARANA PRATAP, US SADI KE DO MAHAAN HASTIYON KA AAMNA SAAMNA HUA!😉

Rather like the caption of the frame in the 1982 film, Coolie , when it was released after Amitabh Bachchan's recovery from near death, showing the exact moment when Amitabh took that mistimed, almost fatal punch to his abdomen!

That is it for now, folks. The next time, en avant to the Kali Maa mandir, and the cutting of a Gordian knot!

In toto you have given 11 out of 20 which is 55% ,i.e., High second class!

Shyamala/Aunty/Akka/Di

Sabdabhala thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
DEAR SARASWATHI AUNTY
PLEASE ACCEPT MY WARM WELCOME TO YOU INTO THE" LETS BE TEENAGERS AND ENJOY THE ROMANCE" CLUB. NOT TOO MANY WHO RESPOND TO SHYAMALA AUNTY'S THREAD OPENLY PROPOUND TO THE ROMANCE, LIKE U DO, AND HENCE THE WELCOME

YOUR UNENDING ENTHUSIASM AND EUPHORIA FOR JALAL JODHA LOVE MATCHES MINE AND IS CERTAINLY INFECTIOUS

I LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR CONTINUED ENTHUSIASM ON THE TOPIC. FORTUNATELY FOR US, WE HAVE TIME AND OPPORTUNITY TO DISCUSS THIS AT LENGTH TILL JODHA BEGUM DELIVERS HER INFAMOUS DHAKKA TO JALAL (EPISODE 131 OR SO, I GUESS) , AND THEN AGAIN DURING THE BADAL KAJRI TRACK. SO YAAY TO THAT!!

CHEERS

LAVANYA

P S - YOUR JACK AND JILL AND BABA BLACKSHEEP, BOTH WERE HILARIOUS 😉

P P S - JALAL, WITH HIS TWO WIVES, SEEMS DESPERATELY IN NEED OF LORD KRISHNA'S CLONING AND OTHER CAPABILITIES TO MANAGE HIS 16000 WIVES 😆
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
My dear Saraswathi Akka,

I never knew you were such a closet romantic! No wonder you swallowed the satire in my last post like a kid swallowing cod liver oil with its nose held tight!😉😉

I am delighted that you are happy with my latest, but my poor Akka, while you will have a lot of company in this forum, which is largely made up of starry-eyed Akdha fans, you will not have me. I am not a romantic, and while I favour strong women, being one myself for the most part, I also insist that they be rational, logical and fair. Not the Jodha Begum type at all, with a pronounced sense of entitlement which is only worsened by the likes of Hamida Bano, and next to no sense of her responsibilities towards her husband. Why even my dear Vicki, who loved Jodha to bits, said exactly that in her post about Jodha's suicide attempt, and I had quoted her in my corresponding post now.

I have nothing to add to your happy comments, except about 2 points. Firstly, I really cannot understand why you would have felt impelled to read me a nice little corrective bhashan for the following😉:

Then came the Scene 1, which of course upset all my calculations. For the first 30 seconds, as Jodha neither enquired after Jalal's health, nor sought to apologise for the narnaal fiasco, nor even thanked him for arranging Sukanya's alliance, but launched into a broadside against his taking aapke parivaar ko (in which she obviously does not include herself) to Amer, I was all at sea.

Would it not have bothered you that Jodha did none of the things she should have done in her first meeting with Jalal after he recovered? It did bother me, for I would have liked to think well of her. But I have come to believe that she is like a countryside bullock car stuck in a deep rut in the mud,and she cannot get out of it even should she want to!😉

Secondly, your question in A more devious explanation section.

A more devious explanation: There is another possibility: that Jalal shocks Ruqaiya with Hum mohabbat karte Jodha Begum se quite deliberately, so that in the overwhelming relief when he tells her that he was only joking, she will easily accept that the visit is a purely political exercise.** Personally, I would opt for this, for there is no real reason that I can think of for Jalal to inform Ruqaiya that he has fallen in love with the woman of whom she is acutely jealous!

** How? Will it not give Ruq more reason to suspect that his visit is for Jodha?

See, Akka, if Ruqaiya is first given this huge shock of being told that Jalal is desperately in love with Jodha, and is then told that it was all a joke, the relief she will feel will be overwhelming. In that state of mind, she will accept the political explanation immediately, for she will, after the earlier jhatka, be no longer inclined to question any alternative explanation. There is no longer any reason for her to suspect that there is a Jodha factor involved here.

Jalal does not try the political explanation on Maham, for it has many holes and she will take it apart. So there, he simply issues a fiat.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: karkuzhali


Dear Shyamala,
I am seeing a very pleasing, witty,balanced, harmless(?) and friendly Shyamala of my ilk here.👏 If I were asked to assess your review I would give you 10/10. I even gave a thorough second reading but found nothing to bring your top score down! Good Lord, do you rate me by the amount of romantic stuff I dish out? I am of course always the same Shyamala, only the material I handle changes. But I can see that I will not get even passing marks from you half the time!😉
Today I wanted to assume myself as a teenager in the process of reviewing your thread. Of course! What a delightful idea!
My comments are as usual in red.

Saraswathi.

Edited by sashashyam - 9 years ago
adiana12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Dear Shyamala, I was reading this book 'Marvels and Mysteries of the Mahabharata' by Abhijit Basu. There is a specific speech by General MacArthur that the author quotes while presenting Krshna's methods in the context of the war. The speech is the celebrated 1951 farewell speech by the General to the US congress - "But once war is forced upon us, there is no other alternative than to apply every available means to bring it to a swift end. War's very object is victory, not prolonged indecision. In war there is no substitute for victory." It seems to me Akbar too believed this maxim and as I am reading this book I keep reflecting on Akbar as well.
Edited by adiana12 - 9 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Yes, Saraswathi Akka to kamaal ki cheez hai!😉 I want to see how she rates my Sunlight on a butterfly's wings post, the only start to finish romantic post I wrote here. She will give me 12/10!!

And Lavanya, I think Lord Krishna had a few more wives, I understand the total was 16.009!

Shyamala Aunty


Originally posted by: Sabdabhala

DEAR SARASWATHI AUNTY

PLEASE ACCEPT MY WARM WELCOME TO YOU INTO THE" LETS BE TEENAGERS AND ENJOY THE ROMANCE" CLUB. NOT TOO MANY WHO RESPOND TO SHYAMALA AUNTY'S THREAD OPENLY PROPOUND TO THE ROMANCE, LIKE U DO, AND HENCE THE WELCOME

YOUR UNENDING ENTHUSIASM AND EUPHORIA FOR JALAL JODHA LOVE MATCHES MINE AND IS CERTAINLY INFECTIOUS

I LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR CONTINUED ENTHUSIASM ON THE TOPIC. FORTUNATELY FOR US, WE HAVE TIME AND OPPORTUNITY TO DISCUSS THIS AT LENGTH TILL JODHA BEGUM DELIVERS HER INFAMOUS DHAKKA TO JALAL (EPISODE 131 OR SO, I GUESS) , AND THEN AGAIN DURING THE BADAL KAJRI TRACK. SO YAAY TO THAT!!

CHEERS

LAVANYA

P S - YOUR JACK AND JILL AND BABA BLACKSHEEP, BOTH WERE HILARIOUS 😉

P P S - JALAL, WITH HIS TWO WIVES, SEEMS DESPERATELY IN NEED OF LORD KRISHNA'S CLONING AND OTHER CAPABILITIES TO MANAGE HIS 16000 WIVES 😆

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
That is very true, my dear Adiana. Dithering in war only causes even more damage and lasting suffering on both sides. And cutting a few corners for victory is entirely laazmi.

But it is interesting that the author cites MacArthur in a book on the Mahabharata. Usually,it is the Mahabharata that is cited in books on war.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: adiana12

Dear Shyamala, I was reading this book 'Marvels and Mysteries of the Mahabharata' by Abhijit Basu. There is a specific speech by General MacArthur that the author quotes while presenting Krshna's methods in the context of the ear. The speech is the celebrated 1951 farewell speech by the General to the US congress - "But once war is forced upon us, there is no other alternative than to apply every available means to bring it to a swift end. War's very object is victory, not prolonged indecision. In war there is no substitute for victory." It seems to me Akbar too believed this maxim and as I am reading this book I keep reflecting on Akbar as well.

karkuzhali thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Thank you dear Lavanya,
I bow to you for welcoming me to the LBTAETR Club.
I am also a regular reader of your posts, which you do with substance.
It is nice to have so many friends as"likers" (I don't know why the computer marks this word incorrect)!
Thank you again,

Yours
Saraswathi aunty.

(member) LBTAETR Club.



Originally posted by: Sabdabhala

DEAR SARASWATHI AUNTY

PLEASE ACCEPT MY WARM WELCOME TO YOU INTO THE" LETS BE TEENAGERS AND ENJOY THE ROMANCE" CLUB. NOT TOO MANY WHO RESPOND TO SHYAMALA AUNTY'S THREAD OPENLY PROPOUND TO THE ROMANCE, LIKE U DO, AND HENCE THE WELCOME

YOUR UNENDING ENTHUSIASM AND EUPHORIA FOR JALAL JODHA LOVE MATCHES MINE AND IS CERTAINLY INFECTIOUS

I LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR CONTINUED ENTHUSIASM ON THE TOPIC. FORTUNATELY FOR US, WE HAVE TIME AND OPPORTUNITY TO DISCUSS THIS AT LENGTH TILL JODHA BEGUM DELIVERS HER INFAMOUS DHAKKA TO JALAL (EPISODE 131 OR SO, I GUESS) , AND THEN AGAIN DURING THE BADAL KAJRI TRACK. SO YAAY TO THAT!!

CHEERS

LAVANYA

P S - YOUR JACK AND JILL AND BABA BLACKSHEEP, BOTH WERE HILARIOUS 😉

P P S - JALAL, WITH HIS TWO WIVES, SEEMS DESPERATELY IN NEED OF LORD KRISHNA'S CLONING AND OTHER CAPABILITIES TO MANAGE HIS 16000 WIVES 😆

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".