Jodha Akbar 52-54: A new hope

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Folks,

My title for this triad really comes from the third and best episode, but alas, it was an evanescent hope. We all know that it will be drowned and destroyed in the tsunami of bitter grief and unthinking rage that consumed Jalal when the child he was expecting with such joy proved to be a mirage. But I decided to stay with the title regardless, for if one could try and blot out what is to come, one would be fully justified, Saturday night, at feeling a sense of happy anticipation about the Jalal-Jodha relationship.

Let us start with Episode 52.

Episode 52: A clearing of the air

There was a lot of this around in this episode, was there not? Rather like a giant exhaust fan in operation, sucking up the cobwebs of misunderstanding/ misconception on several issues, of the kind that are the daal roti of TV serials, and which festoon every one of them from the beginning to within 3 episodes short of the end. I was quite amazed, and this reinforced my conviction that, the sudden downward plunge in Ruqaiya's character notwithstanding, Ekta's writing team for Jodha Akbar was not, at least till this point, from the usual soap factory lot.

Let me just list the highlights, and let us dispose of the unpleasant bit first.

Chinti ke par nikal aaye: Sharifuddin's natural cunning and instinct of self-preservation kick in almost as soon as he has finished slapping Bakshi Banu (to take out his ire at Jalal having ordered him to give back the exactions he had made from Bharmal). Aided by his foolishly gentle wife ( she is of the kind that breeds wife-beaters) , he extricates himself from a potentially deadly faux pas.

Then he proceeds, in the time honoured manner of old fashioned screen villains, to proclaim (for our benefit), to the accompaniment of a loud stagey guffaw, that he actually has ambitions to rule the Mughal empire.

It seems that no one was listening in, which seems impossible in the Agra palace, but as Sharifuddin's head will be still on his shoulders for a while yet, one presumes that all the chartered eavesdroppers must have had a day off then😉 .

If Sharifuddin had had a mother like Mahaam Anga, he would have received 3 ringing slaps, but his mother had probably kicked the bucket soon after finding out that she had produced such an offspring😉, so he escapes that salutary lesson for excessive ambition. His eventual fate is likely to be the same as the aforesaid chinti.

Sharp eyes: That Jodha is excellent at spotting what others seek to hide was already evident at the Amer jail, when she recognized Jalal from just a wavy image sighted in the water, that too an inverted one. Now she proves it again by spotting the dark mark of fingers on Bakshi Banu's cheek, but she also proves her sense of diplomacy by covering up the bruise, and her knowledge of it as well.

A gentle mind and a generous heart: That is Salima Begum. She is wonderful in her scene with Jodha, and not just because she clears away so many of Jodha's misunderstandings and fills in so many gaps in her knowledge of the various dramatis personae in her new world: about Rahim's real parents, about her own happy life with Bairam Khan, about Jalal and Bairam Khan, about Jalal and Rahim, about Ruqaiya and Jalal.

Most important of all for Jodha and Jalal is her clarification about what happened to the parents of that little Hindu boy, who were initially sentenced to prison at the Diwan-e-Aam. (The CVs slipped up there; they should have inserted a flashback of Jalal gripping Jodha's arm hard and hissing Adhuri jaankari ek gunaah hoti hai, Jodha!).

It was ill-considered, and hardly tactful of Jodha to voice such sharp disapproval of the Shahenshah - beginning with Vishwas nahin hota ki Shahenshah ke man mein bhi komalta bhi hai! , then citing the example of the little Hindu boy, and ending up by nearly spitting out the words aur yahan pitrutva vyavahar! - to another begum on his, that too one she hardly knows.

But Salima takes it in her stride and goes on to add a very pertinent and educative comment: Kabhi kabhi unhein kadhe kadam uthane padte hain, lekin Shahenshah ke man mein bhi ek mohabbat ka sauta (?) behta hai jo humne mehsoos kiya hai, Rahim ko lekar.

The real importance of Salima's role in this segment lies more in the deep and compassionate insights she provides the normally impatient and judgemental Jodha, not just about Jalal's hidden qualities and about the compulsions of imperial rule, but even about Ruqaiya's hidden hurts and what lies beneath her aggressive possessiveness towards Jalal.

The lovely little scene earlier, between Jalal, Ruqaiya, Salima and Rahim, illustrates and emphasizes all that Salima has to say here. It is also an upgrading of Ruqaiya (for want of a better term) by making her more human and more vulnerable, both in her open, unalloyed affection for Rahim and in her desperate longing for a child of her own, and thus less of the plastic harem superintendent she had been presented as for these last few weeks. It was most refreshing, and it made me realise once more how much I was missing the old Ruqaiya. Regrettably, it proved to be an one-shot exercise!

To revert, when Salima says that what matters is not how long one lives, but how one lives, and with whom, the wisdom of the ages speaks thru her to Jodha.

Jodha herself seems to have arrived at some measure of wisdom and acceptance when she tells Bakshi Banu earlier that time heals all wounds: I wondered then if she was referring to Suryabhan's death. After the conversation with Salima, her mind must be more open, and more at rest, than it has ever been since the battle for Amer.

The quality of caring: With apologies to Shakespeare. Like Portia's quality of mercy in The Merchant of Venice, the quality of caring in Jodha is also twice blessed: it blesses her that gives and also the one who takes.

Jalal wonders earlier what more there might be for him to discover about Jodha. He gets a large dollop of it here, served up front and centre, with the natural self-assertion of a wife who insists on setting her laggard spouse right where she believes that he has fallen short. A most novel experience for both Jalal and the Shahenshah! But of that a little later.

The earlier part of the scene with Jodha, Hamida Banu and Sheikh Salim Chisti is charming, both in the affectionate respect that marks Jodha's behavior towards her Ammijaan, and in her calm demeanour when she receives the holy man's blessings on her marriage with Jalal. When he prophesies that this will herald a new bright era for the Mughal empire, maybe her thoughts go back to what her mother told her, before the wedding, about bhagya choosing its own yoddha.

New sensations: Even when the Sheikh goes on to proclaim that this union would soon produce an heir for the empire, she does not flinch. It is worth noting that at this point, Jalal, who is of course constantly stealing sidelong glances at Jodha, does not look either smug or triumphant. On the contrary, he looks very serious and even a tad troubled, as if he were wondering how on earth any such near miracle was to be pulled off when his wife cannot even stand his touch.

The touch part takes a baby step forward when Jodha, after some initial hesitation, lets Jalal help her off the podium. The look he gives her afterwards is neither amused nor one of arrogant self-satisfaction. It is one of pure pleasure and happy possessiveness, and when she looks up and catches it, there is no distaste or pulling back in her eyes. There is something quite different in them, and that relates to Hamida Banu's sudden mannat to walk to Ajmer and back to ensure that the Jalal-Jodha baby does make its appearance as the heir to the Mughal empire.

To go back a bit, when Jodha immediately endorses his protest against this alarming proclamation - Shahenshah bilkul sahi keh rahe hain, Ammijaan!- Jalal does an imperceptible double take. It was not clear whether it was because he heard Jodha calling his mother Ammijaan- with all that implies, not just for her relationship with Hamida Banu but also in terms of Jodha's desire to adopt Mughal tehzeeb - or because her ready support for him astonishes him😉.

Thereafter, once he gives up, with a weak smile, one sees Jodha darting some fairly irritated glances at him when they are still seated on the podium. It seems clear that if they had been on even slightly better terms, she would have nudged him sharply and hissed instructions into his ear 😉that he should react more strongly and decisively to halt this dangerous mannat .

It is also to be noted that when Jalal, who spends a much longer moment looking down at his wife than taking leave of the rest, finally departs, he nods farewell to Jodha, and her eyes follow his retreating figure - both firsts of their kind!

An aggressive biwi: This is one delightful scene - the Shahenshah being hauled over the coals relentlessly by his hitherto distant wife for having, of all things, failed to prevent his mother from undertaking a hazardous pilgrimage.

When Jodha lands up at Jalal's suite, he must have wondered what was in the offing, though he maintains a poker face. This is accentuated when she begins by apologizing: Sabse pehle is samay for disturbing him: he was surely wondering Ab isko kya ho gaya hai, ki hamare saath itni tameez se pesh aa rahi hai? 😉

But she is dead set on her worries, and does not bother about his expression or even pause as she launches into her arguments. The beautiful face is creased with genuine fear and concern for her Ammijaan as she ticks Jalal off in no uncertain terms for not having been forceful enough in stopping his mother: Yadi aap samajhte hain to aapko phir se samajhane ki aavashyakta kyon padti hai?

Dismissing Jalal's narrow-eyed retort : Par humne unhein mana kiya tha na? - she steams ahead: Aapki na mein wo bal nahin tha jo unke pran mein tha..Ek bar apni baat par bal dekar samajhane ka prayas kyon nahin kiya aapne?

He is bemused, and even as he lodges a proforma protest about his being lectured to about how he should handle his mother, one can see that he is both touched and impressed by the quality of caring that is so evident in her. As for her, for once her retort is not acerbic, but rational and telling.

Har prashna ka uttar prashna nahin hota, Shahenshah, kabhi uttar bhi dena padta hain! Batayiye, kaise manayenge aap Ammijaan ko ki wo apna hat tyaag dein?

What follows is, at one level, a triumph of quick thinking by Jalal, who is undoubtedly used to exploiting every opening he can get in battle, and this is, after all, also a battle of a kind. The stroke of pure genius lay, however, in his remembering the way in which Jodha had given a kasam to Motibai in the Diwan-e-Khas, and immediately adapting it to his own benefit! Poor Jodha is, by episode end, boxed in by the kasam on her patidev's head on the one hand, and her fears for the mother-in-law she has come to love on the other. No wonder that she makes anguished attempts to read his eyes!

Two caveats :One, this is a totally implausible idea of Jalal's, and worse, it will definitely not answer his and Jodha's immediate purpose. For whatever the degree of sudden closeness Jalal and Jodha now set out to exhibit to the rest of their world, they can hardly announce that Jodha is in the family way for at least 6-8 weeks. How do they make sure that Hamida Banu does not set out for Ajmer Sharif by then?

Two, I am a great admirer of Rajat and his mastery of facial nuance. He scores very high grades in that department 99 times out of 100. But here, as he was making an overly eager sales pitch to Jodha about the naatak that he was proposing, it was the 100th. His eyes gleamed too much, and the whole expression was too forced. The director should have spotted it and got him to tone it down in a (rare) retake; it would have made that part of the scene a lot better.

Paridhi, on the other hand, her anguished eyes, filmed over with unexplained tears, desperately looking into his and searching for reassurance (probably that this would remain a naatak), was pitch perfect.

And so on to Episode 53.

Episode 53: Anticlimax

Well, well, good old Isaac Newton, and his law of gravity, which ordains that whatever goes up has to come down, prevailed, and Episode 53 turned out to be mostly a dud. Not even the materialization of the precap of the previous day could save it from being an irritating hotch potch, with only a couple of bits to salvage it to some extent.

Let us take the best bit first.

The cultural gap: the Aarti: I know that 90% of you would not have looked beyond those 3 minutes 10 seconds, and could not care less what was there, or not there, in the other 17 minutes 31 seconds . I loved it too: it was so sensuous and delicate, so mischievous, so graceful and tantalizing. At least Jalal made it so, with some little help from Jodha.

But the best bit about her was an inescapable inference can be drawn from her behaviour, and it is this.

A devious wench!: Why does Jodha ( now totally at home in her harem rooms, with a lush tulsi plant in a proper tulsi mandap to boot), want to give Jalal the aarti at all? She has just asserted to her Kanha (by now surely equipped with a pair of good earplugs ) that she has itni ghrina for Jalal, and she rages Hat ki bhi koyi seema hoti hai (about his idea of the naatak). When she finishes giving the aarti to her maids, Jalal is a good distance away and he is engaged in working out with weights. He is not, bar an initial glance, looking at her. Why does she not quietly take the aarti thali and go back to her suite?

But that is what she does not do. Instead, muttering under her breath Man to nahin karta inke saamne jaane ka, she then proceeds to do precisely that, rationalizing her action to herself : Parantu bhagwan ki aarti hai; chalo de hi deti hoon! She goes right up to him, waits till he turns around - and he is still sulking about her refusal of the day before (wrt his wacky plan for a virtual waaris), so he takes his time about this - and proffers the thali, gesturing mutely to him with her eyes.

I do not know what you folks feel about it., but if I had as much ghrina towards anyone as Jodha professes to feel for Jalal, I would stay a good 500 yards away from him whenever possible!

A little later, when she is muttering to herself Talwar chalane aur dand dene ke atirikt kuch nahi aata inhein!, her eyes belie her words, for they show an indulgent amusement that is a first for her. Not just that, Jodha makes no move to pull her hand away when Jalal grasps it, as she did even with Suryabhan, and she must have caught a glimpse of his melting look as well as he was taking the aarti, for he never moved his gaze from her face. She is one devious wench, folks, is apni Jodha, make no mistake!😉😉

The Barfi act: To go back a bit, Jodha's actions with the aarti ki thali resemble nothing so much as a tubelight that has a faulty choke😉. Instead of explaining the aarti procedure to Jalal at once, she goes thru a number of false starts before hitting on Hum batate hain!

First Jalal, who obviously has an excellent memory for detail, goes by what Mynavati did while welcoming her javaisa, and does his best to cope with the cultural gap, lowering his forehead for the tilak. Why the two of them then have to do a Barfi act - with Jodha wondering Yeh sar kyon jhuka liya inhone?, and Jalal thinking to himself Humne sar bhi jhuka liya hai to phir yeh tilak kyon nahin kar rahi hai? - and cannot speak up is incomprehensible.

The next bit, with Jodha's Tilak ki thali nahin, aarti lene ki thali hai, which naturally results in Jalal grabbing the thali, is clearly supposed to be funny.

Mischief abounding: Jodha is so busy patronizing Jalal mentally for not knowing how to accept the aarti (though how she expects him to know that is a mystery), that she does not cotton on to the fact that he singes his right hand quite deliberately over the flame. He knows that she will then do it for him and raise her hand, which he can then promptly grasp in his. In fact his eyes begin to crinkle in pure mischief as soon as she says Aapse nahin hoga!, and proceeds to do it for him.

What follows is a superb display of delicate flirting a la Jalal. His eyes, lambent with a hidden emotion, tender and teasing at once, never leave her face, while she keeps hers lowered till almost the very end. His hand slides down, never letting go of hers, till he shifts it to cup the flame.

He then cheekily makes it clear, by taking the aarti in due and proper form, that he was fooling her all along. It was exactly like the fake hand injury trick on the road to Agra, only it is gentler and free of any intent to ridicule.

It is only at the end,when he has finished with the aarti, that she raises her eyes, grave and questioning, and more than a little shy, to his. What they might have said to each other remains unknown, for the messenger from Ruqaiya comes up just then, and the unsure and embarrassed Jodha seizes the opening and makes good her escape. (I bet the CVs did not know what to write in here for them, and took the easy way out!😉)

This apart, the whole conception of the scene, especially Jodha's script, was illogical and faulty. Here she is, offering the aarti to her Muslim husband, who naturally has no idea what he is supposed to do with it. The scene was apparently played for laughs, but in the process, the opportunity for a charming and gentle reaching out to each other was lost.

Nonetheless, the execution, mostly from Jalal's side, with those Rudolf Valentino eyes, was so impeccable that by the end, as he rubs his sooty and slightly singed right hand thru his hair, eyes crinkled in his private thoughts and a slight smile twisting his mouth, even I did not mind that this scene shortchanged the viewers.

NB: There is a continuity lapse wrt Jalal's singed hand, for the extent of blackening on it varies widely during the aarti taking bit!

Now for the fatiguing bits.-

Retro mode for Jodha: There is Jodha who, having turned down both the kasam on her patidev's head, and his nutty plan to announce what would nowadays be called a virtual heir to the Mughal empire, is now going into retro mode.

She is now again seen sulking in front of her long-suffering Kanha, making faces at the prospect of letting that ghrina ka paatra character anywhere near her. If she does not beware, she will wake up one day to find that not just the bansuri, but the whole moorti has vanished, thanks to Kanha's kaan having been pakaofied to excess by her eternal complaints about Jalal, and his having decided to go back to Brindavan to escape this daily torture 😉😉 .

The soon-not-to-be waaris: There is Ruqaiya, back in the vamp mode after raising our hopes about her becoming almost human, only to dash them the very next day. She first laughs like a hyena about the Jodha-Jalal prophecy. Next, once she learns that she is expecting, she makes it abundantly clear that she is not interested in the joys of motherhood, but only in becoming the Mariam-uz-Zamani by producing the heir to the Mughal sultanate. One shudders to think of how she would behave if the baby were to turn out to be a daughter. Farm her out to the highest bidder from the harem , very likely, poor mite!😡

In this context, I was standing up and clapping for Jalal when he declares Humein yakeen hai ki tum humein waaris dogi, lekin Khuda ne humein ladki bhi di to hum us shehzadi to Khuda ki nimat samajhenge, use naaz-o-nashan (?) se paalenge! It was wonderful to see an emperor, on pins for a male heir, nonetheless ready to love a daughter every bit as much as a son.

The Enlightened Sixteenth Century Man Award (actually, it could apply to the 21st century as well!) is hereby conferred on Shahenshah Jalaluddin Mohammed!👏👏👏

Rajat was extremely convincing as the expectant father, wonder and delight pouring out of him as his voice catches in his throat in his breathless eagerness. His bubbling joy as he issues instructions for the glad event to be celebrated all over the empire might seem excessive, and more important, premature, but the very excess shows how much this child of his means to him.

It is thus a given that he would promise Ruqaiya a gift of her choice, which she salts away, like a chipmunk ( her two centre front teeth do make look a bit like one, come to think of it!), for after the arrival of the anticipated heir.

I wondered why she did not grab something while the going was good, but the real reason comes out soon enough. She wants to oust Mahaam Anga from the position and the powers of the Wazir-e-Aaliya,and take her place.

Since doors, windows and, in a historical serial, huge billowing curtains, exist for the sole purpose of facilitating the work of eavesdroppers😉 , the news of Begum Ruqaiya's ambitions reaches Mahaam Anga's ears almost as soon as her words have been uttered.

With that, the fate of the poor little baby is sealed. Maham Anga will ensure, by means subtle, effective, and undetectable, that it never sees the light of day. Jalal will be devastated, for it is he who loves his unborn child with all his heart, and yearns to lavish all his pent up affection on it.

And Jodha will also soon see at first hand, to terrible effect, what bitter grief can do even to an emperor. And so on to Episode 54.

Episode 54: A new hope

The New Hope of my title is of course that of the first Star Wars film, but it also perfectly sums up what I felt, once again after 2 years, at 9:00 pm Saturday night. The beautiful, imaginative script, and the pitch perfect performances by our duo, seemed to open the door on a new vista. A vista of a new beginning, a beginning of a sincere understanding of each other. An understanding based not on attraction on one side or the end of repulsion on the other, but on mutual, warm appreciation of each other's qualities of head and heart. For that moment, the fact that this hope was to be so short-lived made no difference.

Jodha:transparent goodness: This episode belonged to Jodha, and Paridhi sailed thru the whole effortlessly, projecting the simple, transparent, unclouded goodness of Jodha's whole persona with total conviction.

The unruffled dignity and nobility with which she answers Ruqaiya's wild accusations (which only revealed the depth of the latter's by now endemic insecurity vis a a vis this polar opposite of a woman, whom she cannot understand and thus hates).

The warm gratitude with which she responds to the outpouring of love and admiration from her Ammijaan -Khuda ki or se sultanat ke liye tohfa ho tum, Jodha! - touching her feet repeatedly in respect and affection.

The genuine detachment and goodness of heart with which she silences the complaints of Motibai.

And finally, the eager warmth and sincerity in her eyes, and her whole face, as she explains to the Shahenshah the import of her gift and her poem of welcome for the new arrival.

Not one line, not one expression, however fleeting, was out of place, not one was either over the top in cloying mahaanta or found wanting in sincerity. It was a visually and tonally perfect performance which gladdened by my heart, for though I am no sentimentalist, and have by now, with age and experience, become more of a cynic than anything else, genuine goodness always moves me.

Subtle regret?: But the most arresting bit in the whole was not in any of the above-mentioned scenes. It came when Jodha is leaving Hamida Banu's rooms, after the latter voices the hope that Jodha too would soon give her the same happiness that Ruqaiya was now about to do. Jodha's smiling face becomes serious, and she tries to smile, the right side of her mouth lifting in a forced attempt at cheerfulness.

As she comes out of the room, the flames from a nearby mashaal shade her face, which appears and disappears as they waver in the breeze. Her eyes seem desolate, clouded with a sense of despair. What is it that she feels? She believes what she says earlier to Ruqaiya, that a woman, no matter how highly placed, is truly fulfilled only in motherhood. Is the sudden sorrow reflected in her eyes because she sees this longed for motherhood, as she sees it, forever outside her grasp? I felt so.

NB: To see this exquisite little bit, you will have to watch the original online. Zee Anmol edited it out to save their regulation 1 minute.😡

Jalal:a soul connect: He too was a revelation. I have often written that what Jalal feels for Jodha is neither a pedestrian attraction rooted in admiration of her beauty, nor physical desire, nor even the pull of the unusual in the first woman who, far from running after him like all the others, does not even want him. It was always something more, a desire of the heart that he could not understand when it dragged him on that dangerous adventure to Amer just to catch a glimpse of her.

It was the same with Jodha. The face in the water that haunts her conscious and her subconscious, the face she sees even with her eyes closed. Now that she knows whose face it was, she has buried it deep inside her, under layers of stubborn, and by now irrational ghrina. A ghrina that she repeats to herself every now and then as if she might otherwise forget it!

But it is there, nonetheless, and as she watches Jalal leave her rooms, it is reflected once more in the curiously gentle expression in her eyes. A look of tentative hope, which seeks more of it knows not what.

Humein choo gaya: When the lines of Jodha's poem haunt Jalal's sleep and echo and re-echo in his zehen, the underlying note, for all that he remembers the beauty of the Amer ki shehzadi seen up close, is one of gratitude, of a sudden emotional connect. He understands instinctively that her joy at the prospect of the child is both deep and genuine, and it is this generous and caring spirit that touches him as perhaps nothing else so far in his life.

Har bar kuch naya kar jati ho, Amer ki shehzadi! Hum tumhare bare mein sochna nahin chahte. Lekin, phir bhi, humein sochne par majboor kar deti ho. Tum hamari khushi jataane nahin aayi, par hamare bachche ki khushi jataane tumhara aana humein choo gaya!

Rajat brings what Jalal is feeling on to the screen flawlessly, especially the dreamy sense of this new emotional bond with the Amer ki shehzadi.

(NB: It is this conviction of Jalal's that will, at least initially, negate the stratagem of Mahaam Anga, with her talent for killing several birds with a single stone, eventually makes to blame Jodha for the loss of Ruqaiya's child).

It is this same gratitude that lights up Jalal's whole face when, after seeking the explanation for the kin beharateen labzon mein aapne hamare aanewale waaris ki taareef ke hai, and having listened, with unwinking concentration, to Jodha's enthusiastic explanation of the significance of the spoon and the meaning of her poem, he praises her words for having embellished and enriched her gift.

Maashallah, kya soch hai! Aapke labzon ne aapke tohfe ko beshkeemati bana diya hai!

For the first time, he smiles at her with a warmth that is untinged with even a hint of the usual mockery or one-upmanship, or even his trademark mischievous flirtatiousness. It is a smile of empathy, of understanding, of a liking that is direct, candid and genuine. Something that he has perhaps never before felt for a woman.

The same empathy, of recognition of what he feels, and of a reluctant liking, are reflected in Jodha's eyes as she watches him leave.

It is in this quantum shift on both sides that the new hope of my title - alas to be as evanescent as the morning mists- is rooted.

Ruqaiya: purblind folly: Earlier, the scene in Ruqaiya's rooms, as Jalal opens Jodha's gift, brings out with blinding clarity the basic difference between the two bachpan ke dost.

Jalal instantly sums up what lies behind Jodha's lovely poem to the child he awaits: Lagta hai ki dil se likha hai. But it needs a dil, and a sensitive and perceptive one, to recognize what another such dil feels. The look on his face as he says this is a delight for the viewer: Rajat brings out perfectly the sense of pure joy that Jalal feels at this moment.

Ruqaiya, on the other hand, is unseeing in her total self-centredness and foolish vanity. Her comments about Jodha's supposed chaaploosi, and her apparently trying to cultivate Ruqaiya's favour, are incredible in their blind folly. I do not suppose that Jalal, still lost in the aural beauty of the poem, even hears what she says, which is probably just as well for her!

Choice snippets: The little exchange between Jalal and Jodha, about her oblique manner of getting him to leave, was delightful in itself, but even more so for the new sense of camaraderie in her retort and his comeback.

-Utsav ke liye humein tayyar hone hai, Shahenshah! Samay kam hai.

-Yeh andaaz bhi achcha hai! This with a tilt of his head and an amused half smile.

-Ab humne kya kaha? Jodha, opening her eyes wide in mock puzzlement.

-Aapne bina kahe hi humein yahan se jaane le liye keh diya!Which is no more than the truth, and this is said with a smile, to rob the words of any negativity.

- Kisi ki shabdon ko man mein rakhkar, samay padte hi uttar dena aapki aadat hai! What does she know of his aadatein? Next to nothing, and then again, her retort is not strong on logic. But that is not the point. The point in that she feels comfortable enough with him now to make a sally about his habits!

- Aur aap ki aadat bhi kamaal hai! Jodha opens her eyes wide and looks at him suspiciously. Tohfa bhi deti hain, Kafin (?) bhi deti hain! And then, even as he claps his hands and the daasis have reappeared, Jalal is still holding Jodha's eyes with his own for a moment before he turns to then and announces their gifts.

At long last, they seem to be on the way to becoming friends, and there is no stronger foundation for eventual love than friendship.

- Jalal's phenomenal memory for the spoken word. He is able to recite the whole poem (see text below), most of the words in which he cannot understand, faultlessly (except for Yahi vardaan right at the end) after just one hearing, which shows how keen is his faculty for Shruti . No wonder Akbar always had something significant read out to him daily before he retired for the night. It must all have imprinted itself in his memory, word perfect and docketed away for future reference.

Ek nanha-munha lal dega sabke hoton pe muskan,

Is kilkari gunjan ke liye Ishwar shat shat tumhe pranam

Tum pe barse amrit banke jeevan ka har kshan, har pal

Surya chandrama mathe chamke, naina bane kamal,

Tum par nyochavar ho jag sara

Gun gaye har disha tumhara.

Ujjwal bhavishya kare bhagay pradhan.

Jodha mange yeh vardaan.

-The sudden sense of deprivation on Jalal's face when Ruqaiya, with unthinking casualness, asks him to read Jodha's poem. That he cannot read and write is a lifelong and bitter regret for Jalal; remember his rooh describing himself, even centuries later while speaking to Jodha's rooh, as an anpadh jaahil? That Ruqaiya rubs this wound raw, and does not even realise it, is typical of her.

-Jalal's curious expression when Maham Anga asks him whether he agrees with his Ammijaan's paean to Jodha. It is not resentment or even mild jealousy, but rather a bemused, and amused, acceptance. As for his Badiammi, one can practically see smoke coming out of her ears😉 at this highly unwelcome praise of her bete noire, the Hindu begum!

-One feels for Maham Anga in the precap, faced with an obviously sozzled Adham in furious frustration. If they had had hospitals for deliveries in those days, she would surely have sued them for saddling her with a changeling !😉

Ok, folks, this is it for the day. See you again on Thursday, by when we shall be in very choppy waters.

For now, please do take a look at the admittedly very brief responses to your comments on my last thread that I hope to put up once I have got this one out. Aap log apni tippani bhejne ki takleef uthayein, aur hum uska koyi bhi jawaab na dein, yeh humein khatakta hai! I shall try and do the same for this one too, by Wednesday, unless things get worse with me in the meantime.

Shyamala/Aunty/Akka/Di

Edited by sashashyam - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

7.4k

Users

20

Likes

226

Frequent Posters

Suganya.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Hello Shymala Aunty , Hope ur doing well 😊 As usual , ur post is a jhakaas n mast 👏😆 The bit about kaan Prob of krishna was 🤣 The scenes that i liked the most was :
1) Aarthi scene : Again like the sword fighting scene , this one i have watched umpteen times and yet would never get bored 😳 Expressions of both Paridhi n Rajat was marvellous and i wished dearly then , the both would have civilized normal conversation then 😕 But this Daasi's of Agra 😡 They dont have enough sense not to disturb the Emperor with his queen nor they have the habit of having a door in all the rooms of Agra 🥱 So that maids like Resham would not here other's conversation so easily 😡 2) The scene of Rahim with jalal , ruqaiya n salima : This scene along with the reminiscent of Child jalal riding on Bairam khan's back was well done😳 , Unlike jodha n Salima scene were as usual jo would start complaining on Jalal's attitude 👏 I kinda liked the scene for its hard truth , though now they r king n queen of whole hind " they too have their own worries on CHILDREN 😊 And of course yeah , Ruqu had it for whole set of other reasons 😡
3) The Prophecy : It was much as well done wrt baba's predictions and consequent jo-jal holding scene , as u have described so well they both have achieved that stage where they had come to accept the truth of wat's happening to them even if they hate it now 😳
4) Jo's Good Nature : This scene of Jo wishing Ruqaiya for her child and giving the present she bought with her to ruqs 👏 ( minus the non sense of Ruqs🥱 ) And the subsequent scenes of Jalal thinking about Jo n jo-jalal scene of saturday , surely as u have mentioned crctly bought that sense of all will go well btw Jo n jalal here after 😳 But as we know very well it will be worse there after due to EVIL witch 1 of Agra 😡 Kheir i liked the words , Jo used .. the genuine wishes for the child , really touched my heart too like jalal 😃
So this week's episodes we hav all sorts of non sense against jo n her family !!! I once watched it wen originally telecasted in 2013 then , n now watching again ll surely make me feel bad 🥱 Nevertheless ll watch for sake of continuity 😕 and i expect to u hav very gud improvement in health wen u post next analysis thread 😳
karkuzhali thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3


Dear Shyamala,

Thank you for the wonderful analysis with your usual humour punches!

As I had already pointed out elsewhere in Harshu's thread, the CVs have beautifully conceived/picturised the scene where Jalal comes to Jodha's hojra to appreciate her poem. He could have simply told her,"Oh, I like your poem; it is very nice..." or something similar. But the situation gets a very beautiful dimension when he recites it verbatum and with such a bhaav!And the pleasant surprise that Jodha shows on her face is enjoyable!

Regarding the caption, "sharp eyes",
'Jodha recognised Jalal from just a wavy image sighted in water,that too an inverted one...'. But I think that his image along with Jodha was erroneously shown as inverted! When Jalal was standing behind Jodha, how would the image be upside down? It should be straight! But it is different during the mukh dikayi
ceremony, where he stands in front of her.

Once again I thank you for the pm . Pl take care of yor health.

Saraswathi.
PutijaChalhov thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Another lovely analysis Shyamala, fascinating reading but I am from Andhra so the spelling😊 but staying nearly 20 years in Lucknow .

Just a few points for what you wrote in question mark

mohabbat ka sauta (?) behta hai jo humne mehsoos kiya hai, Rahim ko lekar.

something like a pool flowing

use naaz-o-nashan (?) se paalenge!

naaz o shaan means with lot of affection and grand style


Tohfa bhi deti hain, Kafin (?) bhi deti hain!

khafa bhi rahti hai you give gifts but are still angry/displeased
Donjas thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
First of all, I see several humorous phrases in your post, I hope it means that you are feeling better. Once again your analysis is superb, a guide to the episode. I wish everyone associated with the serial including Rajat and Paridhi should read it, they will get new insights. Now for my feedback-
1 The Sharifuddin situation was interesting, but while reading that serious passage I grinned twice, first the eavesdropper and then the mother joke.

2 Salima is an all round good person. The advantage she has over Jodha is tact and understanding. She is like the female version of Abdul, but with even better sensitivity for people. Our Ameri mirchi is too impetuous for her own good. Jodha is lucky to have a wonderful mother in law in Hamida, and a loyal and powerful friend like Salima. And yet even blessed with these two great relationships, she gets into despair over her Jallad husband's activities and dives into a nearby pond.

3 I enjoyed reading your description of the Salim Chisti scene. Both Rajat and Paridhi excelled. The look of confusion on their faces, when the seer made the divine prediction was a sight to behold.

4 The looks that Jodha and Jalal gave each other over the mannat, and later the light hearted bickering in Jalal's room over this issue, was such fun to watch. You captured it so nicely and your vivid description played in my mind like a video.

5 I know my feedback today will appear too sweet, but what can I do, your description of the Tulsi scene was just out of this world. Relived it and enjoyed it.

6 I just had to give my feedback on Akbar's phenomenal memory. To illustrate it a copy/paste from an article by Audrey Truschke, who is a Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow at Stanford University and Assistant Professor of South Asian History at Rutgers University-Newark-

If the Mughals are approached with fresh eyes, their dynamic interweaving of politics and culture can be identified as the solid bedrock on which they built their empire.

Over the course of roughly one hundred years, from 1560 until nearly 1660, the Mughals cultivated a thoroughly multicultural and multilingual imperial image that involved repeated attention to Sanskrit texts, intellectuals, and knowledge systems. Monarchs and communities outside the ruling elite responded to this self-fashioning in many ways, and their reactions no doubt encouraged the Mughals to continue these dynamic encounters. Nonetheless, the Mughals did not pursue this set of exchanges for the benefit of their population but rather mainly for themselves. They sought to understand what it meant to become rulers of India.

In the absence of an obvious answer, the Mughals set out to formulate a cluster of possibilities, many of which prominently featured Sanskrit, India's foremost premodern tongue of literature and learning. Reconstructing this complex set of encounters will undoubtedly change how Indologists understand Mughal history and also offers a fruitful case study for analysing the culture of power in a non-Western, premodern setting. The Mughals may have declared Persian the medium of government, but activities at the royal court reveal a significantly more complex picture of how imperial claims actually worked on the early modern subcontinent.

Jains and Brahmans at Akbar's court

Jain and Brahman Sanskrit intellectuals visited the courts of Akbar, Jahangir, and Shah Jahan in considerable numbers.

A select few entered the royal court at the direct invitation of the crown, whereas others gained entre through regional or subimperial patrons. Many championed political causes on behalf of their religious communities or local rulers. Above all, Sanskrit literati sought access to famed Mughal patronage, which drew individuals working in various languages from across much of Asia. Sanskrit authors crafted many works under imperial sponsorship and participated in numerous aspects of court life. They acted as intellectual informants, astrologers, religious guides, translators, and political negotiators for the Mughals...

The Mughals also turned to Sanskrit intellectuals for information concerning other Indian practices and ideas that could inform an imperial agenda, including the notion that Akbar was an incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu. Bada'uni unhappily attests that Brahmans introduced Sanskrit works that predicted Akbar's rise to power as Vishnu's avatar:

[Cheating imposter Brahmans] told [the king] repeatedly that he had descended to earth, like Ram, Krishan, and other infidel rulers, who, although lords of the world, had taken on human form to act on earth. For the sake of flattery, they presented Sanskrit poetry [shir-ha-yi hindi] allegedly uttered by tongues of sages that predicted a world-conquering padshah would arise in India. He would honor Brahmans, protect cows, and justly rule the earth. They wrote such nonsense on old papers and presented it to [the emperor]. He believed every word.

Some Sanskrit works written under Akbar's support mirror these claims rather precisely. For example, in his bilingual grammar from the late sixteenth century, Krishnadasa praises Akbar as Vishnu embodied:

Since Brahma was described by the Veda
as changeless and beyond this world,
therefore Akbar, great ruler of the earth, was born
in order to protect cows and Brahmans.
His virtuous name is celebrated throughout the ocean of shastras
and among scriptures [smriti], histories [itihasa], and the like.
It is established forever in the three worlds, and
therefore with his name this work is composed.
It is no surprise that cows were protected by Lord Krishna, son of Gopala,
and the best of the twice born guarded
by the Ramas, gods of the Brahmans.
But it is truly amazing that the lord Vishnu
descended [avatirna] in a family of
foreigners that loves to harm cows and Brahmans.
Akbar protects cows and Brahmans!

Jains also provided Akbar access to certain Sanskrit-based practices that would prove politically potent, such as sun veneration. Bhanucandra, a Tapa Gaccha ascetic whom Hiravijaya sent to the Mughal court in Lahore in 1587, taught Akbar how to recite a Sanskrit text titledSuryasahasranama (Thousand Names of the Sun). Siddhicandra, Bhanucandra's Sanskrit biographer, tells the tale thus:

One time, the ruler of the earth repeatedly asked the Brahmans for the Thousand Names of the Sun, but they could not find it anywhere. By a stroke of luck they located some wise man. He gave [the text] to them, and they presented it to the glorious shah [shrisaha]. Having seen it, the glorious shah said to them excitedly, "Tell me who among good people can teach me this?" They replied, "Only one who has subdued all the senses, sleeps on the ground, and possesses sacred knowledge is qualified in this matter." When he heard this, the shah said, "Only you [Bhanucandra] possess such qualities here. You alone, venerable one, will teach me this every morning."

Later in his work, Siddhicandra portrays Akbar as devoted to honouring the sun to the exclusion of other religious activities:

The glorious shah diligently learned the Thousand Names of the Sun.
He forgot any other taste and recited the names there. He devoted his
mind, stood in the correct direction facing the sun, and learned from
Bhanucandra with his folded hands pressed against his forehead.

Siddhicandra does not explain further this "other taste" (anyarasa) for which sun veneration eliminated any need on the part of the Mughal emperor. But it is likely a covert reference to Islam, especially given that Siddhicandra carefully mentions that Akbar faced the correct direction in venerating the sun and used his head and hands properly, which are both important concerns in Islamic prayer as well. Furthermore, Bada'uni, a notorious critic of Akbar in his unofficial history of the era, testifies that this ritual occurred up to four times daily, including at times for Islamic prayers such as sunrise. Jerome Xavier, a European traveler, even noted Akbar's predilection for sun worship as one reason why he was best not considered a Muslim. Most likely, rather than indicating his personal religious inclinations, Akbar designed this royal custom to promote his absolute sovereignty.



Now if Akbar could learn and recite the 1000 names of the sun despite having no Sanskrit background, that says a lot about his memory.

I will post again later on for thoughts on the remaining part of your analysis.
alffim thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Dear Syamala Di! A great pleasure to read your analysis! And me very like Your sarcastic comments. Dilutes the unction (oil).😛
Edited by alffim - 9 years ago
karkuzhali thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Shyamala,

A PS to my earlier post:

I really loved the scene where Jodha comes to meet Jalal after he finishes his namaaz. The conversation between them is very cool and without any inhibitions, just like a normal couple , taking liberty with each other. May be if Ruqaiah did not really get pregnant, Jodha , on second thoughts, would have agreed to Jalal's proposition to save Hamida from the ordeal!

Saraswathi.
Kalgi22 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
As usual another wonderful review Aunty!! Salima Begum... A gentle mind and a generous heart. Well said!!! 👏 And my all time favorite scene... that's Aarti scene! Rajat's facial nuance... Awww a treat to eyes And your detail analysis make us drooling over him yet again😆 I agreed with your points what pull Jalal more towards Jodha.. It's just not only external beauty but the internal beauty of her.. Beauty.. Pureness.. Goodness of her heart! Waiting to read more Aunty. Take care!😳
Nonie12345 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Nice analysis Shyamala Aunty 😃
I hope u are fine
Take care of your health
Edited by Nonie12345 - 9 years ago
KanJmaskis thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Aunty Amazing analysis ... while u r suffering a lot kudos to ur hard work no matter how much this rheumatoid arthritis want to stuck pain in u bt u always seems as a fighter...that's the spirit...👏
Jo and salima scene proved to be an answer of many asked and unasked questions while salima's revert back " Kabhi kabhi unhein ...mohabbat ka sauta (?) behta hai " on jo' s accusations " yakin nahi ...pitratu vayavhar" showing her understanding of human behaviour and something that is only unknown to our begume - e - khaas 😉 as Hb , Ma and now Sa begum believe so except her .

Ur view upon jo 's still not affecting response even after knowing the truth , i want to say that it seems that she deliberately made her blind to watch that he too has soft side atleast till the ajmer track and like so did ruk fr jo till the end of the series...

Seeing ruks on the verge of crying was a beautiful emotional scene as to watch lavina first time like that bt as u said it remained only fr a moment and it happened many time ... she possessed a speedy rollar coaster behaviour which we will found out more in further tracks

Next her will to gain power from mahamanga...now i want to say that she always have the problems with anyone ...as for now she has power of harem .. Malikai begum ja's best frnd and his begum then what she has with vajire - a - aliya if she wants the power in court to speak along with harem then she would be muz and malikai Hindustan so her jealousy towards jo is considered bt with ma is useless and showing she has always issues with koi- na - koi.

Next episode was a treat to watch as u said the best episode with the three special scenes , ja- ruk scene , vicharmagan ja in his hojra, or jo- ja scene before jashn ...these all shots presence r very perfect i remembered last year when i was watching the episode i was very excited that what would be her gift and whether ja saw it or not or ruks told him about the gift or not ... Something that we want to see

Agree with u episode belongs to jo ... Paridhi displayed it fully what jo ' s persona ... She has genuine care fr the baby ...bt ruks approach when jo came to give a gift was showed her shallow or uncontrolled behaviour ( not getting perfect word)

Whereas ja's response having seen the gift was prooved like a treat in the form of dialogue ' lagta hai ki dil se likha hai ' ...and as u said ja gave a perfect shot all while with Rt' facial naunce while paying a deaf response on ruks cheeky remarks " chaploosi & dil ki baat juba pe " ...this also showed one more quality of ja that one can not easily get what in his mind untill he tells and that is same when Ma asked him Are u agree shehenshah with malika - e - begum with what she said about jo begum...😉😉

At night ...soliloquy of ja was the loving one can't say it was the best as there r soo many bt my favourite one ,, was a perfect shot of awakening feelings ... Rt left me enthralled 😳😳 ...will not want to write more about it as u described it very aptly ...

Jo ja scene before jashn was a lovely one and i was in full anticipation that what would he said bt that is another thing ...when he came in front of her and said in strong voice ' Takhliye ' a little bit showing that style of his With pleasureful smile is ' what he is going to do in alone ' ...😳 Bt jo bach gayi 😆...and after all finally he conveyed it with an indirect approach that "Tohfa bhi deti hai khafa bhi rehti hai "...😳...uff he is damn good in all these ones... 😛😃 ...
That's it aunty seems it became very long ...waiting to read more of ur wonderful analysis ... Bt take care of urs first ...
Edited by KanJmaskis - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

1 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: lkdaswani

11 months ago

The Real Akbar.

Hello! This is a continuation of our discussion on just who the real Akbar was. Anyone is free to give their opinion and if all you guys wish to...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: msbhattacharya

7 years ago

HIRA AUR AKBAR KI PREM KAHANI

I WILL POST THE NEXT CHAPTERS BY THE END OF THIS WEEK THOSE WHO ARE NEW TP MY STORY PLEASE GP THROUGH THE LINK I AM GIVING HERE PERVOUS CHAPTERS

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".