myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

You know why titanic sank, some crew members said a huge ice block is in that direction and to go another way but captain was adamant to follow the path

Almost every accident is because a human does error or does not listen to others
JA serial I becoming like titanic ship
The biggest error CVs are doing from beginning of introduction of Salim is showing him hate his father mother
First Salim was terrified of Akbar as a kid so much that he lied about shooting arrow to a boy by mistake
After that he started hating and going silent in presence of his father and mother
Now as adult he hates them to the core
Yes Jodha Akbar have not been great parents in his childhood agreed but why not Salim keep a big heart and forgive them now that he is big and mature?
CVs stop this Salim hating his parents or the serial will sink badly
Second stop this afeem addiction of Salim - he is what 16-17 years now? he had not even started drinking at that age as per history and here he is addicted to afeem for 8 years
Third stop this Ruq drama of being his mom, I mean which child love a step mother more than his own? Ruq orders and he drops his sword, Ruq makes him fall at her feet etc this is degrading Salim and his parents to the core
Let JA and Salim know who made him addict immediately
Lastly this JA acting like saints and taking all blame on their head not letting Salim know anything, JA treating all equally I mean there was major class difference in those days so stop this artificial treating all equally nonsense on this show by an emperor and empress
Because if that is not shown on what basis will they oppose salim marriage to anarkali or nur jahan or anyother commoner girl?
Commoners were not treated equal to royals and rich in those days not even now in 21st century at least in india and asia class diff exists and should be just shown as that.
Pls tell a commoner can he go and meet or speak openly with ministers, rich etc in 21st century answer is no same in 16th century
Pls show that which makes sense not some dream land that never existed or exists.
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

2.4k

Users

12

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

Tarunika13 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: myviewprem

You know why titanic sank, some crew members said a huge ice block is in that direction and to go another way but captain was adamant to follow the path

Almost every accident is because a human does error or does not listen to others
JA serial I becoming like titanic ship
The biggest error CVs are doing from beginning of introduction of Salim is showing him hate his father mother
First Salim was terrified of Akbar as a kid so much that he lied about shooting arrow to a boy by mistake
After that he started hating and going silent in presence of his father and mother
Now as adult he hates them to the core
Yes Jodha Akbar have not been great parents in his childhood agreed but why not Salim keep a big heart and forgive them now that he is big and mature?
CVs stop this Salim hating his parents or the serial will sink badly
Second stop this afeem addiction of Salim - he is what 16-17 years now? he had not even started drinking at that age as per history and here he is addicted to afeem for 8 years
Third stop this Ruq drama of being his mom, I mean which child love a step mother more than his own? Ruq orders and he drops his sword, Ruq makes him fall at her feet etc this is degrading Salim and his parents to the core
Let JA and Salim know who made him addict immediately
Lastly this JA acting like saints and taking all blame on their head not letting Salim know anything, JA treating all equally I mean there was major class difference in those days so stop this artificial treating all equally nonsense on this show by an emperor and empress
Because if that is not shown on what basis will they oppose salim marriage to anarkali or nur jahan or anyother commoner girl?
Commoners were not treated equal to royals and rich in those days not even now in 21st century at least in india and asia class diff exists and should be just shown as that.
Pls tell a commoner can he go and meet or speak openly with ministers, rich etc in 21st century answer is no same in 16th century
Pls show that which makes sense not some dream land that never existed or exists.


Very well said!!!

JA is also the sinking Titanic ship where viewers are telling the CVs not to take the path of SA at the cost of JA, but they are adamant. This adamancy has already initiated the downfall of JA😡
amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Cvs and writers are in illusion dear,they have no idea what to do any more,they dont need to desgrace this people any further why cant they shup shop now
Sweet24 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Dear u have writen very well, but CVs and writers r brainless, adamant, deaf

Don't waste ur time, thinking on this useless creature. Because the result is zero.
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
yes the cvs are portraying it so wrong
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: amina1

Cvs and writers are in illusion dear,they have no idea what to do any more,they dont need to desgrace this people any further why cant they shup shop now

every relationship is filled with hatred
be it parents and kids like JA and Salim
or lovers Salim anarkali or before husband wife JA why?
Why start every story with hate? Do all people hate and then only love?
Why not show love without hate, relation without hate, family without hate?
Is that too much to ask for?
.GreekPrincess. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
salim really needs to take a hike...seriously
like damn dude...communication is a two way thing, try shutting up and listening for a change!...is it too much to ask?😕
its so irritating having to watch him waste the screen with his arrogance and terrible acting n horrible presumption with regards to his parent
This is boring and stupid. How long will ruks get away with her evil doings
Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: myviewprem

You know why titanic sank, some crew members said a huge ice block is in that direction and to go another way but captain was adamant to follow the path

Almost every accident is because a human does error or does not listen to others
JA serial I becoming like titanic ship
The biggest error CVs are doing from beginning of introduction of Salim is showing him hate his father mother
First Salim was terrified of Akbar as a kid so much that he lied about shooting arrow to a boy by mistake
After that he started hating and going silent in presence of his father and mother
Now as adult he hates them to the core
Yes Jodha Akbar have not been great parents in his childhood agreed but why not Salim keep a big heart and forgive them now that he is big and mature?
CVs stop this Salim hating his parents or the serial will sink badly
Second stop this afeem addiction of Salim - he is what 16-17 years now? he had not even started drinking at that age as per history and here he is addicted to afeem for 8 years
Third stop this Ruq drama of being his mom, I mean which child love a step mother more than his own? Ruq orders and he drops his sword, Ruq makes him fall at her feet etc this is degrading Salim and his parents to the core
Let JA and Salim know who made him addict immediately
Lastly this JA acting like saints and taking all blame on their head not letting Salim know anything, JA treating all equally I mean there was major class difference in those days so stop this artificial treating all equally nonsense on this show by an emperor and empress
Because if that is not shown on what basis will they oppose salim marriage to anarkali or nur jahan or anyother commoner girl?
Commoners were not treated equal to royals and rich in those days not even now in 21st century at least in india and asia class diff exists and should be just shown as that.
Pls tell a commoner can he go and meet or speak openly with ministers, rich etc in 21st century answer is no same in 16th century
Pls show that which makes sense not some dream land that never existed or exists.


Each and every point of yours is valid.

Unfortunately, the big block of ice that the ship in question is hitting are the Creatives themselves. Their thought process has frozen. I can see the ship steadily moving, towards the bottom of the sea.😔

In spite of several feedbacks via various sources, I do not see any improvement in the script at all. It is still not too late to make sensible, authentic, believable changes to the story and direction.
Edited by Charu.S - 10 years ago
Coolpree thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Well said. your points are all very valid but I am afraid none of what you have asked for will happen as the creatives of this show are of a very sick mindset.
People here seem to think it is the SA track which is sinking this ship...I dont think so. no matter how mediocre the acting of sanar, the audience would have watched if the leads of this story were given their rightful screen space, SAlim would have respected his parents as per history and Ruk would not have been made this all powerful evil step mother of Salim. This behaviour between Salim and Ruquayya is nauseating and impossible to look at. And yes, Jodha and Akbar need to be shown as brave, smart, attentive and majestic as they were in history.
amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: myviewprem

every relationship is filled with hatred

be it parents and kids like JA and Salim
or lovers Salim anarkali or before husband wife JA why?
Why start every story with hate? Do all people hate and then only love?
Why not show love without hate, relation without hate, family without hate?
Is that too much to ask for?
I watch SAB tv shows,now comng to hindi tv agar koi ladki seriuosely dekh le to shadi ke naam se hi daar jaye,the way a bagu is treated and not to talk about how her husband is,i dont know if to laugh or cry,ekta ke show me naam ke meaning hi gayab pavitra rishta me pavitrata dhoondhte thak gayi yeh hai mohabbate muhabbat kiya hai pata nahi and now the new one what a comedy and our show JODHA akbar,akbar ka to naam hi nahi😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".