Protocol and other issues

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

JA has the worst protocol observed among historicals

Many times I feel I aam watching some 21st century modern show rather than an 16th century royal show
Sample this
Anarkali goes to Man Bai room to dress her up no adab no permission just starts making her hair
Anarkali gets a letter from Salim and she goes and screams Shezade Salim- in 16th century the gaurds would have arrested her and she would be thrown to lions no adab no liyaz no respect nothing
Salim in commoner dress goes to meet anarkali at her house without any security - isn't he walihaad?
Anarakli badmouthing Akbar and Salim to Salim - uff real Salim would have given her one tight slap even if he was in commoner dress(I am thinking for Junior Salim how he had shouted at her gustaak tumhari itni jhuraat mat bulna tum kiske sat baat kar rahi ho)
Salim practicing with a short put without top and princesses ogling at him
Why are lady and boys tents not separate area?
Man Bai and Jagat are his cousins but are not introduced to him yet why?
Salim knows anarkali house how?
Even better Akbar kids are all here 3 boys and a girl but their mothers are gayab other than Jodha. So who takes care of the kids? OK Salim and Murad are 17 years but Daniyal and aram are small 14 and 5 years do they not need moms to take care of them. Instead Salim is feeding aram, Qutub is taking a sleepy daniyal to tent etc Salim and his friends are on baby sitting duty for younger sibings or what? May be this is also part of his shahenshah training 😆
Aram bano has become a dadima keeping eye on her Salim bhaijaan about who troubles him and stares at him 😆 hamida bano duty transferred to her maybe is this not Jodha and hamida work hamida has not come and jo is busy romancing in her late 40s.
Farhan loves tribal princess - pray tell me he was in war field till last week with salim and how he got time for this romance and how could he meet some princesses
Aanrakli is friends with all Salim's cousins oh wait did I hear her say she hates all royals. Then what are Man and Jagat? aren't they both dusth bigdel shezada salim's cousins as per anarkali?
Anarakli's characterisation is most illogical and stupid in all characters because OK may be Salim was dressed as commoner in amer we can atleast believe that because king/prince would wear commoner dress and go out, salim friendship with farhan believable because in history salim had many commoner friends like qutub, mahabat etc but anarkali friendships with princesses unbelievable.
Bacche bigadenge nahi toh aur kya karenge 😲
this story has become comedy of errors only if story writing does not improve it will sink badly
Show some reality please
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.5k

Users

11

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

marshi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
True prem but anar was fictional it was bibi sahib jamal right
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: marshi

True prem but anar was fictional it was bibi sahib jamal right

sahib jamal was his wife and second son parvez mom
sahib jamal was Akbar's milk bro neice
Akbar objected to their wedding but then permitted almost a year after he was pestered by salim
but Akbar never accepted her as bahu she died young in her 20s
anarkali tomb is rumoured to be sahib Jamal's only but dates of death mismatch on tomb
and definetly salim shall not write all those love messages on grave for a wife calling himself majnu will he?
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago
amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Oh dear ,yeh adaab to pehle se hi gayab the,now akbar has nothing to do but to go in his sasural and be romantic with his wife havent watch todays episode but this anar knows everything about what happend yet she hates royals ,akbar treated her father fairly it was the people burt she has problems with salim,you are right prem it looks like21 century rather than 16 century btw how anar dresses like a some rich girl rather than a dancer,this show is PR no 2
amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Wese history ka to dur dur tak ka rishta nahi hai lol
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
it was gayab from jodha time only
i dont think real jodha went out much without ghoonghat
nor she she come openly to DEK always and fight with jalal
9699 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: myviewprem

JA has the worst protocol observed among historicals

Many times I feel I aam watching some 21st century modern show rather than an 16th century royal show
Sample this
Anarkali goes to Man Bai room to dress her up no adab no permission just starts making her hair
Anarkali gets a letter from Salim and she goes and screams Shezade Salim- in 16th century the gaurds would have arrested her and she would be thrown to lions no adab no liyaz no respect nothing
Salim in commoner dress goes to meet anarkali at her house without any security - isn't he walihaad?
Anarakli badmouthing Akbar and Salim to Salim - uff real Salim would have given her one tight slap even if he was in commoner dress(I am thinking for Junior Salim how he had shouted at her gustaak tumhari itni jhuraat mat bulna tum kiske sat baat kar rahi ho)
Salim practicing with a short put without top and princesses ogling at him
Why are lady and boys tents not separate area?
Man Bai and Jagat are his cousins but are not introduced to him yet why?
Salim knows anarkali house how?
Even better Akbar kids are all here 3 boys and a girl but their mothers are gayab other than Jodha. So who takes care of the kids? OK Salim and Murad are 17 years but Daniyal and aram are small 14 and 5 years do they not need moms to take care of them. Instead Salim is feeding aram, Qutub is taking a sleepy daniyal to tent etc Salim and his friends are on baby sitting duty for younger sibings or what? May be this is also part of his shahenshah training 😆
Aram bano has become a dadima keeping eye on her Salim bhaijaan about who troubles him and stares at him 😆 hamida bano duty transferred to her maybe is this not Jodha and hamida work hamida has not come and jo is busy romancing in her late 40s.
Farhan loves tribal princess - pray tell me he was in war field till last week with salim and how he got time for this romance and how could he meet some princesses
Aanrakli is friends with all Salim's cousins oh wait did I hear her say she hates all royals. Then what are Man and Jagat? aren't they both dusth bigdel shezada salim's cousins as per anarkali?
Anarakli's characterisation is most illogical and stupid in all characters because OK may be Salim was dressed as commoner in amer we can atleast believe that because king/prince would wear commoner dress and go out, salim friendship with farhan believable because in history salim had many commoner friends like qutub, mahabat etc but anarkali friendships with princesses unbelievable.
Bacche bigadenge nahi toh aur kya karenge 😲
this story has become comedy of errors only if story writing does not improve it will sink badly
Show some reality please



haha oh my god you just spoke from my mind ,this story has become comedy
thats 100% true its full of nonsesnse and you know why THE ANSWER IS
BECAUSE director Santram Varma HAS LOEFT THE SHOW EVER SINCE HE LEFT
THE SHOW BECOME JOKE ,Santram Varma WAS THE HEART OF THIS SHOW
JODHA AKBAR BECOME NUMBER 1 ITS BECAUSE OF HIM HE WAS VERY SMART
AND GREAT WITH SKILLS NOW ITS DEAD THE SHOW AS HE LEFT YOU HATE HIM BUT DONT FORGET HE IS WHAT JODHA AKBAR WAS BECAUSE OF HIM. I ADMIN HIM AND RESPECT HIM FOR HIS HARD WORK.
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: morsal_cute



haha oh my god you just spoke from my mind ,this story has become comedy
thats 100% true its full of nonsesnse and you know why THE ANSWER IS
BECAUSE director Santram Varma HAS LOEFT THE SHOW EVER SINCE HE LEFT
THE SHOW BECOME JOKE ,Santram Varma WAS THE HEART OF THIS SHOW
JODHA AKBAR BECOME NUMBER 1 ITS BECAUSE OF HIM HE WAS VERY SMART
AND GREAT WITH SKILLS NOW ITS DEAD THE SHOW AS HE LEFT YOU HATE HIM BUT DONT FORGET HE IS WHAT JODHA AKBAR WAS BECAUSE OF HIM. I ADMIN HIM AND RESPECT HIM FOR HIS HARD WORK.



in blue..cannot agree more!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
i think SV made jodha akbar with his hard work and when the show reached its top he was thrown out and now look where the show is!
stephhh thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
No expectations from this show anymore. As they only dressed up as royals with royal type setting but the story, dialogue, characters behaviour nothing is royal or of mughal time when strictly pardha was mandatory. How can jo talk with birbal with out any ghunghat on her face covering? Unlike before no one says Adaab or namaste anymore. The show salim and akbar look like brothers not a 40 or 17 yr old. The fact is the current writers have no real knowledge of history or its protocols thus this mess. Plus real shortage of funds visible in JA.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".