Why all blaming jalal?

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
i am not angry with jalal i am angry with jodha's father
because in those days the norm was all husband have many wives

and is it rule that king cannot marry when wife is pregnant

akbar married many princess the year salim was born or aram banu was born historically

and i know bharamal, bhagwan das, man singh, rao maldeo etc all had many wives from 20 to 60 and coucubbines too

so why show only akbar as lustlful and others as mmaryada purushothams

akbar married many for love and even more for political gain

but all are forgetting that bharamal married his daughter against her wishes for political gains and safety only. why blame husband when father is only bargaining daughter

Is it not a father and brother duty to take care of sister/daughter and protect her? Or are they to be bargained like cattle protect my kingdom give my captured sons back and take my daughter in return.

Is Akbar to be 100% blamed? Akbar like all other kings marrying many girls and love many girls. So why all saying he is lusting? Indeed it is Akbar greatness that he gave respect to Jodha and gave her religious freedom. Ruqaiah, Salima and Jodha are safe and protected. Its other harem women(read wives/cocubines of akbar) who are marginalized and have no one and left to fend for themselves.

Ruqaiah had akbar and salim and khurram to protect and look for her needs, salima had akbar and rahim and salim too, jodha had akbar, salim, rahim, man singh, bhagwan das so many to protect her in agra fort and she never lonely. What about other wives of akbar who there to remove their lonliness and take care of them in old age, illness etc no one? Who care if they died? No one again. So i am pity all other wives of akbar not these three for sure. They are lucky.
rao maldeo married rukmavati to akbar another daughter to bhagwan das another to sher shah suri another to maharana pratap another to haji khan another to mahmood shah etc

First father's must be questioned for not caring for daughter feeling and marrying them like barter system then speak of husbands

atleast husbands like akbar, sher shah suri, mahmood shah, haji khan treated those daughters respectfully gave them freedom to follow their customs and took care of them and protected them and did not barter them like their fathers for gains

So shouting/slapping/blaming akbar is wrong. He did what all other kings did used marriage to promote loyalty among other subordinate kings. Atleast Abkabr loved his sisters/daughters/grand daughters so much that ne never barter them for political gain. I respect him as a brother/father/grand father and son immensely. As a husband yes he married many to expand kingdom but atleast he took care of all wives and protected them and did not abondon them.


Edited by myviewprem - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.1k

Users

14

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

preetgurti thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
We not blaming real akbar why don't all understand its ekta akbar sorry jalal ekta jallad dont deserve name akbar

This show was not abt his Begums and rasleelals ir his sex life or lustfull it ws abt
the love soul connection which they buil from pasy 300 episode the dialogue that u gavr me heart and bla bla
was all only to take her to bed
the love story looked faked
hope now u understand
...Radhika... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: preetgurti

We not blaming real akbar why don't all understand its ekta akbar sorry jalal ekta jallad dont deserve name akbar

This show was not abt his Begums and rasleelals ir his sex life or lustfull it ws abt
the love soul connection which they buil from pasy 300 episode the dialogue that u gavr me heart and bla bla
was all only to take her to bed
the love story looked faked
hope now u understand

I'm totally agree with you! For God's sake it's based on a love story and not just on Akbar's life! 🤢
Forthislifeonly thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: PupCat

I'm totally agree with you! For God's sake it's based on a love story and not just on Akbar's life! 🤢

Then they should named it as "AKBAR".not "JODHA AKBAR"😔 😔
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: preetgurti

We not blaming real akbar why don't all understand its ekta akbar sorry jalal ekta jallad dont deserve name akbar

This show was not abt his Begums and rasleelals ir his sex life or lustfull it ws abt
the love soul connection which they buil from pasy 300 episode the dialogue that u gavr me heart and bla bla
was all only to take her to bed
the love story looked faked
hope now u understand


you are right

but again if akbar becomes only one wife husband to jodha is that not injustice to other wives

what will other wives do all life? Akbar is 20 years old his other 299(if he had 300 wives cum cocubbines) wives same age or younger. what should they do if akbar becomes one wife husband? Is that not injustice to them? Forget husband wife relation is it not akbar duty to meet them check if they are fine spend time talking, playing, eating, takin care of them etc with other 299 wives.

Just because akbar loves jodha can he forget other 299. That is not possible. All his other 299 wives are young, pretty, many are royals come from big and great family. Will they keep quiet, will their family keep quiet if ignored?

Its not 21st century love story that akbar will be one wife husband. They must show some authenticity.

Yes but akbar lusting after atifa etc i do not approve. If it was one of his 300 wives he spend time, like etc its Okkk. But this lady is already married. What example he is setting to his kids and younger siblings or neice/nephews?


myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: PupCat

I'm totally agree with you! For God's sake it's based on a love story and not just on Akbar's life! 🤢


Given akbar's many wives it cannot be a typical love story like 21st century bollywood movie or romeo-juliet

This story should have been concieved differently. The premise is wrong.
bokul thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: myviewprem


you are right

but again if akbar becomes only one wife husband to jodha is that not injustice to other wives

what will other wives do all life? Akbar is 20 years old his other 299(if he had 300 wives cum cocubbines) wives same age or younger. what should they do if akbar becomes one wife husband? Is that not injustice to them? Forget husband wife relation is it not akbar duty to meet them check if they are fine spend time talking, playing, eating, takin care of them etc with other 299 wives.

Just because akbar loves jodha can he forget other 299. That is not possible. All his other 299 wives are young, pretty, many are royals come from big and great family. Will they keep quiet, will their family keep quiet if ignored?

Its not 21st century love story that akbar will be one wife husband. They must show some authenticity.

Yes but akbar lusting after atifa etc i do not approve. If it was one of his 300 wives he spend time, like etc its Okkk. But this lady is already married. What example he is setting to his kids and younger siblings or neice/nephews?


agree with u 😳
_shadesnature_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
yup we cannot blaming real akbar but the way ekta is protraing akbar is annoying and the point u have writen i totally agree with u how can a father can make ''deal ''for her daughter at everyone who is behind this marriage and somewhere akaber is responisble
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
We are not after real akbar! We are disappointed with ekta's jalal!😃
We do respect real Akbar!
Rak014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: myviewprem


you are right

but again if akbar becomes only one wife husband to jodha is that not injustice to other wives

what will other wives do all life? Akbar is 20 years old his other 299(if he had 300 wives cum cocubbines) wives same age or younger. what should they do if akbar becomes one wife husband? Is that not injustice to them? Forget husband wife relation is it not akbar duty to meet them check if they are fine spend time talking, playing, eating, takin care of them etc with other 299 wives.

Just because akbar loves jodha can he forget other 299. That is not possible. All his other 299 wives are young, pretty, many are royals come from big and great family. Will they keep quiet, will their family keep quiet if ignored?

Its not 21st century love story that akbar will be one wife husband. They must show some authenticity.

Yes but akbar lusting after atifa etc i do not approve. If it was one of his 300 wives he spend time, like etc its Okkk. But this lady is already married. What example he is setting to his kids and younger siblings or neice/nephews?


I do agree to your points! It would be a injustuce ot other wives if he forgets them! But i wouldnt expect CV's to show the same in a show named JODHA AKBAR! This show is jodha-akbar love-story centric and it looks fair for me if akbar's relation with his other wives are side-lined in this serial!😃 Had it been the story of Akbar-the great, i would have expected jalal relations with all his other begums to be shown!😃


Edited by Rak014 - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee Ā· 7 months ago

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ā–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".