Jodha Akbar 174: Shadows over Camelot

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Folks,

Let us begin where we left off the last time.

As Shaikh Salim Chisti, looking at Jalal and Jodha kneeling before him, intones Taarikh badalne ke liye betaab hai, aur aap donon ke chehre par khuda ke noor ka taap hai, it is not Jalal who, finally setting aside his fears about her reaction to being declared the future Mariam-uz-Zamani, immediately looks across at her.

She looks across at him first, her eyes soft and shadowed with a hidden contentment at what she now knows is to come. Eyes that are lit up with a slow smile that is neither shy nor hesitant, but open and warm, full of a welcoming acceptance of their saanjha kal.

As they both do a maatha tekhna before the saint and receive his farewell blessings, and Jodha smiles once more, this time to herself, it is evident that they are both full of a quiet joy that needs no words.

It is their first truly shared emotion as husband and wife.

Ek hi dhaaga, ek hi mannat: When Jodha goes to tie the mannat ka dhaga in her turn, there is a very beautiful detail that sums up their new relationship. Not so long ago, at the dargah in Ajmer, Jodha had tied her dhaaga separately, at some distance from Jalal's, and sought peace and wellbeing for her loved ones. Jalal had prayed for Jodha's dua to be accepted.

This time, Jodha carefully ties her dhaaga right over Jalal's, on the same khoonta, so that they become, in effect, a single thread. And she does it with a kind gentle deliberation, as if, just as her dhaaga is entwined in Jalal's, so too are her fate and her dreams for the future now entwined with his. As if, with that gesture, she was merging herself, out of her own free will, with him and all that was his.

Jalal seems to understand this, if only vaguely, for his face, even in profile, reflects unexpected delight.

It is the same with their respective wishes, which are in effect the same: that they should be companions for life. In a revealing mirror image of his dua at Ajmer, Jodha now wants nothing for herself, but only that Shahenshah ki manokaamna poori ho.

Which is in effect herself, her saath all thru the journey of his life, but does she really know that? For Jalal makes his wish soundlessly, and if she knows his man ki baatein, as she claims, she has become clairvoyant where he is concerned!

That little scene is pure delight. When he immediately asks her, as before, what she had sought in her dua, she protests and declares, Hum aapko nahin batayenge! But there is such shy coquetry in the little pout that accompanies this statement, and in the cheeky tilt of her chin as she eyes him, that Jalal, if he was not so preoccupied with trying to learn what she had prayed for, would have been on to this new ada of his Jodha Begum in an instant.

As it is, he is still in that groove. So he next proposes, with the shy eagerness of a little boy trying to discover what is inside the gift boxes at the foot of the Christmas tree, Agar hum aapko apni murad batayein to kya tab aap apna batayengi? It was so utterly charming and childlike that I was in stitches, and for two pins, I would have dived into the screen and hugged him, as if he had been my Sasha in a similar situation. And if I had been 40 years younger and in Jodha's place, I would have hugged him at once, if in a different spirit😉, and told him not to worry, that he would get everything he had prayed for.

Jodha of course, being a sanskaari 16th century queen, cannot hug her husband in full public view, however much she might have wanted to😉. So she does the next best thing, and proceeds to tease him, by declaring that she knew what he had wished for, Kyonki , Shahenshah, aap man mein bhi itne oonche swar mein bolte hain ki hamein sab sunayi de chuka hai!

Jalal is torn between his dil , which wants to believe that she can read his mind, and his dimaag, which refuses to do so. So he begins with Jhoot hai, aap sirf baatein bana rahi hain! But as she insists, her eyes fixed unwaveringly on his, that she is not fibbing and she does know what he wished for, he ends up (despite her dodging his demand that she tell him), with a wistful, hopeful Kya aap wakayi jaanti hain ki humne kya maanga?

As he watches her eyes fall slowly and her lips widen in a smile, there is a sudden flutter of eagerness in Jalal's face. Next, the eyes rise again, the eyebrows arch in mischievous assent to his question, the head nods in sync, and the lips smile teasingly. As Jalal watches this new roop of his Jodha Begum in astonishment, she hides her face with the end of her dupatta, bites it, and flees in shyness and charming confusion.

It is the typical gaon ki gori ka lajaana sharmaana act that has been shown any number of times on the big and small screens, where it nowadays evokes only a yawn. But when Jodha does it, very prettily, it is so unexpected from her that it seems as fresh and appealing as if it had never been seen before.

Plus, it shows up the core of what is new in her. For when does a girl feel shy in front of a man, that too a nakchadi (ex-)chudail like Jodha, ever ready with aggressive retorts to Jalal in the past?

As for Jalal, he seems unable to believe his good fortune, for he is now convincde that she does know his dil ki baat, which can thus be now safely revealed to her without any risk of a rebuff. He goes after her to do just that.

Unfortunately for him, Lady Luck, who is a capricious female, has by now decided that she has done enough for him of late😉. So she trips him up neatly just as he is getting set, after a chummy exchange of views with Jodha about the spiritual merits of this retreat, to finally open up to her.

Jalal is telling Jodha about his hope that their duas would be fulfilled when they both look up. There is Ruqaiya Sultan Begum, barring their path, with an expression of mingled disdain and resentment on her face. The sun is still shining, but shadows have fallen over Camelot.

Nascent posssessiveness: How does Jodha react to this sudden invasion of their togetherness? Why, with distinct dismay. I rewatched that sequence frame by frame, and in the last shot of Jodha, it is clear that she is more than disappointed at having her little idyll with Jalal so rudely disturbed.

For this is not the Jodha who was shooing Jalal off to Ruqaiya not so long ago. Not the one who, when Ruqaiya arrived while she was giving Jalal a head massage, promptly got up and left.

When she now leaves Jalal and Ruqaiya alone, it is not because she feels that Ruqaiya has a superior claim to Jalal's time and togetherness. It is rather because she fears that Ruqaiya is all set to make a scene, and she does not want Jalal to be embarrassed by her presence.

And when she leaves that khema declaring to Jalal, with a little catch in her voice, that she prefers to sleep in the open air, there is the hurt and the resentment that comes with nascent possessiveness. Not the kind of possessiveness that demands exclusive rights to his time and his attention, but the kind that seeks unfailing regard and caring from him.

I was very pleased to see that Jodha is no longer going to automatically defer to Ruqaiya when it comes to Jalal, but will stand up for herself, even if in the most understated and civil manner possible.

Hamari zid samajhiye ya hamari khushi: Unlike many here, I was also pleased when Jalal, while laying down his rules firmly regarding the return journey, also reassures Ruqaiya that she is his dearest friend and he would be very pleased to have her with him for that journey.

He is obviously dismayed and displeased to see her land on them, and that too with such abysmal timing. His thoughts are still fixed on Jodha, and as he looks at her thru the lattice, his eyes are dreamy and far away. Ruqaiya can see this.

If now he was off putting and tried to pack her off, it would be a tauheen of what is perhaps his oldest relationship, the one of lifelong friendship and camaraderie with her. And Jalal, who has had very few real relationships in his turbulent life, values those he has, and he will never wilfully damage any of them. Least of all this one, where there is genuine affection on both sides. And this no matter how tiresomely Ruqaiya behaves, for he knows that he is all she has ever had or ever will. I love this trait of his.

Thus, while he schools her with his hamari zid samajhein ya hamari khushi pronouncement, tells her bluntly that with her lazazmi (pomp and show?) she had spoilt his plans to make this trip as an aam aadmi, and sends her off alone to make her obeisance to the Shaikh, he will never even hint to her that she is unwelcome.

He is also used to her overbearing nature. So, in the hut, when Ruqaiya complains about the insects and the mahaul, asserting that she is not used to this kind of life, he listens impassively, merely pulling her leg a bit, though he does point out, now as earlier, that Jodha and he are enjoying it.

Jodha understands all this instinctively, and accepts it as part of him, something with which she needs to help him cope. Which is partly why she is so indulgent to Ruqaiya, responding to all her impertinences, big and small, with unwavering calm and good sense.

She will not compound Jalal's problems with any flare ups of her own; so there are now none of the smart retorts with which she used to face down a rude, overbearing Ruqaiya in the past. There is merely the smiling, gentle reasonableness with which a grown up tackles a troublesome child's temper tantrums.

Thus she reassures the distraught Ruqaiya, almost in tears over the charring of the first ever roti she had ever made, and that too with such childlike pleasure,that the Shahenshah will appreciate the effort and affection that she has put into even the charred roti. Jalal sees this, and he is grateful for it. And he reacts exactly as Jodha had known he would.

I had hopes that with this, Ruqaiya would have felt reassured and secure enough to be at least civil to Jodha. But that was a hope belied, and her nasty streak resurfaces at once, and in full strength, while she is making the bed in the khema .

NB:I do not propose to speculate about why, having this luxurious khema at hand, Ruqaiya was bemoaning her not having a chatai to sit on inside the hut, and shoving Jalal back as she appropriated a good chunk of it. Nor why Jalal, so intent on being an aam aadmi, does not send the khema packing as soon as he sees it.

Nor why travelling as an aam aadmi has to mean sleeping in ramshackle barns. Why can they not stay in a proper sarai, modestly but in relative comfort? An aam aadmi does not have to be literally on the roads! Next, the seth looks prosperous enough, so why can he not have some ready cash for buying provisions for dinner? How long is he planning to live off Jodha's head ornaments (for the necklace, bangles and earrings are gone, to pay the jaziya)?

The whole scenario is plain cuckoo. It was aimed, in the first half, solely at promoting the Jalal-Jodha relationship, and now at sketching out for Jalal the skills he will have to acquire to balance his 2 khaas begums. Plus being a comedy track, such as in Ruqaiya's roti-making session.

For the rest, the latest segment is clearly part of a plan to paint Ruqaiya a deeper shade of grey. As this seems to be a given, and we have to discuss a character as given, there is no point bothering about it.

I will also pass over all the glaring holes in the script I have listed above; there would surely be many more. Maybe the CVs like Swiss cheese, which always has lots of holes in it!😉

Shades of Panchavati: Before you start wondering at my sudden geographical (and mythological) leap, from Camelot to Panchavati, let me explain.

I listened to Jodha tell Jalal, beginning with a gentle Aap aise to mat kahiye!, how happy, indeed blessed she feels to have been able to come here and have the darshan of such a very holy man, and how grateful she is to him for having brought her here.

Later, I watched her hurry after him into the hut, exclaim about his having stretched himself out on the bare hay-covered ground, and look around for a spread to make him more comfortable even as he insists that he is just fine. Hasten to spread the chatai offered opportunely by the banjara. Settle herself, quietly and companionably, next to him on a corner of the chatai, while taking care not to disturb him.

I watched her make out at once, from seeing him look across at the banjaran cooking on the chula, that he is hungry and needs to be fed. Hustle off at once to cook something for him, dismissing his saying that he did not need it with the mischievous observation that she knew he liked to eat a little every few hours. Jalal is obviously chuffed up by this evidence of her caring for him and his needs, and this surfaces in his teasing her about doing jasoosi about him as she goes, smiling widely, to buy the necessities from the banjaran with an easy friendliness that shows her innate kindness and common touch.

As she begins to make the rotis, she turns and smiles at him, and there is, in that smile, all that has now changed between them.

Watching all this, and though the parallel, is a loose one, I was suddenly reminded of Sita during those 13 years of exile in the forests with Rama. It has long been accepted wisdom that Sita had made a great sacrifice in abandoning all the comforts of the palace to face the hardships of exile with her husband, but I have never felt so. It is true that Janaki had never before set foot on the hard ground or had her feet bruised by stones or pierced by thorns. She had never had to subsist on fruits and roots for years on end.

But yet, she had made a clear-eyed choice driven as much, indeed more by her personal desire to be with the husband she loved above all else,than by the concept of the dharma of an ardhangini. I am sure that Sita was as blissfully happy in exile with her Raghunandan, all the privations in the forest notwithstanding, as she would have been wretchedly unhappy without him, in the luxuries of the palace at Ayodhya.

Of course Jodha is, as yet, no Sita in her total, unquestioning devotion to her husband. It is far too early for that. But still, when she constantly looks out for Jalal, when she is sensitive to his feelings, to what hurts him, what angers him, when she wants him not to worry about her comfort, when she does all these little caring things for him, when she tells Ruqaiya, with total sincerity, that she has never felt so much anand on any other journey as she felt of this one -the jail episode, the biting cold, the swollen feet, the dacoit attack notwithstanding - it is the same kind of affection and loyalty and sense of belonging together that she is moving towards.

In fact, one gets the feeling that this Jodha would have been perfectly happy traipsing around the countryside on foot with her sethji for weeks on end, making jowar ki rotis for him on a chula and then contentedly watching him eat! I have to keep pinching myself to make sure that it is all for real!

Andar-baahar: I do not trawl the forum, basically for sheer lack of time, but even on my own last thread, I could sense the outrage among some at Jalal for what seemed like his having let Jodha sleep outside in the cold, while himself sleeping in the comfort of the khema Ruqaiya has forced on him.

For a moment to begin with, I shared this feeling. That Jalal should have put his foot down and told both his begums that Jodha cannot sleep outside, she is not well and it might not be safe, even if Hoshyiyaar and the baandis Ruqaiya had brought along would be there (the soldiers escorting her would have been left behind). That they could all sleep in here on 3 separate bistars.

But a bit more of consideration produced a different interpretation. Jalal has always, even when he was very angry with Jodha, been very careful about her welfare. He risked his life to save her from the tiger. On this trip, with the newfound closeness between them, usne Jodha ko har waqt palkon par bithaya hai.

Nor is it as though he cannot put Ruqaiya in her place when he wants to. He did assert himself when nullifying Ruqaiya's orders and returning her hoojra to Jodha , He also insisted now that Ruqaiya could come along only if she came as a commoner (with 2 baandis, Hoshiyaar and the khema, of course!).

So it would be strange and totally inconsistent if he were suddenly to leave Jodha, who is now so close to his heart, to her own devices outside. In fact he would not have done it even if it had been any other begum of his.

It is very likely that Jalal, not having listened to what Ruqaiya was saying to Jodha, assumed that it was Jodha who would not have wanted to share the khema with him and Ruqaiya. It is a perfectly plausible assumption to make.

He might also have assumed that Hoshiyaar would have arranged a proper bed for her outside, even if it was in the open, with a fire to keep her warm. That is after all what would have been the case for all of them but for Ruqaiya and her khema. Except that instead of mosquitos, they would have had Ruqaiya's constant complaints to keep them awake!😉

He must have gone out very soon to persuade Jodha to come back into the tent, using the arguments of her health and safety to overcome her reservations, and found her already uneasily asleep, tossing and turning on the hard ground.

The slight, sudden smile of tender amusement which twists his lips as he stands there looking down at her tells its own tale. He must have been saying to himself Humne to theek hi kaha tha ki ye to adiyalon ke sultanat ki malika hi hongi! Achche khaase bistar ko chhod kar, apni zid ke liye yahan aise leti hain!

My bet is that he will now either pick Jodha up or wake her up, drag her into the khema regardless of her protests, and force her to sleep in his half of the bed, while he makes some alternative arrangement for himself. It would be the exact parallel of the hoojra restoration incident.

He will not rebuke Ruqaiya, but his silence while he goes about doing all this will be worse for her that a sharp rebuke. Let us see if my take, based solely on the logic of Jalal's nature and his present equation with Jodha, proves to be at least halfway correct.

Lastly, for those wondering why I am so uncommonly kind in my takes on Jodha since the last week, it is not I, but she who has changed. For me, the first priority has always been my boy Jalal. If I am so warm towards Jodha now, it is because she has now learnt to care for him and is so good to him in so many ways.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

PS: I am now at the beginning of a bad bout of conjunctivitis, and I have had to do this post,which I wanted to share with you all, in bits and pieces. I will thus not be able to respond, as I always try to do, individually to all those kind enough to add their comments on this thread. But I am sure you will all have a lot of fun arguing among yourselves, so much so that you will not even notice my absence!
Edited by sashashyam - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

621

Views

36.2k

Users

47

Likes

1.3k

Frequent Posters

aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Lovely Shyamala, we are having good episodes back to back. And very eager to know, what happens today.
Jodha- she has become darling now, the way she takes care of her hubby is delight to watch and hope he remains the priority for her in future as well. The way she tells him " hamare liye to acchha hi hain", I have to cook in small portions. That was too cute and lovely. They have eyes only for each other, yes Ruq coming in, spoilt their trip, and I m not in for screwing her image more now, but that's how CV's have planned it, so I don't want to bother about it anymore now, but all I want is, Jalal to be the way he is and he will have his reasons for not getting Jodha in (even if he doesn't get her in and watches her all night sleeping there).
ashpat thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
So nice of u to still write a post after suffering from conjuctivitis. But, u really did not have to. You should take care and rest.
My fav. Part of episode was dhaaga scene. I feel exactly same way as u do abiut the scene. U have described it beautifully.

Regarding last scene, i am going to wait for the episode and then make an opinion of it. I did not like what ruq did and i really cannot stand ruq in the show but i thought she seemed cute while trying to make rotis. Although, i dont like her, i want jalal to respect his relationship with ruq but he also needs tonstand up when he needs to and hope he will.i hope jalal finds out about what ruq said somehow.


As long as my akdha i mean jalal and jodha r together outside or inside, i will be happy. Unlike many, i am not just jodha or jalal fan; for me its only AKDHA.

Take care aunty.

Ayesha


Edited by ashpat - 11 years ago
Muggle_Diaries thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Hello Shyamala,
Lovely post. I always enjoy reading your articles.

How true your words are: "It is their first truly shared emotion as husband and wife. "
In addition to this, there is another aspect of Jodha which we need to understand.
During Ruq's pregnancy (before, during and after) we have seen Jodha in a different light. She feels immense regret and sadness because she never imagined herself to be a mother after her marriage with Jalal. Given her hatred and helplessness towards Jalal, she never imagined her marriage in a positive light and hence never thought there is even a slight chance of her motherhood. But now that there is a change in how she views her marriage, Salim Chistis saab's vision gives her a new hope. She may not realise her love towards Jalal, but she sees him as a husband and hence even a possibilty of a child in her future brings a new joy. This joy is hers alone.

The Dhaaga scene was lovely. This gentle teasing and flirting from Jodha was a pleasure to watch. And Jalal's confusion was adorable too. In this whole trip, we can see a young man and his equally young wife on the brink of something new. In a way they are newly weds. Their marriage may be old, but they are new persons.

This whole Ruq's presence in this track is giving way to Ruq vs Jodha from Jalal's point of view. And I also like the way Jalal handled Ruq's tantrums. I do not want Jalal to completely cut off Ruq for the way she is, just because he found Jodha. Ruq is still his childhood friend and knows how she is. She may be childish and tantrum queen. He will have to deal with this delicately, without much hurting her. He would not want to hurt his dearest friend after knowing that he would never love Ruq the way he does Jodha and knowing that in the end Ruq may find herself lonely.

Great interpretation of the precap. Going by the way Jalal behaved till now with Ruq and Jodha, I am sure he will do justice to both his begum in this regard too.

Love

Kshithi

PS: Lets forget the loopholes in the script for our own sanity, shall we??? 😆

ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
another excellent post by my shyamala👏..beautiful, impressive first part of the episode and you have so beautifully expressed with your impeccable command on the language! the last and the controversial part is where lots were disappointed with jalal..some will wait till monday..and few of us know that he will not let any wrong happen to jodha..he took care of her during her ghrina mode..he so gracefully strolled through her bhashans..and now when he is in love with her..will he let her do something that he thinks might not be right for her..i do not think so! if that happens then there will be a major inconsistency in characterization which will not make any sense at all!

shyamala i too like the new jodha just because she is caring for our boy😳
Edited by mandyg - 11 years ago
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Beautiful analysis aunty - though I'm unhappy you decided to overlook doctor's orders and do this one.. Hope you get well soon! 🤗

As Shaikh Salim Chisti, looking at Jalal and Jodha kneeling before him, intones Taarikh badalne ke liye betaab hai, aur aap donon ke chehre par khuda ke noor ka taap hai,

It is their first truly shared emotion as husband and wife.

👏

Ek hi dhaaga, ek hi mannat: When Jodha goes to tie the mannat ka dhaga in her turn, her dhaaga is entwined in Jalal's, so too are her fate and her dreams for the future now entwined with his. As if, with that gesture, she was merging herself, out of her own free will, with him and all that was his.

Jalal seems to understand this, if only vaguely, for his face, even in profile, reflects unexpected delight.

Beautifully put aunty...she is happy if he is happy and asks for his happiness without knowing that his happiness lies with her which is what he asks for..a full circle of emotions there! 😃

It is the same with their respective wishes, which are in effect the same: that they should be companions for life. In a revealing mirror image of his dua at Ajmer, Jodha now wants nothing for herself, but only that Shahenshah ki manokaamna poori ho.

Which is in effect herself, her saath all thru the journey of his life, but does she really know that? For Jalal makes his wish soundlessly, and if she knows his man ki baatein, as she claims, she has become clairvoyant where he is concerned!

That little scene is pure delight. When he immediately asks her, as before, what she had sought in her dua, she protests and declares, Hum aapko nahin batayenge! But there is such shy coquetry in the little pout that accompanies this statement, and in the cheeky tilt of her chin as she eyes him, that Jalal, if he was not so preoccupied with trying to learn what she had prayed for, would have been on to this new ada of his Jodha Begum in an instant.

I was mooned by her new adaa... especially the manner in which she's transformed (just like her Badal has) to a perfect Kajri...with her shoulders back and gait royal we're used to seeing her as Jodha Begum...here with a more lively gait and mischief in her manner (including the ease with which she bit the end of her dupata) she's got into the skin of Kajri with no conscious effort whatsoever! 😳

I say this again..the Badal-Kajri track of Jodha akbar has been my favouritest so far... and I am terribly going to miss this camarederie when its gone because we know the evil forces at Agra are just not going to let them be!😭

As it is, he is still in that groove. So he next proposes, with the shy eagerness of a little boy trying to discover what is inside the gift boxes at the foot of the Christmas tree, Agar hum aapko apni murad batayein to kya tab aap apna batayengi? It was so utterly charming and childlike that I was in stitches, and for two pins, I would have dived into the screen and hugged him, as if he had been my Sasha in a similar situation. And if I had been 40 years younger and in Jodha's place, I would have hugged him at once, if in a different spirit😉, and told him not to worry, that he would get everything he had prayed for.

ROFLLL OMG OMG OMG periyamma... 🤣our Jalal is definitely doing things right then, with his various nuances if he managed to get you to wish you were 40 years younger...

oh yes...I confess too.. many-a-day I wish I was 10 years younger myself... 😆

Jodha of course, being a sanskaari 16th century queen, cannot hug her husband in full public view, however much she might have wanted to😉. So she does the next best thing, and proceeds to tease him, by declaring that she knew what he had wished for, Kyonki , Shahenshah, aap man mein bhi itne oonche swar mein bolte hain ki hamein sab sunayi de chuka hai!

Jalal is torn between his dil , which wants to believe that she can read his mind, and hisdimaag, which refuses to do so. So he begins with Jhoot hai, aap sirf baatein bana rahi hain! But as she insists, her eyes fixed unwaveringly on his, that she is not fibbing and shedoes know what he wished for, he ends up (despite her dodging his demand that she tell him), with a wistful, hopeful Kya aap wakayi jaanti hain ki humne kya maanga?

As he watches her eyes fall slowly and her lips widen in a smile, there is a sudden flutter of eagerness in Jalal's face. As Jalal watches this new roop of his Jodha Begum in astonishment, she hides her face with the end of her dupatta, bites it, and flees in shyness and charming confusion.

It is the typical gaon ki gori ka lajaana sharmaana act that has been shown any number of times on the big and small screens, where it nowadays evokes only a yawn. But when Jodha does it, very prettily, it is so unexpected from her that it seems as fresh and appealing as if it had never been seen before.

Aunty, did you catch her flummoxed reactions there.. she didn't EXACTLY know what was in his mind...she was making a guess.. and was in DEFINITELY no mood to reveal it then!😉

Unfortunately for him, Lady Luck, who is a capricious female, has by now decided that she has done enough for him of late😉. So she trips him up neatly just as he is getting set, after a chummy exchange of views with Jodha about the spiritual merits of this retreat, to finally open up to her.

*Sigh*

Jalal is telling Jodha about his hope that their duas would be fulfilled when they both look up. There is Ruqaiya Sultan Begum, barring their path, with an expression of mingled disdain and resentment on her face. The sun is still shining, but shadows have fallen over Camelot.

Nascent posssessiveness: How does Jodha react to this sudden invasion of their togetherness? Why, with distinct dismay. I rewatched that sequence frame by frame, and in the last shot of Jodha, it is clear that she is more than disappointed at having her little idyll with Jalal so rudely disturbed.

Oh yes... only one watching would suffice... the disappointment on BOTH their faces is quite plain to see! It's an apparent 'Oh! SHE's here now?'😆

When she now leaves Jalal and Ruqaiya alone, it is not because she feels that Ruqaiya has a superior claim to Jalal's time and togetherness. It is rather because she fears that Ruqaiya is all set to make a scene, and she does not want Jalal to be embarrassed by her presence.

Whatever the reasons, its gracious that she does so of her own accord and that Ruqs needs repeated Takhliyas from him to get the jist!😊

And when she leaves that khema declaring to Jalal, with a little catch in her voice, that she prefers to sleep in the open air, there is the hurt and the resentment that comes with nascent possessiveness. Not the kind of possessiveness that demands exclusive rights to his time and his attention, but the kind that seeks unfailing regard and caring from him.

That and even the burnt roti scene... our on screen bahus would have downed the burnt rotis themselves and given the Seth and his first wife..fresh clean rotis.. fibbing to make it seem like the first wife had done all the hard work! Thank God she is devoid of all such 'Mahaanta' here and is very down-to-earth... noble, but realistic... 😃

Hamari zid samajhiye ya hamari khushi: Unlike many here, I was also pleased when Jalal, while laying down his rules firmly regarding the return journey, also reassures Ruqaiya that she is his dearest friend and he would be very pleased to have her with him for that journey.

Oh yes... he was quite noble and realistic too..he'd wished she hadn't been there (for a second) but then overcomes such feelings to give his friend the apt choices😃

And this no matter how tiresomely Ruqaiya behaves, for he knows that he is all she has ever had or ever will. I love this trait of his.

Love Jalal and love you for this line! 😛

Jodha understands all this instinctively, and accepts it as part of him, something with which she needs to help him cope. Which is partly why she is so indulgent to Ruqaiya, responding to all her impertinences, big and small, with unwavering calm and good sense.

She will not compound Jalal's problems with any flare ups of her own; so there are now none of the smart retorts with which she used to face down a rude, overbearing Ruqaiya in the past. There is merely the smiling, gentle reasonableness with which a grown up tackles a troublesome child's temper tantrums.

How beautiful... so Jalal and Jodha are the pestered parents here and Ruq their adopted (spoilt) brat! 😆

NB:I do not propose to speculate about why, having this luxurious khema at hand, Ruqaiya was bemoaning her not having a chatai to sit on inside the hut, and shoving Jalal back as she appropriated a good chunk of it. Nor why Jalal, so intent on being an aam aadmi, does not send the khema packing as soon as he sees it.

Nor why travelling as an aam aadmi has to mean sleeping in ramshackle barns. Why can they not stay in a proper sarai, modestly but in relative comfort? An aam aadmi does not have to be literally on the roads! Next, the seth looks prosperous enough, so why can he not have some ready cash for buying provisions for dinner? How long is he planning to live off Jodha's head ornaments (for the necklace, bangles and earrings are gone, to pay the jaziya)?

The whole scenario is plain cuckoo.

Yup! A lot of loopholes... but, not not enough to ruin the flavour of an otherwise beautiful episode 😳

Shades of Panchavati:

Watching all this, and though the parallel, is a loose one, I was suddenly reminded of Sita during those 13 years of exile in the forests with Rama. It has long been accepted wisdom that Sita had made a great sacrifice in abandoning all the comforts of the palace to face the hardships of exile with her husband, but I have never felt so. It is true that Janaki had never before set foot on the hard ground or had her feet bruised by stones or pierced by thorns. She had never had to subsist on fruits and roots for years on end.

Jodha as the Panchavati Sita beautiful parallels here

Andar-baahar: I do not trawl the forum, basically for sheer lack of time, but even on my own last thread, I could sense the outrage among some at Jalal for what seemed like his having let Jodha sleep outside in the cold, while himself sleeping in the comfort of thekhema Ruqaiya has forced on him.

For a moment to begin with, I shared this feeling. That Jalal should have put his foot down and told both his begums that Jodha cannot sleep outside, she is not well and it might not be safe, even if Hoshyiyaar and the baandis Ruqaiya had brought along would be there (the soldiers escorting her would have been left behind). That they could all sleep in here on 3 separate bistars.

But a bit more of consideration produced a different interpretation. Jalal has always, even when he was very angry with Jodha, been very careful about her welfare. He risked his life to save her from the tiger. On this trip, with the newfound closeness between them,usne Jodha ko har waqt palkon par bithaya hai.

Nor is it as though he cannot put Ruqaiya in her place when he wants to. He did assert himself when nullifying Ruqaiya's orders and returning her hoojra to Jodha , He also insisted now that Ruqaiya could come along only if she came as a commoner (with 2baandis, Hoshiyaar and the khema, of course!).

So it would be strange and totally inconsistent if he were suddenly to leave Jodha, who is now so close to his heart, to her own devices outside. In fact he would not have done it even if it had been any other begum of his.

It is very likely that Jalal, not having listened to what Ruqaiya was saying to Jodha, assumed that it was Jodha who would not have wanted to share the khema with him and Ruqaiya. It is a perfectly plausible assumption to make.

Exactly! He didn't listen to their conversation so he knows not what transpired before - though, I do hope he didn't miss Jodha's unhappiness as she stepped out!

The khema doesn't look like it had the provision for a three bed arrangement (at least by going by the AAP principle) - if nothing else, Ruq would have ensured there was NO WAY there was provision for a third bed somewhere around there! Isn't that precisely why she's come in the first place?😉

The whole thing happened quite suddenly - he walks in she walks out... during the Hojra issue he was at a different mind-set and the matter at a different level... here the issue is quite different... it is after all, the first time he's coming to face with all these delicate situations and being a young lad he would need more time and tact to deal with the feuding ego of two loved ones (unlike the science of court politics where one can set aside emotions completely😕)

If nothing else, say he did ask Jodha to stay in the same khema with Ruqaiyya - Jodha wouldn't agree to it because she's too self-respecting to do so and Ruqaiyya wouldn't share her bedspace because she is too proud to do so...obviously, Ruqaiyya is going to refuse to sleep out..I am certain he knows his ladies better than we do... so, with all those option out of the window he possibly let the queens do as they willed - but, at the cost of his sleep and peace, of course!

I took it symbolically 'He let the lady who needed the confines of luxury to have hers - so he could step out in freedom of the open skies and under the stars to be with the one who needed his care, attention and time!'

Let's see how the episode pans out!😃

PS: I am now at the beginning of a bad bout of conjunctivitis, and I have had to do this post,which I wanted to share with you all, in bits and pieces. I will thus not be able to respond, as I always try to do, individually to all those kind enough to add their comments on this thread. But I am sure you will all have a lot of fun arguing among yourselves, so much so that you will not even notice my absence!


How about if someone at home could read the replies to you, while you rested in bed? 😉
Lovely post as always dear 🤗
Edited by lashy - 11 years ago
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
shyamala, do take proper rest please, i hope you feel better!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: lashy

Res

Should you even be doing this now?... should I put up a morcha saying I'm not going to reply because you overlooked the doctor's orders and decided to sit down and write this one... 😕
I'm not happy periyamma!
Please take care of your health dear... it should always come first!



lashy, loved the apnapan in your tone🤗
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mandyg



lashy, loved the apnapan in your tone🤗

Awww thanchoo Mandy 🤗

Gayuraj thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
wow super
awesome update
wonder analysis of episode
loved it

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani · 3 months ago

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman · 6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman · 9 years ago

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".