Hi Mansi, good analysis ... but then u r best (remember award u won)š , so ur analysis has to be good one, right?š
Oooh, I am all puffed up with pride. Someone stick a safety pin into me and let out the hot air! Fast!š
the first scene, perfect... had we got to see what they said in spoiler, that Jo will console him, that would have meant that he will be on his knees and shading tears and Jo gets upset seeing that, and consoles him...and had they shown all this, damn, it would have been too much boring... and as far as I ll analyze Jalal, he will ask for forgiveness, but only after he steadies his own mind ...
and so day before , when we finally had them alone with each other, had i said that he won't ask for forgiveness, but his first question might be, " What do u think u were doing, when u had that poison?" i m sure, if i had written it, Mansi, u may have supported me, but few may not have liked it... many still want him to beg for her forgiveness... and nothing wrong , even i want it... but one thing... Jalal is what he was yest... fierce , proud and arrogant emperor , and he understands himself perfectly... and i think now she too does it and rather likes it more abt him...
Actually I agree with you Diksha I too ddn't want him to as for forgiveness, and neither did Jodha. Technically speaking, not belieiving Jodha's story about ben was not a crime or mistake. For example, you may tell me something that is true but I may not choose to believe it because
a. my intuition tells me there is no proof or
b. I may not be able to digest the fact or
c. I might not take it seriously enough.
So he did not commit a "mistake" by disbelieving her, so he need not apologize, as such.
What he did was an "error in judgement" which now he realises was the wrong way to have assessed the threat. These days it is called "threat perception analysis" and even these days experts get it all wrong!
right
and so not once in all their sweet scenes, he asked her to forgive him.. nor did she expected... had he asked her forgiveness, then she would have forgiven him, but then they couldn't have relaxed with each other , like they did... in fact , Ben being the topic of their discussion , was that both r clearing all her memories once and for all... and the person who took their relationship to nearly breaking point, is now bridging the gap btw them, after her death...
i loved that scene... Jo was clear enough to tell him her feelings...that too twice.. but as i call him, he still is tubelight, where she is concerned... he smells her jealousy, but only through her spoken words, he still can't understand the meaning behind her words..
see firstly , she says, that she would have died happily than losing him... she actually says, aapko khone se ye thik tha... what else he wants to understand where he stands in her life? what importance she gives him?
later , she straight away ask him , when he is her husband, why he can't fulfill her wish? ... he is taken aback at her question... still doesn't understand that she wants him to show his rights as a husband, not just keep asking for her permissions... she wants him to give her , her right place in his life... when he will understand her unspoken words? coz Jo will never speak them, till it will be impossible for her to bear her feelings...
See how far she has come from saying she is doing things for him from kartavya ... to now telling him "I want you to take me outside as you are my husband!" Now she's demanding like a wife and treating him as a husband who won't take offence. Previously she was acting the martyr and treating him like the King rather than a husband!
Lekin Jallu hai ki samaz hi nahi raha... uski Begum ko pati chahiye.. shehenshah nahi...
he keeps enjoying teasing her, thinking and enjoying her jealousy... but at the same time he thinks she should be the one who fills the gap in his heart/life so that no one can come btw them... but not once he thought, how could she do it, when he is the one who till date has been saying he doesn't have a heart... ok, he has accepted, that he loves her, but he still has to understand the depth of the word 'LOVE', and when he finally understand it, only then Jo will lose in him, forever and ever..
abt Ruku, and MA, i m not interested in wasting my precious words, on them . now they r getting overconfident , and r abt to make such mistakes, which will take Jalal away from them... let's wait for the day...
abt that last family get together , then Saleema and Raheem were missing... i would have liked to see Raheem cuddling Jo , that time when Jalal was there... it would have been picture perfect...
Yup, Salima and Rahim should have been there, but good thing Ruq and maham were not there!
Mansi... i read in many posts , including u , that Ruku's words hurt... even to Jo... that she can ask anything but Jalal... yes, it hurts... but then how can Jo ask for Jalal when he is only hers? coz u ask for something which is not urs, not for something which is all urs... right? and wait, one day Jalal himself will say these words to Ruku, Jo just have to be there with him, without saying a single word, claiming her rightful place...
Diksha you just spoke my heart's wishes there!
hearts entwinned ??š
š¤
Edited by sweet_diksha - 11 years ago
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki
Hindi TV Shows
