Weekend Analysis Thread: 7th-11th October

skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Hi friends, how are you are surviving this last week of episodes? Jyoti is busy celebrating Durga Puja, and like a good Bengali she must be eating truck loads of tasty rossogollas one after another (lucky girl!), while I am doing this homework of the Weekend Thread, so I hope you'll will forgive me if I make some mistakes here and there in between my sobbing and crying! Jyoti will join in later (with rossogollas I hope!)

Waise, I wanted to do a list of ten highlights of the week gone by, and my gutter mind was continuously thinking maybe I should make a detailed list of ten places where Tiger Mohan bit Jalal. Because those would have been the Super High Points of the Week! There are four bites we have seen on his face, plus two more on his hand that he showed to Rahim. That makes six bites. Remaining four bites I ll leave you all to fantasize! Let's see who comes up with the best four "spots for hidden bites" on Jalal's utterly edible body ... please rush your answers to this thread!

Accha, now turning more serious, here's my pick of the highlights of this week:

1. The tiger fight and the rescue were well directed!

Last week itself Tiger Mohan was seen prowling round the countryside and this Monday began with a bang. Or rather it did not begin with a bang because Jalal's gun would not work without the bullets that Jodha had removed! So we had a hand-to-hand combat between Jalal and the tiger in which, after getting bitten black and blue, Jalal vanquished the tiger. These scenes are difficult to shoot, we know that, but I am happy overall that it did not look like a botched up job. It was a reasonably well shot and directed sequence and the tiger fight at least looked credible. The wounds on Jalal's face and body also looked reasonably credible, and not like pasted on Plaster of Paris (execpt one or two). So all in all I'd give about 70% marks for the tiger sequence. The rescue part by Jodha also was nice, especially where they are on horseback and she holds his face to keep him close to her! And the dialogues by Jalal in his "breathless husky voice" were sexy! It was brilliant that in that dying declaration Jalal forgot Maham totally as he mentioned Ruq, Hamida and even Jodha! Monday was good except for one thing that sorely disappointed the viewers ...


2. The outdoorsy wound-nursing did not happen!

Yes, we were all given the impression that Jalal and Jodha would adjourn to some convenient tabela in the forest, they would light a cozy bonfire and there Jodha would tend to his wounds amidst lots of very coochey-coo moaning sounds from Jalal - and then Jodha would blow soft air on to make them feel better etc. etc. etc. Unfortunately nothing of the sort happened! Instead the soldiers rushed Jalal back to Agra as fast as they could and only strange part was it looked like the Creatives forgot to put Jodha on a horse because when she arrived at Agra she looked as if she had walked the whole way back! Jalal's family took over the whole scene and Jodha was left looking very guilty on the sidelines, and although Jodha had nightmarish visions earlier of having to tell the family that Jalal was dead, in fact he was still very much alive and so the viewers were given about two and half episodes of Jalal without a shirt and covered only in leaves! Jodha got three tights slaps from Ruq - which was also one of the high points of the week.

3. Agra patient hungama and the bad sides of everybody!

Accha, this is my favourite part, how everyone reacted when the patient arrived in Agra. Firstly Adham started making plans to ascend the throne! Then his mother took charge of the army in full style, looking like a hilltop Hitler, and giving a speech which was full of "naaraas". The ending of the speech with the hurrahs to the emperor were straight out of C-Grade war movies, and I have a strong feeling that the soldiers below were yawning throughout this fiery but demotivating speech. Meanwhile of course, the Rajvanshi enemies were acting as if it was Christmas, and everyone was ready to uncork the champagne in anticipation of Jalal's death (all except Maharana Pratap who was sorely missed in this sequence by me!). Here in the Agra palace, bandhis were gossipping about the state of the Shahenshah, some harem begums led by Salima were getting ready to eat a full meal and then consume poison (which again Ruq wanted to be the "first" to do!) and some other desperate harem ladies who never had a chance yet with the Emperor thought it would make amends for their lack of time with the Shahenshah if they could run away with the jewelry at least! Jodha and Kanha were inseparable, and Hamida showed that her hysteria was as good as Mainavati's ...

4. Hamida shows her screwed up "Jodha priorities"!

One of the lowest (rather than highest) points this last week was how Hamida Banu showed her desperation to get Jodha safely out of the clutches of those who would like to kill her, when her own son Jalal was dying and the Hakim had barely given him one more day to live! I have already done an exhaustive post on this topic because this sequence defied all logic! Was it an oversight on the part of the Creatives to make Hamida show her screwed up priorities? Or was Hamida so gone on Jodha that as Jalal himself once said "She loves Jodha more than she loves me!" ... In the end of course, Jodha managed to save herself by making some miracle lep and curing Jalal, but even in that situation how Hamida could accept some amateur lep made by Jodha as a last resort cure for a dearest son who was on his last legs was a total mystery. The character of Hamida got assassinated, and by association, the character of Jodha too was not at its shiniest! The whole situation smacked of the incredulous!

5. Adham, Sharif, their stupidity and their soldiers!

I loved the interludes we had with Adham Khan and Sharifuddin and their whole band of buffoons! First of all Adham did the foolhardiest thing and called his wife "Fatima" and then searched around for other names till he got around to her real name Javeeda! Thankfully the wife was sillier than the husband and was only interested to see if the necklace he gave her was a fake or not! Then Sharifuddin somehow sprang into the room from behind the curtains! And both the men started saying "Do you want Agra or Delhi?" as if they already had the kingdom and only they needed to ink the contract! Then both congratulated each other that their soldiers were stationed on the road to Agra to prevent the Gwalior Hakim from reaching Agra and saving Jalal. Thus they were going to capture Delhi and Agra between themselves. For this wonderful plan, they had both selected some bony-puny soldiers who looked like they had not eaten for months - and when the two sets of soldiers then suspected each other and began a roadside warfare, the Hakim escaped to Agra to help Jalal in a spectacle that was this week's finest moment! But look at Adham and Sharif after that. When they both discovered that their plans had gone kaput and Jalal was alive, they both gave dramatic speeches with narrowed eyes of "intezaar karenge" as if it was a wonderful new idea! What other choices did the two duffers have?

6. Hakimery at its finest was on full display!

I enjoyed myself this week with my post on the Bada Hakim from Gwalior, the Chota Hakim from the local garden shed, and the Hakimlette (Jodha) and how the three of them did their quackery to save Jalal. The only redeeming feature of this whole display of medicine-men-and-women and their leps and leaves and flowers decorating Jalal's wounds, was the fact that we were able to see glimpses of the bare-bodied Jalal quite a lot and were greatly satisfied with what we saw! Jalal in clothes looks good, but Jalal without clothes looks even better! Meanwhile, the scene of Jodha learning lep-making from the self-same Gwalior Hakim in Amer, where he was brought by none other than Chugtai Khan, was all a bit too much to swallow. It was again one of those unbelievable spins of yarn that Jodha would have learnt it all from the same Hakim, and that Hakim would then just smell Jodha Ka Lep and say only Jodha could have made it! And while the Hakim had been brought all the way to cure Jalal who was breathing his last, the Hakim was actually wasting time telling everybody the story of Sujamal's injury in a similar shikar incident! On the whole this treatment and cure of Jalal was very badly scripted and directed and I would give it just about 30% marks (all 30% for showing Jalal's bare body and nothing for the rest of the cast and the script!)



7. Ruq getting distraught, the Amer shaadi and the flirty Jalal!

The episodes on Thursday and Friday also brought us the high points of Jalal getting well and Ruq getting increasingly distraught. First the shots that showed how Ruq ran to Jalal's side after hearing he was so critically injured were beautiful at first glance, and I remember even feeling very sorry for Ruq for she looked like a young girl about to lose her dearest friend and she had in fact no other family! But on second glance all the flashbacks we were shown of Ruq's childhood with Jalal were about when they both were barely 8 or 9 years old. There were no flashbacks of them in their teens, adolescence or middle years? I wondered at the time why that was so? And then it occurred to me that may be this was the weak link in the Jalal-Ruq relationship. They were both in a time warp, they had forged their bond at 8-9 years of age, and the bond had probably not grown into something else over the years! At least that was the symbolism I got from the flashbacks!

Then Maham started poisoning Ruq's ears against Jodha and her growing closeness with Jalal after the Ajmer trip. After that, Jodha did the miraculous by making people forget the bullet-removal issue by succeeding with the lep issue. Ruq must have already felt checkmated by Jodha, especially after she had earlier landed three triumphant slaps across Jodha's face for endangering Jalal's life.

Anyway in the Thursday episode out came the story of how Jalal had himself found the rishta for Sukanya. As if that was not enough, in the Friday episode, Ruq seemed to get more and more insecure as Jalal overruled her diktat and accepted to go to Amer, and then Jalal pullled that "joke" on her about being in love with Jodha to see how she reacted before saying it was just a joke. Now the Amer trip sans Ruq is in the offing and Ruq must be surely feeling that Jalal was slipping away (Jyoti, I am happy to tell you that I noticed the sunset as a symbolism of the sunset of their relationship!)

I have already done a detailed post on this whole Jalal-Ruq disenchantment that is on the way to happening while the Jalal-Jodha flirty side has seemingly begun. My premise on my post has been that Jalal now is ready to take his relationship with Jodha one step further (even if it's not yet love) and he has got flirty, but on the other side he senses Ruq's possible alarm and has yesterday done this "joke" story to check out how disturbed Ruq may be about his growing closeness with Jodha.

Whatever may be Jalal's situation and whether or not he is in love yet, he is at least being careful not to get too serious with Jodha in a hurry nor to hurt Ruq too badly in the process. As long as he seems in control of what he is doing we can all enjoy the Amer trip. Hope they are given a single bedroom to share by Mainavati!
There now, I'm done with my take. All of you can now pitch in and have a ball!
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

3.4k

Users

15

Likes

71

Frequent Posters

StardustSandy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
U covered all highlights nothing much is left to say 😊
elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Wonderful post mansi...
Yes it is difficult to say whether he is in love with J or not! !!!!!! but surely he too must be thinking why
he keeps thinking and reacting and talking abt Jodha all the time?...

One thing is sure that he is slipping away from the cluches of Ruku and MA..
Edited by elasingh - 11 years ago
Star_girl thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Ooh, lovely. 👏 You have pretty much said it all and so beautifully. I don't know why but Jalal's expressions were rather strange last night while confessing about his supposed love for Jodha. It is supposed to be a joke, or is it? He seemed very intense and weirdly resigned. I have a good feeling about this. 😉
Oh, and happy Durga Puja to both you and Jyoti. 😊

Edit- can I ask you something? I have been freaking out over the fake-love track. Do you suppose it will happen? With my experience in Ekta shows, I think it can. But the fact remains that she hates, hates making her heroines pine after the hero. It is the job of the hero himself. So I live in hope. What do you figure?
Edited by Star_girl - 11 years ago
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Maano_billi

U covered all highlights nothing much is left to say 😊

There is something you can add ... how about guessing the hidden spots where Tiger Mohan has bitten Jalal! C'mon, give us your best guess! And don't feel shy!😉
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: elasingh

Wonderful post mansi...

Yes it is difficult to say whether he is in love with J or not! !!!!!! but surely he too must be thinking why
he keeps thinking and reacting and talking abt Jodha all the time?...

One thing is sure that he is slipping away from the cluches of Ruku and MA..

Yes that sunset was symbolic of the waning relationship of Jalal-Ruq. By the end of that talk with Ruq Jalal's expression was like "OK, I have seen what she will be like if I have this Jodha relationship. But kya karen, life must go on, and I cannot stop myself from going towards Jodha"
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Thanks very much!😛
BerryBlush07 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: skanda12

Thanks very much!😛

U r welcum 😛 😆...btw...i have always wondered...how do u ppl type sooo much 😲
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Star_girl

Ooh, lovely. 👏 You have pretty much said it all and so beautifully. I don't know why but Jalal's expressions were rather strange last night while confessing about his supposed love for Jodha. It is supposed to be a joke, or is it? He seemed very intense and weirdly resigned. I have a good feeling about this. 😉

Oh, and happy Durga Puja to both you and Jyoti. 😊

Edit- can I ask you something? I have been freaking out over the fake-love track. Do you suppose it will happen? With my experience in Ekta shows, I think it can. But the fact remains that she hates, hates making her heroines pine after the hero. It is the job of the hero himself. So I live in hope. What do you figure?

Did you see my post on this topic? Its at:

"The "revenge love game" theory seems wrong!"
Lots of people have also added their views on this thread!
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: BerryBlush07

U r welcum 😛 😆...btw...i have always wondered...how do u ppl type sooo much 😲

My job involves a lot of reports writing and all that so I have to type fast to keep deadlines! Becomes a habit!

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: hemakeerti

4 months ago

FF: Pale Blue Dot Thread 6/19/2025 Chapter 44 Part2

Hemakeerti OSes - Compiled PBD INDEX Prologue Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Chapter 9 Chapter...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

2 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Shinning_Stuti

5 years ago

Thread 3: Destined Love... (Chapter 61 updated)

Prologue: How it happens when both the hearts fall for each other madly without knowing each other? He is the emperor of the great Mughal...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: hemakeerti

11 months ago

FF: Pale Blue Dot Thread 02/16/2025 Chapter43 - Part2 Updated

Hemakeerti OSes - Compiled PBD INDEX Prologue Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Chapter 5 Chapter 6 Chapter 7 Chapter 8 Chapter 9 Chapter...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".