Judge Comments & Marks--Any connection?? - Page 2

Sorry to say but the judges really dunno how to score dem....

Shakky said to Harshit that he was off the sur from start till ending...and gave him 9 marks??? i mean whats this???

Unfortunately they aint doing justice to their judgement..!!

Toshi sang better than rahull yesterday...but still got less marks than him...??? its so unfair..

Originally posted by: Donny COMB

Sorry to say but the judges really dunno how to score dem....

Shakky said to Harshit that he was off the sur from start till ending...and gave him 9 marks??? i mean whats this???

Unfortunately they aint doing justice to their judgement..!!

Toshi sang better than rahull yesterday...but still got less marks than him...??? its so unfair..

toshi was very good yday..i was surprised with rahuls mks...the commnts were opposite completely

saara...i luvv ur sigg..srkkk sooo adorable😳😳

Originally posted by: the_charm

Yeah thats what I've been wondering forever. Specially Shekhar's marks. No offense to him and his fans (which also includes me).

includes me 2😆

Originally posted by: silverspike

I think the marks that the singer get is absolutely correct...We have to remember that the caliber of singers in JJWS is the best of the bests so even if the judges critisize dosent mean its the worst...if you hear these performances in live or in some other show you might not even find the mistakes..Remember they are now singing with gr8s like udit, shaan etc...so now they are getting compared with them...i think 10 should be given to only those performances when its absolutely outstanding....By giving 9 they are just raising the bar of singing.

but u knw sometimes the judges criticize a lottttt n the mks r opp!

Originally posted by: slash

i believe that they have differnt rules for different singers which is not right ...


i am seriously baffled with the way farah scores .. its weird and funny at times

dun think diff rules for diff singers...

Originally posted by: koolgal_anisha

They do....its just dat how u comprehend it.... u cant expect 'em to just say good good things they are there to criticise as well n wen they say sumthing lyk dis was missing dat was missing or dis was wrong dsnt mean dat the performance ws as bad as to be thrown outta d window ...its juss abt as good as 8-9 n those criticism is wat they lacked to reach to the "10" so i dun feel marks n commenst r completely different they r surely related
i agree they hv 2 critic
the Judges arent dumb u know..!!

i agree they criticize its gud for the singers but yday they criticized toshi less n gav him lesser mks and the amt they criticized rahul n his mks were higher

Originally posted by: silverspike

I think the marks that the singer get is absolutely correct...We have to remember that the caliber of singers in JJWS is the best of the bests so even if the judges critisize dosent mean its the worst...if you hear these performances in live or in some other show you might not even find the mistakes..Remember they are now singing with gr8s like udit, shaan etc...so now they are getting compared with them...i think 10 should be given to only those performances when its absolutely outstanding....By giving 9 they are just raising the bar of singing.

Yeah got that...I told ya, only Vineet fans will find them fair enough...but if u look closely...hardly any one really agreed with u....

Originally posted by: msuns

Yeah got that...I told ya, only Vineet fans will find them fair enough...but if u look closely...hardly any one really agreed with u....

i agree wid u

lol but im ot a vinnet fan im no bodys fan actually im a neutral person so will gv a neutral opinion which usually favours d judges cuz frm the angle frm which i see i dun find d judging unfair..!

Originally posted by: msuns

Yeah got that...I told ya, only Vineet fans will find them fair enough...but if u look closely...hardly any one really agreed with u....

please dun start ne argument talkin bt vineet fans or this fan or that fan...

my topic is just in general..and im not even a vineet fan..i do find him k but not his fan!

Originally posted by: msuns

Yeah got that...I told ya, only Vineet fans will find them fair enough...but if u look closely...hardly any one really agreed with u....

I can say same is happening with you...may be your Fav is not getting as many marks as vinit is getting...so your disappointed...But it true that the level of singing in this show is preety high so marks should 10 when the sining is outstanding!!