do u understand these judges?

farah khan - for her i wud just say "lik a blind man cannot pass judgement on a painting - the deaf lady should not pass judgements on singing"

her biggest example- "sur vur jayein bhaad mein?"

she doesnot knw ny abcd of music....a very biased lady....

she was i think judging himani's character rather than her singin.....in her opinion baghban is a very uncommon nd unheard song....then wot bout o re piya?????strange yaaa

vishal and shekhar - guys....u gotta check this out.....wen they were in c2005...they gave many of the singers shocking marks....like wen sumedha sang aao huzur (full on besura, really...) they gave her 9....she dint deserve 9 there...she was besuri right frm the beginin of the song

here evn wen sum 1 does a minor mistake..they wud cut their marks....like wen abhijeet sang "taare zameen par". i think there was a minor pitching problem and vishal gave him 9......

kucch bhi ho raha hai....

i think vs are afraid of opposing farah as she wont give them work afterwards😆😆😆

plz. give sum more examples if u guys agree wid me

I am in agree. 😆

Farah seems to be present in this show to comment on aspects that has nothing to do with singing. Like Vineet's age, Priyani's outfit, Ishmeet's closed eyes, Himani's scripted strategy and last but not the least Neha's tantrums and height. 😆 😕 😛

While VS judging seems inconsistent. Sometimes correct...mostly wrong.

they r singers they knw exactly all details even minute details they observe...thats what a true musician or snger is

we cnt say that we judge bttr than them otherwise they wudnt reach such heights

neway thats my personal opinion

but i feel these 3 r the best judges right on the face

It was not VISHAL

It was SHEKHAR

Maybe Abhijeet is not in his good book anymore

Originally posted by: amsjms

It was not VISHAL

It was SHEKHAR

Maybe Abhijeet is not in his good book anymore

oh yes.....sorry bout that...

Originally posted by: rashi85

they r singers they knw exactly all details even minute details they observe...thats what a true musician or snger is

we cnt say that we judge bttr than them otherwise they wudnt reach such heights

neway thats my personal opinion

but i feel these 3 r the best judges right on the face

i m not opposing u but this is my opinion.....that if they are very honest here then y werent they in c2005??? were they carried away by the other judges in the show?

Please be mindful of the language used towards the judges... No posts bashing judges/contestants shall be entertained... You sure can give your opinion, but to call someone a deaf lady or such is totally uncalled for... Please refrain from such remarks and express your views appropriately...

Topic Closed