amit tandon's performance was horrible. - Page 2

Originally posted by: smallwonder

he may not be that good, but i like his fighting spirit... its not easy to take all those harsh comments and low scores and keep being reminded that u r undeserving... the way vishal told him that u r the weakest and shud be eliminated was not a great thing to do... And yet, he went back saying he will try to show wat he has come here for - that was a great spirit... and after all "jo jeeta, wohi superstar" 😉

okay, i do agree with your points. he did take the criticism very well. some of the other contestants would've had a negative response to it.

well isnt the concept of the show for all the weaker competitors to be eliminated and the "stronger" one to be the winner?? 😕

this isn't a school........its a competition.....where every week someone is eliminated and at the end there is ONE winner. and even in the bigger marathons you have to have a certain time in order to qualify the race...otherwise your not able to run the marathon.

Originally posted by: mittijalebi

well isnt the concept of the show for all the weaker competitors to be eliminated and the "stronger" one to be the winner?? 😕

this isn't a school........its a competition.....where every week someone is eliminated and at the end there is ONE winner. and even in the bigger marathons you have to have a certain time in order to qualify the race...otherwise your not able to run the marathon.

Originally posted by: smallwonder

no, the concept is not essentially for the strongest to win - if that were the case, the last thing they would have opted for would be "public voting"... as for qualifying, it was for the show producers to decide that... the fact that he is on the show means that the channel considers him qualified enough to be there... now once that is so, he is well entitled to an equal opportunity to win! most definitely - i am not lobbying for an amit tondon's win... all that i am saying is, once they have him there, they need to show some respect...

well we all know that with public voting its not the strongest who wins, but the most popular. but even in that sense amit has no chance of winning.

and who says that he's not getting an equal opportunity to win. just b/c he was told that he was the weakest and the next to go doesn't mean that they'r not giving him the same chance as the others. the judges are there to give their opinion.......whether its by the marks that they're giving or the remarks. by praising a better singer and criticising a weaker one they are not taking away anyone's opportunity.

i don't think they showed him any disrespect. but i do agree taht amit took the criticism very well. 👏

His voice is totally not for singing.. and his attitude stinks when he is performing.. he doesnt deserve to be singing in this competition..but still wish him luck and hope he improves...

Originally posted by: rashi85

I saw JJWS first time yday...and i was surprsied by amit singing..he is soo bad...i actually thought he must have improved over the years..........he was reallly bad...

I ont b surprised if he is out the next round