Anyone missing Madhuri? - Page 2

I am not a very big fan of md but post seeing Jacky I have realized that md is the best option as a female celebrity judge. She has experience too, she has her own stature which makes her earn the respect of being called a judge. You tend to listen and accept her comments, in Jacky place it is enforced upon you.

My choice as judges would be MD, Karan and Ganesh. Not that I really like Karan but then he sometimes is bearable only if he stops dancing every now and then. If purely on dance then MD, Remo and Terrence - my all time favourite.

Originally posted by: shinningstar

thank god madhuri is gone too much of madhuri jaap by all celebs on the show...plz get rid of ganesh hegde too. y cudn't they get ganesh acharya instead or vaibhavi merchant...better still let salman win this year then next year make him the judge as he's simply awesome

I understand what you wanna say. Yup last time the madhuri jaap has become excessive even when I was watching So You Think I felt Madhuri is just looking for opportunities to dance. Also too much of her is also not likeable. It seems as if we are watching not the contestants but her all together coz half the time she is in front of the camera. It seems as if she wants to grab the limelight which she not but the contestants deserve. But then she is 1000 times better than Jacky. So comparison wise its better to bring in MD.

Why make Salman a contestant he should actually been a judge. I think his experience and knowledge would have made him a much better judge than the current ones.

Madhuri pooja was OTT and very irritating. So no.

Originally posted by: ProudRSfan

I understand what you wanna say. Yup last time the madhuri jaap has become excessive even when I was watching So You Think I felt Madhuri is just looking for opportunities to dance. Also too much of her is also not likeable. It seems as if we are watching not the contestants but her all together coz half the time she is in front of the camera. It seems as if she wants to grab the limelight which she not but the contestants deserve. But then she is 1000 times better than Jacky. So comparison wise its better to bring in MD.

Why make Salman a contestant he should actually been a judge. I think his experience and knowledge would have made him a much better judge than the current ones.

Well, for that matter, they would do jaap of ANY actor they bring - that is a standard routine... For instance, should they get kajol - they would worship kajol, shud they get govinda - they wud worship govinda... Thats the way these shows are - they treat their judges like that - ever praising, all the time dancing to their songs and stuff... Leaving that aside, I thought madhuri was charming... She looked stunning all the time and had a star presence about her... Not like Jacq who just doesnt know how to handle herself - swooning over guys, allowing manish to say anything to her, wanting to count her songs all the time, waiting to dance... If pure judging is concerned, I would love to have Saroj Khan there... She judged nach baliye 1 and was so unique in her judging style... Her comments were so raw yet potent... She was blunt when she needed to be, she praised when she had to, she was fair as a judge...

Originally posted by: lostNfound

I skipped last season, after Madhuri was replaced. I was the perfect judge for a dance show like Jhalak. Best thing about her was despite being critical about performances she would also always have something encouraging to say to the participants.

Thats a good point you make 😛

nope...madhuri jaap was boring though her comments were better than jacky

I would like to see vaibhavi Merchant . She is such a graceful and pleasent personality. Even her judgements are detailed and warming. She always keeps on encourage tyhe contestants.

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Well, for that matter, they would do jaap of ANY actor they bring - that is a standard routine... For instance, should they get kajol - they would worship kajol, shud they get govinda - they wud worship govinda... Thats the way these shows are - they treat their judges like that - ever praising, all the time dancing to their songs and stuff... Leaving that aside, I thought madhuri was charming... She looked stunning all the time and had a star presence about her... Not like Jacq who just doesnt know how to handle herself - swooning over guys, allowing manish to say anything to her, wanting to count her songs all the time, waiting to dance... If pure judging is concerned, I would love to have Saroj Khan there... She judged nach baliye 1 and was so unique in her judging style... Her comments were so raw yet potent... She was blunt when she needed to be, she praised when she had to, she was fair as a judge...

Well yes how can I forget Saroj Khan. She can be a part too of this show.

You said it right the any female judge comes they are gonna do her pooja. Why don't they stick to the dance competition like some fun elements are good but they try and do excessive drama. Judges dancing now and then, idiotic competition for god sake when you have such great contestants then let them have limelight. Why to enforce the judges down our throat that is the reason why some ppl think Jhalak is better of MD. But same sought of thing is now happening with Jacky.

I dont understand why people have problem with madhuri jaap!! Not to forget she is a superstar. If salman, srk or aamir were to judge a show, would there be no jaap? C'mmon guys!

Originally posted by: smallwonder

Thats a good point you make 😛