deep0909 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
a few things
- how biased JDJ8 is! shamita is a very graceful dancer. And a treat to watch. However I dont understand the judges handing out 10s for average performances of hers! what part of her act got her 40 ? The rest of the contestants are all lumped together and handed out numbers. Mohit, sanaya performed just as well as shamita. Yet they got lower numbers.
And in that continuous dancing round - she won! against faisal and vaishnavi? I guess the judges should realize that the audience also have eyes and can see whats going on! another couple got eliminated for doing too many lifts. I guess lifts are a way to give the contestant a breather. and shamita and her choreo did as many lifts as that other couple and still won! ridiculous

- I very much doubt if Sanaya will win JDJ8. Please dont get me wrong I love Sanaya. Here is why, She is getting terrible marks from the judges. And they dont explain why. what kind of comment is " I expected more" . more what? u are a judge u need to qualify. Also none of them had any negative comment on the dance itself. not one of them. but still rated her low.same as that new entrant lady who looked like she was doing some kind of exercise. she looked so stressed! so what I dont get about the judges is how do you give marks without explaining a lil bit about why so the contestant can improve themselves

Low marks could be a ploy by the channel to get her massive following to send more SMS. and hence set the cash registers ringing! So one thing is for sure. they will surely have sanaya in the finals but keep her marks low so the fans spend some moolah.

But the crown itself?...

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

7.1k

Users

34

Likes

231

Frequent Posters

Anju.. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
One thing is sure..judges being biased to shamita is known to all,infact they made it very obvious
they praise her as if she is the only good dancer in the entire world
abt sanaya winning trophy...if they go by ACTUAL votes sanaya is pakka winner..its well known that sanaya gets maximum votes even malaika mentioned it
however winning by cunning methods is equal to losing
losing with fair play is equal to Winning
whiteMagic thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Shamita is favoured. Period. But she is a good dancer and saying shamita's act was equal to sanaya's act.. really
It was far better than sanaya's. Shamita deserve to be here. Sanaya is here because she gets a lots of votes and can even win the trophy no matter how she perform
Ankudi15 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
comparing shamita to faizal is still fine but i agree wiyh judges that she was gud
and giving her best competition to faizal

noone can be as good as faizal here they can only challenge him by giving their best .

i have seen other reality shows like nach baliye where amruta and himanshu won despit the fact that they were remotely known before but yet they deserved andaudience also voted accd.and made them win

so you never know that despite sanaya 's huge fan following online ...the overall audience makes other contestant the winner

but that is not happening as it is colors and it is never fair .
waise shamita is better than sanaya in terms of dancing..no doubt about that
PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
judges are biased judges are biased 🥱 god so what... they are giving marks to shamita but what will shamita do with those marks achaar dala gi kyaa..
performance acha ho ya naa ho kya farak padta hain it is all in votes 😆

and i agree with whiteMagic comments shamita has more grace in dance than sanaya/mohit and her choreographer is way more talented...

JDJ winner will sure be based on votes than marks ... so it is of no use if shamita gets 40 and others get less 😆


Edited by -PD- - 9 years ago
947708 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
If judges are biased towards shamita then should be a reason because her dances are better than others .
But my personal fav this week was Faisal so he got final ticket good going judges and next 2 best is Anita and mohit so judged accordingly .
I don't understand why ppl are irked with special attention to shamita given by judges but voting we know result will be way different average performance will get because of popularity even though jai lacked in choreography couldn't balance 2 stars and horror act both had no innovation jai is playing safe because his acts were never gone out of comfort level as we audience expect or judges .
Edited by rs.shailu29 - 9 years ago
monaya_sajan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -PD-

judges are biased judges are biased🥱god so what... they are giving marks to shamita but what will shamita do with those marks achaar dala gi kyaa..

performance acha ho ya naa ho kya farak padta hain it is all in votes😆

and i agree withwhiteMagiccomments shamita has more grace in dance than sanaya/mohit and her choreographer is way more talented...

JDJ winner will sure be based on votes than marks ... so it is of no use if shamita gets 40 and others get less😆






True JDJ winner is based on votes rather than marks! but who is to say that the votes received are the real ones n not the manipulated ones? I mean, is it e1 possible that Vivian could have got out had it been fair and square voting? e1 the voting system of JDJ cannot be trusted! 🤢
PD_forums thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: monaya_sajan




True JDJ winner is based on votes rather than marks! but who is to say that the votes received are the real ones n not the manipulated ones? I mean, is it e1 possible that Vivian could have got out had it been fair and square voting? e1 the voting system of JDJ cannot be trusted! 🤢


@bold i am not surprised much when vivan went out... i still feel he got less votes unfortunately
Pari-sona thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
If shamita deserve to stay here then sanaya also deserve to stay her by saying this sanaya is here only becoz of her populartity is an insult to her hardwork n the improvment she had shown in this stage.She did not take her popularity granted but she also equally doing hardwork just like other contestant.she also gave some awesome performences for that she got two times POTW n one time IB.Everyone saying jai is a week choreo then tell me getting a gracefull dancer like shamita did Deepak realy gave her out of the box concept which faisal choreo did.Jai atleast tried diffrent concept but the choreo who played safe is deepak he never tried any diffrent concept most of his acts r copy from the orginal song steps.Is this a brilliant choreographer sign.Shamita is a good dancer but being good dancer is the only criterea on this stage then scarlett also deserve to stay here n why did faisal choreo present diffrent concepts everytime when faisal is an awesome dancer no need to do that na.And about judges favouring shamita then yes shamita is the most favoured contestant this season n everyone can see it clear. how much some people try to defend nobody can denied that forgetting steps she get 38 marks in made in India episode n giving medicore acts she never score less than 36.In the end i want to say If u dont like some1 is ok but atleast dont disrespect her hardwork tagging that she is here only becoz of her popularity.
947708 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Every season judges have there own fav 's but they never won judges are there to judge but real game is voting .
If judges were main then scarlet never would have exit .
Jdj main game is voting why should ppl get irked with shamita praised on stage .
Please everyone works equally hard no one does charity here whole day they burn there body to give the best not one contestant alone does the hard work shows off in all performance.
But good choreography wins judges heart simple funda
Edited by rs.shailu29 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".