Kids deserve 30??? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

Honestly when it comes to the kids, I am confused about their marks.

A part of me thinks they should get 30, because the level of difficulty is so high, and they are very very talented at such a young age.

I do notice the mistakes in their acts, but there Is always an internal debate If marks shoud be cut or not.

I mean there are some contestants who get a 30 for an act where they are just hanging from a pole and waving their hand as if they're Queen Elizabeth at a parade. So on that basis, if those kinds of act can get 30, then kids deserve 100 points 😆

So I am on the fence on this one.

The problem is not with 30, or the actual act. The problem is with the judges, they themselves are confused creatures who don't even know what they are saying/doing half of the time.

I love how judges discredit someone for their mistakes and take extra marks off but then conveniently overlooks them for certain people.

Agree.Judges r biased at times.Kids case so much lifting and they have done the same in IGT.Chrographer should make them dance more than lift.

Well, yes, they do have some flaws in their dancing. Their forte is salsa, which is very fast paced and energetic, and when they try to to classical, Kathak in this case, they don't quite pull off that grace and polish in each step that should come with classical dancing.

But, the thing is that the judges don't really critique the classical dance steps that severely. Madhuri Dixit basically showers everyone who even attempts classical with superfluous compliments, and Remo might make a comment now and then. I was glad when he pointed out Sana's weird Kathakali bit (i thought I was the only one who hated it until he commented). And Sonali/Sumant's south indian classical inspired dance where they painted themselves bronze? Anyone remember that? Well, that one had a lot of difficult lifts and stunts, but the actual dance part was mediocre. Sonali and Sumant don't have the right body language. They rush each step and their only strong point is how fast they can dance. But the judges didn't see that and gave them perfect scores. And in Mukti's Jaan Ke Liye Dance this week, she did a lot of Bharatanatyam adavus, and she had the PERFECT body language, but no one even pointed that out. They just said they liked her dancing better than Sidharth's but no one freaking pointed that out!! So, I guess that is kind of the reason why? The judges don't really pay close enough attention to the classical dances.

That being said, I am a fan of theirs. No one can beat them when it comes to doing lifts or the fast paced dances that they do, but it's just their classical pieces that pissed me off. It lacks finesse.

They are showing same stuff. same lifts etc.. High time was ask them to provide something else.. Just like Karan said.

At their young age, I think its hard for them to be good at classical and salsa. Two completely different and diverse forms.

I think judges should ask them not to use any lifts atleast in one of they act. 🤔

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

At their young age, I think its hard for them to be good at classical and salsa. Two completely different and diverse forms.

Im sure by the time they are 20 years old they will be good in everything.

Agreed.. the act ws full of flaws.. agreed dt dey are kids but mistakes are mistakes.. and the judges shld point dem out so dt dey cn improve and becm better dancers.. we all knw nobody cn cm close to der lifts but der dance spclly sonali needs plenty of improvement.. her solo bit in the beginning and also wen both of dem wer dancing together completely lacked finesse and grace.. she often doesnt complete her steps and just hurries on to the next.. dey are exceptionally gifted but mistakes if not pointed out will only grow bigger wid time.. and i also agree Sumanth never gets the praise he deserves.. madhuri is always full of praises for sonali .. she at times goes to the stage and showers sonali wid hugs and kisses and da other kid is left behind.. at times i really feel bad for him.. both are kids dey shld be given equal attention.. cnt understand the step motherly attitude towards sumanth..

I just feel...that they lost co-ordination so many times... hadn't remo pointed out about co-ordination...I wouldn't have minded but... since he SAID that their co-ordination was lovely...I felt like WHAT??