Nicole’s Injury a Hoax to get votes - Page 4

I only believe that in today's time of Paparazzi like Indian Media and the competition between rival channels, it is difficult to openly bluff about something like that on national TV. If she is not injured and saying so then she is sure to get caught by the noosy media people and the rival channels too have their traps.
Yes, but I do agree that an exageration is possible coz you can get injured but the degree of injury can be told only by the sufferer.
However it is the humane thing to do and give her the benefit of doubt. Mathey Hadden scored a 100 with a broken toe, malcom marshall had taken 5 wickets with a fractured toe. Goal keeper of chelsea played with a broken skull bone ! Kumble bowled with a broken jaw bone !
When all these miracles are possible, then someone dancing with a little injury in today's advanced medicine field is very easily possible.

And I am not a ronit fan (nor anyone elses) but I believe in looking for the positivity.

Originally posted by: ovaltine

This entire topic has been posted and discussed before. Since the show is produced under license from BBC, I am sure there are certain rules that have to be adhered too. This would include all injury claims.
If the audience are not happy they should contact SONY directly.
None of the IF members are the producers of the show. You can't ask a member to produce documentation to support an occurence reported by the channel on national tv. All members can do is post their opinions and there are always two sides to any matter.
As far as asking for medical proof is concerned, present your medical qualifications to the channel and better still get a court order to release and view the relevant medical reports etc.
Better still please report it directly to BBC who own the license to the show.
The channel and the producer of the show have a reputation to uphold. If the channel is involved in misinformation, then legal action should be taken by the viewers.
Today there is a report that Sandhya has injured her ribcage, and she is wearing a chest strap. So is she succumbing to sympathy vote tactics?
At the end of the day, fans always back their contestants and others go against. But there is no reason to keep arguing on the same topic when it will yield no result and the query should in fact be direct at the channel itself SONY because only they have all the answers.

As per you if BBC and Sony can be manipulated by Balaji and Ekta to bring Prachi back, I think they can be manipulated to not dig deep when an contestant clearly overhypes an injury. When Nicole was asked by the judges if she was alright to perform as she seems to be a little injured, Ronit chimed in and said it is not a little injury but a very severe one and went on to describe the severity of the injury. One week after that Nicole was in high heels giving a really high voltage performance flawlessly and got a 30. They had to have practiced it for a week. So when did she recover. This whole thing smells really badly.

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

I only believe that in today's time of Paparazzi like Indian Media and the competition between rival channels, it is difficult to openly bluff about something like that on national TV. If she is not injured and saying so then she is sure to get caught by the noosy media people and the rival channels too have their traps.
Yes, but I do agree that an exageration is possible coz you can get injured but the degree of injury can be told only by the sufferer.
However it is the humane thing to do and give her the benefit of doubt. Mathey Hadden scored a 100 with a broken toe, malcom marshall had taken 5 wickets with a fractured toe. Goal keeper of chelsea played with a broken skull bone ! Kumble bowled with a broken jaw bone !
When all these miracles are possible, then someone dancing with a little injury in today's advanced medicine field is very easily possible.

And I am not a ronit fan (nor anyone elses) but I believe in looking for the positivity.

I agree with a little injury dancing is possible, what I did not appreciate is how the contestants stressed the severity of the injury. Bowling with a broken Jaw is very different than dancing with ligaments torn in both legs with internal bleeding within a week with no visible signs of discomfort. It is not only the people on the forum who are questioning, Mona also asked the question and they bypassed answering it. Similarly there have been a few articles also.

Look, I am myself saying that the extent of injury can be not soooo serious but surely would have been an injury of a decent magnitude. But in todays advanced medic world it is possible to take a diclofenac injection and carry on. I am a biotechnologist and can also say that it is literally impossible to tear ligaments in both legs ! That too at the same time. This can happen only in car accidents or something like that, I have never heard of this. So this in itself was exagerated.
But i still feel that she had some injury which surely was discomforting and hampered her movement. However it was overplayed.

Just came across this and wanted to add my two cents. Torn ligaments and muscular injuries have varying degrees. Now I am not sure of the exact nature of Nicole's claimed injury but it appears to be a form of Achilles tendinitis a common injury amidst athletes. It was probably minor tearing and not a major rupture. Those who have had ankle tendinitis know that it can be extremely uncomfortable and painful, but allows more room for movement compared to hamstring and calf tears.

If you look at Nicole's performance when her feet were bandaged you can see minor winces in her expressions. The performance next week also had lighter choreography with more lifts and less stretching or weighing of the feet.

I have known athletes who have played with broken ankles and other ankle injuries. While her healing process has been quicker then usual, I would not say it is impossible. Her situation is quite probable.

It could as well be a hoax to incite pity, and script in some drama. However, I would like to give them the benefit of doubt. Innocent until proven guilty.

Originally posted by: tweetyangel

As per you if BBC and Sony can be manipulated by Balaji and Ekta to bring Prachi back, I think they can be manipulated to not dig deep when an contestant clearly overhypes an injury. When Nicole was asked by the judges if she was alright to perform as she seems to be a little injured, Ronit chimed in and said it is not a little injury but a very severe one and went on to describe the severity of the injury. One week after that Nicole was in high heels giving a really high voltage performance flawlessly and got a 30. They had to have practiced it for a week. So when did she recover. This whole thing smells really badly.

Well dear, that is why I suggested if one really think its a big cook up go take legal action and demand justice! instead of repeating post after post that she is faking it. We seem to be running around a tree in this matter, so why not seek the proper redress, go get a petition going whatever or put the matter to rest. No one forces another to vote for sympathy. Its a freedom of choice.
With regards to Balaji pulling strings, every quote has been from printed articles post PD elimination. Now that sounds fishy to me. Whatever it is we are all entitled to our own opinions.

Originally posted by: Garv_Kumud_4eva

FSAM
How come u see everything all the time...u see people mentally abused people like AD mentally abused Bani and now u see internal injuries...and what not... just keep ur observations to urself...that are against an actor.
The bottom line is u don't know anything, u don't have proof besides ur "i have seen this and i have seen that ALL the time"
Seriously...SONY knows that RR and Nicole didn't fake it.
I wont comment on Prachi coz she is nice and i have nothing against her...
You need to just leave RR alone...HATERS!!


And Meena or Je_aime or something....don't do anything....RR fans know what is the truth and what's not the truth. the truth is that Nicole recovered in 2 weeks and the man who doesn't even as for votes, won't sink so low to garner some votes.

And lovly_angel...😆😆😆 whatever!!

Look ms. If you can answer with medical proofs that she can dance with internal injury in both legs, do that? Dont need pick on me. Dont bring in rivalry to other sections.

Frankly, if one has to make assumptions and draw conclusions, the injury thing was played after they were in danger zone for two weeks. So one will automatically assume that they did it for votes. And I am no different. I assume the same. It has got nothing to do with if I like RR or not. I have all right to voice my opinion. I just voiced my view if you can medically prove it wrong, do so or else dont pick on me.

MS. Meena...I think u r doin the pickin business from other sections here...since u mentioned it urself. Rest of the stuff u mentioned doesn't make sense, so i will not comment.

Lovly_angel...u seriously r cheap to even think about someone cutting their legs and all, disgusting mind. Who made u a mod? U need to quit, u can't handle it, even if u are the mod of some other section, u seriously don't deserve it. Freakin Jay fan

Moderator's Note: Consider this a warning... DO NOT attack members... You need to mind your language and it's because of a few comments like these that an otherwise healthy discussion turns into some nasty attacks on other members... So please quit it!

When there is a calf muscle injury with internal bleeding it takes 6-7 weeks to several months to heal but then there are various factors on which the healing depends. The production house must have definitely gone through the entire matter & checked if whatever is being said is true or notWe can't point fingers at anyone without any proof.

Shruti

Originally posted by: Garv_Kumud_4eva

MS. Meena...I think u r doin the pickin business from other sections here...since u mentioned it urself. Rest of the stuff u mentioned doesn't make sense, so i will not comment.

Lovly_angel...u seriously r cheap to even think about someone cutting their legs and all, disgusting mind. Who made u a mod? U need to quit, u can't handle it, even if u are the mod of some other section, u seriously don't deserve it. Freakin Jay fan

U jus gt a life and y u always brng up questions of me being a mod r u jealous o wat the time u waste in writting in here go vote for ur ronit man jus mind ur language man ..ya i am freking jay fan u got any problem