Are judges fair? - Page 3

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

I think that the judges were biased cuz they only wanted Mahesh and Shveta to be in the finals. Even Farah Khan admitted that for purely selfish reasons I want you to stay in the show. Don't you think she is biased. Even SLB said that ppl say I give more marks to Mahesh cuz he is a flim director. He said that so cuz ppl are thinking and talking behind him that he is an unfair judge. He is defending him. If he was not biased towards Mahesh then he need not need to defend himself. Also SLB was biased towards Mahesh when he performed his last dance on October 12th episode. Farah pointed out two mistakes and she gave Mahesh 8 pts. But when SLB turn came in giving marks he said that farah pointed out 2 mistakes but 100 mistakes are forgivable for you. Isn't dat biased. As far as Shilipa is concerned I dun even wanna talk abt her cuz she herself doesn't know what she is doing.

whts the mahesh bias doign in this final? did those judges say to Shveta that they want them to be in TOP 2? They were like to place Mahes in TOP 2 & gave moan & shveta on Public hands by giving tie....If they really want Shveta that time they shoul have give Shveta second & Mona third rt?

So ur comments does not make they r biased on Shveta....They said deserving words for Shveta only....👏

Originally posted by: coolprince143

I personally think judges were unfair to Mona. She deserved more points then she got, definately in the first round. Please vote for MONA!!!

Reply with comments

Thanks

i think the judges have been absolutely fair........

This is the first reality show where i think the judges and public have voted perfectly and only those who deserved to be in the final have been in the final...................

But in the Final round...it was shevta who rocked all the way...........

Yay ..Way to go shevta.............SMS Shevta 2525

Originally posted by: silverwing1527

*sigh* we've already decided that the judges were biased and unfair since the starting. oye! did you see mona's second performance? I LOVED IT! i dont care what anyone else says, i simply loved it. 😃 MONA to 2525!

Who decided that the judges were biased ...a handful of u..........Grow up...............Mona's second performance was Ok........she deserved 24 not more........The choice of song was Yuck........the judges didnt give her that song...She and Toby chose it.............So why blame the judges????

Originally posted by: dhru4u

who cares about svetha...

mona deserved more points.. looking at the performance from the last
episode mona deserves more points..
JUDGES ARE BIASED... i lost hope of mona winning... cuz they will just claim
that mona's fans didn't help her... stupid ppl .. they are not even sticking to
their own concept...

Mind yr language buddy😉............."who cares about Shveta..."

We do.........v are not her fans.....but we are fair, just like the judges...and we think she deserves to win............

Dont live in the past...........Mona was great as Jassi.............It was a great show..blah ....blah...Lets put that show in the "Hall of Fame"

She does not need to win JDJ for being Jassi...this is a dance competition........And Shveta dances par excellence..........Point to be noted before voting........

Originally posted by: fan no 1 jjkn

biased judges. They have done deliberately Mona was given her performance to get such lower score.

Now whatever is done is done. Now let us vote for Mona

Do u even know what u are saying????????

Mona was not given any performance........Mona and Toby chose their own song and their choreography..........Where do the judges come into the picture here????

Understand the show and the concept before u go about making vague statements😳.......

I am not a Shevta fan......but a very mature viewer.😉...........

I think of the two.....Shveta is better by a mile and deserves to win..........

SMS Shveta 2525...........

Originally posted by: bsmartguy

I agree judges were biased towards MONA and underated MONA's performances... But I m sure that Mona will get gud public support.

VOTE 4 MONA.

he he he 😆😆 U need to correct yr statement ......if the judges are biased towards Mona why will they underate her..........they will overate her....😆😆

Biased means liking...............not disliking............😆😆

And Mona will get good public support for what?????? Acting or Dancing........

😕i am confused😕...I thought this was a dance show😆

Originally posted by: luckyleo

I don't deny svetha is a fairly good dancer. she has a natural grace. but i do think the judges are biased. SLB in particular. he is totally smitten by svetha. he could dream of her all he wants, shoot a song with her, but comparing her with madhuri is too much to digest! 😡 😡 madhuri is probably one of the finest dancers in our film industry. she is a legend in her own right when it comes to her talent in dancing. svetha can in no way fill the void which madhuri has left.

the judges have been biased even when mahesh was around. and now it shows openly in their remarks and points. something tells me this could backfire on svetha... and mona will be the winner!

If SLB is comparing Shveta to Madhuri.......he is in a position to do that............He has worked with Madhuri.......

U and I only see what we see on screen..............So lets not take that away from him..

Besides a song dance shown on the big screen takes almost a week to shoot, with hundreds of retakes...............here there are no retakes.......

So if SLB wants to take Shveta up there with Madhuri he is entitled to.......Who are we to negate that...........Did u direct madhuri or watch shveta live???????

I know its been said soooooo many time But its the Truth "THE JUDGES ARE UNFAIR" That's it. There is no question about it, They supported Mahesh (who i love for his movies)even though he was an average dancer. So all the best to the 2 girls's. But i hope justice prevails and Mona wins!!!!!!!!

Shveta is nice but too stiff a dancer even though she has had extensive dance training and is a trained dancer!
and her expressions are not all that great, She borrows a great deal from Madhuri, no originality.

Originally posted by: paayal007

But i hope justice prevails and Mona wins!!!!!!!!

Now that really had me in splits😆..If justice should prevail,Svetha should win,as she was the better dancer.😉

Lets forget about the judges comment for a while,as an audience,most think that SVetha was much much better....

Originally posted by: payal007

Shveta is nice but too stiff a dancer even though she has had extensive dance training and is a trained dancer!
and her expressions are not all that great, She borrows a great deal from Madhuri, no originality.

SVetha's stiff....this is news to me....

Fine,lets buy what you say...If svetha's stiff, then Mona is immobile..Just a relative comparison

Svetha's NOT a trained dancer...Some people choose to just ignore the N number of posts where it has been clarified that Svetha is not a trained/professional/experienced dancer

Svetha would have danced earlier at awards/parties...and even Mona has danced that much..She used to dance at garbas,she used to dance at awards shows,Mona's also done a music video,wherein she had danced...thus,whatever little dancing svetha has done prior to JDJ,even mona has danced that much....

LMAO....shweta is stiff 😆 Good reply buffie....

Lvoed ur get back on teh MAdhuri comment HArdy.....none of us can refute wht SLB said coz SLB has worked with some of the best dancers ever lik Ash n MAdz....he sure knws wht he's talking abt!

As for justice prevailing...well lik buffie said: justice would onyl prevail if shveta who is the bttr dancer wins!