Why Karan lost in votes - Page 2

Originally posted by: sakshiluvskaran

oh pls when karan inspite of getting low scores got tremendous votes then why in grand finale his votes got less... why after twelve damn weeks did jdj people realised he didnt get good votes... they used him for votes and thats clear... i am damn sure the entire jdj is rigged... karan has a huge fan-following and they knew its last time so they sure wud have voted..

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

Well he got tremendous votes when compared to the votes of Gauhar, Shilpa, Monica & HK. But his votes were not tremendous when compared to the votes of BB. Lets face facts, BB is equally popular and was never far behind in votes. Like Karan, he also never came in Dance off. So in the finals if you add the votes of HK fans to the tally of BBs votes, then I am sure he is way ahead of votes as compared to Karan.

I know that no matter how much logic and justification is given, it is hard to convince die hard fans other wise, I know as I have been there. I am sure that with time you will move on. Please dont be too upset.

Reema

Originally posted by: roshnirj

well....it rly surprises me that for all this time u say "karan survived b'coz of his votes"..and 1 day suddenly u say..."it just so happened that in the grand finale...he didn't get the highest votes"....right....now what if i say that sony got maximum money through karan's votes......and so they kept him till the end and when it came to the results....BANG!!! karan didn't get highest votes...waow!!! now that's what u call a story...well done sony!!! gr8 job creatives!!!!

Originally posted by: harpkaur

u ppl prlly sent him d same amount of votez bt dis time NE sent extra extra extra votez...which made ur votez very less...if u think dat dey kept him 4 votez why did u gve dem a chance 2 ? u shdnt ve voted den...

if u say dat entire JDJ iz riggid so it meanz keepin karan wz riggid as well...if karan wud hve won..den wud u say d same thing...ohhh nooo u wudnt cuz ur fav wud hve won..

sum ppl r sayin dat he got d highest votez for 12 weekz..no he dint...dey onli told in d few episodez dat hez d highest voted..bt nah all...so u cant say dat he wz d highest voted contestent.

Originally posted by: roshnirj

well....it rly surprises me that for all this time u say "karan survived b'coz of his votes"..and 1 day suddenly u say..."it just so happened that in the grand finale...he didn't get the highest votes"....right....now what if i say that sony got maximum money through karan's votes......and so they kept him till the end and when it came to the results....BANG!!! karan didn't get highest votes...waow!!! now that's what u call a story...well done sony!!! gr8 job creatives!!!!

Originally posted by: sakshiluvskaran

[there is no question of moving on i was prepared for the worst the way marks were given to bb they wanted him to win can u tell me in the last performance of bb on kaise mujhe did he dance it was soniya who danced and judges praised only her and gave ful 40 marks why they did not say that its not choreographers dance that mattered and of participant and then remember tere bin performance of karan he emoted it so well and then the judges were harsh saying you didnt dance and all and they got 18... its not voting but partiality that hurts... think if it had happened with u...

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

I understand that Karan's loss is hard for his fans to cope with. But this is reality TV and you have to accept the people's verdict gracefully coz some go your way and some dont. Till the time Karan was roping in the votes and better contestants like HK were being ousted, till then it was not rigged. This happens in all reality shows, sometimes the result are expected and sometimes not but to call them rigged without proof would not be the right thing.

The moment he lost and BB won, it becomes rigged. Please discard these double standards. You live by the sword and die by the sword. Karan was in the show largely coz of the votes , so now if Baichung fans have returned the favour, then why complain ?

I think its fair decision and NOT RIGGED. If anyone feels so, then he should prove it or else it becomes only speculation.

Why I feel that Karan lost to BB in votes is because there are lot of true admirers of dance, who I think were supporting HK (like me) and they saw her elimination as a result of Karan's extensive vote bank. In this the judges also played their part as they made it very apparent to HK fans that she was out because people voted on popularity (for Karan even though he had the lowest scores). I have a strong feeling that most of HK fans turned their votes to BB with a vengence as they knew that it was only BB who could beat Karan in votes. If you had only BB votes then maybe he would not have crossed Karan's votes, but if you add the votes which HK was getting to the tally of BB, then I am sure that they would excede Karan's votes.

At the end I can say that it was only HK who deserved to win this and anyone other than her is a Farce. But to Say that it was rigged just coz Karan did not win is not correct. I know how Karan's yound fans must feel at this moment coz I felt the same when HK was eliminated, I too was very upset coz the best dancer was eliminated due to the vote bank of others. But watching reality shows has taught me that we should not get too emotional or worked up as its just a show and before we know it, there will be another such reality show round the corner in which the result will make you happy again. So My advice to Karan fans is that they should not feel bad but pround and i am sure the future for their beloved Karan is bright as he has such dedicated fans. So just Chill.

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

Here I agree with you that the judges at times were unfair as they gave BB more marks than he deserved. But if marks were the only thing then HK would have never been out. Such competitions are not decided on marks but on votes & popularity (unfortunately) and I believe both were equal in those terms and so it was anyones game.

I can only say that the true winner was HK as she was miles ahead n=in dancing & variety as compared to all of them put together.