Jhalak 3....few thoughts

Originally posted by: tintiny

2: Judging was inconsistent....with due regards to both Saroj Khan and Vaibhabi Merchant, who have whole body of work to support their reputation I somehow expected a more consistent performance from them. Juhi inpite of being a non dancer I felt was more consistent compared to the other two....I think the first season judges were the best upto now....

Originally posted by: tintiny

Dear Friends,

Jhalak 3 has ended and Baichung Bhutia has been declared the winner, I will wait eagerly to watch the finals....but let me share few of my thoughts for the show with you.

1: I thought the show was meant for non-dancers...if so what is Gauhar Khan doing here? I have nothing against her but to be very frank this does give an extra leaverage to her compared to other participants....It is a dance show fine but meant for non dancers who are celebraties too....next time please Sony choose your participants carefully.

2: Judging was inconsistent....with due regards to both Saroj Khan and Vaibhabi Merchant, who have whole body of work to support their reputation I somehow expected a more consistent performance from them. Juhi inpite of being a non dancer I felt was more consistent compared to the other two....I think the first season judges were the best upto now....

3: I hated the acts and ghar ki kahani shelved out to get sympathy votes. I hated Parul's dark girl talk and Monica's going wrong in youth...we see enough drama in form of saas bahu etc., if this is a dance show lets stick to the hardships being faced by the participants to learn dancing and funny incidents while practicing....

4: Please choose your Hosts carefully and do some justice to their dresses too....I do not want to see Shweta again. Enough of her screaching and bad dress sense...

Last but not the least, I loved Ram, Hard Kaur, Mohinder Amarnath and Baichung Bhutia....while Baichung Bhutia showed remarkable attitude and improved greatly on his dancing, I wished RK stayed a bit longer, he was making us laugh while Hard Kaur should have been in the finals until the judges goofed up. I am very very dissappointed with Karan, had hopes he will do well but to be frank he was more interested showing his body without any facial expression or improvement in dancing....he survived till finals because of the votes and in process destroyed the chances of deserving candidates.....this sms thing is turning out to be a spoiler in many reality shows ....but then we did get a deserving winner....well done Baichung....Your thought friends, love Tin

Originally posted by: tintiny

Dear Friends,

Jhalak 3 has ended and Baichung Bhutia has been declared the winner, I will wait eagerly to watch the finals....but let me share few of my thoughts for the show with you.

1: I thought the show was meant for non-dancers...if so what is Gauhar Khan doing here? I have nothing against her but to be very frank this does give an extra leaverage to her compared to other participants....It is a dance show fine but meant for non dancers who are celebraties too....next time please Sony choose your participants carefully.

2: Judging was inconsistent....with due regards to both Saroj Khan and Vaibhabi Merchant, who have whole body of work to support their reputation I somehow expected a more consistent performance from them. Juhi inpite of being a non dancer I felt was more consistent compared to the other two....I think the first season judges were the best upto now....

Originally posted by: tintiny

Dear Friends,

Jhalak 3 has ended and Baichung Bhutia has been declared the winner, I will wait eagerly to watch the finals....but let me share few of my thoughts for the show with you.

1: I thought the show was meant for non-dancers...if so what is Gauhar Khan doing here? I have nothing against her but to be very frank this does give an extra leaverage to her compared to other participants....It is a dance show fine but meant for non dancers who are celebraties too....next time please Sony choose your participants carefully.

2: Judging was inconsistent....with due regards to both Saroj Khan and Vaibhabi Merchant, who have whole body of work to support their reputation I somehow expected a more consistent performance from them. Juhi inpite of being a non dancer I felt was more consistent compared to the other two....I think the first season judges were the best upto now....

3: I hated the acts and ghar ki kahani shelved out to get sympathy votes. I hated Parul's dark girl talk and Monica's going wrong in youth...we see enough drama in form of saas bahu etc., if this is a dance show lets stick to the hardships being faced by the participants to learn dancing and funny incidents while practicing....

4: Please choose your Hosts carefully and do some justice to their dresses too....I do not want to see Shweta again. Enough of her screaching and bad dress sense...

Last but not the least, I loved Ram, Hard Kaur, Mohinder Amarnath and Baichung Bhutia....while Baichung Bhutia showed remarkable attitude and improved greatly on his dancing, I wished RK stayed a bit longer, he was making us laugh while Hard Kaur should have been in the finals until the judges goofed up. I am very very dissappointed with Karan, had hopes he will do well but to be frank he was more interested showing his body without any facial expression or improvement in dancing....he survived till finals because of the votes and in process destroyed the chances of deserving candidates.....this sms thing is turning out to be a spoiler in many reality shows ....but then we did get a deserving winner....well done Baichung....Your thought friends, love Tin

Originally posted by: kaushikbasu

@TC

Agree with you on almost all counts. Also for the fans of all sides, we should learn to respect all the celebrities and judges. We can be critical of them but not insulting as many memebers of IF have been.