Isha in the Semi-Finals(?) [All discussion here]

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#81

Originally posted by: chocolover89
THAT is the point everyone is making in this thread when they say it's unfair Isha gets a free pass to the semifinals. What happens to the competition then? Does it exist at this point? Just because Isha is portrayed as a supposedly "betetr" dancer than the others does not mean it's okay for her to get a free pass while the others toil hard.

How is comparing Bharti's back problem to Isha's fracture comparing apples to oranges? they're both injuries at the end of the day. 😕 Except one chooses to perform despite it, and the other gets a free pass for 2+ weeks. 🥱

Actually comparing Sushant's veto save to Isha's is apples to oranges. You seem to think that just because a veto power was used last season it is okay for it to be used this season. Fine, but at the same time you're totally ignoring the KEY part of the veto last season: Sushant DANCED...he PERFORMED for the veto to be used. So did Yana did. They did NOT get a free pass straight into the competition without doing anything like Isha has gotten this time.

Honestly, this season of JDJ is BY FAR the most biased, unfair reality show I have seen on Indian TV. I have never seen any one contestant get this much of a leeway as Isha has gotten this season. Everyone expects a certain amount of unfairness, but this is crossing the line. Plain and simple. Nobody expects a perfect show. 😕

Please do not take a line outta context and make it seem something else all together.

@ bold, Anyone who performs day and night they will have back issues, joint pain, lethargy and many other issues. It seems she has a problem with back pain and not some sorta limitation like Isha, from what I can see. I might not be the right person to judge her condition based on what I see on screen. But the doctors and makers down there would make sure if one is able to perform or not. And why do people assume that Isha isn't performing because she simply wants to gather the votes. As a dancer who loves dancing, I am sure she would have performed if she could have. Having a fracture and perform, doesn't make any sense to me. If it does to you, your choice and your POV.

I don't know how the VETO power will be used this season. So I can't say anything on it. It is up to the judges and makers of the show. And I agree with the manipulation and scripted part, but it has been happening from time to time, even with Bharti being on the stage questions the legitimacy of the show. Unfairness is part of any reality show. So people will simply have to suck it and move on, whether it's you or me and if it bothers you too much simply fast forward like I do with Bharti (just a suggestion).

Anyways, there is no point to this debate when people expect only others to have an open mind and not vice versa. So you all can gladly stick to your views. And I will stick to mine😃

I am outta here. Peace out.

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

priya

@JugniPH

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#82

feeling sooo happy that judges used their veto power for the most deserving person..isha deserved it..just look at her performance from the day 1 to the last one..anyone can say feel her magic.. its her fate that the accident happend..bt considering her performances isha deserves a second chance for sure..and i'm happy tht judges did it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Neeta

@U-No-Poo

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#83

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

And the day people stop looking for fairness and justice in a thing called "reality show", I shall maintain a five minutes of silence 😆😆

I'm not looking for anything in the show, I'm looking for something in fans like you. Clearly I shall be looking into a pensive full of

Quote

Neeta

@U-No-Poo

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#84

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

Snape died and made me the judge on behalf of all the tormented souls suffered on the hands of "U No Poo" So I hereby rule in the above statement of mine for any haters out there 😉

P.S: I don't have to pay a tax for saying anything I feel like on a virtual forum. You can either take it or leave it 😆

@Bold - You have no idea what you just did 😆 Next you report a post, think a hundred times before doing so. Or if you're ok with that, I guess you're also ok with being a hypocrite.

Quote

RAJ

@MrChatVsNorway

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#85

yeh main kya sunraha hun yeha akar itne dino bad

isha salman in semi finals

i want those hours back in my life which i wasted watching jdj season 5

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#86

Originally posted by: U-No-Poo

I'm not looking for anything in the show, I'm looking for something in fans like you. Clearly I shall be looking into a pensive full of

Thank you for showing some more of your frustration and living up to your profile ID !!!

Like they say extreme haters are also pensive full of and after all the arguments, you have just proved yourself to be one 😃

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#87

Originally posted by: U-No-Poo

@Bold - You have no idea what you just did 😆 Next you report a post, think a hundred times before doing so. Or if you're ok with that, I guess you're also ok with being a hypocrite.

Being some actor's or should I say actress' hardcore fan and taunting others of being the fangirls shows who the hypocrite really is 😉

P.S: I was actually trying to debate our opinions very gracefully. But you clearly showed me your immaturity and that you indeed are one of those certain people whose posts I would like to leave. You have answered your own very question why I like to not reply back to certain blind haters.

Now I am done here. Do come by time to time to spread your hatred 😃

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#88

Originally posted by: DIDfan89

Ofcourse hardcore Salman fans are going to take this as an "insult" or as "being a hater"

I dont think anybody who disagrees about Isha's presence in the semi-finals is being a hater. I mean its so blantantly obvious. Im sure if this kind of exception was made for Bharti or Gurmeet the same Salman fans would be all over them and attacking them. Ofcourse, not ALL Salman fans are like that, but the majority of them cant seem to handle constructive criticism.

Not sure how she can be safe with 0 points, it just doesnt make sense. But whatever, Its fine that shes in the semi-finals. Its great. But I surely dont see her winning.

So why dont they give Bharti higher marks for performing WITH an injury/ She has a back problem right? So why arent they giving her a 10?...If they can allow Isha to "not perform" and still make it to the next round, then shouldnt everyone be subject to special treatment? Its only fair right?

Its funny because ON THIS SAME SHOW in the past I have heard judges say things like the show must go on and even if you have an injury, this is a competition and they have zero tolerance for any kind of excuse or situation. Even if IT IS an injury. I find that "making" Isha safe is not only showing bias, but it is also lowering the value of the show.

Have you ever seen a salman fan creating a bashing post for other celebs on the name of criticzm ...show me any one of them...Ppl who rome bashing aroud here are only and only gurmeet fans...
were was ur opinion wen bharti and gurmeet got saved with 19 and 20 marks...oh one sec . gurmeet fans vote all nyte rite ...hum to chane bechne baithe hain prolly ...some ppl just watch the show ..they have nothing to do with voting ...but there are 1000s of salman isha fans who voted 1000 times this week...If gurmeet and bharti is getting saved with low marks ...its becoz of their fans ...but if salman n isha got saved ...its becoz of manipulation ...hypocrisy !!!

Now hatred and jealousy has crossed that level ...that ppl are here compairing isha with bharti ...😆

Quote

Parijatrocks

@Peacefulmind

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#89

If i am not mistaken... What did isha say regarding her injury...
What doctor advice her... Her injury is very severe...

And can a severe injury can get cured within 2 weeks...

If so all other contestants in the show should also have this kind of injury so that they will land in finals...

Jokes apart again same no 2 veto powers should have been given to same contestants... Its unfair the person who is gonna be eliminated this week and also next week elimination...

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#90

Originally posted by: bhavya
If i am not mistaken... What did isha say regarding her injury...
What doctor advice her... Her injury is very severe...

And can a severe injury can get cured within 2 weeks... You should do some research and enlighten us

If so all other contestants in the show should also have this kind of injury so that they will land in finals... I wonder why Gia didn't think of it, this way she could have reached semi finals without any sorta dancing which is her expertise.

Jokes apart again same no 2 veto powers should have been given to same contestants... Its unfair the person who is gonna be eliminated this week and also next week elimination...

There is only one veto power which will be used. Other weeks, they have been saved based on "votes". Yeh there are many unfair things happening on this stage, so accept it and move on.

P.S: Your unfair comment will become fair when Isha gets eliminated, so you can happily have your cake cuz she isn't winning this thing.

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

1 ... 7 8 9 10 11 ... 25

Isha in the Semi-Finals(?) [All discussion here] - Page 9

Related Topics

Explore Topics